This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
forum
Nagi - Sounding Beat (FELT - Increase Beat) [Osu|Taiko]
posted
Total Posts
5
Topic Starter
Easy:
You are breaking a guideline: Avoid slider-only sections.
Also get rid of those break times.
00:43:331 (1) - New combo not on white tick. Turning this into slider might be better.
Normal:
00:53:331 (4) - Unpredictable and breaking a guideline: Avoid 1/2 sliders with multiple reverses. (edit: just to clarify: "Rhythm related guidelines apply to approximately 180 BPM maps." Your map is 99 BPM so your 1/4 sliders would be 1/2 sliders in 180 BPM. Don't break this guideline)
Song perfectly supports Hard and Insane and maybe even Extra difficulties. You have a lot of work to do.
You are breaking a guideline: Avoid slider-only sections.
Also get rid of those break times.
00:43:331 (1) - New combo not on white tick. Turning this into slider might be better.
Normal:
00:53:331 (4) - Unpredictable and breaking a guideline: Avoid 1/2 sliders with multiple reverses. (edit: just to clarify: "Rhythm related guidelines apply to approximately 180 BPM maps." Your map is 99 BPM so your 1/4 sliders would be 1/2 sliders in 180 BPM. Don't break this guideline)
Song perfectly supports Hard and Insane and maybe even Extra difficulties. You have a lot of work to do.
from my queue
Easy
you could lower HP to 2, I don't think easy and normal should be the same hp
00:41:513 (2) - the cymbal is on blue tick. I think better way to map this part is like this, you get the cymbal on repeat and the next beat on white tick is clickable too.
00:48:785 (5) - this isn't on any strong sound either. You could use a 3/4 repeat slider again if you removed 00:47:270 (4) - and started the repeat slider at 00:48:179 - . doesn't work perfectly but better than what you have now
Normal
0.5 between ar and od is pretty low, od4 would be more standard
00:15:755 (1,2,3) - make the angle between 1,2 smaller? I think it looks a bit better
00:17:573 (4) - personally i would remove it to have a longer pause, but it works fine like this too
00:20:603 (1,2) - i think two doubles represent the song better, could stack a note on blue tick after 1 have a 1/4 slider on the next blue tick http://puu.sh/wojHa/a621ad81ea.PNG. You would have to change some other places for consistency but it would make the map more interesting imo.
the same rhythm that would have to be changed is 00:23:331 (2,3) - , 00:25:452 (1,2) - , 00:28:179 (2,3) -, 00:33:028 (2,3) - , 00:35:149 (1,2) - , 00:37:876 (2,3) - . probably a bit difficult for normal but you could use something similar for hard if you make it.
00:23:634 (3) - bit too tilted for me, the repeat is really close to 2
00:37:876 (2,3,4,5) - these could make a bit better square
00:51:513 (4,1,2) - bit ugly, rotating 1,2 counter-clockwise makes it look better. not much room for it but you could create that by moving 4 to the left
finally some touhou song, gl with the map
Easy
you could lower HP to 2, I don't think easy and normal should be the same hp
00:41:513 (2) - the cymbal is on blue tick. I think better way to map this part is like this, you get the cymbal on repeat and the next beat on white tick is clickable too.
00:48:785 (5) - this isn't on any strong sound either. You could use a 3/4 repeat slider again if you removed 00:47:270 (4) - and started the repeat slider at 00:48:179 - . doesn't work perfectly but better than what you have now
Normal
0.5 between ar and od is pretty low, od4 would be more standard
00:15:755 (1,2,3) - make the angle between 1,2 smaller? I think it looks a bit better
00:17:573 (4) - personally i would remove it to have a longer pause, but it works fine like this too
00:20:603 (1,2) - i think two doubles represent the song better, could stack a note on blue tick after 1 have a 1/4 slider on the next blue tick http://puu.sh/wojHa/a621ad81ea.PNG. You would have to change some other places for consistency but it would make the map more interesting imo.
the same rhythm that would have to be changed is 00:23:331 (2,3) - , 00:25:452 (1,2) - , 00:28:179 (2,3) -, 00:33:028 (2,3) - , 00:35:149 (1,2) - , 00:37:876 (2,3) - . probably a bit difficult for normal but you could use something similar for hard if you make it.
