forum

Ray - ebb and flow

posted
Total Posts
3
Topic Starter
aramaking
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2017年10月18日 at 20:50:49

Artist: Ray
Title: ebb and flow
Source: nagi no asukara
BPM: 106
Filesize: 3944kb
Play Time: 01:30
Difficulties Available:
  1. nagi (3.15 stars, 158 notes)
Download: Ray - ebb and flow
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
4th anniversary
keima915
Hello there! I'm just randomly modding maps because I want to improve my modding/mapping skills, don't mind me. :D

Mods:
SPOILER
1. Don't you think the note on 00:02:842 should be moved earlier to 00:02:700 since that's when the sound is?
2. You also ignore the same sound on 00:04:964 and the sliderhead at 00:05:106 doesn't represent any sound in the song. My suggestion: remove 00:05:106 (1,2) and replace with a note at 00:04:964 and a reverse slide at 00:05:389 like this:
3. Another similar issue with the slider at 00:07:370. Maybe remove it and replace with a 3/4 slider starting at 00:07:228 like this:
4. This is a bit subjective, so feel free to ignore this one. The objects at 00:12:464 (2,3,4) don't fit the persisting instrument and voice sounds, I think. Maybe replace them with a note at 00:12:464, a spinner from 00:12:747 to 00:13:596, and a note at 00:13:879. Or scrap the note at 00:13:879 and just make the spinner last until then
5. 00:19:681 - why not add a note at this part, to represent the "na" syllabe.
6. There's an unrepresented sound at 00:40:766. Maybe add a note here or remove the note at 00:41:332 and add a 0.80 speed slider like this: (it's supposed to look like a nagi but meh I'm bad at slider shapes)

That's all :D Good luck on this map and all of your future maps!
Topic Starter
aramaking

keima915 wrote:

Hello there! I'm just randomly modding maps because I want to improve my modding/mapping skills, don't mind me. :D

Mods:
SPOILER
1. Don't you think the note on 00:02:842 should be moved earlier to 00:02:700 since that's when the sound is? fix
2. You also ignore the same sound on 00:04:964 and the sliderhead at 00:05:106 doesn't represent any sound in the song. My suggestion: remove 00:05:106 (1,2) and replace with a note at 00:04:964 and a reverse slide at 00:05:389 like this: fix
3. Another similar issue with the slider at 00:07:370. Maybe remove it and replace with a 3/4 slider starting at 00:07:228 like this: fix

4. This is a bit subjective, so feel free to ignore this one. The objects at 00:12:464 (2,3,4) don't fit the persisting instrument and voice sounds, I think. Maybe replace them with a note at 00:12:464, a spinner from 00:12:747 to 00:13:596, and a note at 00:13:879. Or scrap the note at 00:13:879 and just make the spinner last until then fix a little
5. 00:19:681 - why not add a note at this part, to represent the "na" syllabe. i think it shold not add note this part. 00:19:540 (2) - "a" 00:19:823 (3) - "no-"
00:20:389 (4,5) - "hi no-" "あの日の"

6. There's an unrepresented sound at 00:40:766. Maybe add a note here or remove the note at 00:41:332 and add a 0.80 speed slider like this: fix
(it's supposed to look like a nagi but meh I'm bad at slider shapes)

That's all :D Good luck on this map and all of your future maps!
Thanks modding!

but i want this map be graveyarded.

so i put a link fixed map

https://puu.sh/yddas.osz
Please sign in to reply.

New reply