Nekomata Master feat. Sana - Ookina Koe de · forum

Curisu

Joined January 2010

Curisu 2011-10-05T16:06:49+00:00

Nekomoeta Master <3

[NM]
00:38:563 (6) - vol-10
02:00:163 - slience here?

[HD]
...circle size-1?
00:38:563 - vol-15
01:35:563 - +whistle?
02:00:163 - as same as NM..

wow moe map

Niva

Global Moderator

3,190 posts

Joined November 2009

Niva 2011-10-05T22:55:01+00:00

Mod request from Mini Maya Queue ~

[General]
-> Offset 458 (-6) ? Sounds better for me ><
-> ~~Why not Normal -> Hyper orz~~

[Normal]
-> HP Drain 2 seems too low >< 3 better imo
00:14:263 (4) - There's a high-pitched instrument here. Add whistle here?
00:55:063 (2) - Whistle here?
00:59:863 (2) - This note is too close to (1), maybe use grid lv4 here
01:11:863 (4) - The 5/4 delay might be tricky for new players. I recommend changing it into a slider to prevent beginners confused about the timing
01:55:663 (1) - ~ 20 - 30 % volume whistle sound here maybe?

[Hard]
00:14:863 (1) - Finish on slider start better imo
00:37:813 (4) - Move the whistle to (5) ?
00:41:263 (1,2,3,4) - Suggestion, you can create a jump like this (which plays better in DT imo) : http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/158513, or just swap (3)'s and (4)'s position
00:49:063 (3,4) - Combining these two into a slider like http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/158512 could give more flow imo. Not really necessary to change though.
01:49:363 (7,8,9,10,11) - Quite hard to read >< Star-shaped jump plays better imo

Awesome map ><

DeadAlready

1,575 posts

Joined August 2008

DeadAlready 2011-10-06T20:40:15+00:00

1st star~ >w</
~~oh no message limits now?xD~~

AisamaDX

211 posts

Joined November 2009

AisamaDX 2011-10-07T10:01:39+00:00

KAM
I

Sure

4,220 posts

Joined February 2009

Sure 2011-10-13T15:40:31+00:00

[General]
Tick rate 2 is much better.
If you decide to use TR 2, set BSD to 1/4 before change it.
Only one slider will have the ticks that doesn't fit. 01:10:058 (3) - this.
You can use audio volume 5% for that.

[Hard]
01:49:658 (8) - New combo?

[Normal]
01:43:358 (1) - Remove new combo to be consistent with 01:24:158 (3)

Lalalala lala lalala

tutuhaha

3,000 posts

Joined October 2010

tutuhaha 2011-10-14T22:21:23+00:00

Mp3 maybe make 192KB?
too low there...
KIAI time → 01:12:458 - 01:26:858 ,01:31:658 - 01:46:058
PreviewTime: 67658

Normal

....OR Easy？..
OD-1
HP+1
00:24:458 (1) - finish
01:02:858 (1) - whistle
01:10:658 - you don't need this green line I think

Hard

OD-1

00:24:008 (7,8) - space
00:29:108 (X) - add one circle
01:06:308 (X) - ^
01:17:108 (X) - ^
01:36:308 (X) - ^
01:50:708 (X) - ^
01:54:308 (X) - ^

nice I like it XD！

Zelos

1,111 posts

Joined May 2010

Zelos 2011-10-19T20:05:40+00:00

I request when answering my mod that you state if you accepted it or if you denied it and why if you dont mind :3

Folder:
Clean!

Please note any mod post is only a suggestion and can be freely ignored.

Normal:
00:38:558 (6) - I know the song itself has a cymbal finish like sound hear but in my humble opinion, osu finish hitsound does not fit here.
Thats it on this difficulty

Hard:
00:34:058 (1) - (nazi alertz!) the fact that the hump in this slider is not symmetrical is really really bothering me. perhaps maybe make symmetrical?

Nothing really wrong at all in this mapset.
Nice.

mauyakeso

1 post

Joined October 2011

mauyakeso 2011-10-27T16:27:39+00:00

Magicphoenix

2,142 posts

Joined April 2010

Magicphoenix 2011-11-27T00:37:34+00:00

Don't let this die....

