Leorda wrote:

Hiiii

General
* Your bg dimension is 959x767, you need to resize to 1024x768
* There are 2 osb files in this mapset, remove the wrong one both fixed

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Amateur
00:09:044 (2) - I think wave slider is better (Nazi) idk, i still feel like keeping this
00:10:461 (2) - ^
01:06:423 ~ 01:06:777 (T) - 5 inherited timing points? For what? LOL i forgot to delete those. I used to have those in my extreme diff, but from some self modding i removed them, but i totally forgot about them in amateur
02:09:115 (1,1) - Uhhh, 2 spinner? Is that necessary? Well, I recommended replace the 1st spinner into a single slider (I guess so) k sure
02:13:719 (1) - Too far from spinner for easy diff, make it closer to spinner. Otherwise, the beginners will sometimes hard to reach this object while gameplay now that there's about 3 measures of a spinner, i think there should be enough time for the beginner to react.

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Gabex3's Hard
* Please map the beginning, break and end part, like winber-chan's diff Gabex3 has completely remappe dhis diff, so yea
* AR -1, your current approach rate it's feels bit fast

00:32:421 (1,2,3) - I don't think this jump is fit to song....
00:35:254 (1,2,3,4) - I feel this jump kinda unbalanced, and it's makes players go confusing
01:06:423 ~ 01:06:777 (T) - 5 inherited timing points? For what?
02:09:115 (3) - This notes is getting offscreen

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Extreme
00:25:515 (4) - Unsnapped note
00:36:672 (3) - ^
00:42:162 (2) - ^
00:42:339 (3) - ^
00:40:567 (5,6,7) - This sudden jump can makes players go confusing this is a jumpy map and i feel the players will understand this, if they can at least beat this song.
00:44:640 (4,5) - I feel this jump are too far, since this has a high BPM. Reduce it? i kinda like this big jump, but i am not that attached to the pattern, so if it becomes a huge problem i may change it
01:43:083 (5) - Unsnapped note
01:43:260 (6) - ^
01:43:437 (7) - ^ fixed all unsnapped notes

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Bye niiiii

Byakugan249 wrote:

Yo modding this map because of ur request

General:
can u put an audio lead in. probably between 1000-2000?

Amateur:
00:21:795(1,1) - since this is the easiest diff beginners wont hav enough time to recover for this. end the spinner at 00:23:920 so that it follows "Felt"? sorry, the auto gets 13k on this spiner i feel that that is probably enough time for even a beginner to clear this spinner in time. Also, the next note is fairly close to the center
00:39:859(3,4) - for (3) align it to the end of (2) to make it easier for beginners and for (4) how about flipping it like This? 00:35:608 (1,2,3,4) - That pattern is supposed to be symmetrical to this one and i don't want to get rid of that, and it seems fine. I don't think it would make it harder to read.
01:18:465(2) - Ctrl+H for an easier path? hmm i kinda like how this looks tho
02:09:115(1,1) - end the spinner at 02:11:948, move the slider to 02:13:365 and add a circle at 02:14:428 there's definitely enough time for a beginner to clear this spinner and move on to the next note

EXTREEMMME:(Fairly odd parents reference) oh man, good old times.
00:44:109(1-8) - u dont need to change this but i havent seen this jump pattern in a while. this kind of jump pattern is my favorite
00:54:380(2,3,6,7) - why dont u make this a slider so that every combo makes a pattern. for example the 1st combo has a slider and then the next combo has a circle. i kinda like the way i positioned these things
01:42:019 - add a circle? no sorry
02:06:813(3) - move it down because its touching the Hp bar ok
02:16:907(5) - same as above but its because its touching the score at the top right i don't think that matters as much

this is the best i can do. GL

_Gezo_ wrote:

D-POST

Taiko

Slider velocity is a tad too high. I have no trouble with SV 1,42 but 1,40fags would yell at you if this isn't 1,40. Set it to 1,40. ok, someone suggested to just use 1.4 throughout the map so i did, but ok. fixed all below
Suggestions for your HS changes (=SV)

1. 00:24:274 - 1,20x
2. 00:34:900 - Delete it.
3. 00:35:608 - Delete it.
4. 00:44:109 - 0,60 or 0,75x
5. 00:49:776 - 0,80 or 0,87x
6. 00:55:443 - Add one at 1,00x
7. 01:01:110 - 1,20x
8. 01:12:090 - Delete it.
9. 01:12:444 - Delete it.
10. 01:23:778 - 0,80x
11. 01:36:529 - 1,00x
12. 01:47:863 - 0,75x
13. 02:13:365 - 1,00x
14. 02:24:345 - Delete it.
15. 02:24:699 - 1,20x
16. 02:30:366 - 1,00x

00:21:795 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,1) - This stream is plain random and doesn't fit AT ALL. I suggest deleting it and putting either a spinner or a slider covering all the stream.
Make sure there are no finishes in the streams that are >5 notes (If not kk[...]kkkK or dd[...]dddD)
Delete Epilepsy Warning.
At some parts like the beginning, try to stick to 1/2s.

