CrumpetFiddler wrote:
i think this rebubble is incredibly hasty, expecially because of how... questionable the top difficulty is. - YikesTofu1222 wrote:
Rechecked and top diff is quite well polished. Rebubbled!
Some of the mods that have been posted have either been shoved to the side or straight out ignored and i really thing as a mapper you really should go back and read the mods and think about what people are asking you to do before you respond. - Find one that has been completely shoved to the side and come back to me, thanks.
From what ive seen in discord talking to you and others who have also spoken to you, you seem incredibly reluctant to change even when its clearly beneficial.
"Reluctant" lol error is literally the only person you are referring to (which wasn't ignored). So stop with the baseless accusations lmfaoPics 1Useless picsError's moderror_exe777 wrote:
well this is not how i would go about this map honestly.
okay its hard to make objective points with this map since im basically contradicting your mapping style but i thought id say something after i heard concerns from a couple people.
m o s t of the map is charted with vocal or guitar over the drums. and quite frankly i feel that they have all blocked you from creating any sort of interesting patterns or concepts and instead its just a blur of LNs which seriously aren't nice to play. there is tons of strain and pressure behind them and it really ruins the experience from a playing point of view. from a mappers view, it doesnt give any emphasis towards the drums, which in this song are prominent throughout the song and since you prioritised (by the looks of it) the guitar, vocals etc it takes away that kind of emphasis or feeling that the drums give off during the song.
oh god and kiai. ah kiai. if this didnt exist i wouldn't make this post but here i am. my god kiai is an absolute state. since you again charted vocals AND another synth sound thing it takes this feeling of lost emphasis to a whole new extent. it feels extremely overmapped to the point where it feels like an attempt at something cool but instead is a mess of LNs that contradicts the music. the song itself is very sharp and in a way sophisticated and by charting LNs it completely goes against what the song is trying to convey. if it was another keymode it would be less of a pain to play and chart but since its 4k you're stuck with the mess that is this section.
the whole kiai is also very sudden and in a way shocking after the whole note spams at 00:36:294 - to 00:46:032 - . you would kind of expect more notes but i guess this is fine.
take a look at ash's diff, specifically kiai. its pretty much exactly how i would map this, and if these concepts were applied to higher diffs, it would work perfectly.
now this was a pretty subjective argument, since i disagree with how you've mapped the song as a whole, rather than sections within the map. im not asking you to change anything since its your mapping style and you're allowed to have that, i just feel in this instance it gets in the way of what the song is trying to portray/convey. if you were open to changes (which i doubt since its bubbled and blocko is on the way) i recommend you chart the drums over all else within the map. it would show the song (imo) alot better than it is now, since there will be more emphasis on the more prominent sounds which is essentially a basic osu mania principle.
here's a mod bc i found some stuff
[top diff]
i have to say it is pretty well polished.
00:06:294 (6294|1,6372|2,6451|1,6608|2,6686|1,6765|2,7079|3,7158|1,7236|3,7707|0,7786|3,7864|0,8100|3,8179|1,8257|3) - this whole section is infested with some weird trills which kinda make it awkward to play and hinders flow slightly. if its intended then go ahead but i personally would prefer rolls or bursts rather than trills because they are more comfortable to play
00:10:535 (10535|1) - like umo said, this should end 1/4 earlier but its up to you really, since it would flow better as 1/2
00:11:948 (11948|0,12184|0) - this LN shield here makes no sense to me since it only makes it cancer to play and doesnt give any chart benefits or whatever. a simple solution is to CTRL+H these 00:12:184 (12184|0,12262|3) -
00:33:624 - triple for cymbal, right? or a quad like at 00:38:493 -
01:00:011 (60011|3,60090|2,60168|0,60247|3,60325|0) - these need to trill like at 00:49:959 (49959|3,50037|0,50116|3,50194|0,50273|3) -
nothing here was meant to be rude. if i came across as rude then i apologise.btw alluka doesnt appear until one of the later arcs in hxh and the song is from the first arc so pls change bg kthx
This mod inparticular expresses concerns with the map, most prominently the play-ability of the song during the kiai time which had some very valid points that absolutely could of been resolved or reasoned against.
Instead from all i can gather theres reluctance to change, or even consider change.
You blind my dude?
Me memeing for the most part, oh my lord! Sorry! (referring to "Pics 2" box)
I feel this map still has a ton of room for discussion and think its way to early to result in a bubble, i feel more selfmodding / mods from other modders should be gathered to assist this map in becoming the best it can be. - Thanks for your opinion, how about you mod it then
TO CLARIFY ; Im not making this post to be an ass (I'll be nice and not resort to screenshots lmao), im making this to help have this map be the best it can be, especially since its clear your going for ranked.
I'm looking forward to your response on errors mod as i think that was heavily overlooked.
"Heavily overlooked", once again are you blind? lmfao
I wish you luck on furthering this map, its got alot of potential, but i dont think its quite ready yet. Thanks
~Crumpey
Said "scummy" then edited it lol, it's fine if you want to look at little more mature in the public eye though c:
The picture above is referring to me editing the post in error's mod. The self mod and rebubble modding was done after error's post was already out and the edit (which was me toning my response further after the recent mods done by myself and tofu) was done before CrumpetFiddlers post lol..
try being more perceptive before you bag on someone my dude