00:23:634 (3) - bit too tilted for me, the repeat is really close to 2
00:37:876 (2,3,4,5) - these could make a bit better square
00:51:513 (4,1,2) - bit ugly, rotating 1,2 counter-clockwise makes it look better. not much room for it but you could create that by moving 4 to the left
finally some touhou song, gl with the map
Topic Starter
LittleEndu wrote:
Easy:
You are breaking a guideline: Avoid slider-only sections. I think what to do in this section the sliders it's normal idea, but if more people more write about it - I will fix the section where only the sliders
Also get rid of those break times. I think what breaks this complexity is fine for the song
00:43:331 (1) - New combo not on white tick. Turning this into slider might be better. fixed
Normal:
00:53:331 (4) - Unpredictable and breaking a guideline: Avoid 1/2 sliders with multiple reverses. (edit: just to clarify: "Rhythm related guidelines apply to approximately 180 BPM maps." Your map is 99 BPM so your 1/4 sliders would be 1/2 sliders in 180 BPM. Don't break this guideline) fixed
Song perfectly supports Hard and Insane and maybe even Extra difficulties. You have a lot of work to do.
hohol454 wrote:
from my queue
Easy
you could lower HP to 2, I don't think easy and normal should be the same hp fixed
00:41:513 (2) - the cymbal is on blue tick. I think better way to map this part is like this, you get the cymbal on repeat and the next beat on white tick is clickable too. I don't think it would be better to put on the blue tick, so I put on the next white tick, as is the sound
00:48:785 (5) - this isn't on any strong sound either. You could use a 3/4 repeat slider again if you removed 00:47:270 (4) - and started the repeat slider at 00:48:179 - . doesn't work perfectly but better than what you have now it's not good idea, but i'm remove circle and add slider on next white tick
Normal
0.5 between ar and od is pretty low, od4 would be more standard fixed
00:15:755 (1,2,3) - make the angle between 1,2 smaller? I think it looks a bit better fixed
00:17:573 (4) - personally i would remove it to have a longer pause, but it works fine like this too I think that the spinner i can leave
00:20:603 (1,2) - i think two doubles represent the song better, could stack a note on blue tick after 1 have a 1/4 slider on the next blue tick http://puu.sh/wojHa/a621ad81ea.PNG. You would have to change some other places for consistency but it would make the map more interesting imo. i like this idea, fixed
the same rhythm that would have to be changed is 00:23:331 (2,3) - , 00:25:452 (1,2) - , 00:28:179 (2,3) -, 00:33:028 (2,3) - , 00:35:149 (1,2) - , change to circles - I think it's not the best idea, but I changed the sliders
00:37:876 (2,3) - . probably a bit difficult for normal but you could use something similar for hard if you make it. i think it's normal for players
00:23:634 (3) - bit too tilted for me, the repeat is really close to 2 fixed
00:37:876 (2,3,4,5) - these could make a bit better square I think it can be leave as is
00:51:513 (4,1,2) - bit ugly, rotating 1,2 counter-clockwise makes it look better. not much room for it but you could create that by moving 4 to the left fixed
finally some touhou song, gl with the map thx
Oni:
General - I think SV should be 1.6, because BPM is very small and the finishers in the KIAI look untidy. Or alternatively, double the BPM.
00:14:543 (15) - add d, just like you do it here 00:04:846 (5)
00:24:997 (10) - - k sounds good here
00:25:906 (14) - move it here 00:26:209 (15). Here is more important sound
00:31:058 (36) - add d
00:34:391 (52) - change to K and 00:34:543 (53) - change to d
00:39:240 (73) - move it here 00:38:937 (72) - because the finisher at the beginning of the stream is a bad idea.
00:41:513 (7,8,9) - dKd to be consistent with 00:34:240 (51,52,53) - if you accepted my past suggestion
00:44:846 (21) - change to d
00:50:149 (47) - add d?
00:51:967 (57,58,59) - maybe ddd triplet here?
00:52:725 (61,62,63,64) - Oh, this is a bad idea and it does not match the rhythm. If you follow the rhythm, then it should look like this:
00:53:482 (67) - add k. This is a strong sound, so don't miss it.
00:56:361 (83) - change to d
00:59:391 (1) - I think the spinner should end at 01:09:088
Good luck with the map!
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.