Gaia wrote:

came from #moereq
stayed since botan is best girl indeed greatest


[!]
ar9.1 is a bit random lol, just 9 is good imo uhm weird to say it but im not fan of using ar9, even though 9.1 is almost the same. im weird

00:01:957 (4) - try ctrl+g on this, emphasis should be on the snare on (5) (which is missing a clap) so it works out nicely ok ok
00:03:269 (3) - also clap, 00:03:457 (4) - remove clap here and consider adding a drum clap on the end and head of 00:03:832 (5) - fix
00:04:582 (2,3,4) - soft clap on (2,4) drum clap on (3), there seems to be a lot of weird hitsounds so i'll leave them out for your sanity lol i try to fix?
00:06:925 - strongly recommend mapping this beat, it's quite audible so it sounds empty like it is atm used a 1/4 slider
00:07:207 (1,2,3) - i love how this is constructed, 1,2 are mapped similarly and (3) is pointed the other way because it's distinctly different in the music, try to do the same thing in the next few sections as well - 00:10:207 (1,2,3) - 00:11:519 (1,2,3) - etc. yea ill go do that (ctr+g lol)
00:12:644 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - not very appealing as a stream, try making a curved slider and ctrl+shift+f
00:13:394 (1) - 00:14:332 (4) - there's a crash on the end so it'd be nice if they were clickable, try this rhythm (and maybe pattern) instead http://puu.sh/xjNBB/081114a840.jpg
o cool thanks for this
00:22:207 (1) - move this further away since spacing atm looks like this is a 1/2 gap i.e. 00:25:582 (2) - like this hmm ok
00:29:707 (1,2,3,4) - try this pattern? seems cuter to me http://puu.sh/xjNKd/13c6029c94.jpg does look cuter, ill just slight edit your way
00:37:957 (3,4,5) - doesn't flow nicely imo, try this http://puu.sh/xjNMN/8dd53d2c1c.jpg cool fixed
00:38:519 (1,2,3) - a 3 slider pattern followed by 3 circles would suit this nicely, like this http://puu.sh/xjNQM/c832820f8a.jpg nice
00:46:207 (1) - try to have more spacing on notes like these, doesnt make sense that this is lower spaced than (3,4)
00:47:144 (4) - also try to avoid linear motion like here , moving it up more for an angle would be nice, good execution would be something like 01:02:144 (3,4,5) - suits a lot better since it's emphasizing the repetitive vocals made the 2 circles before it to a slider so it moves circularly
00:49:019 (1) - this is a very emphasized note, give it a jump! ye
00:50:707 (1) - skystar slider pattern like this doesnt really fit here imo but i want to keep it this way
00:55:207 (1,2) - 01:01:207 (7,1,2) - 01:08:707 (1,2,3) - it's all the same stuff so you should try to make the rhythms more consistent with eachotherok fix
01:13:207 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,1) - try this pattern. (3) is emphasized with a jump and change in flow, followed by circles for vocals. symmetry works nicely since it's 2 very similar melodies repeating http://puu.sh/xjO9e/bede0091cf.jpg I would also recommend changing 01:14:707 (1) - into 2 circles since there's a snare on the upbeat ok ok made jumpy
01:19:207 (1) - 01:20:519 (1) - this current copy pasta section doesn't really represent the music well, i'd suggest scrapping the copy pasta and focus on emphasizing these 2 beats
01:22:019 (6,1) - 01:23:519 (5,1) - highly recommend making this into a 1/1 slider, there's no kick on the downbeat so it fits a lot more fixed from irc
01:26:144 (1) - slider + circle pls, the sliderend is very stressed and should be clickable ok ok
01:28:581 (1,2) - bad polarity here, consider making this into 1 slider ill see what i can do

aa it became a wall mod so i'll stop here x.x if you want me to finish the mod then feel free to poke me in game
otherwise glhf!

