tailsdk wrote:

Mod from my queue
Sorry for delay really busy atm just barely made time for this mod

Mod

[Life]
00:09:793 - would add notes on this sound /ok
00:11:126 - ^ and so on/^
00:35:459 - add note here /no
00:36:459 - ^/no
00:37:126 (37126|1,37126|2,37459|1,37459|0,37793|2,37959|1,38126|0,38126|2,38459|2,38459|1,38793|1,38793|0,39126|2,39293|1,39459|0,39459|2) - change it a little same pattern twice in a row
actually it's a of times in a row remember that it can also go this way /ok
[NM]
00:16:626 (16626|2,16626|3,16793|0,16793|1) - these can also be placed like this and still make sense http://prntscr.com/hdhlsn/?no
00:20:626 (20626|3,20626|2,20793|1,20793|0) - also you do this in the same direction many times in a row/^
[EZ]
00:11:126 - would change it to look like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9594085 just because it would feel weird to skip out on the sound compltely/OK
00:33:126 - ^/^

i only mentioned mistakes once or twice make sure to check through

Good Luck with the map

DustMoon wrote:

我觉得可以水摸一波
1|2|3|4|

NM

1.00:22:459 (22459|3,22459|0,22626|1,22793|2,22793|3,22959|1,23126|0,23126|3,23293|2,23459|1,23459|0,23626|2,23793|3) - 建议这样的排列：https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9774292这样也比你的White难度的排列简单。
2.00:43:959 (43959|2,44126|3,44126|0,44293|1,44459|2,44459|3,44626|1,44793|0,44793|3,44959|2,45126|1,45126|0) - 建议直接上对拍：https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9774315
/星数要超过N标范围了，而且这样改的我也不喜欢，不好意思都拒了，nokds

祝早飞

Sinnoh wrote:

can we stop mapping ringtone size

the song benefits so much from its buildup and conclusion, just cutting out the chorus loses so much of the song's meaning
it changes it from emotional compositions on the meaning of life to just a really repetitive song
like, it's doesn't even take that long to map this mode so I don't know why it wasn't done. /

00:04:459 (4459|2) - keysound missing for this sound multiple times/I just want to noted those obvious melodies
00:32:793 (32793|1) - reduce volume on this hitsound, high pitch note is quieter in music./OK
00:37:126 (37126|2) - feel like this should have lower pitch/I feel it just right

Also, why is volume at 5%, I'd pop but I'd rather not have another month of probation

infilect wrote:

00:04:459 (4459|2) - keysound missing for this sound multiple times/I just want to noted those obvious melodies Asking anyone else in the thread to confirm whether or not this sound should be keysounded, as from what I can tell it's very much part of the main melody.

Sinnoh wrote:

The ranking criteria does specify to use common sense, just because it's not written there doesn't mean it's 100% ok for everyone.

In addition, cutting the song to be this short doesn't allow for variation in the music, it's just one monotonous section which is quite boring to play on its own. Mapping the rest of it allows for actual variation to occur, and can let you show the world that you have some creativity, rather than just mapping the same chorus for 45 seconds./So what do you want to say? If you want me to complete mapped this song, so obviously, it is no longer possible, I am ready to rank it. To me, it does not violate the ranking criteria and the map itself is playable, is enough.

Regardless, 30% is still wayyyy too low to be audible, considering that you used 70% on drums, using 60% is more appropriate./I really dont like such a big volume, this feel just like playing a osu mode map in mania mode gameplay.

infilect wrote:

00:04:459 (4459|2) - keysound missing for this sound multiple times/I just want to noted those obvious melodies Asking anyone else in the thread to confirm whether or not this sound should be keysounded, as from what I can tell it's very much part of the main melody.

infilect wrote:

Sinnoh wrote:

The ranking criteria does specify to use common sense, just because it's not written there doesn't mean it's 100% ok for everyone.

In addition, cutting the song to be this short doesn't allow for variation in the music, it's just one monotonous section which is quite boring to play on its own. Mapping the rest of it allows for actual variation to occur, and can let you show the world that you have some creativity, rather than just mapping the same chorus for 45 seconds./So what do you want to say? If you want me to complete mapped this song, so obviously, it is no longer possible, I am ready to rank it. To me, it does not violate the ranking criteria and the map itself is playable, is enough.

Regardless, 30% is still wayyyy too low to be audible, considering that you used 70% on drums, using 60% is more appropriate./I really dont like such a big volume, this feel just like playing a osu mode map in mania mode gameplay.

Does osu mode Nominator has so much free time that can view the mania mode things?

infilect wrote:

Does osu mode Nominator has so much free time that can view the mania mode things?

error_exe777 wrote:

bit disappointed that nothing was done with spread

still believe what i said is relevant in some way. Easy is more like a beginner diff in my opinion. its got really basic patterning for 80% of the map which creates a huge gap between easy and normal.



most of the map is like this and for a new player that wants to try something harder than easy they get stuck because normal is wayyy too hard for any sort of progression when compared to easy.

despite the SR, the diff is very basic and if those 1/2 streams didnt exist then this would easily be a beginner diff, rather than an easy. honestly, even if the icon turns to a normal (what you wanted to avoid) i still believe it will be beneficial to the spread of the map tbh.

if you want you can make easy a beginner diff by changing the 1/2 streams but eh, i just recommend buffing the easy slightly, in a way that creates more of a balanced spread.

while im at it i may as well mod because i found some shit

[Easy]

00:22:459 - these rolls are a bit of a concern for me. since the rolls here are basic [4321] it is easier to play than the ones at 00:11:793 - since its a less complex pattern. the sound behind the rolls at 00:22:459 - are more prominent due to the 1/2 clap sound. in my opinion, i would prefer if the rolls at 00:22:459 - 00:43:793 - were more complex than the ones at 00:11:793 - 00:33:126 - since the strong sound is on the prior ones

00:23:793 - this is weird, why didnt you add the LNs like the other diffs? seems counter-intuitive and makes things inconsistent between diffs tbh. i highly recommend adding them since it would make things more consistent and honestly doesnt give much variation within the map and gets pretty boring to play after a while.

[Normal]

00:21:626 (21626|2,21793|1,21959|2,22126|1,22293|2) - pretty long trill which can be avoided honestly. just feels awkward to play and doesnt give much variation

[White]

00:02:626 (2626|1,2793|2,2959|1,3126|2,3293|1,3459|2,3626|1,3793|2,3959|1,4126|2,4293|1,4459|2,4626|1,4793|2,4959|1,5126|2) - holy mother of trills this is a bit long

00:06:626 (6626|2,6793|1,6959|2,7126|1,7293|2,7459|1,7626|2,7793|1) - ^^

okay there are quite a few. idk if they are intended but i guess they're not the end of the world. other than that the diff is cool

[Hitsounds]

all diffs unless specified

00:06:126 - missing keysound
00:16:793 - ^^
00:27:459 - ^^

not entirely sure why you skipped them. i mean, yeah its fainter than the others but tbh its easy to figure out the key signature and if you map it, it can bring foward the sound more while playing (a technique ive seen a few people use). i mean, i guess they're fine without but would be cool if you added them./
I think now is enough, I dont want to make a full piano hitsound when follow exactly all the rhythms.

okay i've been pretty subjective so if you disagree dont be an ass and be polite, thanks. that means anyone, not just the creator of the map.

Asherz007 wrote:

Tofu was asking for opinions when I spotted there was an unused hitsound. No direct qualifications from this, but once everything's settled on this argument the mapset is free to be re-iconed.

Unused hitsound: "C4#.wav"

For future reference, musical notation makes C#4 better than the way they've been labelled here./done.

