Excellent chart, it has some really nice slider work put into it. It doesn't seem to much out at the end for me but who knows. It follows the song really well and is enjoyable to play, also the song choice was nice. 4 suggestions though
- More of a personally preference but I think the sliders were a bit too fast for the style of the song. But don't worry about changing it now since you would have to replace all the sliders in the song and basically ruin all the nice work.
- I'm not sure if this is true but all the sliders seem to be using the Catmull-Rom curve type. Even though you made very good sliders if you wanted the curves to be smoother rather than a corner you can switch the type to Bezier in the Options menu.
- The ending section is slightly too hard compared to the rest of the song making it feel out of place. But this is probably because I really suck at holds with the mouse
- It got better as the song went on but the first minute or two of the song was probably a slight bit too repetitve for my liking. It's a good thing you flipped or mirrored the patterns to add variety though.
Overall I would give this probably a 7.5 maybe 8 out of 10! Great job
Last edited by [deleted user] , edited 1 times in total.
Being a Jay Chou fan, it's awesome to see someone make a Jay Chou beatmap. I was surprised that such a slow tempo song would be difficult (for me). I agree with peppy that the timing seems slightly off, but otherwise, it's a great beatmap.
I was just thinking about beatmapping Jay Chou! I might make a beatmap for Jay Chou's Ninja or another of his songs when uni doesn't take up so much of my life. Also, I might have the video for this song somewhere, maybe I'll pass it onto peppy in the future.
Very nice map. As MCXD said, it may be a little repetitive, but it's still quite challenging. I'm glad map makers aren't neglecting the slower paced songs even though the game is probably more suited to faster songs with strong beats.
Looking forward to seeing more Chinese/HK stuff from you. Maybe some Jacky?
Strongly thanks for all replies, I am glad to see many feedbacks!
Yes the timing is not very accurate. I adjusted the bpm for number of times and still can't make it perfect... I am not good at beat counting =[ I will modify the beatmap so not to make it too repetitive and make the last part a little bit easier !~