Mythol wrote:

Hard

00:19:727 (3) - http://puu.sh/hGyy Sounds better. Don't forget to add the finish.

01:02:746 (1) - Finish?

arien666 wrote:

[Haruka's Normal]
00:05:576 (2) - Shape seems little sharp'd so why don't you make it more smooth :3? it's intended to have that shape. D: sorry!
00:27:934 (1,3) - Swap new combo? it was originally like that before first mod. >< thank you!

Makar8000 wrote:

[Haruka's Normal]

• 
  Recheck I guess~ Mostly hitsounds. Good first map :3 thank you! ;w;

1. 00:23:972 (3) - Clap? my bad! I missed that! OTL
2. 00:24:255 (4) - Clap at the end? there is a clap at the end. OTL
3. 00:33:312 (4) - Remove clap at the repeat, add one at the end? sounds much better! -w-
4. 00:34:444 (5) - Only put a clap at the end? ^
5. 00:37:840 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - this part is really cool =w= but its a sudden change in difficulty that ends in the next combo. If you want to fix, my suggestion would be to shorten 00:38:406 (3) to end on the white tick, then remove 00:38:265 (2). done and done! -w- Oh and imo the whistles should be removed but we already discussed that in PM orz. okay okay I removed the whistles. OTL
6. 00:38:406 (3) - If you do shorten this, add a clap at the end? okie~
7. 00:39:821 (6) - Remove clap? gonna keep it. -w-
8. 00:40:104 (7) - Clap at the end? there is a clap at the end. OTL
9. 00:42:368 (3) - Finish at start, maybe remove whistle? done and done.
10. 00:43:925 (5) - Remove whistle? fine. :c
11. 01:02:746 (1) - Clap maybe? whoops, forgot to add that! D: done.
12. 01:08:406 (3) - Clap at the end? ^
13. 01:29:349 (7) - Clap at the end? ^

Mythol wrote:

Randomly modding this o.o saw that coming lol

Normal
00:08:406 (3) - NC it's fine.
00:11:236 (1) - Clap? nope; it doesn't follow the pattern and there's no accent there.
00:38:406 (3) - http://puu.sh/hGtq Old one doesn't fit, and is too hard. already changed.
01:01:472 (5) - Stack on top of 4 and make it blanket 3. http://puu.sh/hGv0 yeah no.
01:02:746 (1) - Finish. I was told to also add a clap, so I've done both cause it sounds better.
01:13:359 (3) - http://puu.sh/hGw7 Sounds better. that sounds terrible.
01:23:265 (4) - Remove whistle. Add clap on 01:23:123 instead. there is a clap there, and I'm keeping the whistle on the red tick.
01:24:821 (7) - Fix blanket. done.

Cool map \o/ \o/

Pereira006 wrote:

hello~~ hello~
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Haruka's Normal

AR -1 is better imo looks good. :3

00:01:614 (3) - grid 1 up to make symentric with 00:01:048 (2) ? whoops, forgot to align when I resnapped. OTL
00:03:878 (6,7,1) - not better triangle try perfect triangle like this http://puu.sh/hIO4 ? looks better, thank you~
00:05:576 (2) - I can see my owm is ugly slider "cicle" because this http://puu.sh/hIOz just ugly try better slider "cicle" like this http://puu.sh/hIPT IMO if you fix this you need really change at 00:03:878 (6,7,1) and fix spacing at 00:08:406 (3,4,5,6) this just my IMO I still like the shape of this slider; I might change it if another person finds it weird.
01:01:331 (4,5) - will most better if stack it done.
01:04:727 (1,2,3,4,5) - grid 1 right to make center yay, center!

stuff cool you is cool
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
that all i think pleasse some mod you can't understand my eng is suck pleasse ask me in-game i will explain better

good luck and bye bye thanks for the mod!

spboxer3 wrote:

[Makar's Easy]

• 
  
  mapping
  

1. 01:18:595 (1,1) - too far spacing for center. Because it's Easy diff is for new player... It's really Hard to play for new player! Ill fix =w=

spboxer3 wrote:

[JBsparta's Hard]