1. 00:01:207 - reduce SV like x0.8 for intro? It also helps to show the intensity difference with 00:07:207 -
2. 00:12:925 - this might cause overmap since there's almost no drum sound (hell ye i played with 25% speed), maybe changing to 00:12:831 (6) - as 1/4 slider works or put it as just 2 triples r better for safety thingy
3. 00:13:207 (1) - missing finish i guess
4. 00:15:269 (3,4) - adding drum clap would be great
5. 00:40:207 (1,3) - almost-touching sliders :weary:
6. 00:43:207 (1) - kinda crappy suggestion but ye blanket would be nice
   
   u can use animated fading slidertail for life hax

   
7. 00:48:457 (3,4) - uhm i can feel som lack of emphasis with those high-pitchd vocals, maybe u can try this, i only moved slidershape of 1 and 23 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8946227
8. 00:55:769 (2) - slight offscreen can cause to bubble pop UwU ctrl + up key lik 8 times for safety thingy
9. 01:28:019 (9,1) - isn't should be swap NC for SV change on 01:28:019 -
10. 01:29:144 (4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - u can polish that stream shape w
11. 02:15:269 (2) - ye
12. 02:39:457 (3) - nazi tip : ctrl + g this > move to 355 | 75 > ctrl + g again
13. 02:47:613 (1) - maybe stop this at 02:50:332 - for som background sound
14. again u might want to touch with sv on 04:46:207 - and 04:52:207 - since they have different intensity
15. 04:59:143 - im triggrd on timing lole

Akitoshi wrote:

fist me daddy

Connect

1. 00:01:207 - reduce SV like x0.8 for intro? It also helps to show the intensity difference with 00:07:207 - ok i use 0.9 instead
2. 00:12:925 - this might cause overmap since there's almost no drum sound (hell ye i played with 25% speed), maybe changing to 00:12:831 (6) - as 1/4 slider works or put it as just 2 triples r better for safety thingy made them trple
3. 00:13:207 (1) - missing finish i guess forgot to put mb
4. 00:15:269 (3,4) - adding drum clap would be great ^
5. 00:40:207 (1,3) - almost-touching sliders :weary: o no, fixed
6. 00:43:207 (1) - kinda crappy suggestion but ye blanket would be nice mb, didnt see this
   
   u can use animated fading slidertail for life hax

   
7. 00:48:457 (3,4) - uhm i can feel som lack of emphasis with those high-pitchd vocals, maybe u can try this, i only moved slidershape of 1 and 23 https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8946227 ok emphasis
8. 00:55:769 (2) - slight offscreen can cause to bubble pop UwU ctrl + up key lik 8 times for safety thingyok pop imakoko
9. 01:28:019 (9,1) - isn't should be swap NC for SV change on 01:28:019 - dafak this was nc'd before, idk what happened, fix
10. 01:29:144 (4,5,6,7,8,9,1) - u can polish that stream shape w ctr+shift+f
11. 02:15:269 (2) - yehelye
12. 02:39:457 (3) - nazi tip : ctrl + g this > move to 355 | 75 > ctrl + g again ook? i didnt see difference but i did so
13. 02:47:613 (1) - maybe stop this at 02:50:332 - for som background sound o k
14. again u might want to touch with sv on 04:46:207 - and 04:52:207 - since they have different intensity ok
15. 04:59:143 - im triggrd on timing lole sori cant time

goodluck uwu

Mirash wrote:

