forum

Skillet - Hero

posted
Total Posts
13
Topic Starter
DampfNudel
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Montag, 20. Februar 2012 at 00:47:45

Artist: Skillet
Title: Hero
Source: Awake
Tags: Life save die world superhuman love me now fight pain broken
BPM: 142
Filesize: 4541kb
Play Time: 02:55
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (2,21 stars, 153 notes)
  2. Hard (4,57 stars, 291 notes)
  3. None (4,89 stars, 436 notes)


Download: Skillet - Hero
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------

Grave~
ibavnoci
Overal: BPM and offset seems fine

Insane:
00:24:945 + 00:25:368 - Make these sliders longer or replace them with a hit
00:32:549 - 00:34:029 - Replace these triplets with sliders? It doesn't folow the music like this
00:36:353 - 00:36:987 - Very confusing, Delete or at least make them start at the same position.

00:40:579 - make this slider last until 00:41:213 and delete this slider: 00:40:896
or
00:40:579 replace this slider with a hit and delete this slider: 00:41:001

Song is pretty cool 8-)
Keep up the good work
Topic Starter
DampfNudel

ibavnoci wrote:

Overal: BPM and offset seems fine

Insane:
00:24:945 + 00:25:368 - Make these sliders longer or replace them with a hit
00:32:549 - 00:34:029 - Replace these triplets with sliders? It doesn't folow the music like this
00:36:353 - 00:36:987 - Very confusing, Delete or at least make them start at the same position.

00:40:579 - make this slider last until 00:41:213 and delete this slider: 00:40:896
or
00:40:579 replace this slider with a hit and delete this slider: 00:41:001

Song is pretty cool 8-)
Keep up the good work
Thanks..
Jenny
I just IRC-modded the None-diff with my unique kiai-ololol-modding style, slideradvices, rhythmsuggestions & stuff - if any stuff member wants me to post the log I don't mind, got it saved~

also diff-setting suggestions about the other diffs
Topic Starter
DampfNudel

Jenny wrote:

I just IRC-modded the None-diff with my unique kiai-ololol-modding style, slideradvices, rhythmsuggestions & stuff - if any stuff member wants me to post the log I don't mind, got it saved~

also diff-setting suggestions about the other diffs
Thanks for the IRC mod :3 :)
-Napoleon-
My mod! :D
[General]

Why is Yellow in the colours?

[Normal]

00:27:152 (1) - Put like this: http://puu.sh/fWEv I think will be more easy to read! ;D
00:39:303 (5) - Make the symmetrical more good
00:57:050 (8) - ^
01:20:500 (7) - New combo
01:24:092 (1) - Remove new combo
01:26:205 (2) - I think it should start at: 01:26:627
01:28:740 (8) - New combo
01:35:500 (6) - ^
01:40:571 (4) - ^
01:44:374 (10) - ^
02:01:275 (7) - ^
02:14:796 (6) - ^
02:35:500 (6) - ^
02:46:064 (8) - This is cofuse! Ò.Ó
02:54:726 (6) - New combo
02:54:726 (6,7,8,9,10) - This confuse! Ò.Ó

[Hard]

00:11:838 (6) - New combo
00:30:852 (6) - ^
00:53:669 (6) - ^ Beacuse there appears a note in the same place at: 00:53:036 so it's dificult to read
00:58:740 (5) - Add a Hit Sound Finish
00:58:951 (6) - Remove note
01:17:754 (5) - New combo
01:25:147 (6) - ^
01:37:402 (5) - ^
02:05:712 (6) - ^
02:42:895 (6) - ^
02:44:162 - at: 02:46:486 Break
02:47:754 (5) - New combo

[Insane]

00:12:683 (5) - New combo
00:54:092 (4) - ^
01:00:641 (8) - ^
01:18:599 (6) - ^
01:25:782 (5) - ^
01:28:106 (5) - ^
01:31:698 (6) - ^
01:34:655 (7) - ^
01:39:726 (6) - ^
01:41:838 (6) - ^
01:59:162 (5) - ^
02:06:557 (5) - ^
02:11:416 (7) - ^
02:13:740 (6) - ^
02:23:669 - at: 02:27:472 BREAK NOW!
02:32:754 (5) - New combo
02:36:979 (5) - ^
02:39:726 (5) - ^
02:40:571 (11) - ^
02:42:683 (7) - ^
02:44:162 - at: 02:47:120 BREAK AGAIN!
02:49:233 (8) - New combo
02:53:458 (8) - ^

Done! :D
Topic Starter
DampfNudel

Xavier18488 wrote:

My mod! :D
[General]

Why is Yellow in the colours?

