1. Advanced (3.36 stars, 177 notes)
2. Basic (1.76 stars, 114 notes)
3. Extreme (4.84 stars, 262 notes)
4. Taiko Muzukashii (4.72 stars, 354 notes)

OzzyOzrock wrote:

SPOILER

I'll make the taiko, but I'm modding this as well. Yup, that's what I was hoping for.
[General]
Try to make the BG a 3:4 aspect. This looks nicer than having those black borders.
- This will unfortunately stretch the BG to no end, so find a better BG.
Done.

Also, BPM seems off at parts orz
[Basic]
Pretty boring easy lol, especially with the somewhat ugly sliders.
Refer to this if you haven't: viewtopic.php?f=56&t=37194

01:05:682 (1,2,3,1) - No spacing increases on an Easy lol. Could blow their faces up. Fixed.
01:19:344 - The End - You don't use any sliders for this whole part, that's a bad thing. More sliders added here.

All I can really say is to make this look nicer. Try using a larger grid size so that circles don't vary in distance and stuff. Try not to use many boxy patterns, but instead use awesome sliders so there's a nice look of flow in the map. And don't map to vocals too much on Easy lol. Done, I went through the entire map and tweaked everything to be curvier, less boxy, and hopefully not so ugly.

BUT, there's nothing WRONG with an ugly map, it's just ugly. Which is... bad.
[Advanced]
Pretty much the same as above. I found the problem though, slider speed.

At the BPM of this song, I'd recommend a slider speed like 1.50, not 1.00. That's more something for an Easy diff, not a Hard/Normal or whatever this may be, lol. But yes, I'd recommend re-mapping this with a faster speed. Done; I simply changed the x1 sections to x1.5 and remapped them.

Then it'll look nice yadda yadda and boom magic.
[Extra]
What the hell?
WHAT THE HELL!?

You kept using 1.00... for the EXTRA? Use at least 2.00. AT LEAST.
And because you'll be using 2.00, don't use those x2 sections. Done, everything's 2.00 now.

But yes, fix up those common new mapper mistakes and this should be moddable. Good luck. Moddable? Do you mean rankable? Or was it actually too crappy to even mod?

Neptunus wrote:

SPOILER

Basic:
00:55:106 (2,3,4,1) - these four notes are not well distance snapped Fixed.
01:19:344 (1) - good inspiration but this may be too hard to read for a Basic diff since most of the player would be beginners. Overlapped is hard for them OK, changed it.

Advanced:
00:56:428 (1) - I dont think this note is acceptable for a ranked map, please asked BATs about this I was a bit worried about this one too. Changed it just to be safe.
00:56:428 (1) - it is not suggested that you use double timing in a [NORMAL] diff This is meant to be a Hard diff, actually.

Extreme:
00:22:715 (6,7) - oh oh~spacing problem again Fixed.
01:12:513 (4,5,6,7,8,9) - also these Fixed.
01:04:140 (9) - should newcombo here, although it was like "全部.....なになになに。。。。（わかな。。。）"but according to the rhythm pattern ,you should newcombo here I added the new combo there, although this made for two unusually short combos, so I removed the new combo at 01:06:123 (6) to compensate.


Good luck on ranking , awesome mapset~
頑張ります～
Thank you!
ありがとうございます～

Kawayi Rika wrote:

SPOILER

hi ~ PoochyEXE

my some tips.

[General]

read-in time it's too long, 2 seconds OK. Changed to 2 seconds.
You should have a complete set of Skin. The skin is still a WIP, I do plan on having a more complete one before it gets ranked.
change BG Size 800*600 or 1024*768 plz. Done.