- 00:07:207 (1,2) - since this two sounds alike maybe place them together http://i.imgur.com/WeOfbRS.png and next one sounds different so change the shape and also extend it to blue tick because it sounds better, something like http://i.imgur.com/JxuS57L.png will work nice hmm ok,but i change the way 3 will be placed
- 00:10:957 (3,4) - ^ ^
- 00:12:832 (6) - clap on tail sounds not right and spammy, also 00:13:113 (8) - consider removing it too ah mb,forgot to change hs when this was still a stream part
- 00:13:394 (2,4) - imo should be circles instead because sounds are like clickable lol, or if not circles then http://i.imgur.com/fGO6l5o.png this rhythm sounds better circle does seem more natural to do
- 00:14:894 (1,2) - movement from these two into that shape of slider seems harsh for such intense in music, could use different flow here http://i.imgur.com/emX86t8.png maybe ok
- 00:22:207 (1) - yo this should get more spacing, also gap between 00:22:582 (2) - seems not nice, i could suggest to move it under (1), so the end pattern will look like http://i.imgur.com/L0lppvE.png distance fixed and variety
- 00:25:207 (1,2) - ^ ^
- 00:28:207 (1,2) - o! well idk if previous things was for variety or something else but whatever ye variety, but idk if its passable reason for a bn so ye
- 01:10:582 (2,3) - stack on this doesn't work that well for me, it could be better if you maybe use something liek http://i.imgur.com/1v3MWUw.png so slider gets jump and it feels nice ye. idk why i stacked it tbh
- 01:11:519 (6) - also this thing is spaced more then it should be in my opinion, try http://i.imgur.com/RWxgyLR.png mb, vocal emphasis
- 01:42:082 (2) - skipped clap aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
http://i.imgur.com/YzRZmYW.png OK rip
- 01:59:707 (1,2,3,4) - claps?? wttff where they go, im dumb wtf
- 02:01:019 (4,2) - try avoid such overlaps, it'll make your map cleaner in editor o k
- 02:02:707 (1) - clap on tail a
- 02:13:488 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - hs? ye
- 04:42:270 (3) - i think it should be more spaced, try placing it at the head of 04:42:644 (4) - o k
- 04:57:457 (4) - these sound start from here, so nc it too lol it disoriented me thank
- 04:59:143 (1) - place a note here and spinner just after that, on blue tick, so sound will be covered with something ok
05:05:143 - also i think it will be more accurate to end the spinner here, since ending it on red tick somehow feels not comfortable, also fix your green line, it doesn't work now, since it is unsnapped by 1 ms lol ok

Maxylan wrote:

NM From my "Modding Madness!" queue!
Other than this being an overlap fiesta with flow that always challenge the player, I do like it! The constant flow-breaking and switching kept it entertaining to play despite the fact that a BN or QAT might tell you othervise, but hey what do I know! The blankets are nice and the intensity of different parts of the beatmap always does a great job at reflecting the different intesities of the song. Clean difficulty, I hope you'll follow what I said and get this ranked!
[]

Connect
00:06:644 (6,1) - Overlapperino, there's quite alot of these, almost everywhere, some are understandable, others are small mistakes, others just needs to be stacked with the closest slider head, anyways good luck going on a treasure hunt for overlaps because I want to avoid a nazi wall of text mod =p some or maybe most overmaps are ok and justifiable since they dont make it look messy, yea maybe there are some that need to be fixed
00:13:769 (4,5) - This could flow better hm? but the movement is ok
00:36:269 (3) - This is acceptable but personal preference forbids me to not mention it, it'd be sweet if it didn't end on a note with equal strength as it's head keep since its kind of equally the same the 2 red ticks, plus to follow the hs properly aswell
00:40:207 (1,2,1,2) - I get that this is a nice pattern but once again personal taste would rather want this blanketing the circles =p symmetry here, and this plays ok it gives a dancing movement
01:00:082 (2,3) - I know I already mentioned overlaps and how I wouldn't mention them again but this one bugged the hell out of me, even though I can sortof see the reasoning behind it. o k
01:00:832 (5,1) - Unrankable sliderino, I saw this repeated a few times as well, in the ranking criteria you're not allowed to cover up a sliders repeat arrow because not everyone uses a transparent skin. A BN taught me this, actually =p yes covering a sliders reverse is unrankable but its a 1/1 beat gap starting from 5 to 1 which gives time for object to be clearly seen even if you dont have a transparent skin, check the testplay in the editor
01:24:269 (3,4) - This should lead into the stream better. y
01:35:707 (1,2) - I hate you and this shouldn't need any explaining )))))) I mean this pattern is repeated and works in the section that follows but the fact that this one comes after a STREAM! git gud, all seriousness this ok i dont see a problem

just, no

[]

Good luck!

