late boop
[General]
00:05:509 (5509|0,5607|1,5704|2,5801|3) - I like the clean and simple roll, but if you wanted, Im sure you could get away with an accordion style LN here since the strings almost seem to run into each other in sound, like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971094
00:14:860 (14860|3) - Could also extend this LN to be 1/1 to represent the open hat which almost seems to drag the song into the next measure.
00:18:366 (18366|4,18756|4,19146|4,19535|4,19925|4,20314|4,20704|4) - Quite the long stack in col 5 here. I know it's mostly the result of the repeated [13]
and [57] patterns, but I think you could shift the notes around so that the repeating chord is still there, but in a different column to avoid too much strain, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971101
00:20:607 - Might be nice to map the 1/4 hihat here since the section is kind of quiet, so it's much easier to notice little things like this.
00:29:860 - Shouldn't this be a triple for the snare like at 00:28:301 - ?
00:33:366 - The flute or held sound is a bit off in rhythm in that it's not a pure 1/4 triplet. It's really just shifted down by 1/16 a bit for the first three notes,
and the following three are kind of ??? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971116
00:59:081 (59081|6,59081|0,59275|5,59275|3,59275|1) - I think the chord size here should be flipped as the snare which tends to be mapped with a heavier emphasis is on 00:59:081 - whereas a weaker kick follows directly after at 00:59:275 -
01:11:548 (71548|6,71548|0,71743|5,71743|4,71743|1) - ^
01:04:730 (64730|3,64827|4,64925|3) - I think this is a bit of an awkward turn and disconnect in the brackets. Instead, I think it might be cool to mirror both patterns across both hands for symmetry and even strain + weight, like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971127
01:23:626 (83626|0,83724|1,83821|0,83821|2) - Feels a bit awkward to put a one handed mintrill on the ring + middle finger imo cause of the restriction in hand movement. I'd instead try to pattern the triplet in a way that the OH minitrill is on the index + thumb or index + middle as those tend to be the strongest fingers to hit with https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971136
01:24:211 (84211|2,84405|3,84600|2,84795|3,84990|2,85185|3) - This feels very uneven to me. I don't really hear anything in the music to suggest an alternating trill here either, as the bass is more of a hooked rhythm on the upbeat of 01:24:405 - 01:24:795 - , along with the kicks. So maybe separating the notes might be better, like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971142 (added an extra note on 01:24:990 - for the snare)
01:24:990 - 01:25:185 - You could also stack both chords here together since they're the same snare sound.
01:25:574 - I'd also make this a triple cause it's the same snare as at 01:25:769 - , so making them both different sizes, one with less emphasis and one with more, seems misleading.
01:26:159 - You've used a lot of 1/4 brackets before in this difficulty, so ending it off with a single 1/4 burst feels anticlimactic as the player is expecting one final double burst to finish off the song, but instead it's just a clean and simple roll. I might try this instead, with a bit of ending symmetry https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971149
Top diff looks pretty cool. Poke me if you've got any questions. Might get another mod or two on the 7k set and feel free to poke me for a check
[General]
- Might make the OD of 7K Easy 7 because there aren't very many LNs present in the song to necessitate a lower than normal OD.
- Think this might be a better clap than the one you have now as it's a bit closer in sound to the song without a complete blend https://puu.sh/xmWS3.wav
00:05:509 (5509|0,5607|1,5704|2,5801|3) - I like the clean and simple roll, but if you wanted, Im sure you could get away with an accordion style LN here since the strings almost seem to run into each other in sound, like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971094
00:14:860 (14860|3) - Could also extend this LN to be 1/1 to represent the open hat which almost seems to drag the song into the next measure.
00:18:366 (18366|4,18756|4,19146|4,19535|4,19925|4,20314|4,20704|4) - Quite the long stack in col 5 here. I know it's mostly the result of the repeated [13]
and [57] patterns, but I think you could shift the notes around so that the repeating chord is still there, but in a different column to avoid too much strain, like so https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971101
00:20:607 - Might be nice to map the 1/4 hihat here since the section is kind of quiet, so it's much easier to notice little things like this.
00:29:860 - Shouldn't this be a triple for the snare like at 00:28:301 - ?
00:33:366 - The flute or held sound is a bit off in rhythm in that it's not a pure 1/4 triplet. It's really just shifted down by 1/16 a bit for the first three notes,
and the following three are kind of ??? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971116
00:59:081 (59081|6,59081|0,59275|5,59275|3,59275|1) - I think the chord size here should be flipped as the snare which tends to be mapped with a heavier emphasis is on 00:59:081 - whereas a weaker kick follows directly after at 00:59:275 -
01:11:548 (71548|6,71548|0,71743|5,71743|4,71743|1) - ^
01:04:730 (64730|3,64827|4,64925|3) - I think this is a bit of an awkward turn and disconnect in the brackets. Instead, I think it might be cool to mirror both patterns across both hands for symmetry and even strain + weight, like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971127
01:23:626 (83626|0,83724|1,83821|0,83821|2) - Feels a bit awkward to put a one handed mintrill on the ring + middle finger imo cause of the restriction in hand movement. I'd instead try to pattern the triplet in a way that the OH minitrill is on the index + thumb or index + middle as those tend to be the strongest fingers to hit with https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971136
01:24:211 (84211|2,84405|3,84600|2,84795|3,84990|2,85185|3) - This feels very uneven to me. I don't really hear anything in the music to suggest an alternating trill here either, as the bass is more of a hooked rhythm on the upbeat of 01:24:405 - 01:24:795 - , along with the kicks. So maybe separating the notes might be better, like this? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971142 (added an extra note on 01:24:990 - for the snare)
01:24:990 - 01:25:185 - You could also stack both chords here together since they're the same snare sound.
01:25:574 - I'd also make this a triple cause it's the same snare as at 01:25:769 - , so making them both different sizes, one with less emphasis and one with more, seems misleading.
01:26:159 - You've used a lot of 1/4 brackets before in this difficulty, so ending it off with a single 1/4 burst feels anticlimactic as the player is expecting one final double burst to finish off the song, but instead it's just a clean and simple roll. I might try this instead, with a bit of ending symmetry https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8971149
Top diff looks pretty cool. Poke me if you've got any questions. Might get another mod or two on the 7k set and feel free to poke me for a check