Byakugan249 wrote:

Yo modding this map because of ur request if u ignore any of my suggestions, please tell me a reason why u ignored it so that i can learn from this in the future. Just note, I don't ignore any suggestions. I always try them out before I deny them. The thing is that I will almost always prefer my current note placement/pattern over someone else's.

General:
i suggest that u make an easy diff because the song length is around 1:30. not necessary


Normal:
00:46:636(5) - x:116 y:208. it should align to (4) no
00:47:026(1) - x:160 y:288 if u follow the suggestion above. it should make a nice flow pattern IMO no
00:53:260(1) - make this look the same as (2) no
01:22:870(1) - make this a curved slider? no

er. my reason for denying these suggestions is because i like my current note placements and some of the suggestions don't have any significance in the changes

Hard:
00:28:324(1) - Stack this at the end of (2) at 00:27:253 i placed the slider in the middle of the previous slider intentionally

Insane:
00:33:584(2) - move it up so that it will make a better blanket and make it like this http://puu.sh/9xem i did this intentionally and i want to keep it that way
00:47:610(9) - NC not going to add NC here, but to the next circle because the combo seems a bit large

this is the best i can do. GL

Shana Aisaka wrote:

Sorry seems like i didn't find anything wrong with your map

Purple - Map seems okay~
Pink - Suggestion~

That's all i got ↓↓↓↓↓↓↓↓
[Hard]
00:04:753(x) = add note ~ no
00:07:870(x) = ^ no
00:34:169(x) = ^ no


I give you star instant ~ >~<"

-Baby Strawberry- wrote:

❤Hihi~!
❤here comes the modding~!

❤In General
❤What can i say about the song....its kinda cute but....so weird! its quite out of tune~!
❤delete .osb not necessary

❤【Insane】diff
00:33:584 (2) - this slider is too near i think . may be u can do it like:00:32:415 (3,4,5,1,2) - all Ctrl+H then move 00:33:584 (2) - like thishttp://puu.sh/9yVl i placed them close intentionally

❤【Hard】diff


❤【Normal】diff
the only thing i found is the new combo , its kinda weird.....hope u could do it like in other diffs hm? I think it's fine

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Good map and i like ur mapping style~! but the song...........
Gook luck~!
Since i am a new modder, all the moddings are ONLY PERSONAL SUGGESTIONS

TheNutritiousGuy wrote:

Modding~

[Normal]
Dang..

[Hard]
00:21:604 = I would remove this Combo.
00:36:604 = ^
00:39:915 = ^
00:43:032 = ^
00:46:149 = ^
01:14:104 = ^

[Insane]
00:02:221 = Dat Sliders are stupid. You should take just Circles. But don't mix Reverse Sliders with Circles.
00:03:000 = ^
00:20:922 = ^
00:21:701 = ^
01:37:285 = ^ (But otherwise, it would be k.)
01:38:065 = ^ (But otherwise, it would be k.)
00:05:630 = Remove the Circle. Why? It sounds way cooler without it.
00:05:727 = ^
00:22:675 - 00:23:454 = You should change something.
00:28:909 - 00:29:688 = ^
00:37:383 = I think the Rhythm of the Map is soooo cool enough. I perfer you to remove this Circle.
00:37:578 = ^
00:40:500 = ^
00:40:695 = ^
00:43:092 = ^
00:52:091 (1, 2, 3, 4, 5) = Wtf are those Jumps?
01:18:195 - 01:19:588 = Soft Hitsounds would be nice.
01:18:389 = Clap
01:18:779 = ^
01:19:169 = ^
01:19:558 = ^

The Song is pretty cool. At first I could found nothing. Really nice made.

S h i o n wrote:

:) Hi

Request from my modding queue :

General

1. I highly recommend you apply a soft hitsound to such a cute and relaxing song. i prefer the sound of drums
2. Delete .osb file and then have a full submission if you don't have a storyboard. not necessary

Normal

1. You put many new combos on stacked notes, like 00:12:350 (3,1) , 00:18:584 (3,1) and so on. They are too much and quite ugly. Maybe you can change some color or remove those new combos. hm. I like it like that
2. 00:48:584 (2) - Remove whistle from the end.
3. 00:51:701 (2) - Whistle on end this time
4. 00:53:260 (1) - Remove whistle on end but on start
   fixed hitsounds. I was following a certain part of the instrument but i guess it's not that noticeable.
5. 01:22:675 (4) - Put it 1/2 earlier would sound better and easier to new players imo okay

Hard

1. 00:11:961 (4) - Ctrl+R ? You will have a better flow and a nice small jump because of doing this. no
2. 00:13:519 (4) - ^ no
3. 00:25:792 (3) - Work out a better shape to flow better ? i think it's fine
4. 00:46:636 (T) - Unused timing section ? it's for slidertick hitsound

Insane

1. 00:29:493 (5) - Try this to have a better flow ? no
   

   276,204,29493,2,0,B|216:196|208:264,1,90,2|0

2. 00:37:285 (1,2,3,4,5) - This stream is really overmapped imo. Same as 00:40:402 (1,2,3,4,5) i don't think it's overmapped :l
3. 01:25:987 (5) - Since this , you have too many new combos. Make them compact ? no

Sorry for my late and noob mod, don't kd the post if it is of no use.

Miya wrote:

Hi qilliam, it's time to mod your map

General

1. Fine, i don't see any problem here.

Normal

1. 00:54:818 (2) - I think it's better for this slider to have the same shape like 00:53:260 (1) - It's more consistent imo. no
2. 00:57:935 (2) - Same as before, i think it's better to change this slider shape like 00:56:376 (1) - no
3. 01:32:221 (1) - Adding a finish at the startpoint will be nice to hear and it will make hitsound more consistent. FIXED

Hard

1. 00:08:844 (3) - It's better to change this 1/2 repeat slider to 1/4 repeat slider. It's more fit the song than 1/2 repeat slider and it doesn't too much hard for the player. no
2. 00:53:260 (1) - How about adding a finish sound at the startpoint? It's better to hear imo. no

Insane

1. 00:08:844 (5,6,7) - I think adding a stream between this note will be more fun and chalengging. Well, if you follow this, you should rearangge your jump since this pattern is jumpy >.< no
2. 00:22:091 (1) - Same as normal, i think you should add a finish here at the startpoint of the slider. no

Very decent mapset. That's all from me. Sorry if my mod is not helpful.
Good luck qilliam ^^

Takos wrote:

Hi~ >w</
From my modding queue~
All Suggestions

General
Composer: MasKaleido
Vocal: Arima Misaki
Add these to tags? ok


Normal
01:07:091 (5) - NC if you're following vocal? i add new NC after every 2 measures
01:10:208 (4) - ^
01:19:558 (5) - ^

Hard
01:38:454 (1) - You forgot adding a finish here orz. FIXED

Insane
I think this diff should be renamed to "Lunatic" since this is a Touhou song. i think it's too easy to be called lunatic
You're using too many NCs in this diff. ;_;
00:02:610 (1) - Remove NC
00:08:065 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Make a cleaner hexagon? You can do it by placing a note, and then rotate it 60 degrees, do it for the next one, and so on. remade hexagon and changed jump pattern
00:10:402 (1) - Remove NC
00:11:961 (1) - ^
00:13:519 (1) - ^
00:16:636 (1) - ^
00:18:195 (1) - ^
00:19:753 (1) - ^
00:21:311 (1) - ^
00:33:584 (2) - Too close to the previous note. Ctrl+R instead? intentional
01:26:766 (1) - Remove NC
01:28:324 (1) - ^
01:29:883 (1) - ^
01:33:000 (1) - ^
01:34:558 (1) - ^
01:36:117 (1) - ^
01:37:675 (1) - ^ no NC changes

I love Touhou songs~
Good luck!

No_Gu wrote:

request from my queue

[insane]
00:44:396 (2) - remove it

[hard]
00:47:026 (1) - copy last 5 .ctrl+h and ctrl+r.then fix spacing
00:49:850 (5) - move it to 00:50:045

[normal]
00:47:026 (1) - finish instead of whistle
01:04:169 (1) - whistle instead of clap at the beginning


I can't find more problems.If you change nothing.Please don't give me kud

mercury2004 wrote:

Sorry for 2 day late. I was busy recently.

S Priority Mod.

Red: Means.You are breaking beatmapping rules or something that doesn't right. You should change it immediately.
Orange: Means. My Suggestion. It is okay whether you change it or not
Purple:Means. Highly Recommend you to change it.

General
-Folder OK
-Hitsound is a bit too loud. Decrase all timing section by 10% i think it's fine
Add the embodiment of scarlet devil beloved tomboyish girl into Tags i don't think it's necessary. ppl would most likely search cirno if they want to find this map

Normal Difficulty
Fine

Hard Difficulty
Use 1 Slider tick. I don't know why you use this though. no
00:49:753 (4,5,6) - Put like this sounds better no
01:31:636 (3) - You forgot your whistle here[/color] orz. FIXED

Insane Difficulty
Use 1 Slider tick. no
00:00:273 (1,2) - [NAZI] Put 2 same level as 3. Better gameplay. and Put 4 same level as 3 no
00:05:922 (6) - [NAZI] Put 6 same vertical plane with 00:05:337 (2) - no
00:18:584 (2) - [NAZI] Stack this under 00:17:026 (2) - no
00:29:883 (1,2,3) - This pattern does not fit with the music well. The jump feel very uncomfortable. Put them like this? no
00:44:396 (2) - Remove this note no
00:56:182 (7) - [NAZI] Stack this with 00:57:156 (4) - . And fix these 00:55:792 (4,5,6) - spacing no

I can only give you a suggestion. The maps set look good already. Star thanks

If this mod proved to be not helpful. Don't kudos

Dangaard wrote:

[General]

1. title should be either "Heart-Racing☆Frozen Pack" or "Tokimeki☆Reitou Pakku" I think the current title is better. Similar to how your recently ranked map is called "hare hare sailor fuku" and not "hare hare se-ra- fuku". And I don't think you can use "☆" in osu.
2. as mentioned before, you should add the following tags: "the embodiment of scarlet devil" and "beloved tomboyish girl"
   It's always better to have more specifications than having the bare minimum. ok fine, added

[Normal]

1. changing to new combo in the middle of a stack can be quite confusing for novice players. Since this is your easiest diff, you should change it, so that new combos are placed on the starting notes of each stack. This applies especially to the intro section, but it can be found in the other diffs as well, so you might want to change it on those as well for consistency. Changed NC for normal stacks. The NC stacks in other difficulties are unchanged for consistency within the difficulty.
2. seeing as you are using tickrate 2 in the other diffs, you should do here as well. Imo it goes well with the winter theme of this song. ok, changed.

Nice map!