Magicphoenix

2,142 posts

Joined April 2010

Magicphoenix 2012-01-13T19:59:21+00:00

DON'T LET THIS DIE !! :_<

yeahyeahyeahhh

osu! Alumni

2,850 posts

Joined December 2008

yeahyeahyeahhh 2012-02-29T06:54:03+00:00

la laaaaa laaaaa la la la lala laaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa~

NewRulerNA

1,301 posts

Joined December 2010

NewRulerNA 2012-07-23T10:12:47+00:00

hi

[General]

fine

[Normal]

00:10:058 (1,2) - (2)のスライダーのアプローチサークルに沿った配置となっていますが、僅かにズレが生じています
00:11:258 (2) - x:128 y:100に移動させればこの僅かなズレは解消します
00:14:858 (1,2) - 個人的にはこのスライダーエンドとスライダースタートの位置が同じ方が好きです
00:14:858 (1) - 変更をするならばx:372 y:268に移動で
00:35:258 (2,4) - この2つを比べると1gridだけ横にズレています
00:36:458 (4) - x:438にすると綺麗に並びます
00:50:858 (4,5) - 00:10:058 (1,2)と同じ
00:52:658 (5) - 1grid right (Tiny)
01:37:658 (2,3,4) - ここのDistanceの変化の仕方が私は良いとは思えませんでした
01:38:558 (3,4) - 1 grid left (Tiny)
01:52:058 (3,4) - 00:10:058 (1,2)と同じ
01:53:258 (4) - 1 grid left (Tiny)

[Hard]

00:36:458 (1,2) - ここの段差が私は気になりました
こんな感じの段差のない流れのほうが私は好きです
01:53:258 (4) - 01:52:058 (3)比較で見ると、(4)の始点の節の位置がやや低いように見えます
節の位置をx:82 y:244に設定することで見た目がやや改善します

これだけです

譜面の流れ、音取りを見てもどちらの難易度も申し分なく、細かな指摘/提案のみです

good luck

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-07-23T11:59:32+00:00

thanks

yeahyeahyeahhh

osu! Alumni

2,850 posts

Joined December 2008

yeahyeahyeahhh 2012-07-23T14:17:50+00:00

Maybe source just beatmania IIDX and put rest in tags?

Ryafuka

840 posts

Joined May 2010

Ryafuka 2012-07-24T00:45:11+00:00

from #modreqs

[Normal]
00:38:558 (6) - move to x:93 y:294? better flow than now.
00:52:658 (5) - remove whistle from end?
00:57:758 (5) - add finish instead whistle like 00:52:658 (5,1) - ?
02:00:158 - change volume to 5%? because that is end of the music and very quiet.

[Hard]
00:29:858 (3) - replace for ctrl + H?
00:53:258 (3) - add finish at start?
00:57:758 (5) - same as Normal.
01:48:458 (6) - add new combo?
02:00:158 - same as Normal.

good luck with ranked~

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-07-24T03:45:54+00:00

thanks Ryafuka!

Yoru-hide

68 posts

Joined April 2011

Yoru-hide 2012-07-25T18:01:41+00:00

HI! from my modding queue~

[General]

Grid Level 4? The song is constructed by Snap 1/6(00:14:458 (7)), why now is 1/4 ?

[Hard]

AR 7 ?

00:28:358 (2) - move to x:64 , y:248.
00:31:358 (6) - move to one grid right.
01:16:058 (1,2) - try this
SPOILER
01:21:758 (9) - NC?
01:23:558 (3) - move to one grid right.
01:48:458 (6) - NC?

[Normal]

Fine.

Good Luck!

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-07-25T23:54:15+00:00

thanks Yoru-SAN

popner

osu! Alumni

2,407 posts

Joined March 2011

popner 2012-07-27T03:47:11+00:00

Hi ~ Mod request from My Queue.

Just suggestions:

[Normal]
00:13:658 (3) - move to 00:13:058 (3)? Better to me

[Hard]
00:35:258 (3,4) - use same rhythm like 00:30:458 (4,5,6)? Seems fit the vocal better
01:11:408 - add a note?
01:11:708 - ^
01:19:658 (5) - move a little to make a curve like 01:14:858 (5,6,7) ? http://puu.sh/M4jm
01:38:858 (5,6,7) - ^ http://puu.sh/M4l7

That's all I can find. GL~

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-07-27T06:44:22+00:00

thanks popner

HelloSCV

3,490 posts

Joined April 2011

HelloSCV 2012-07-29T16:36:30+00:00

Hi~ From my Queue
My Modding is Suggestion so you can ignore this

SPOILER

Normal
OD -1?
00:46:058 (3) - NC
01:00:458 (3) - add whislte start of slider

Hard
00:13:658 (5) - NC
01:05:258 (7) - ^
01:17:258 (1) - add finish start of slider
01:20:858 (8) - NC
01:25:358 (8) - ^
01:26:258 (1) - add finish on slider back
01:40:058 (8) - NC
01:43:658 (6) - ^
01:48:458 (6) - ^

Lovely song <3 Good luck!

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-03T07:11:23+00:00

thanks HelloSCV

Saturnalize

1,490 posts

Joined March 2011

Saturnalize 2012-08-08T21:53:45+00:00

la la la la lala lalaa~
lala la la lala lalala~
lala la la lala lalala~ lalala~
la la lalala~

Why no normal hitsound? Just suggestion though, but I think it fits on some places.

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-08T22:54:43+00:00

where part? I disagree.
btw thanks for star

CTB Fia

CTB Fia 2012-08-10T03:22:16+00:00

this song is great
i suggest you to make more difficulty like easy and insane

Normal - Nothing to say

Hard
change your slider tick rate to 4 to fit the song ryhtm
00:00:758 - try to start your beats here (with soft sound effect of course)
01:07:658 (1,2,3) - change it to spinner

that's all i can say
then i shall take my leave
anyway GOOD LUCK and i'm sure your map will be ranked or apporved for sure!!!

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-10T05:56:50+00:00

thanks shojimeguro

Genkishi

566 posts

Joined September 2010

Genkishi 2012-08-10T06:14:24+00:00

[Normal]
01:50:858 - I think adding some timing point with 40% of volume sounds better
01:36:458 (1) - add finish on th head of this slider
01:55:358 - add note?

[Hard]
-I saw this error in the Aimod http://puu.sh/Qka9..maybe you could fix it?
01:04:658 (6) - Add new combo here?
01:50:858 - I think adding some timing point with 40% of volume sounds better

Overall Good map..

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-10T06:25:25+00:00

thanks Genkishi

Sekai

6,376 posts

Joined February 2011

Sekai 2012-08-11T16:11:45+00:00

Mod requested via in-game pm :3

General:
Clear~

Normal:
AR +1 makes it better for normal diff~

00:13:058 (3) - I think you should add a note here seems empty >< don't forget to fix the spacing after that~
00:14:858 (1) - add a finish on slider's head sounds better to me ~
00:19:358 (5) - remove this finish it's sounds really off orz~
00:24:458 (1) - maybe make a nice blanket with the other slider like this?
SPOILER
00:26:858 (3) - I think you should add a finish here to make your finish hitsound consistent~
00:29:258 (1) - you should lower the volume on this finish in like this
00:31:358 (4) - remove this whistle sound >< why on red tick?
00:36:158 (3) - ^
00:37:658 (5) - i dont think this slider curved it well so maybe do it like this?
SPOILER
00:38:558 (6) - remove the whistle and finish on this note then add a finish here 00:38:858 (1) - it's sounds really good to me
00:40:958 (4) - orz just like i said before 00:31:358 (4) -
00:43:358 (7) - ^
00:50:558 (3) - ^
00:52:658 (5) - remove the finish and whistle on the slider end. it really dont follow anything~
00:57:758 (5) - remove this whistle orz with same reason above~
01:02:558 (5) - ^
01:11:858 (3,4) - what the hack is this? lol
01:40:958 (5) - finish dont really fit here orz~

Hard:
AR and HP +1 it's really slow atm ><
Nothing much to find good work ~

Nice Map and song Muya ~ Good luck with ranking~ :3

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-11T16:39:34+00:00

thanks Sekai

YTYuyu

osu! Alumni

4,147 posts

Joined January 2011

YTYuyu 2012-08-12T22:57:02+00:00

alright let's get started...mod requested on my queue.

Bold: Unrankable/must fix.
Red: You should fix it, but it's up to you.
Italic: Suggestion. Feel free to ignore this if you don't like it.
Blue: Comment. I'll give you my opinion, advice, or if i'm curious about something.

[General]
aww Rorona kawaii~ <3333
if this is from beatmania, consider adding "Komani" since they're the developers of beatmania, and "Benami" in the tags because it's Konami's music video game division.
you have no breaks, so disable the letterbox during breaks for all diffs.

[Normal]
00:13:058 - maybe add a circle to keep that 1/1 rhythm, not to mention it'll follow the bass?
00:13:658 (3,4,1) - consider adding whistles to match the bass in the song. i think it'll be consistent with the green combo colors at the beginning of the song IMO.
00:19:358 (5) - reduce the volume to 50%. i feel that doing this would emphasize the instrumental in this part of the song. if you do this, raise the volume back to 70% for (1) to represent a new pattern.
00:31:358 (4,5) - i think it sounds a lot better if the whistle is at the beginning of the slider and not at the circle. i find the whistle at the circle unfitting with this part of the song IMO.
00:36:158 (3,4) - ^
00:38:558 (6) - that finish is too loud and it might distract players during gameplay. i suggest reducing the volume to 40 or 50% to match the cymbals in the song.
00:52:658 (5) - same as above but at the end.
01:05:258 (3) - do Ctrl+H instead. the slider should be blanketed for this part. like this if you don't know.
01:24:458 (4,5) - flip these sliders around like this. i feel that doing this would make the flow smoother during gameplay.
01:26:858 (1) - maybe replace the whistle for a finish to emphasize the vocals and to represent a new pattern?
01:34:058 (4,5) - i think it sounds nice if you can add whistles at the end of (4) and the beginning of (5). basically adding a whistle at (5) would emphasize the vocals, and (4) would follow it up.
01:40:958 (5) - replace the finish for a whistle. it'll be consistent with 01:21:758 since it has a whistle-finish pattern.
01:55:658 (1) - i feel that the spinner's end should be silenced since the instrumental dies down here.

[Hard]
00:38:258 (6) - same as normal but at the end.
00:53:258 (1) - add a finish at the beginning for consistency with the normal diff.
01:53:258 (1) - remove the NC for this. same reason as above.
01:55:958 (1) - same as the last suggestion on normal.
other than that, this is a nice diff.

I guess that's it. Star and GL

Niva

Global Moderator

3,190 posts

Joined November 2009

Niva 2012-08-13T11:12:27+00:00

Hi Muya~ orz my mod post on first page ._.

Let me recheck this...

[General]

-> I really recommend PreviewTime: 71810, I already experimented around and it's the most accurate preview time (: (you must set this manually in Notepad though)
-> Add "ookinakoede" to tags, in some website this song is written without space (also add "Sayonara Sekai" if you want~)

[Normal]

-> Well, there are many variations about how the whistles can be placed on this song though...

00:10:058 (1,2) - CTRL+R (1) and curve (2) downward instead of upward? It'll give a better circular flow imo, plus an elegant movement between (2,3) xD
00:14:258 (4) - Add whistle here? (you have whistle on 00:23:258 (4)'s end orz, plus this whistle fits actually :3)
00:16:058 (2) - (optional) Place slightly higher (~x:461 y:135), to create a less narrow angle between (1,2)?
00:28:058 (5) - Uhm, I think adding whistle on slider's end to follow the trumpet-like synth here won't hurt xD
00:46:658 (4) - It's closer to (3) compared to (5), not a big issue though >_<
00:55:658 (3) - Err... Not really sure with whistle on slider's end here, what it's following actually? (yes, all of the instruments aren't standing strong here, I suggest to add whistle to your blue (2) and remove whistle on slider's end here for a better rhythm~)
00:57:458 (4,5) - (optional) imo you can put (4) a bit more to the upper-left and adjust (5) to form an arc like this:
SPOILER
01:00:458 (3) - Because (2) has no whistle, add whistle on slider's start here instead? Feels quite lonely without whistle here >_<
01:05:258 (3) - (optional) ...uhm, as said in above post, I don't feel really right with this slider... imo it doesn't need CTRL+H though, something like this flows better because of the circular movement:
SPOILER
01:08:858 (2,3) - Perhaps use 40% volume (instead of 70) to make these two more dramatic? :3
01:19:358 (3,4) - Uhm, it's unclear whether you're arranging these in a straight line or not >_< (I prefer slightly curving upward though, fits your style more I think xD)
SPOILER
01:22:058 (1) - Add whistle (together with finish) on slider's start - you have it on Hard~
01:35:258 (5) - Whistle on slider's start sounds cute with the synth here imo~ Not a must though (:
01:38:858 (4) - Again, (I think) it'll fit your style better if you put the arc upper (~x:200 y:148) orz ._.
01:47:258 (3,4,5,6) - (optional) ...to be honest I don't think encircling (4) to (3) works quite well here (somehow it looks rigid because of your previous (1,2)'s placement), I'd focus on these four's arc angle like this:
SPOILER
01:53:258 (4) - Shorten by 1/1 and don't add anything else? (the synth ends there actually, plus the delay to the spinner really looks dramatic :3)

