bakabaka wrote:

心理覺得善良~圖也會變鬼畜的

1. 00:24:670 (1,1) - 這樣排不好吧.. 這樣? http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/206453
2. 00:46:366 (3) - 被擋到了
3. 01:21:723 ~ 01:23:866加些note?
4. 02:17:437 - Add a note?

1. 00:53:464 (6) - Clap
2. 01:08:866 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - 要排星星嗎? 要的話排好點吧....
3. 03:08:598 (11) - Clap

1. 00:49:045 (2) - 前面兩個折返Whistle 不要Clap
2. 01:10:473 (4) - ^
3. 01:55:473 (2) - ^
4. 02:15:295 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3) - 太花了吧....改改排版?
5. 02:16:902 (1) - 一樣同第1條
6. 03:17:170 (3) - 不要finish 加whistle
7. 03:25:741 (6,7) - Clap

256,96,164491,2,0,B|176:112|104:80,1,150
56,24,164893,1,0
32,96,165027,1,4

ertyukjh010 wrote:

Ertyukjh010's modding ><"

Spinboxer

AR-1 OD+1? HP也調高一點... （我對這些數值的概念很弱，只是覺得AR OD HP太極端了，平衡一下比較好
00:26:277 (x) - 同Normal；不過似乎是組員之間共識了0.0? 那就別改了（炸
00:54:536 (2) - 不好看....
02:04:045 (4) - 換成2個Circle，跟前面一樣
02:53:866 (5) - Slider的第2和第4白點重疊，不然按Ctrl+H會看到不對稱（好吧，我其實在找渣~
03:04:580 (1) - 別偷懶，刪掉1個轉盤 你不懂 Baka當初找我作的是Normal阿!親
03:27:616 (1,3) - 這對Slider也不好看

Nymph wrote:

Hi Nymph here


Spinboxer:
Issues
HP和OD未免太低了。。这绝对会被吐槽。。
顺便问一下 这个难度算hard还是normal？ 节奏大概是normal的节奏 排列和SV像Hard 那几个变速重叠可以算I了 這你要問Baka 當初我作的時候爆表了 便成Hard 後來baka說 ma...也行
02:08:866 (1) - newcombo bug又来了 加newcombo 恩

Beatmap design/suggestion
00:24:670 (1,1) - 我实在不觉得这个有必要叠在一起 看着和玩起来都不是很好 而且新人估计不少会发蒙
00:40:473 (1,2,3,1,1,2,1,2,1) - 这样的变速slider加重叠 我觉得已经算Insane的范畴了 在normal diff里面的话 我觉得实在非常危险
02:10:071 (4,5) - 这节奏我实在是搞不懂 尤其4的位置 fix
02:59:759 (5,6,1,2) - 这样的spacing不用Y轴做个对称嗎 fix

Hitsound
这hitsound不行啊。。太应付了 我强烈建议remap hitsound 现在这一点氛围都没 改了大小聲了

376,200,106634,2,0,B|336:296|336:296|272:256|224:320|160:232,1,280

• 
  KIAI seems not consistent...but that's fine since all diffs are made by different mappers.
  If you can, please consider it but I don't force you.

1. 01:00:295 (1,1) - There is too short time after a spinner. Remove 01:02:705 (1) or try the pattern below?
   
2. 01:53:866 (1) - Yes, actually this slider follows the vocal correctly, but I recommend you to changed it to 3/4-length-slider with one repeat because many-repeat-slider is kinda hard for newbie to read in easiest difficulty.
   
3. 02:05:920 (4) - Add new combo.
4. 02:06:723 (1,1) - Fix as well as above.
5. 03:36:723 (1) - Clap sound fits the music too, but I recommend you to use finish instead of it as well as other diffs.

• 
  You should try HP+2, OD+2. Current set is too low as hard difficulty.

1. 00:41:812 (1) - I think it's not good idea that you use x0.50 SV here. It's better to use x0.75.
2. 00:43:955 (1) - ^
3. 00:46:366 (3) - Don't put a note under the slidertracks. It's hidden and hard to read.
4. 01:02:437 (2) - Add finish to the top of slider.
5. 01:44:491 (1) - Using x0.50 SV is kinda confusing...yes please change it to x0.75.
6. 01:48:241 (1) - As well as previous same pattern.
7. 01:50:384 (1) - ^
8. 02:08:866 (1) - Add finish.

1. 01:16:902 (4,5,6) - Try the pattern below, I feel that one fits the music more.
   