1. reconsider Volume, such as ↓↓↓ high SV with low volume, and it's repeating paragraph …… i will use same SV/Volume
   
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 04:13:769 (4) - it's B-slider not L-slider, i be convinced of you dislike it http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9027605
   
3. e …… look like you use soft-whistle/clap follow drum …… but i see you miss many,
   
   00:31:769 - 00:55:769 - 00:56:144 - 01:01:769 - 01:07:769 - whistle
   
   00:07:957 - 00:08:144 - 00:09:269 - 00:09:644 - whistle, maybe you want not add whistle here, but if you skip drum. i think you need add other Hitsound like Default soft-whistle
   
   00:28:207 - clap bad …… it's different with Snare-Drum, finish or add new Hitsound better,
   
4. 02:31:019 (6,1) - unrankable in low diff, maybe 4.4insane not low diff yet —— but i still suggest don't stack reversearrow
   
   01:00:832 (5,1) - same as ↑↑↑ but not serious
   
5. 01:14:894 (2,3,4) - you use many straight line 3note, but it's not suit all part …… here should be 3+1 or 2+1+1 https://puu.sh/xsXwV/84ef036080.jpg
   
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   01:02:144 (3,4,5) - is good , 00:32:707 (1,2,3) - 01:40:207 (1,2,3) - is unnecessary …… If you always use straight line, assembly line is dull
   
6. 04:04:300 - 04:05:050 - sound like overmap, and violin should be http://puu.sh/xsYkf/2ce8f3de39.jpg
   
   03:57:925 (5) - 04:16:675 - sound like overmap too ...
   
7. 04:16:769 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,1) - nice stream imo ……

Narcissu wrote:

timing is wrong, 04:57:082 (2) - early 50+ms yet, try find timing check …… hmmm ye i should find timing check

[Connect]

1. reconsider Volume, such as ↓↓↓ high SV with low volume, and it's repeating paragraph …… i will use same SV/Volume ah fix
   
   
   SPOILER

   
2. 04:13:769 (4) - it's B-slider not L-slider, i be convinced of you dislike it http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9027605 well.... i dont really like the slider shape
   
3. e …… look like you use soft-whistle/clap follow drum …… but i see you miss many,
   
   00:31:769 - 00:55:769 - 00:56:144 - 01:01:769 - 01:07:769 - whistle aaa my bad, looks like i forgot
   
   00:07:957 - 00:08:144 - 00:09:269 - 00:09:644 - whistle, maybe you want not add whistle here, but if you skip drum. i think you need add other Hitsound like Default soft-whistle
   
   00:28:207 - clap bad …… it's different with Snare-Drum, finish or add new Hitsound better,
   
4. 02:31:019 (6,1) - unrankable in low diff, maybe 4.4insane not low diff yet —— but i still suggest don't stack reversearrow fix
   
   01:00:832 (5,1) - same as ↑↑↑ but not serious i think keep, there is enough beat distance for this
   
5. 01:14:894 (2,3,4) - you use many straight line 3note, but it's not suit all part …… here should be 3+1 or 2+1+1 https://puu.sh/xsXwV/84ef036080.jpg fix, just diff note placements
   
   
   SPOILER

   
   
   01:02:144 (3,4,5) - is good , 00:32:707 (1,2,3) - 01:40:207 (1,2,3) - is unnecessary …… If you always use straight line, assembly line is dull ill see what i can do
   
6. 04:04:300 - 04:05:050 - sound like overmap, and violin should be http://puu.sh/xsYkf/2ce8f3de39.jpg fix
   
   03:57:925 (5) - 04:16:675 - sound like overmap too ...
   
7. 04:16:769 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,1) - nice stream imo ……

1. 00:07:207 (1,2) - such small spacing here plays strange, especially when you have bigger spacing in similar moments 00:10:207 (1,2), I would like to make it bigger
2. 00:38:519 (1,2,3) - what about making these sliders with the same curve for more connected pattern?
3. 00:39:644 (4) - this slider looks like meh with this curve, can you make it less curved for me?
4. 01:59:144 (4) - again :c
5. 00:42:832 (4) - I would like to ctrl+g this slider for more pleasant movement and more situable spacing for 00:43:207 (1)
6. 01:06:363 (4) - is there any strong sound on this tick or it's just me? o.o Anyway, I would like to remove this note, starting stream from white tick looks more logical for me
7. 01:06:269 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - I think you can improve form of this stream and make an ideal semicircle here. Also will be cool if you hitsound this stream properly. like you did here - 01:24:457 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11)
8. 02:25:769 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - same about this stream
9. 01:13:019 (6,7,1) - can you stack it with 01:12:269 (3) slider's end, please? >_<
10. 01:19:957 (3) - move it a bit down for avoiding overlap with end of 01:19:207 (1)?
11. 01:24:269 (3) - add whistle??
12. 02:04:207 (1) - stack it with 02:03:269 (2)?
13. 02:31:769 (2) - stack it with 02:30:832 (5)?
14. 02:58:582 (2,3,4,5,6) - rhythm here confused me a bit, try more violin-based one? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9035301
15. 04:38:707 (1) - try this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9035334

PandaHero wrote:

m4m

[General]
04:59:143 - you have red line and green line with different volume lvl here o mb forgot to change green line
01:30:269 (2) - 01:31:582 (2) - 01:37:957 (4,1) - etc - these little overlaps makes me sad, try to avoid it ok

[Connect]

1. 00:07:207 (1,2) - such small spacing here plays strange, especially when you have bigger spacing in similar moments 00:10:207 (1,2), I would like to make it bigger ok
2. 00:38:519 (1,2,3) - what about making these sliders with the same curve for more connected pattern? im pretty sure these are similar but i did copy paste to recheck so yea fix
3. 00:39:644 (4) - this slider looks like meh with this curve, can you make it less curved for me?ok for you
4. 01:59:144 (4) - again :c
5. 00:42:832 (4) - I would like to ctrl+g this slider for more pleasant movement and more situable spacing for 00:43:207 (1) cool
6. 01:06:363 (4) - is there any strong sound on this tick or it's just me? o.o Anyway, I would like to remove this note, starting stream from white tick looks more logical for mehmmm, i kinda hear the violin
7. 01:06:269 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12) - I think you can improve form of this stream and make an ideal semicircle here. Also will be cool if you hitsound this stream properly. like you did here - 01:24:457 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) okok but idk about hitsounding the stream, its kind of weird if i hs as the same as the one mentioned
8. 02:25:769 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - same about this stream
9. 01:13:019 (6,7,1) - can you stack it with 01:12:269 (3) slider's end, please? >_< i use stacking view, so when i try to stack it there it comes out like that so idk what to do
10. 01:19:957 (3) - move it a bit down for avoiding overlap with end of 01:19:207 (1)? hmmm i want it this way but i did move it a bit
11. 01:24:269 (3) - add whistle?? ok
12. 02:04:207 (1) - stack it with 02:03:269 (2)?ye im stupid
13. 02:31:769 (2) - stack it with 02:30:832 (5)? i think its okay
14. 02:58:582 (2,3,4,5,6) - rhythm here confused me a bit, try more violin-based one? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9035301 ok
15. 04:38:707 (1) - try this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9035334 hmm ok

Rest of map is fine, I can find only some aesthetic things that I personally dislike

timemon wrote:

[diff]
Combo 4 too dark, ppl play with bg dim will not see the approach circle ok

00:40:207 (1) - don't do dis why
01:10:582 (2) - no why tho, but whatever change

01:24:457 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - ctrl+shift+F on sliders to create dank streams ye fix

01:25:582 (2,3) - I like how you give the snare drum and cymbal the same emphasis, move the 3 further away this is fine

01:28:581 (2,3,4) - the map loses momentum here just change the 2 circle to a slider like this ok

01:31:019 (1) - there are a few ways of making wave sliders, this isn't one of them (tip: use grid snap on tiniest grid when u make them) fix

02:13:957 (7,8) - bad stream exit point move 8 to around x274 y196 or something ok