[Normal]

00:27:152 (1) - Put like this: http://puu.sh/fWEv I think will be more easy to read! ;D
00:39:303 (5) - Make the symmetrical more good
00:57:050 (8) - ^
01:20:500 (7) - New combo
01:24:092 (1) - Remove new combo
01:26:205 (2) - I think it should start at: 01:26:627
01:28:740 (8) - New combo
01:35:500 (6) - ^
01:40:571 (4) - ^
01:44:374 (10) - ^
02:01:275 (7) - ^
02:14:796 (6) - ^
02:35:500 (6) - ^
02:46:064 (8) - This is cofuse! Ò.Ó
02:54:726 (6) - New combo
02:54:726 (6,7,8,9,10) - This confuse! Ò.Ó

[Hard]

00:11:838 (6) - New combo
00:30:852 (6) - ^
00:53:669 (6) - ^ Beacuse there appears a note in the same place at: 00:53:036 so it's dificult to read
00:58:740 (5) - Add a Hit Sound Finish
00:58:951 (6) - Remove note
01:17:754 (5) - New combo
01:25:147 (6) - ^
01:37:402 (5) - ^
02:05:712 (6) - ^
02:42:895 (6) - ^
02:44:162 - at: 02:46:486 Break
02:47:754 (5) - New combo

[Insane]

00:12:683 (5) - New combo
00:54:092 (4) - ^
01:00:641 (8) - ^
01:18:599 (6) - ^
01:25:782 (5) - ^
01:28:106 (5) - ^
01:31:698 (6) - ^
01:34:655 (7) - ^
01:39:726 (6) - ^
01:41:838 (6) - ^
01:59:162 (5) - ^
02:06:557 (5) - ^
02:11:416 (7) - ^
02:13:740 (6) - ^
02:23:669 - at: 02:27:472 BREAK NOW!
02:32:754 (5) - New combo
02:36:979 (5) - ^
02:39:726 (5) - ^
02:40:571 (11) - ^
02:42:683 (7) - ^
02:44:162 - at: 02:47:120 BREAK AGAIN!
02:49:233 (8) - New combo
02:53:458 (8) - ^

Done! :D
Hm, Ty
something was useful but not very much :3
Hikato
[General]

There's alot of kiai, you might wanna cut back on it a little.

[Easy]

00:28:740 (2,3) - Spacing.
00:35:078 (2,3) - While overlaps like this would be fine in harder difficulties I think this could be too confusing for an [Easy].
00:49:444 (1,2,3,4) - While there's nothing wrong here, I think you can come up with a more intuitive pattern or arrangement for this section.
{However if you feel you want to keep it how it is, 00:53:036 (3) - stack this on the start of the (4).}
01:16:486 (1) - Stack on the start of (2).
01:19:867 (4,5,6,7) - Too hard for [Easy]
01:24:092 (1) - Add a repeat to this.
01:45:641 (11,12,13) - Spacing between these.
02:13:951 (5) - Confusing, it's hidden.
02:30:007 (1) - This spinner is completly unexpected. You should remove this and maybe extend the previous one.
02:42:472 (2) - Overlap, make it more visible.

Combos
00:10:571 (6) - nc
00:29:585 (3) - nc
00:35:923 (3) - nc
00:39:303 (3) - nc
00:46:064 (5) - nc
00:53:036 (3) - nc
00:56:205 (5) - nc
01:19:867 (4) - nc
01:24:092 (9) - nc
01:30:852 (1) - nc
01:32:120 (1) - Remove nc
01:36:768 (10) - nc
01:35:078 (6) - nc
01:37:613 (1) - Remove nc
01:40:571 (5) - nc
01:44:374 (7) - nc
01:46:909 (3) - nc
01:49:021 (2) - nc
02:01:275 (7) - nc
02:07:613 (4) - nc
02:13:951 (5) - nc
02:34:233 (4) - nc
02:37:613 (6) - nc
02:54:726 (6) - nc


[Hard]