[Extreme]

CZ+1 Done.
00:10:155 (6) - too Noisy,only finish plz. OK.
00:58:411 (4) - add NC. I disagree with these; I think having an NC every measure is too frequent for this section.
01:06:123 (6) - ^
01:08:988 (4) - ^
01:12:513 (4) - ^


[Advanced]

AR+1 Done.
This difficulty is very noisy,Delete redundant finish,clap. Took out a whole bunch of them. Not sure if I caught them all, though.
00:33:953 (7) - add NC. I disagree with this one. This would be a NC right smack in the middle of a phrase in the lyrics, the music doesn't have anything to suggest an NC as far as I can tell, and it'd be in the middle of a circle pattern (the lightning bolt). An NC here just wouldn't make any sense to me any way I look at it.
00:49:377 (5) - ^ Done. This one I agree with.


[Basic]

00:55:106 (2,3,4) - Distance error. Fixed, hopefully. If not, someone PLEASE give me exact (x, y) coordinate suggestions.


good luck~ Thank you, and thanks for the mod~

f-INVERSE wrote:

SPOILER

[Basic]
OHHHHH MY GAWWWWWWWWWWWD IT'S SO SLOW I COULD DIE .
Please, increase the Approach Rate a little faster! OK.
Sounds a little wrong, but maybe I'm hearing things wrong.
The ending is VERY REPETITIVE. Try using Ctrl+H or Ctrl+J to change the beats.

[Advanced]
Use 1/4 beat snap divisor instead of 1/2 for a harder difficulty. Some parts sound really wrong. My opinion. There's plenty of stuff snapped to 1/4, the editor just happens to be on 1/2 since my last tweaks were on a section full of 1/2-snapped beats.
00:45:884 - Your loop is WRONG. Look at spoiler for guide. Your points must be symmetrical. Use Ctrl+H to check for this, ALWAYS. I could've sworn I caught this one and fixed it, back when I remapped it in response to OzzyOzrock's suggestions. Must've forgotten to save or something. Thanks for catching it.
The ending is VERY REPETITIVE. Try using Ctrl+H or Ctrl+J to change the beats.

[Extreme]
PLEASE DO NOT USE EXTREMELY SMALL CIRCLES. People on Hard Rock will not be able to even play this. Unless they are divine people. Okay, Circle Size - 1.
Please put STACK LENIENCY at Level 4. You can change stack leniency by going to Advanced in the Song Setup. Ditto for all other difficulties. Um, sure, but I don't see where I have any stacked beats that this would affect.
00:45:843 - Again, this loop is not symmetrical. See spoiler in Advanced difficulty. Same comment as for the one on Advanced. Again, thanks for catching it.
The ending is VERY REPETITIVE. Try using Ctrl+H or Ctrl+J to change the beats. I'm really tired of doing Y stuff.

/endmod
____________________________

• Nazi discussion on tags:
  - remove jubeat as it appeared in source.
  - Doubtful on "game" because it's more like the song from animation? Game is something like the OP of a visual novel game, etc
  Countdown set-up should be unique, even you don't start as early as other diffs for [Basic], you should remove the countdown. Of course I'll suggest you to start [Basic] as early as other diffs.
  Offset seems too early.
  I don't see the point to make different combo colour settings for different diffs.

• 00:00:460 (1,2) - off vocal significantly. [same as adv.]
  00:17:647 (1) - left 1 grid lv 4
  00:22:935 (7,8) - consecutive claps sounds too loud for me, try to remove the clapping at the middle tick, at least.
  01:06:674 (8) - you can make this slider parallel to last part of next slider (1), then it looks much better.
  01:21:107 (1,2) - avoid this kind of slider. (2) is partially covered by (1) that theoratically this creates difficulty for player to see the coming notes.
  01:24:632 (1,2) - ^
  01:28:148 (1,2) - ^
  01:31:683 (1,2) - ^
  01:35:209 (1,2) - ^ [bored to type this so many times, fixing the coming similar slider patterns]

wmfchris wrote:

SPOILER

Answering your question:
Each song has its own lovers and they can be as fun as each other. I don't think the majority tends to play one version than another one here, so just make this one on the track, than make another if you like.
Thanks for the input!