[Hard]

00:10:058 (1) - Extend by 1/4? There's a bass sound there orz ._.
00:13:658 (2,3,4,5,1) - I highly recommend an arc like this, flows a lot better compared to straight line: (I don't really mind the small gap between (1) and (2), I'd sacrifice a tiny spacing inconsistency for a much cuter flow here :3)
SPOILER
00:29:558 (2) - Minor stuff, move to ~x:385 y:372 for better triangle spacing here (:
00:37:658 (3) - Put in ~x:422 y:76 for a slight arc? (if you listen to the vocals the notes sang isn't flat, it went down and up so it'll fit the vocals if you made this go down and up :3)
00:38:858 (1) - (optional) CTRL+R like this? Plays more natural imo >_<
SPOILER
00:41:258 (1,2) - orz, you can also CTRL+R this for a circular movement if you want xD
00:55:058 (5) - Whistle on slider's end here? Feels quite empty without it...
01:04:358 (3,4) - (optional) Apply a triangle jump like this? I personally liked the circular movement on (4,1) here (you can choose not to CTRL+R (4) if you want though :3)
SPOILER
01:10:058 (3) - Same as Normal, whistle on slider's end here fits the vocal very much and it won't hurt~
01:15:158 (3,4,5,6) - ...make the spacing gradually increase like this?
SPOILER
01:21:758 (5) - ...Add finish also here for more power? (not really sure though >_<)
01:31:358 (4) - Same as above
01:35:258 (4) - Add whistle as well here? Blends well with the flute ~
01:43:358 (5,1) - The small jump here, is it intentional? (not that hard to catch though)
01:55:358 (3) - (optional) Delete note? Basically same as Normal, deleting note will cause more delay before the spinner (plus dramatizes the ending (: )
01:55:958 (1) - ~~Why start spinner 1/2 after last note, why not 1/8 orz~~ Not a big issue though~

orz, I'll personally recheck this when you've applied the mods~

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-13T13:58:20+00:00

thanks both

Niva

Global Moderator

3,190 posts

Joined November 2009

Niva 2012-08-15T00:58:41+00:00

Okay~ Only one thing though (don't kudosu this):

[Normal]

01:50:858 (1) - You're not using any hitsound here while in Hard you're using Whistle + Finish, is it intentional? (doesn't sound bad though, just asking...)

Well, I'll edit my post after I get your response (:

-----------------------------------------

EDIT : Oh, fast response o.o

Bubbled ~

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-08-15T01:07:28+00:00

done!
btw congrats joined BAT

nanda2009

925 posts

Joined October 2009

nanda2009 2012-08-16T00:43:41+00:00

awesome map is awesome~

HakuNoKaemi

3,828 posts

Joined October 2009

HakuNoKaemi 2012-08-23T09:04:03+00:00

Draining Time: 1:45
2 difficulty-spread

hmm

please get some guest or create another difficulty. (remember, you can have Taiko or CtB diffs too)

No kudosu for a shabby tentative to make the spread larger

-Baby Strawberry-

387 posts

Joined September 2011

-Baby Strawberry- 2012-09-03T16:07:51+00:00

oww, already bubbled... im too late to mod...
anyway, good map and good luck on ranking~

Garven

osu! Alumni

5,857 posts

Joined January 2010

Garven 2012-09-17T16:27:30+00:00

[General]
Tick rate 2 sounds nice on this song.
I'd use 5% volume sections 01:10:058 (3) - and silence the tick(s)

Maps are fine.
Let me know your thoughts on the tick rate.

Muya

2,355 posts

Joined August 2009

Topic Starter

Muya 2012-09-17T19:52:04+00:00

I dont like tick rate 2