• 
  Settings
  

1. unused green line:
   00:46:897 -

mapping

1. 00:48:029 (1) - bug! you need add new combo at this way

Kawayi Rika wrote:

[JBsparta's Hard]

1. 00:02:654 (4) - Add new combo.
2. 00:07:182 (6) - ^
3. 00:48:078 (1) - This is unrankable bug,Add new combo to here.
4. 00:56:993 (1) - Remove too short new combo.
5. 01:00:106 (7) - Add new combo.
6. 01:12:842 (2,3) - Try like this rhythm will be better.
   

spboxer3 wrote:

[Haruka's Normal]

• 
  
  mapping
  

1. 00:11:236 (1) - too far spacing for center. Because it's Normal diff also for new player... It's really Hard to play for new player! made it easier to play for new player!
2. 00:26:519 (9) - 9 combo it's too many combo in Normal! I suggest you can add NC at 00:25:670 (6) - done. -w-
3. 00:55:953 (1,1) - same as 00:11:236 (1) - done.
4. 01:18:595 (1,1) - ^ done.

Kawayi Rika wrote:

[Haruka's Normal]

1. 00:25:012 (5) - Add new combo,long combo hard for beginner. done from sp3's mod.
2. 00:30:106 (5) - ^ done.
3. 00:26:427 (1) - Remove too short new combo. ugh, that was an error when changing new combos from last mod. OTLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL that wasn't suppose to be like that.
4. 01:13:408 (3) - Try like this rhythm will be better. *sigh* it was like this before but someone complained about following the vocals too much; I'm going to revert back to this, so thanks for the suggestion.
   
5. 01:28:691 (5) - Add new combo. done.

arien666 wrote:

[Cherry's Taiko]
00:13:359 (2) - don? done~
00:19:373 (1) - Just kat ;_;? sure :3
00:26:519 (3) - Change into circles :3? done done!
01:29:632 (1) - Delete finish? o_ob



Err... Taiko seems little hard ;_; orz I'm sorry ;w;
orz orz orz

Nyquill wrote:

arien666 wrote:

Err... Taiko seems little hard ;_; CHERRY YOU KAT GUY *is a kat guy*

MMzz wrote:

Taiko Mod:

00:07:465 (5) - clap done.
00:15:814 (1,1) - reverse these so it's goes blue red done.
00:16:522 (2) - clap yup.
00:16:946 - add normal note okay o:
00:22:606 - ^ fill in that weird pause filled.
00:26:144 (2) - remove clap done!
00:26:427 (3) - short burst sliders are bad! D: You should add notes instead. oops, fixed >v<
00:32:229 - add normal note alrighty c:
00:36:333 (2,3,4) - make these three claps? (2) and (4) are now claps, I had made (3) a don.
00:44:540 (1) - maybe make this a slider? Would fit better, but a spinner is ok. sure, fixed~
00:54:446 (2) - clap sure thing.
00:56:852 - add a normal finisher here, then delete 00:56:993 (1) so it flows. wow great idea, thanks!
00:59:682 (2) - remove clap I believe there's none there... o.o
01:01:380 (2) - add finisher done o:
01:02:654 (1) - ^ sounds strange, no thanks.
01:02:937 (2) - clap sounds better this way.
01:03:361 - add normal note fixed this around a bit.
01:05:484 (3) - why does this have whistle and clap on it? xD remove the whistle, although this would fit better as a normal finisher. did this.
01:29:682 - add a clap, there is a beat there :3 orz how did I miss this @_@

You should stick to mapping the drums more than the lyrics, although lyric mapping works in rare cases. OTL

Sync wrote:

Insane
00:28:125 (4) - I'm not sure if a repeat slider is what you want to do here; my main qualms against this slider is that of three reasons: first off, having the same slider that starts in one section and ends in the next section of a piece of music just doesn't play very well. Secondly, having a slider's end-point lie on a heavier beat than it's start-point is generally bad practice and should be avoided in most cases (however, it can and does work some of the time.. just not in this case). Finally, it messes up this map's combo placement. I would remove the repeat and add a hit circle at 00:28:691. You should also add a new combo. yeah I agree with turning this into a kick slider. I'll figure out how to do it by tommorow.