00:43:106 (2,3,4,5) - Spacing
01:21:768 - Add a beat here
01:34:867 (7) - This is pretty hidden, consider moving it.
01:38:669 - Add a note here, place it on the start of (7).
01:39:937 (1) - Select and press K twice (moves it forward by 1/2) then place a single beat where the slider originally started (01:39:937)
01:57:050 (1,2,3,4,5) - This is confusing and hidden. Consider changing the pattern.
02:36:768 (2,3) - Spacing
02:53:669 (5) - Stack the end on top of the end of (4)


Combos
00:07:190 (3) - nc
00:09:514 (1) - remove nc
00:10:148 (4) - nc
00:25:993 (5) - nc
00:31:064 (7) - nc
00:53:036 (4) - nc
01:01:275 (5) - nc
01:21:979 (8) - nc
01:34:867 (7) - nc
01:46:909 (5) - nc
02:05:712 (6) - nc
02:09:726 (4) - nc
02:14:162 (6) - nc
02:34:233 (3) - nc
02:36:345 (1) - Remove nc
02:37:402 (4) - nc
02:42:895 (6) - nc
02:47:754 (5) - nc



[None]

00:14:374 - It'd be nice if you mapped this break.
00:59:585 - What's with this gap?
01:29:585 (1,2) - Confusing.
01:34:655 (5) - Spacing.
01:44:374 (4,5) - Spacing.
02:16:275 (2,3) - makes the ends stack
02:40:465 - Add a beat here.
02:42:683 (7) - nc
02:49:233 (8) - nc


I enjoyed [None] more than the others, nice maps.
Topic Starter
DampfNudel
Thanks for the Mod Hikato :)
Lucy-Kaede
Hey!
From #modreqs

General
Kiai:
I noticed your kiai times are different, they will need to all be the same if your trying to get this ranked, please change them all to be the same if so :)
Offset:
Also, the offset for "easy" is 7195 where the other two are 7191, after fixing everything else in this mod, please change the offset to 7191.
(Timing>timing panel setup>change the offset, and tick "Snap objects to new timing"

Edit:
Check with AIbat:
Combo colours:
Hard:
Combo1 : 245,159,255 Change this to 255,181,181
Combo2 : 255,181,181 Change this to 245,159,255

This will keep the combo colours consistent on every difficulty ^^



Easy
00:35:927 (5) - NC (New combo)
00:39:307 (3) - NC
00:46:068 (4) - NC
00:47:335 (x) - Add a note to better fit the rythm/lyrics.
00:49:025 (x) - Add a note :)
00:49:448 (5) - New combo! Especially for the beginning of a kiai time :3
00:56:209 (7) - NC
01:19:871 (4) - NC
01:30:011 (9) - NC, and swap this from a single hit circle to a slider ending at 01:30:434.
Something similar to this should suffice :)

01:32:124 (1) - I would move/rearrange this so that its not under the previous slider, doesn't look so good being hidden D:
01:35:082 (5) - NC
01:36:772 (5) - NC
01:37:617 (1) - Remove combo (RNC)
01:41:842 (8) - NC
01:42:265 (1) - RNC
01:45:223 (7) - NC
01:50:293 (7) - Add a note here, with a finish hitsound. (AFTER fixing everything, and the offset: Add a timing point here so the finish is at 40% volume, then make sure to add another point afterwards to bring the volume back up to 80%)
01:59:166 (2) - NC
02:01:702 (6,7) - These look okay, but are pretty confusing for an easy, I would recommend using another shaped slider here.
02:07:617 (5) - NC
02:09:307 (5,6,7,1,2) - I would not recommend using back-and-forth beats in an easy difficulty, it can be very confusing for new/easy players, I would change this out for another nice pattern :) - (Pattern is nice, but confusing for easy ;))
02:14:800 (6) - NC
02:46:068 (8) - NC
02:54:096 (5) - I would move this note from under (3).
02:54:730 (6,7,8,9,10) - Select all these notes, and "edit>flip vertically", then move them further away from (5)
02:54:730 (6) - Also, new combo here.

Sorry for all the combo mods, but I think they are necessary. Feel free to ignore them though. This map had some really nice slider shapes too :)

Hard
The combos here could still be improved, but much more suitable then on easy :)
Just listed a few that I think should really be changed, the rest i'll leave and you can see others opinions ^^
00:48:388 (x) - Add a note? ._.
00:53:036 (4) - New combo
00:53:247 (2) - Consider selecting this slider, and pressing ctrl+r, I think this combo plays nicer like this.