02:50:707 - the notes are all over the place, use some visual spacing and try to make them into patterns or shapes ill see what i can do,
but i dont see it as "over the place"

03:34:207 (1,2,3,4) - ummm why does 3 get smaller spacing and why is the pattern like that? try to use sharp angle plox hm ok but i use wide angle instead

04:10:207 (1) - blanket mb

04:51:269 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - bad stream flow again, you need to pretend that a stream consists of 2 circles, one on the start of the stream and the end. and pretend it's a jump ok

04:57:691 (1,1,1) - do you really need those red lines? they're not needed those beats are on 1/8 snap divisor not sure yet about this cause im gonna need a timing check for last part

Good luck

HabiHolic wrote:

Mod here.

00:04:582 (2,3,4) - here. check for distance. i bad this see. fix distance
00:06:832 (7,8) - hmm.. i think this not sure better patten.. so like this? i change a little bit to fix flow

SPOILER

00:25:957 (3,4,5) - same first modding here. 00:04:582 (2,3,4) - fix
00:40:582 - 00:41:332 - not add clap? aaaaaaa forgot to put
00:43:207 (1) - flowing is bad. ctrl+g fix
01:06:269 (3) - NC here. for that stream start. ye
01:08:707 (1) - this can fixed blanket? ye

SPOILER

01:22:582 (2) - This my suggest. i dont like now patten(lol). so remove reverse and 01:22:957 - this add note better lolol i want to keep it like this for less clickable objects

SPOILER

01:26:894 (3) - NC? flwing 01:25:207 (1) - here? yes
01:51:269 - Finish add here. check your for music sound lol..
01:53:332 - same(^) clap is not remove that
02:04:207 (1,2) - suggest?

SPOILER

02:35:144 (5,6,7) - check distance... so many mistake you lol
02:42:644 (3,4,1) - same(^)

GL!

FiddleBlue wrote:

Hi from queue.

General

• 
  I think the background is better if it's flipped horizontally so that the girl isn’t blocked by the song selection. If you want here's the image: https://gyazo.com/07f0616bd074bb7a698b9a5b25e93ff4. Feel free to compare both! - the orig one seems "natural" so idk if i change yet
  
  I think ar9 suits this better. The song doesn't really have that much intensity even in kiai, and the song isn't that calm as well. Since the majority of players prefer ar9 and higher, I would say ar9 is suitable. i would prefer to keep it ar 8.8
  
  Also since the kiai parts are very similar, the issues I'll state in the first part can be applied to the other.