Fucking awesome mapset Mark's easy be carrying o_ob

Sync wrote:

JBSparta's Hard
00:28:691 (1,2) - Gah, so awkward. It doesn't follow the music well and it disturbed me while playing. You should definitely switch this around -- place the slider on the downbeat where (1) is and move (1) to 00:29:682. I think this follows the music a lot better so you should definitely try this out.

00:30:956 (1) - If you followed the suggestion above, shorten this slider by two ticks and add a hit circle at 00:31:946.

00:49:069 (4) - Start the new combo here and remove the one at 00:49:635. Combos are based off the music, not the patterns. It'd make a lot more sense to see a new combo at the start of a kiai anyways. While we're on this note, I'd like to point out that the pause between this hit circle and the next slider is unnecessary. You should make the hit circle into a 1-beat slider for more movement

Nyquill wrote:

Sync wrote:

Fucking awesome mapset Mark's easy be carrying o_ob

MMzz wrote:

Haruka's Normal:

OD -1? done~

00:24:163 (4) - maybe remove the repeat? To keep consistant with the one before? *resists to correct spelling* removed.
00:34:352 (5) - looks ugly to me, maybe something like: http://puu.sh/jSGc mm, I like how it flows right now.
01:18:595 (1) - end the spinner on the white tick before it? I see what you did with it, just sounds weird to me o_o. ah, what happened here? xD fixed this along with messed up timing points.

Good mapset. =w=b yay David~ and thanks for the mod!

MMzz wrote:

JBsparta's Hard:

I don't think 7 AR is a wise choice, seeing as the BPM is so high, 6 would be better.

JBsparta117 wrote:

MMzz wrote:

JBsparta's Hard:

I don't think 7 AR is a wise choice, seeing as the BPM is so high, 6 would be better.

Got this mod down. Thanks for this. o/

Gabex3 wrote:

00:08:880 : We don't really hear the Clap. It would be better if we could hear it.

Gabex3 wrote:

Modding Queue : Makar's Easy

I see nothing bad here...

00:08:880 : We don't really hear the Clap. It would be better if we could hear it.

-Haruka's Normal-

-Insane-

1. Tags: Inconsistency tags in makar's easy. In other difficulty is makar8000, but in this difficulty is Makar8000. I think should be same in all difficulty.
2. Combo colours: I think dark-brown in here is make too hard for look by players since that will blinded with background. change it into other colour like orange or yellow maybe?

1. 00:11:144 - 01:17:937 I think more better if add some clap in some place since I felt silence in there. because this is supporting with the many drum sound, add some clap isn't bad imo (others that, all difficulty already do that) :3
2. 00:44:540 (1) - why finish in here? the song isn't supporting that imo. because after the spinner is "silent" section (I mean the song is increased into low sound)
3. 00:51:333 (1) - I'm little disturbed by this combo lol. umm, just my opinion, why not remove the new combo in 00:51:333 (1), then add new combo in the next note. seems more fine for me.
4. 01:05:484 (2) - um.. okay just nazi stuff, why not flip vertically this (ctrl + j) for more better look? Since the part shape of this slider is not fit with (1)'s shape imo (I mean the middle of this slider is too sharp)
5. Nice slider in here >v<~

1. 00:00:956 (2,3) - I don't think these notes is fit with the song's sound. Since in there is empty rhytm. consider to remove these note or make it into one slider.
2. 00:02:654 (1) - add clap in here? for supporting drum sound begin
3. 00:11:710 (2) - add clap in slider's reverse? seems ok I think
4. 00:15:106 (2) - why not add finish in slider's beginning? sound like "desh" is heard in there
5. 00:35:484 (1) - change the finish sound with clap more better to heard since the drum sound is more supporting instead the cymbal sound for finish imo
6. 00:37:748 (1) - same as 00:35:484 (1)
7. 00:59:823 (7) - I think you forgot to add clap in slider's end

1. 00:00:673 (2) - same as 00:00:956 in Normal diff. this circle doesn't following anything imo. consider to delete this
2. 00:00:956 (3) - add clap in slider's end? seems felt weird since you already add in the beginning too
3. 00:16:239 (2) - I think this clap should put in (3), because in (3), drum sound is more heard than (2).
4. 00:35:484 (1) - same think as 00:35:484 in Normal difficulty
5. 00:37:748 (1) - same think as 00:37:748 in Normal diff
6. 01:22:465 (3) - add clap in slider's beginning?
7. 01:24:729 (4) - same as above
8. 01:26:993 (4) - ^

