MkGuh wrote:

I wonder now if I should remap my diff or not. I did that completely on purpose (and yes I know this is far from my usual mapping), I don't think aesthetics (slider shapes etc) are important at all in gameplay, players wouldn't notice it (cuz they know nothing about good visual looking maps) as long as the diff plays okay on rhythm and flow (Which I think it does)

Thanks for saying you don't expected a map of mine being unpolished and unexperient btw :V but I'll wait for some more opinions before remapping (including ezek's one if possible) and then we'll see

Also I didn't check the mod, I'll do it later. Just checked your overall opinion on the diff.

Shmiklak wrote:

Good to see that you decided to remap your difficulty. Shooting a Kudosu star.

ezek wrote:

This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Monday, February 12, 2018 at 6:06:38 PM

Artist: The Outfield
Title: Your Love
Tags: 80s 80's tonight Blue Dragon Mismagius CrystilonZ BeatOfTheDragon botd HappyRocket88 ReFaller Xanandra ErufenRito MkGuh gta grand theft auto vice city Luvdic 50 first dates adventureland sing star
BPM: 129.5
Filesize: 22659kb
Play Time: 03:27
Difficulties Available:

1. High (3.05 stars, 462 notes)
2. Love Collab (4.31 stars, 577 notes)
3. Medium (1.95 stars, 352 notes)
4. Mk's Low (1.63 stars, 213 notes)

Download: The Outfield - Your Love
Download: The Outfield - Your Love (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
for that cute girl who is always crying
BG source: https://pajunen.deviantart.com/art/Nigh ... -618257821

Collab Insane:
BeatOfTheDragon
ezek
HappyRocket88
CrystilonZ
ReFaller
Mismagius (aka your favorite blue-colored dragon)
Luvdic (aka ErufenRito / Xanandra)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbbJ_yzwAvM

ezek wrote:

use this button next time pls

Updated~

1. 00:06:595 (4,5) - space this out more, contrasts heavily with the spacing prior and would give a nice emphasis on the rhythm change
2. 00:20:958 (4,2) - stack did an oopsie here
3. 00:29:530 (1) - nc isn't really necessary here
4. 00:44:839 (2) - move nc here instead for the downbeat
5. 00:49:240 (4,5) - move 5 down a bit more? kinda looks ugly with the way the overlap is right now
6. 00:51:789 (4,1) - this is REALLY big compared to other 1/4 rhythms mapped previously, even if it is the kiai, nerf this a bit
7. 01:16:345 (1,2,3) - same thing, the 1/4 gaps here are really large compared to everything else lol
8. 01:19:124 (3,4) - would nerf this spacing to signify that it's a different rhythm compared to the 1/2 rhythm
9. 01:20:051 (1,3) - not really a big concern but having these directly overlap looks, playability-wise, really weird since before the first slider even finishes the third one appears, would probably be better to change 3 or something
10. 01:35:800 (3) - honestly should be no repeat and a note on the white tick here, skipping the very noticeable snare here feels really off for the rhythm of the song zz
11. 01:43:209 (3) - especially this one, this would be much better off as 1/1 for vocals since the drum is practically impossible to follow accurately here
12. 01:51:543 (5) - nc this and also move 01:57:100 (2) - nc here for consistency (every downbeat is nced basically in the map)
13. 02:20:483 (2,3) - this would be better off as a slider, but also in general 02:19:325 (3,1) - i feel like this is way overemphasized since the only other time the song has this spacing is 02:12:843 (1,2,1,2) - here, probably would be better reducing the spacing here
14. 02:27:197 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - intensity noticeably changes here but these are kept at a constant spacing?? should decrease 02:26:965 (1,2,3) - for these since it's less emphasized than the snares before it
15. 02:29:512 (3,6) - shouldn't this be a semi-stack and not a direct stack like the others?
16. 02:42:940 (3,4) - there's nothing that emphasizes 3 more over the other notes, and it keeps the same rhythm so i'm not really sure why you decide to go from 3-note patterns to a 4-note here to begin with :s

Shmiklak wrote:

Mismagius

1. 01:59:878 (1,1) - these NCs are useless because the other NCs in this part are placed for tacts and not for vocals, place it here instead 02:00:804 - makes sense
2. 02:13:074 (2) - spacing is kinda overused here because the sound is much weaker than the previous one but it has the same spacing makes sense to me

some sort of overdone old style Insane difficulty. Didn't really enjoy it while modding. yeah uh thats kind of my style lol

deadpon3 wrote:

01:15:881 (5,2) - the slider shapes look odd with such overlap, I know there's not much place for different patterns so I suggest to just stack these 2 sliders instead, looks less improvised

Good point, will do that
01:20:051 (1,2,3) - imo you could unstack the 2 sliders on the right for more movement and better reading

z

Fixed.

Shmiklak wrote:

• 
  BeatOfTheDragon

1. 01:17:735 (4,5) - 3/4 slider would fit better here because the sound on 01:17:966 - doesn't have any differ with other sounds in this part while all of them were ignored and this one isn't. Good point, will fix.
2. This 1/3 repeat slider 01:22:831 (3) - don't really fit the map. Better replace it with 1/2 slider. The reason I chose to use the 1/3 slider is because I map according to the vocals. 1/3 sliders fits this the best. Without 01:22:831 (3), 01:19:124 (3) would seem random and inconsistent as it is the only 1/3 slider if 01:22:831 (3) was replaced.
3. 02:44:329 (3,5) - the blanket could be polished I suppose, but it's not an issue. I personally find it fine.

fieryrage wrote:

1. 01:16:345 (1,2,3) - same thing, the 1/4 gaps here are really large compared to everything else lol Fixed, switched the head and tail of second slider and moved the first slider a bit lower so transition is smooth.
2. 01:19:124 (3,4) - would nerf this spacing to signify that it's a different rhythm compared to the 1/2 rhythm I see what you mean, but it's already done as the spacing between those two objects are relatively shorter compared to 01:18:893 (2,3) which is 1/2.
3. 01:20:051 (1,3) - not really a big concern but having these directly overlap looks, playability-wise, really weird since before the first slider even finishes the third one appears, would probably be better to change 3 or something Fixed.

niviago wrote:

ezek wrote:

This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on Monday, February 12, 2018 at 6:06:38 PM

Artist: The Outfield
Title: Your Love
Tags: 80s 80's tonight Blue Dragon Mismagius CrystilonZ BeatOfTheDragon botd HappyRocket88 ReFaller Xanandra ErufenRito MkGuh gta grand theft auto vice city Luvdic 50 first dates adventureland sing star
BPM: 129.5
Filesize: 22659kb
Play Time: 03:27
Difficulties Available:

1. High (3.05 stars, 462 notes)
2. Love Collab (4.31 stars, 577 notes)
3. Medium (1.95 stars, 352 notes)
4. Mk's Low (1.63 stars, 213 notes)

Download: The Outfield - Your Love
Download: The Outfield - Your Love (no video)
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
for that cute girl who is always crying
BG source: https://pajunen.deviantart.com/art/Nigh ... -618257821

Collab Insane:
BeatOfTheDragon
ezek
HappyRocket88
CrystilonZ
ReFaller
Mismagius (aka your favorite blue-colored dragon)
Luvdic (aka ErufenRito / Xanandra)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CbbJ_yzwAvM

fieryrage wrote:

i tried

collab

1. 00:29:530 (1) - nc isn't really necessary here yeah
2. 01:35:800 (3) - honestly should be no repeat and a note on the white tick here, skipping the very noticeable snare here feels really off for the rhythm of the song zz I tried it but the rhythm gets actually weirder if I follow the snare and the drum so idk I still belive it plays smoothly this way.
3. 01:43:209 (3) - especially this one, this would be much better off as 1/1 for vocals since the drum is practically impossible to follow accurately here same here.