As for the issue raised by Sinnoh, I have to agree that the hitnormal is too quiet. The idea of the hitsound is to provide feedback to the player, so when these hitsounds blend into the audio, it's more counter-intuitive than anything since the hitsound may as well not be there. I would either increase the volume from the timing point (I would say around 55-65% or so), or you could replace the hitnormal with something that has a little bit of attack at the start so that it stands out a tiny bit./60%

By the way: 00:32:793 (32793|1) - is still at 35%. Intentional?/Yes, because Sinnoh said that this hitsound was too abrupt, but it really did correspond to the original song, so I reduced the volume.

infilect wrote:

Does osu mode Nominator has so much free time that can view the mania mode things?

Nominators are free to look at whatever takes their interest, and shouldn't be shunned away from anything. Just because we are BNs for specific modes doesn't mean we're bound to just those. Please bear that in mind and avoid creating confrontational situations. Thank you.

infilect wrote:

Regardless, 30% is still wayyyy too low to be audible, considering that you used 70% on drums, using 60% is more appropriate./I really dont like such a big volume, this feel just like playing a osu mode map in mania mode gameplay.
Reminder, you're playing osu. If you want to map without hitsounds, go play a different vsrg. If you want to rank a map in osu mania, hitsounds are required to be audible.

Does osu mode Nominator has so much free time that can view the mania mode things? I had confirmed with Blocko that I would have been approved as a mania bn had I passed the activity check, questioning the validity of my opinion doesn't do anything. I'm concerned as to why you're using personal insults to defend the map, rather than reasoning.

infilect wrote:

Easy is Easy, Normal is Normal, There is no way for people is able to play Easy, then they will be able to play Normal. There must be a span between them, Or else what am I doing? A bunch of similar diffs? The point of a spread is to provide all players with something to play. For many completely new players, the easy is just too easy, and the normal is too hard. Buffing the easy accommodates for a much wider playerbase, and the spread is a valid concern.

You know, the mod after the bubbled is always annoying, But thanks, I've now calmed down The whole point of a bubble is to bring it to the attention of others, I did not expect this map to be nominated when I first looked at it a month ago and had no reason to say anything back then. If you'd like a more in-depth explanation of how the system works, I'd suggest checking this video out

Sinnoh wrote:

The point of a spread is to provide all players with something to play. For many completely new players, the easy is just too easy, and the normal is too hard. Buffing the easy accommodates for a much wider playerbase, and the spread is a valid concern.

Rather than trying to explain why the modder's and osu's system are bad, explain why your map is good. From what I've seen, the only reasons you've rejected things is either you think your opinion is correct, or our opinion is wrong. Instead, justify why the map should stay the same, and why applying these changes would make the map worse.

Litharrale wrote:

everyone talkin about spread and im just here wondering why the top diff suddenly gets 10x easier halfway through for seemingly no reason

Litharrale wrote:

Looks pretty good to me

only qualm I have is that some of the piano hitsounds are on the storyboard when they have no reason to be but since the hitnormal is so quiet, this doesn't really make a big difference.

an example would be 00:11:793 (11793|3) - in the normal

I think these should be fixed before the qual just for consistencys sake

Asherz007 wrote:

I'm assuming that the only change that's happened since the bubble is the keysounds in the Normal diff being moved to the storyboard, which is fine by me, but you probably should have confirmed that with a BN before making the change, since we need to track all of the changes made between the nominations, and changing things without notifying anyone makes it difficult for us because mappers may have changed other things in the meantime that we don't know about.

Sorry, if change i will write them in the reply

00:32:793 (32793|2) - I'm still worried about this D5 hitsound because of how quiet it is, so it does blend into the background a bit too much for my liking. I would raise the volume to 60% so that it can be heard without needing to stand out too much (this also applies to the same hitsound in the storyboard for the other diffs)/ok

The background being in a .png format makes the file unnecessarily large, more than twice the size of the .mp3 itself, so here it is again in a .jpg format which makes the file about 7 times smaller. Put this one in the folder and remove the old one, reselect the bg etc./ok, thx

Life White
00:31:793 (31793|0) - I would make this 1/1 shorter to give more space for the 1/4 movement. Same with 00:42:459 (42459|3). Just a personal preference, so up to you./Ok, I changed

Feerum wrote:

Feerum wrote:

Hola. Grats on qualify.
But i found something that needs to get fixed