1. Unsnapped green timing points at: 00:00:472 and 00:19:647
2. 00:00:672 (3,4,5,6) - same reason with before difficulty, in here is empty rhtym imo, and whistle in there is so noisy for me. maybe delete them? or if you won't you can remove all whistle
3. 00:14:540 (6) - add soft-whistle in slider's beginning? I think more fit with piano sound :3
4. 00:19:635 (1) - add finish in here is more better instead the clap since the "desh" sound omg I don't know the real name for this sound is audible
5. 00:28:691 (1) - add finish in slider's beginning?
6. 00:44:540 (1) - add clap?
7. 00:58:125 (1) - add finish in slider's beginning for "desh" sound >_<
8. 01:02:653 (1) - same as above
9. 01:22:889 (x) - add note (circle) in here? seems more better imo

1. 00:47:229 (1) - ..add clap?
2. I think not too much say in here =w=;

Yasora-chan wrote:

Makar's Easy

1. 00:11:144 - 01:17:937 I think more better if add some clap in some place since I felt silence in there. because this is supporting with the many drum sound, add some clap isn't bad imo (others that, all difficulty already do that) :3 The song calls for claps on the 2nd/4th beat in this section, and I dont have notes there. It sounds weird to have claps in this section because it feels unfitting.
2. 00:44:540 (1) - why finish in here? the song isn't supporting that imo. because after the spinner is "silent" section (I mean the song is increased into low sound) Eh I guess you are right, thanks.
3. 00:51:333 (1) - I'm little disturbed by this combo lol. umm, just my opinion, why not remove the new combo in 00:51:333 (1), then add new combo in the next note. seems more fine for me. I tried to keep consistency with the insane/extra as far as new combos go for the most part. It fits imo.
4. 01:05:484 (2) - um.. okay just nazi stuff, why not flip vertically this (ctrl + j) for more better look? Since the part shape of this slider is not fit with (1)'s shape imo (I mean the middle of this slider is too sharp) Nah I think it's fine
5. Nice slider in here >v<~ Thanks~

Yasora-chan wrote:

hi there hi~

Haruka's Normal

1. 00:00:956 (2,3) - I don't think these notes is fit with the song's sound. Since in there is empty rhytm. consider to remove these note or make it into one slider. sounds fine to me.
2. 00:02:654 (1) - add clap in here? for supporting drum sound begin sure.
3. 00:11:710 (2) - add clap in slider's reverse? seems ok I think a clap here sets off the pattern.
4. 00:15:106 (2) - why not add finish in slider's beginning? sound like "desh" is heard in there it was like that before, so thank you for mentioning~
5. 00:35:484 (1) - change the finish sound with clap more better to heard since the drum sound is more supporting instead the cymbal sound for finish imo added a clap instead~
6. 00:37:748 (1) - same as 00:35:484 (1) it's alright how it is.
7. 00:59:823 (7) - I think you forgot to add clap in slider's end oooh, thanks for picking that out~

Nice map (:
Good luck~ thanks for modding!

Regou wrote:

WoW 7 diffs!
Ok I'll mod 4 diff.
[Haruka's Normal]
HP drain-1
00:05:484 (2) - Ugly. no it's not D:<
00:26:427 (4,1) - Put them farther. it's snapped and it looks fine o.o

That's all. Nice mapset! Good luck!

1. The BG... looks odd. It looks like it has been resized from 16:9 to 4:3 aspect ratio. Maybe use this?

1. As a beatmap, it's fine. As a Hard difficulty though, it isn't. It just feels like playing a Normal diff with the HR mod. And the maximum score difference between this diff and Haruka's Normal is only ~150k. I guess you should make it more intense and get at least ~1.5 million points (~2x of Haruka's Normal's maximum score) for this.

1. AR+1? I think AR10 will fit for a song (and beatmap) like this, even if it seems to be a bit too crazy.