Connect

1. 00:01:582 (2,3,4) - I'd say this is better if they're spaced equally as the sound of them are the same. The last one is different but the slider would be enough to reflect the difference as it's not louder or quieter. It will also differentiate it from 00:04:582 (2,3,4) - as this one has drums. this is fine for me i would just increase spacing of 00:04:207 (1,2,3,4) - instead
2. 00:06:832 (7) - I find it weird that the string is emphasized by a 1/4 slider when similar sounds before this are ignored. 00:06:457 - and 00:06:644 - have a string sound on them, so they must be equally emphasized as there's not that much difference to 00:06:832 (7) -. 00:07:019 - seems to sound the same though I'm not sure. i think its ok since 00:06:832 (7) - has the most prominent string sound so its not mapped like it and making it a small jump portion for strings is how i want to interpret it
3. 00:10:582 (2) - Personally, it would be visually better if the slider body is parallel to 00:09:832 (5,6,7,8) -.fixed but kept its distance a bit
4. 00:12:644 (4,5,6,7,8) - the same issue I have with before. 00:12:645 (4,5,7,8) - follows the drum more, but 00:12:832 (6) - is the opposite. Don't change the rhythm when there are no high changes in the music, it makes it random and feels out of place. I would prioritize the string more by putting 1/4 sliders as the parts before following it, though putting triples is fine as well. i did that cause there is no drum sound for 00:12:925 so i cant make a triple without overmapping it
5. 00:13:207 (1,2) - Swap NC as circle 2 sounds more prominent. 1 has finish
6. 00:13:394 (2,5) - Try not to overlap as it looks messy when there's another place to put it. fix
7. 00:17:707 (1,2) - Perhaps make this as a 1/2 slider as circle 2 is emphasizing a sound that is so quiet. ye
8. 00:21:082 (3,4) - Why did the spacing suddenly become larger here? I don't seem to hear anything that supports this. ye mb
9. 00:30:082 (2,3) - The spacing here seems too much as their spacing before isn't that long, and there isn't anything particularly different here so spacing should be short. fix slightly but still same concept, to avoid overlap and her voice raises a bit
10. 00:39:644 (4) - Making this repeat seems to understate this part when it should be the most emphasized on 00:38:519 (1,2,3,4) -. Instead of it repeating, how about making it a circle and slider instead? i prefer this to follow the the slider pattern
11. 00:43:207 (1) - Personally, I find it better if this is ctrl+g. The slider follows the circular flow from the previous NC group, but then it broke on 00:43:769 (2,3,4) -. 00:43:769 (2) - doesn't really support a change in circular flow, and also 00:43:207 (1,2,3,4) - flows really weird. i had a slight concept of lots of flow changing in this map
12. 00:51:457 (3) - I find a circle and spinner suit this better than repeating slider, but not that huge of a deal like the one before. rip background instruments if spinner
13. 00:58:582 (2,3) - I think to reverse this part in the timeline would follow the vocal more. uh i guess to emphasize the whistle hs, idk might change
14. 01:04:769 (3) - This repeating 1/2 slider isn't the same as 01:01:207 (1,1) - as there's no vocal. It's technically not wrong, but it feels off as it's used with a vocal backing it. Even after it, sliders like this has a vocal (01:07:207 (1,1) - ). I suggest making it a circle and slider as 01:04:957 - and 1/2 after has a vocal and you seem to emphasize it with sliders. tbd soon
15. 01:10:207 (1,2,3) - This part breaks the rhythm in the middle as you suddenly stop following the vocals and afterwards following it back. How about making the rhythm like this for the whole NC group: https://gyazo.com/3a5f7982a356d4bd52b29c1b3b8b14dc
16. 01:17:707 (1,2,3,4) - I think it's better if you make 01:17:707 (1,2) - and 01:18:457 (3,4) - different as the second one has vocal while the first one isn't. diffrently angled
17. 01:26:144 (1,2) - I would make this three consecutive 1/2 circles as they sound almost the same. less strain for clicking
18. 02:23:519 (5,4) - Why not overlap these fully? visuals and blanket tbd if fixed
19. 02:25:207 (1) - In the first kiai section this slider stops 1/4 before this and a circle is placed instead, but here it isn't. They sound the same so the rhythm should also be the same. first kiai had extra sound, dunno might fgix
20. 02:38:707 (1,3) - Why is this partially overlapping when after no objects are? mb
21. 02:51:082 (2,2,3,2,2,3,2) - Why put a pattern of "one circle, two circles…" here when they all can be two circles? It makes it hard to read 02:51:082 (2,3) - when there's not that much difference to 02:52:769 (3,4) -. it represents how the one two sounds different when you listen to it
22. 03:41:707 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - I find this section boring as it's the same rhythm repeating over and over. It would be better if there's some variety in it. Also, I think ignoring the part where the vocal comes in is a bad decision as you can reflect those changes by mapping to the vocal and back to the 03:44:707 (1,2,3,4) - when it stops. This will reflect the song more and give you some variety. calm section, dfont want to overmap, ill fix the patterning soon
23. 04:37:207 (1,2,3,4,5) - This is a bit overmapping and don't really follow the song in my opinion. The loudest and most recognized instrument in this part is the string. So how about making the rhythm like this (includes using 04:37:019 (5) - ): https://gyazo.com/c736f30ddd316a5728b4da04444e3270 changed my way
24. 04:59:236 (1) - Spinner would be better ending on 05:02:143 - as that's the place where the guitar finish fading out. It'll still make the map more than 5 minutes, no worries. its fine cause i can still hear sound

Good luck!