Amateur

AR - 1 ? (3 3 3 3 setting) ok
01:12:798 (2) - I don't really say if this fits to 01:12:444 (1)'s AC but I found that moving the 2nd control point (1st = circle itself) would fit it better. im not exactly sure what you're saying, but i blanketed combo 2 better if that's wat you mean
22. Offset: 112 822ms BPM: Inhereted (1x) deleted
23. Offset: 113 176ms BPM: Inhereted (1x)
^ Those two seem useless.

EX

00:46:942 (1,1) - Same as Gabe's Hard. That'd be a waste to use a spinner for such awesome stuff i guess, changed a bit orz I always typo such in suck orz
01:23:424 (8,1) - The reason why you did a taiko (... yeah. Random 1/8s are a lil' annoying imo but since you made a Taiko I'm going to forgive you ) Oh, lol never thot about that. well i liked this slider and I don't feel it's that random, but if worse comes to worst i will delete it, but for now it will stay.
02:21:866 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - I also map this way T_T hmm? well i don't really map like this often, I was trying out different things

Personals opinions and other stuff

This map is awesome excluding some stuff concerning Taiko Oni (Since it's your first attempt I'll say it is still very good) but I got a very high amount of lag on my side (Modding around 16-25 FPS).
I'm also going to make a cool Taiko background. If you still want Miku on the BG, please send me a Forum PM about it. I'm very picky about pictures, so you won't be disappointed !

Byakugan249 wrote:

Yo modding this map because of ur request

Gabex3's Hard:
00:06:565(1) - replace this for 2 circles because it felt odd when i played this Fixed.
00:31:712(4) - *nazi* align this to (3) and make it point in the opposite direction of (3). it should be like This if u dont understand Fixed, is it better like this? http://puu.sh/d7d1
01:35:821(1,2,3,4) - this slider combo is better if it wer an insane diff. but since this is a hard diff replace these for a slider that ends at 01:36*:175 Fixed.

_Gezo_ wrote:

D-POST

Gabe's Hard

See I didn't say Gabex lol. YAY FINALLY SOMEONE THAT DOESNT SAY GABEX. :C. I like you Gezo é.é.
I use Grid size 3. Some of my grid mods are using this size so some spacings should be fixed.
00:37:734 (5) - 2 ticks up, please :U
00:46:942 (1) - I suggest deleting the spinner and map from 00:46:588 to 00:48:359 (ended either by a long slider or a spinner if you don't see any pattern for the slider. No é.é, I like it in that way. ;c
01:24:841 (5) - New combo. (y)
02:01:854 (2) - 1 grid D+L
02:10:532 (1) - Same as 00:46:942 (1) <___< ...
02:17:261 (2) - 1 grid D. Do the same for 02:18:678 (4,5,1).

I don't get it ô.o'

Wiinter wrote:

Modding as requested~

General
consider adding 'everytime we touch' to tags, since it's the song's original album ok
the audioleadin isn't the same in all diffs (you gotta change the one in [Gabex3's Hard] to 1500. you can do that manually opening the diffs .osu file) k
you also gotta keep the tags consistent in all diffs (need to change the one in [Gabex31's Hard] -aka remove nightcore and add "gabex3") and enable epilepsy warning on Gabex3's diff.
use the same kiai times that were used in the other diffs on [Taiko Oni]
no offense, but the sb looks kinda weird with the black thing in the end. why don't you use some image there? >: gotta talk to gabe about that. I originally didn't really want an SB, but Gabe offered and I said if he really wanted to make one, I wouldn't mind. I actually just wanted my original hatsune miku background as an SB, but now there's a whole lot of them, but oh well. so much hatsune miku ahhhhhhhhhh
huge difficulty gap between the two first diffs. I suggest you to map a normal no really. The difficulty gap between hard and extreme is just as much, if not bigger.