2. 01:34:580 (10) - Add new combo please.
3. 01:38:866 (6) - ^
4. 01:43:152 (7) - ^
5. 02:15:295 (6) - ^ as well as previous chorus.
6. 02:19:580 (6) - ^
7. 02:25:205 (10) - ^
8. 02:56:277 (9) - ^ \:D/
9. 03:15:295 (7) - ^
10. 03:19:580 (6) -

1. 00:34:580 (1,1,1) - I feel clap sound doesn't fit here.
2. 00:41:812 (3,1) - It's kinda hard to read them (I guess players will misread (1) as it's at 00:42:348). I recommend you to put a note at 00:42:348 or remove (1).
3. 00:43:955 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - 2-2-2 rhythm should start on whitle line, that's more fun and easier to play. Try to add a note at 00:45:161, and then try the formation below.
   
   SPOILER

   
4. 00:54:268 (2,1,2,3) - Oh, the rhythm is kinda weird, try one below.
   
5. 01:51:723 (1) - You should add finish :3
6. 02:17:437 (3) - ^
7. 02:21:723 (3) - Add new combo as well as previous pattern (01:15:295 (1)).
8. 02:50:652 (1,3) - Try Ctrl+R, and then...
9. 02:50:786 (2,4) - ^ also try Ctrl+R. I think the counterclockwise flow is good, but on current formation, it's kinda hard to read (2).
10. 03:36:857 (1,2,1,2) - I think you should put a note at 03:36:857, and then try to make same pattern after it. (and also reduce a repeat at 03:37:795 (2)). That will create better rhythm imo.
    
    SPOILER

    

Suzully wrote:

From my modding queue.

[Spinboxer]

• 
  You should try HP+2, OD+2. Current set is too low as hard difficulty. OK

1. 00:41:812 (1) - I think it's not good idea that you use x0.50 SV here. It's better to use x0.75. sorry I can't do this because 00:41:009 (2,3,1) - is entirety shape. so sorry I caan't
2. 00:43:955 (1) - ^ ^
3. 00:46:366 (3) - Don't put a note under the slidertracks. It's hidden and hard to read. add newcombo can let it more readable so just add newcombo
4. 01:02:437 (2) - Add finish to the top of slider. sure :3
5. 01:44:491 (1) - Using x0.50 SV is kinda confusing...yes please change it to x0.75. OK
6. 01:48:241 (1) - As well as previous same pattern. same ;_;
7. 01:50:384 (1) - ^ ^
8. 02:08:866 (1) - Add finish. OK

Suzully wrote:

[Insane]

1. 00:34:580 (1,1,1) - I feel clap sound doesn't fit here.
   I think It's ok. sorry for ignore this. lol
2. 00:41:812 (3,1) - It's kinda hard to read them (I guess players will misread (1) as it's at 00:42:348). I recommend you to put a note at 00:42:348 or remove (1).
   I try to find some player to test this part. but them didn't feel unreadable for this part. so sorry I
   don't want >.<
3. 00:43:955 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - 2-2-2 rhythm should start on whitle line, that's more fun and easier to play. Try to add a note at 00:45:161, and then try the formation below.
   
   SPOILER

   
   Good idea!
4. 00:54:268 (2,1,2,3) - Oh, the rhythm is kinda weird, try one below.
   
   Um... I think not weird. because It's really fit in this way In my option
5. 01:51:723 (1) - You should add finish :3
6. 02:17:437 (3) - ^
7. 02:21:723 (3) - Add new combo as well as previous pattern (01:15:295 (1)).
8. 02:50:652 (1,3) - Try Ctrl+R, and then...
9. 02:50:786 (2,4) - ^ also try Ctrl+R. I think the counterclockwise flow is good, but on current formation, it's kinda hard to read (2).
10. 03:36:857 (1,2,1,2) - I think you should put a note at 03:36:857, and then try to make same pattern after it. (and also reduce a repeat at 03:37:795 (2)). That will create better rhythm imo.
    
    SPOILER

    
    fixed for all other :33

Suzully wrote:

[wcx's Normal]

1. 01:00:295 (1,1) - There is too short time after a spinner. Remove 01:02:705 (1) or try the pattern below?
   I think it is fine as a Normal diff , anyway the spinner is long enough , players have time to notise what to do after the spinner imo
   
2. 01:53:866 (1) - Yes, actually this slider follows the vocal correctly, but I recommend you to changed it to 3/4-length-slider with one repeat because many-repeat-slider is kinda hard for newbie to read in easiest difficulty.
   I think this is fine , the slider is not too short to see the back arrows , and its direction shows it has many repeats
   
3. 02:05:920 (4) - Add new combo.
   fixed
4. 02:06:723 (1,1) - Fix as well as above.
   same as I said
5. 03:36:723 (1) - Clap sound fits the music too, but I recommend you to use finish instead of it as well as other diffs.
   fixed