00:54:303 (5,6,7) -
It looked nicer if:
00:54:303 (5) - x:256 y:148
00:54:514 (6,7) - x:256 y:64
01:29:796 (x) - Could add a note here if desired.

01:32:120 (2,3) - Wow, this is a nice fit :D

01:36:768 (6) - Move this up a tiny bit so it doesn't overlap (5), but fits nicely around it. (Might need to slightly adjust anchor points
01:41:838 (6) - New combo
01:42:683 (1) - Remove combo
01:54:303 (4,1) - You should map the space in between here I think. Possibly 2 hit circles, or extend the spinner?
02:02:331 (1) - Move this note. Being stacked at the end of two sliders, it is very hard to determine whether it is a hit circle, the left slider, or the right slider.
02:05:712 (6) - New combo

Once again, really nice sliders!
I'm starting to lose concentration though, so i'll just do these 2 diffs :(

Nice work!
Oh, and I have this cool little star thingy, you can have it if you want ^^
Topic Starter
DampfNudel
@Lucy-Kaede
Thanks *~*
Fixed :P
Stefan
Modding~~

[General]:
-) Ich hasse Anime-Girl-BGs wie die Pest: Zu overused und absolut unpassend zu so einem Lied. Sorry, ist meine Meinung.
Es gibt sicher viel Besseres als das. Versuch zumindest etwas Besseres zu finden.
-) Mp3 und BG sind vom Format ok.
-) Das Offset.. warum setzt du es nicht bei 434? Hat den selben Effekt wie dein Jetziges.

[Easy]:
Combofarbe 1 und 2 sind zu ähnlich. Kann irritierend wirken.
00:06:349 - Setz einen Inherited Point bis 00:07:088, wo die Lautstärke 5% ist. Passt gut zur Musik.
00:06:349 (1) - Finish beim Endpunkt.
00:12:687 (4) - ^
00:24:096 (3) - Clap beim Startpunkt.
00:26:631 (6,1) - Ob solche 1/2 Beats für einen Easy ok sind, bezweifle ich.. (6) ist ok. Aber das dann (1) auch beim 1/2 Beat liegt.
00:26:631 (1) - NC.
00:27:054 (1) - Clap beim Startpunkt. Kein NC.
00:28:744 (2) - Finish.
00:32:547 (1) - Clap beim Endpunkt.
00:35:927 (5) - Finish beim Startpunkt. Und NC.
00:39:307 (3) - Clap beim Endpunkt.
00:41:842 (5) - Clap.
00:45:223 (3) - Whistle.
00:49:448 (6) - NC. Und Finish beim Start- und Endpunkt.
00:53:251 (1) - Keine NC.
00:54:518 (4) - NC.
00:54:518 (1,3) - Clap.
00:56:209 (4) - NC und Finish beim Startpunkt.
01:01:279 (3,4) - Clap.
01:19:871 (4) - NC.
01:21:561 (2) - Clap beim Endpunkt.
01:22:828 (4) - Clap beim Startpunkt.
01:25:786 (2) - Whistle.
01:27:899 (4) - NC.
01:30:011 (9) - NC und Finish.
01:30:011 - 01:50:293 - Kiai Time.
01:32:124 (1) - Der Endpunkt überlappt nicht den Startpunkt von (2). Sieht nicht schön aus. :<
01:35:082 (5) - NC.
01:35:504 (2) - Clap.
01:36:349 (4) - ^
01:36:772 (5) - NC
01:37:617 (1) - Entfern NC.
01:41:842 (8) - NC.
01:42:265 (1) - Entfern NC und Clap beim Start- und Endpunkt.
01:43:533 (3) - NC.
01:46:913 (9) - NC.

Hmm.. Irgendwie wirkt dein Diff sehr unfertig.. Kann sein, dass die Map IMO nicht gefällt. Aber was wichtig ist, keine allzu langen Combos zu machen. +8er Combos bei Easys sind krank. Und wirst du fast garnicht bis garnicht finden, weil man den Diff für Anfänger "noob-friendly" macht. Komisch, dass niemand davor viel zu den Combos gemacht hat. O_o
Den Post musst du nicht kd'en, wenn er für dich sinnlos war. Falls deine Map ein wenig überarbeitet wird, mach ich einen Re-Check.
Topic Starter
DampfNudel
@TheNutritiousGuy

Danke aber der mod hilft mir nix atm sry D:
Please sign in to reply.

New reply