Hi Nymph here and request from ingame.
General:
approachcircle.png is 130x130. you'd better make it128x128.
kiai times are different:
- [Hard] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 02:21:047, ends on 02:50:316
Kiai #2: Starts on 03:57:633, ends on 04:26:901
- [Normal] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 02:21:047, ends on 02:50:316
Kiai #2: Starts on 03:57:633, ends on 04:32:572
Kiai #3: Starts on 04:32:755, ends on 04:44:462
Normal:
Issues
OD 5 is a little high for a diff like this, I suggest -1 at least.
Beatmap design/suggestion
01:48:852 (4,5,6) - spacing here seems a little smaller compared with others.
02:25:803 (2) - maybe make the spacing more consistent. (many places are similar like this, maybe try to make them more beautiful?
02:27:633 (1,2) - this rhythm pattern feels a little weird, I still prefer slider first then note. (some pattern are similar with this, although I thought they maybe a little werid, but maybe just me and they are totally acceptable so I am gonna to mention them again.
02:32:023 (6) - 1/4 beats didn't fit here imo. 02:38:242 (2) - this is much better. nah it is also acceptable though.
04:43:730 (6) - slow down slider isn't quite safe in a normal diff like this.... at least add a new combo?
Hitsound
00:36:413 (1) - you started to use claps on the 1st and 3rd white tick, which feel a little weird, cuz you always using 2nd and 4th white ticks clap before and after 00:41:535 (1). So I think it is better to keep the same hitsound pattern here.
01:33:852 (4) - 01:39:706 (4) - I am not quite sure why you use silence slider tail here, cuz it didn't give me a very good feeling about the silence.
01:34:218 (1) - 01:40:072 (1) - Do you make these spinners have a different volumn on purpose? cuz it is much better to have a same volumn imo of these spinners.
01:56:169 (3,4,5,6) - I didn't quite agree with the hitsound pattern you got here, 2 finishes seems too much. So here is my ideas: ① delete the finish on 3. add whistle on 5, and delete whistle on 6. or: ② delete the finish on 3, add finish on 5, silence 6. You maybe want to try these^^;
03:31:291 (1) - why volumn 100? too loud..
Hard:
Beatmap design/suggestion
00:29:462 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ...too early to use a pattern like these imo.
00:43:364 (1) - this is too far away....
00:47:389 (1) - ....
Hitsound
I really think maybe add claps during the kiai make be better, whistle are too weak imo.
00:57:633 (1) - missing clap?
03:08:608 (2) - whistle?
03:16:657 (2) - ^(not gonna mention these, just try to make your whistle more consistent.
03:18:852 (5) - add finish on 03:19:584?
General:
approachcircle.png is 130x130. you'd better make it128x128.
kiai times are different:
- [Hard] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 02:21:047, ends on 02:50:316
Kiai #2: Starts on 03:57:633, ends on 04:26:901
- [Normal] :
Kiai #1: Starts on 02:21:047, ends on 02:50:316
Kiai #2: Starts on 03:57:633, ends on 04:32:572
Kiai #3: Starts on 04:32:755, ends on 04:44:462
Normal:
Issues
OD 5 is a little high for a diff like this, I suggest -1 at least.
Beatmap design/suggestion
01:48:852 (4,5,6) - spacing here seems a little smaller compared with others.
02:25:803 (2) - maybe make the spacing more consistent. (many places are similar like this, maybe try to make them more beautiful?
02:27:633 (1,2) - this rhythm pattern feels a little weird, I still prefer slider first then note. (some pattern are similar with this, although I thought they maybe a little werid, but maybe just me and they are totally acceptable so I am gonna to mention them again.
02:32:023 (6) - 1/4 beats didn't fit here imo. 02:38:242 (2) - this is much better. nah it is also acceptable though.
04:43:730 (6) - slow down slider isn't quite safe in a normal diff like this.... at least add a new combo?
Hitsound
00:36:413 (1) - you started to use claps on the 1st and 3rd white tick, which feel a little weird, cuz you always using 2nd and 4th white ticks clap before and after 00:41:535 (1). So I think it is better to keep the same hitsound pattern here.
01:33:852 (4) - 01:39:706 (4) - I am not quite sure why you use silence slider tail here, cuz it didn't give me a very good feeling about the silence.
01:34:218 (1) - 01:40:072 (1) - Do you make these spinners have a different volumn on purpose? cuz it is much better to have a same volumn imo of these spinners.
01:56:169 (3,4,5,6) - I didn't quite agree with the hitsound pattern you got here, 2 finishes seems too much. So here is my ideas: ① delete the finish on 3. add whistle on 5, and delete whistle on 6. or: ② delete the finish on 3, add finish on 5, silence 6. You maybe want to try these^^;
03:31:291 (1) - why volumn 100? too loud..
Hard:
Beatmap design/suggestion
00:29:462 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,6) - ...too early to use a pattern like these imo.
00:43:364 (1) - this is too far away....
00:47:389 (1) - ....
Hitsound
I really think maybe add claps during the kiai make be better, whistle are too weak imo.
00:57:633 (1) - missing clap?
03:08:608 (2) - whistle?
03:16:657 (2) - ^(not gonna mention these, just try to make your whistle more consistent.
03:18:852 (5) - add finish on 03:19:584?