[General]

• Nazi discussion on tags:
  - remove jubeat as it appeared in source. Done.
  - Doubtful on "game" because it's more like the song from animation? Game is something like the OP of a visual novel game, etc Well, Inazuma Eleven is a game that spun off an anime, while this song's from the anime and appeared in jubeat, which is another game. Is this enough to qualify it to be tagged with "game"?
  Countdown set-up should be unique, even you don't start as early as other diffs for [Basic], you should remove the countdown. Of course I'll suggest you to start [Basic] as early as other diffs. Removed the countdown. //TODO: I'll consider starting [Basic] at the same time.
  Offset seems too early. //TODO: This has been bugging me as well, but I can't get it just right. If I fix it so it's perfect at the beginning, the ending goes out of sync. If I fix it so it's perfect throughout the ending, the beginning goes out of sync. If I change the BPM, so that the beginning and end are both in sync, the middle goes out of sync. Argh!
  I don't see the point to make different combo colour settings for different diffs. Whoops, that was an accident. I was experimenting with them in Advanced and forgot to duplicate my settings over to the other diffs. Thanks for catching it, I've fixed it now.

[Extreme]

• 00:00:460 (1,2) - off vocal significantly. [same as adv.] Are you sure? I could swear it matches the instrumental melody. (And also the rhythm of the jubeat chart, for that matter.)
  00:17:647 (1) - left 1 grid lv 4 Done.
  00:22:935 (7,8) - consecutive claps sounds too loud for me, try to remove the clapping at the middle tick, at least. Done.
  01:06:674 (8) - you can make this slider parallel to last part of next slider (1), then it looks much better. Done.
  01:21:107 (1,2) - avoid this kind of slider. (2) is partially covered by (1) that theoratically this creates difficulty for player to see the coming notes. I nudged these a bit apart, is that better? Or should I have them completely not overlapping at all?
  01:24:632 (1,2) - ^
  01:28:148 (1,2) - ^
  01:31:683 (1,2) - ^
  01:35:209 (1,2) - ^ [bored to type this so many times, fixing the coming similar slider patterns]

1) lol not really extreme, looks like a hard. The note density seems fine so you can make it harder through increasing the spacing between each notes. and under such notes arrangment, OD 6, DR 6 may suits the diff well. Changed to OD6 DR6.
2) Try to make more variation between slider and notes, I can see some potential from the current one~ OK, any suggestions as to how to do this?
3) regular normal-clap sounds ok, but seems we need some substitution for whistle? I'm inclined to agree (in fact, the very first revision of this chart had a bunch more whistles that I quickly took out because of this), but I can't find a better whistle. Find me a better whistle and I'll be very thankful.

[Advanced]
00:11:918 (3) - up 1 grid Done.
00:22:935 (3,4) - refer to extreme Done.
00:31:309 - all clapping sounds bad. Try clapping on (2,6,10,12) and rephrase the hitsounds till 00:45 Done.
^ and the new combo arrangement is messy. Try a new combo per sentence. I'm finally caving on this one. Done.
00:57:970 (2,3) - spacing Fixed, hopefully.
01:06:123 (2) - left+up 1 grid Done.
- I don't prefer change in SV here because I don't see any reason to do this. Also, this diff looks like a normal, the un-noticed SV change can be a trap for them. If more people say the same, I'll change it. The intention was to have the slider velocity increase with Kiai Time, though, and I made sure the first slider after every SV change has at least one tick to make it more noticeable.
- sounding and spacing seems better in [Extreme], please check yourself by AI mod orz. Don't clap too much OK, toned down the claps.

[Beginner]
Tick rate 1 is preferred. Other than this it would be ok. Done.

In overall it needs more hitsound mod :/
and try to boost your creativity a bit : D

Byakugan249 wrote:

SPOILER

Yo modding ur map because of ur request

Basic:
00:50:939(4) - make the slider like this http://puu.sh/8sL2 because that slider isnt smooth. make u use a 4 point and not a 3 point slider Done, thank you!
00:52:922(1) - extend it to the big white tick Not so sure about these, since then the end point creates a "thump" sound in a pause in the lyrics/melody.
00:56:488(1) - ^
01:07:025(1) - ^
01:10:551(1) - ^
01:22:671(2,3,4,5) - this part doesnt follow the vocals at all. so i suggest that u make it like this http://puu.sh/8sLY Added the 1-beat slider. //TODO: Not sure about the following half-beat slider on (3) since I'm worried that might be too hard. I'll think about it.
01:26:197(2,3,4,5) - ^ same image
01:36:774(2,3,4,5) - ^

Advanced:
00:01:578(1) - make it even by going 1 grid right for the 3rd point Fixed, thanks.
01:29:723(3,4,5,6) - make it like this instead http://puu.sh/8sNq Thought that might be just a little too hard, so I changed it to be somewhere around halfway between what your image shows and what I had before.
01:36:774(3,4,5,6) - ^
01:51:098(1) - extend the repeat till 01:51:759 Whoops, this originally did end at 1:51:759, it just got messed up when I adjusted the BPM and somehow I failed to catch it. Fixed, thanks for catching it.

EXTREEME:(Fairly odd parents reference)
00:03:341(7) - NC I agree this needed an NC, although I ended up putting the NC at 00:02:680 (4) instead. Thanks for catching it.
00:12:376(5) - ^ These I don't agree with - I don't think 2 measures is too far apart for the NCs here, and to put an NC every measure would result in several NCs in the middle of a word in the lyrics.
00:15:902(6) - ^
00:19:648(6) - ^
00:29:344(8) - ^ I put the NC at 00:28:462 (4) instead.
00:54:905(3) - ^ Same comments as for 00:12:376(5)
00:58:431(4) - ^
01:01:737(4) - ^
01:06:144(6) - ^
01:09:009(4) - ^
01:12:534(4) - ^

this is the best i can do. GL

kissfly wrote:

SPOILER

volume - 10 Do you mean reduce the volume on every section by 10%?
Basic
01:45:589~01:51:098 - you should turn off kimi time Problem is, Kiai Time HAS to be consistent across diffs. I either have to leave this as-is or remove the break and map it.
basic is very good

Advance
00:12:596(?) - add circle Changed.
00:16:122(?) - ~
00:19:648(?) - ~
00:31:327~00:36:175 - use distance snap This entire section is consistent with itself, it just has smaller spacing than the previous section.
01:19:366(1) - bad cover Tweaked the slider a little for less overlap.
01:22:451(?) - add note I went with something closer to Byakugan249's suggestions here instead, sorry.
01:25:976(?) - ~
01:29:502(?) - ~
01:36:554(?) - ~

Extreme
use distance snap
00:03:121(6) - too close Fixed.
00:31:327(1) - ~
00:42:125(1) - bad overlapped Tweaked the slider a little for less overlap.

Good luck and happy in "11.11.11"

qilliam wrote:

SPOILER

[Basic]
Fix audio lead-in to 2000 to be consistent with other difficulties Done.

01:45:809 - place a spinner that ends at 01:49:335 instead of a break Done. //TODO: I oughta make a soccer ball spinner.

[Extreme]
I wish you didn't use 0.5x spacing... looks so cramped and messy Don't know how I could possibly change this without the risk of introducing a bunch of other errors, though.

L_P wrote:

SPOILER

extreme: way to far to look like an extreme....
the spacing is too small to be an extreme. map too much on vocal
00:06:206 (5) - this skin make repeat sign like john cena "you CANT see me!" //TODO: Add a custom repeat sign.
00:13:698 (7,1) - time between them is too long for insane Added a circle at 00:14:139
00:56:448 (1) - baaad shape Adding this to my //TODO list. Any suggestions for a fix?

advance: change the name to normal But then it doesn't match up with the jubeat difficulties.
mapped too much on vocal , no complain , nice slider shape~

conclusion: mapped too much on vocal, diff. is too easy......

CDFA wrote:

SPOILER

Oh no it's this soccer stuff again.

I'd go anal on your hitsounds, but I won't. I am gonna say though that you should probably consider playing your claps on the 2nd and 4th beat of each measure. That's just a general thing, so play with it as you wish~. OK, added some claps throughout.

Insane:
00:08:189 (5) - Not moe! Fixed.
00:56:448 (1) - ^ //TODO: Not sure how to fix this one. Suggestions?
01:05:042 (5) - ^ //TODO: Ditto. This one's been bugging me for a while, but I have no idea how to fix it. Tried to improve it a little.
01:52:419 (3) - Add finish on the end Disagree, the music's kinda fading out here already.

Advansu~:
00:29:123 (3) - Although the slider looks nice, don't put squiggles unless they fit with the music or something. The squiggles are meant to coincide with the lyrics. Any suggestions for alternatives?
01:52:420 (2) - Same as hard

Basicu~:
00:29:123 (3) - same as advanced~
01:52:420 (2) - Same as advanced

It's pretty solid. I'm not going to give it a star at the moment, but it's pretty cool stuff going on. Just the hitsounds are INCREDIBLY lacking, which makes me a sad panda.

dkun wrote:

SPOILER

hello there.

modding key
this is something you should fix, or possibly a suggestion
this is something unrankable

General
I found the skin really cute. Haha.
Overall, I would just like to say great job. :p Thanks!

Extreme
00:08:189 (5,1) - This is a bit hard to read on first play. Moved (1) so it's not almost entirely under (5).
00:22:953 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - I would say stack these. Done.
00:36:174 (6,1) - Probably an anti-jump you wouldn't want to keep. Yup, this was unintentional, thanks for catching it! (How did so many previous modders miss this one?)
00:37:497 (4,5) - A bit hard to read as well. Tweaked this a little. Still the same rhythm, just (hopefully) more readable.
00:50:939 (3) - What is this, I don't even. (Totally just joking with you. )
01:13:856 (10) - *personal preference* -> http://puu.sh/bJNh I think that looks better too, I'll use it.
01:45:809 (1) - Very nice. :p Thank you! (I spent quite some time doing trigonometry to get that just right. )

Advanced
00:29:123 (3) - I haven't seen a slider like this in a long while, good job. Thanks!
00:54:465 (2,3,4,5,6) - Putting these on red tick sounds very off. Changed these to be on white ticks.
00:57:990 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^
01:08:568 (2,3,4,5,6) - ^
Love the ending sliders, as well! Thank you!

Basic
01:23:552 (3,4) - Putting these on red threw me off through playthrough. Hm. I can see how this could throw people off, but I don't know how to put these on all white ticks and still follow the music. So I'll just stick a //TODO here.
01:27:078 (3,4) - ^ (pretty sure you get what I mean.)

suzutsukikanade wrote:

SPOILER

From my modding queue.

Favorite Inazuma Eleven song *--* Mine too!

[General]
Fine Here.

[Basic]
01:16:942 (1,2): Try this?//TODO: Maybe.

[Advanced]
00:11:054 (2): End slider in 00:11:494. Nah, ending it on a blue tick was intentional. This way the slider start hitsound, the slider tick in the middle, and the end hitsound all coincide with a note in the melody.
00:16:783: Add a note. Done.
00:36:615 (1): End slider in 00:37:056. Same as 00:11:054 (2).
01:26:197 (3): Spacing... Fixed these, no idea how I never caught this before.
01:36:774 (3): ^

Beautiful sliders here. Thanks!

[Extreme]

This have many spacing error...use DS 1,0 to fix.
00:33:350 (1,2,3): Like this? but no use this spacing. Is a example what I want you to do here. Just a small suggestion. I think that plays well and sounds good too. Replace the slider by notes. //TODO: Looks like a good idea, I'll try it when I have some time.
00:47:193: Add a note here to follow music. Done.
01:00:855 (2): Add whistle in this note. Did the first two, not sure about the last two since they might make the section too noisy. I'll think about it.
01:02:838 (6): ^
01:23:111 (4): ^
01:23:552 (6): ^