[Extreme]
the following notes are unsnapped: there doesn't actually seemed to be unsnapped notes, but i guess i just resnapped just in case lol
00:36:672 (3)
00:42:162 (2)
00:42:339 (3)
01:43:083 (5)
01:43:260 (6)
01:43:437 (7)
---
00:18:252 (2) - new combo here suits better than at 00:17:190 (1) imo k
00:54:646 (5) - add new combo? no sorry, i wnat the new combos every measure here
01:38:654 (3) - ctrl+r it? looks better imo no sorry
anyways.. i wasn't a really big fan of some triplets, such as 00:36:672 (3,4,5) and 00:41:630 (3,4,5). but that's just me

that's all

[Ryuu] wrote:

hello ~
from our queue.
all suggestions.

the main volume is too loud. could make quieter? ok

[Amateur]

00:24:274 - may make this?
no sorry, i'd rather have the spinner end on a note

[Extreme]
I want my new combos to be on the white ticks, all of these start the new combo earlier, so no sorry
00:34:900 (6) - nc
01:06:423 (4) - ^
01:06:778 (1) - delete nc
01:17:669 (7) - nc
01:18:111 (1) - delete nc
01:19:351 (11) - nc
01:19:528 (1) - delete nc
01:20:768 (7) - nc
01:20:945 (1) - delete nc
01:22:185 (6) - nc
01:22:362 (1) - delete nc
01:42:108 (8) - nc
01:42:196 (1) - delete nc
02:18:678 (4) - nc
02:19:033 (1) - delete nc
02:29:924 (7) - nc
02:30:366 (1) - delete nc
02:31:606 (6) - nc
02:31:783 (1) - delete nc
02:33:023 (7) - nc
02:33:200 (1) - delete nc
02:34:440 (6) - nc
02:34:617 (1) - delete nc

good luck :3

ikari_kyon wrote:

taiko mod ovo

sounds very nice, your standard skills are reflected here, but to someone that have no taiko skills there is some stuff that taiko players are not going to like, keep this taiko diff is very good and funny, well lets mod :p

-the most important stuff that I disliked are those slowdown, are so sudden and confusing, see screen
that katsu (blue note) on the barline is part of the previous stream and is absolutely confusing, a comparition on standard difficulty is having a spacing wrong, I mean a 5 notes stream, 4 notes near and the last note placed to x2,0 spacing
-other stuff that I disliked are the 4 notes stream, dont fit to song and are on weird places

00:04:705 (3) - make this a don, that katsu is awful to ears and fingers
00:08:690 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - beautiful ;_;
00:27:905 (7) - that 4 notes stream dont sounds good plus feels weird on incoming double, delete the indicated note to have a nice dk kd k dk kd
00:30:738 (7) - delete please ;_;
00:39:593 (10) - move to previous white tick, then you have a nice 5 notes streamD: but it follows my hitsound pattern. I kinda want to keep this, but idk. adsfsadfagasdf
00:55:000 (7) - move 1 tick before, makes a nice double and a reasonable 5 notes streams incomingim trying to follow the music here so i'm keeping it, but if there is some other huge important taiko thing that i'm missing feel free to point that out.
00:55:443 (1) - and here is the main disagree, Im not a big fan of velocity change on taiko, anyway please change this speed up to 00:55:089 or 00:55:620
01:21:122 (2,3,4,5) - this 4 notes streams are nice here <: keep this and the incoming
01:50:697 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - awesome ;_;
02:13:365 - velocity change again >_<
if i didn't comment it means i fixed it
I hope this help ;_;
star for become a new taiko mapper :3

wmfchris wrote:

checking Taiko diff here:

[General]
Title/tag/source
- wrong tags in [Hard]
- (duplicated timeline in 150366 for [Hard])
Settings & arrangment
- inconsistancy in audio lead-in in [Hard]
- flashy warning for [hard]

[Taiko]
Timing & settings
BG:
I guess the title of the song is a bit covered? How about moving that line downwards slightly? oh... umm,i can fix that? maybe. I didn't any of these taiko backgrounds or SB or anything, but it's probably not a big problem. I'll see what i can do later.
SV change: Just can't understand it's "0.75->-0.8->1.0->1.2* Better put a smoother change like *0.7->0.85->1.0->1.2* to emphasize the change in loudness.

00:21:439 - I prefer placing the last note before the spinner in order to make a complete sentence in taiko, try kkddk then spinner? Kk/color]
00:44:107 - the music change from rock to a nearly vocal solo, but imo it don't need a large SV change, like 1.0x is enough for me. Otherwise it may cause a little confusion for reading d ddk as dddk at the bridging point as well.
01:53:528 - suggestion: k d k k d d K d? feeling that the white tick (where it sings "boy---") is stronger than the next notek
02:35:589 - try kdkkdk to fit with the music better? ok

in overall it fits the music very well, though more variation can be make based on the music <3