hi-mei
hi-mei wrote:
fanzhen's Extra
Aesthetics:
I know there are no standards in regards of slider art but...
00:00:618 (1,1,1,1,2,1,1,1) - how do the reflect the song? they are completely random, doest correlate with each other. Hello its 2017 you can make more simplistic and at the same time more nice stuff. idk, when I first hear this song I think it would fit if I put some awkward sliders. (I don't really know why people tend to like these squeezed shaped sliders from years ago..?) Also it's an easy way to skip a pre intro.
00:46:743 (1) - you could make this look way better, since you started that grid: It's just a copy of 00:44:868 (1,2,3,4) -
Structure:
01:01:368 (1) - and this 00:49:368 (1) - i honestly think you should kinda choose what kind of pattern you use for that sounds. I Still think that escalating distance is better than double-jump-double-jump. For such a 'future funk'' type song, it's just a regular sound sample to me. If you require that I should make exact similar pattern for every similar sound unit, I'm afraid I can't do that, at least in this song.
03:30:618 (1) - I mean... 03:27:618 (1) - 03:29:118 (1) - 03:24:618 (1) - 03:26:118 (1) - and suddenly a cringed something 03:30:618 (1) - and 03:32:118 (1) - 03:33:618 (1) - There are 4 beats for small-large-small patterns already, so I think it's acceptable if I change something.
03:35:868 - here shud be an NC I guess? Not very needed
Rhythm:
01:37:180 - I think it should be 1/2 instead of 3/4, since it lacks the clap like 01:37:930 - here. Sure
02:05:118 (4) - 02:02:118 (4) - this might be a slider end? just like in top diff? youre mapping vocals there, that drum sound implied to be on slider end. I'd move 3 to slider head. Vocals change a bit here.
Hitsounds (i removed custom hitsounds):
02:28:180 - 02:28:368 - 02:28:555 - 02:29:305 - 02:29:680 - etc what happened here?
02:24:618 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - turn off the custom hitsounds and listen.
like... youre making rhythm from claps on 02:25:368 -
but ignoring the normal-hitnormal 02:27:243 - which is referring to 02:25:743 - 02:26:493 - so I guess it might be like
02:24:993 - here might be a normal-hitnormal
02:26:868 (7) - might be a copy of 02:25:368 (3) - (add/normal, clap+whistle)
02:27:618 - from here we got 02:28:180 - 02:28:368 - 02:28:555 - suddenly
why? I mean I know Im not supposed to ask that but, explain please why did you do that in that way. Its just irregular and wrong (in my opinion).
02:59:868 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - sounds nice but, is this a proper reflection of objects? (circled 1/4s stream)
03:04:555 (3,4,5) - same thing, please explain why you picked drums there.
even after that it makes me question your logic of hitsounding, since its pretty irregular how you place them.
I'm sorry I can't reply hs modding point by point... But since the mapper used custom hitsounds why do you disable them when doing hitsound modding? I mean it would be a mess if the mapper rename sounds like crashes to hitwhistle or something else. Regular hitsounding should be heard like a system, I still don't think modding with custom hs disabled is a good choice though.
But anyway I'll check the whole map and check all weird point.
Shiirn
Shiirn wrote:
fanzhen
00:45:618 (1,2,3,4) - any reason this is a straight line and not a twitched shape like the other three 1234s? Maybe it's because the rhythm got dense here.. I just copied 00:42:618 (1,2,3,4) -
also idk why people are up in arms about this either it's just....plain and kind of boring tbh. got some weird melody skips like 03:15:430 (6,1) - that make it feel like the patterns were poorly designed to not actually follow the music, but that's normal for this kind of map.
03:30:993 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - did u just get bored and stop the spacing changes lol ya im lazy
Will update after I checked all hs issues
@Sinnoh: I separated those sliders: