wmfchris wrote:

[Taiko]
-我覺得沒必要加減速 拿掉吧

SPOILER

intro的部分 3/4就免了吧 將x--x--x改成x---x-x也ok :(
00:11:311 - 音樂明明是d k d
00:18:234 - d d k
00:19:677 - 後面有放前奏1/4 這裡也放做ddd
00:29:484 - k d/k k
00:38:327 - ddkkd
00:39:907 - 不要一句聽3次
00:48:602 - kk---kd---dd d ...
01:06:863 - kk d
01:21:972 - 這段的3/4用x xxx x過的話重音左3連中間很怪 改一改吧
01:27:407 - 音樂向下跑 kkddd kkddk
01:35:450 - 沒spinner只好用大圓
01:49:146 - kdd k ddk
02:03:494 - start spinner here spinner跟上一個note只差1/4會把notes蓋住 所以不要用短spinner
02:08:927 - kkd
02:32:623 - kkddk 不想的說 我認為kkkdk也很合音樂
02:33:275 - 大圓大圓大圓!!!!!!!!
02:34:797 - k k d
03:16:536 - kkddd kkddk
03:30:232 - 有誤導性(kkddkD)啊 用長spinner吧
03:37:297 - D
03:41:101 - d
03:42:840 - k D

7/10

- 好多xx / xxxx 還不如多用3連
- 有了每句前面的dk聽上去還好
- 02:25:558 這段砍一下 又不是kiai
- 不要老是一句打幾遍 > : D

oooops 12點 有機會再看看其他diff >_</~

Aleks719 wrote:

#modreqs

-Gamu-'s Normal
HP -1 no fixed
00:34:965 (1) - add whistle? no fixed
01:35:015 (2) - ^ fixed!
02:33:275 (6,7) - add 2 whistles fixed!
03:05:666 (1) - add nc fixed!
03:12:406 (5) - ^ fixed!

useless mod is so useless, star -___-

murasamenosigure wrote:

good map~
ランクド頑張ってください
応援してます
(゜∀゜)。彡゜(゜∀゜)。彡゜(゜∀゜)。彡゜
kudosuくれたら投げ返しときます☆ｷﾗｯ

RainForce wrote:

Great like always.
star.
~~~~~~~~~~~~

1. 真的不用加上short ver?

1. Not much going to say.

1. 00:04:965 (3) - Some rhythm suggestion here:Probably reduce the slider to 00:05:831?Just going to fit the piano and 00:06:119 - here doesn't have any music/musical instrument to support it,so I think end the slider here is inappropriate.
2. 00:08:138 (2) - ^Base on that,I think a note would more appropriate than a slider.
3. 00:12:754 (2) - ^Same T_T
4. 00:25:734 (6) - Yeah,add a new combo here to consistent you combo setting \:D/(The combo length is longer than others)
5. 00:53:494 (1) - Probably add a whistle at the end of the slider?Yeah,follow something in your next 3/4 rhythm :3
6. 02:46:101 (2) - I prefer remove clap here,just a little bit weird if you make a clap suddenly...
7. 02:46:971 (3) - ^Same!

1. I found nothing .__.

1. 00:58:711 (7) - 為了和其他combo的長度大致相等,建議在這裏new combo.
2. 01:03:928 (1) - 其實我覺得這個跳沒啥必要,這種要跳不跳的間距,真的很奇怪,要不把(4)-拉上一點,要不把(4)-完全疊在(1)-上面好了.
3. 01:20:667 (1,2,3,4) - 內眼上看這個正方形歪了,可以把(2)- 往下移一點點.
4. 01:31:102 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18) - 這Combo長得有點離譜orz..我強烈建議加new combo.01:34:363 (13) - 要不在這裏加個?
5. 01:50:885 (1) - 可以把slider的第2個折點拉好一點嗎?
6. 03:21:101 (2) - 其實光聽音樂感覺就可以把這個弄成一個Jump.而且(1.2)-slider的中間疊起來也不太好看.
7. 液,QQ姐的stream都縮短了DS >//< 太萌了

1. 02:06:536 (2,3,4,5) - I don't know it should be 1/3 or 1/4,however it was really awkward during gameplay and 02:06:971 (3) - is obvious off with 1/3 snap(Playrate 25).It should be 1/4 snap after 02:06:971 (3) -
2. 02:10:884 (1,2,3) - ^Same,something should snap in1/4.

1. 00:55:233 (5) - I think this should be 3/4 T_T 3/4 is more appropriate than 1/2
2. 01:06:972 (6) - Probably add a clap here? (S2) Than make it back to Normal hitsound from 01:07:189 -
3. 02:05:015 (1) - I really don't recommend a spinner here,although it's rankable but it doesn't show really good effert during gameplay.I suggest use a x0.5 slider instead of it.
4. 03:23:275 (x) - Probably add a note here?Make a triplet here :> you might need to adjust the spacing after adding.

1. 首先我覺得你必須先檢查一遍所有的3/4note,沒錯這個點子是不錯,但是過量就會有累聚感,就像是一個妹子你會咁興趣,但試太多相同的妹子你就覺得煩,這個是同一個道理,在音樂適合的地方上加沒問題,隨意的加一點也可以,大量的就不好了:/ (你可以去看看RL的圖,3/4note詭異感滿怖)
2. 03:02:188 (x) - Taiko diff在那麼段時間內的Re-Kiai是不允許的,請Remove.

1. 00:39:635 - 從這裏開始可以加一點音量
2. 00:46:102 (3,4) - 這2個都變don把.
3. 00:46:537 (1) - 相反這個因為是高音還有重音所以可以變Finsih+clap
4. 00:50:015 (1,1,1,2,1,1) - 這裏有濫用3/4的可能,這裏聽音樂可是正規的1/2+1/4 3連
5. 01:09:146 (1) - 去掉kat加Finsih
6. 01:09:580 (2) - 這個在鼓點上,建議加k
7. 01:21:972 (x) - 留意這段變速內的3/4note大圓,大部分都和音樂不合,詭異感滿載
8. 03:14:253 (x) - 加note
9. 不列出來的3/4不代表沒問題,還有大量的xx xxxx組合與音樂不太合,新手Taiko mapper還是別用太多偶數連.

kanpakyin wrote:

[-Gamu-'s Normal]
Issue/Unrankable stuff
(Something bad in gameplay or unrankable staff,you should take a look on it.)

1. Not much going to say.

Beatmap design/suggestion
(These are totally suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree.)

1. 00:04:965 (3) - Some rhythm suggestion here:Probably reduce the slider to 00:05:831?Just going to fit the piano and 00:06:119 - here doesn't have any music/musical instrument to support it,so I think end the slider here is inappropriate. fixed!
2. 00:08:138 (2) - ^Base on that,I think a note would more appropriate than a slider. fixed!
3. 00:12:754 (2) - ^Same T_T fixed!
4. 00:25:734 (6) - Yeah,add a new combo here to consistent you combo setting \:D/(The combo length is longer than others)fixed!
5. 00:53:494 (1) - Probably add a whistle at the end of the slider?Yeah,follow something in your next 3/4 rhythm :3 no fixed
6. 02:46:101 (2) - I prefer remove clap here,just a little bit weird if you make a clap suddenly... fixed!
7. 02:46:971 (3) - ^Same! fixed!

Pretty nice map at all,Star!

kanpakyin wrote:

Hi 萌QQ
可能有點nazi xD
[General]

1. 真的不用加上short ver? - hmm,想了一下覺得不需要,雖然mp3經過剪輯修短,但還不至於需要加上這個附註

[Hard]
Issue/Unrankable stuff
(Something bad in gameplay or unrankable staff,you should take a look on it.)

1. I found nothing .__.

Beatmap design/suggestion
(These are totally suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree.)

1. 00:58:711 (7) - 為了和其他combo的長度大致相等,建議在這裏new combo. - Fixed,因為也有其他人曾經建議過,考慮過後決定加上new combo.
2. 01:03:928 (1) - 其實我覺得這個跳沒啥必要,這種要跳不跳的間距,真的很奇怪,要不把(4)-拉上一點,要不把(4)-完全疊在(1)-上面好了. - Fixed,已將(4)拉上一點
3. 01:20:667 (1,2,3,4) - 內眼上看這個正方形歪了,可以把(2)- 往下移一點點. - Fixed,已把第二段方形擺法整個拉下來一點
4. 01:31:102 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17,18) - 這Combo長得有點離譜orz..我強烈建議加new combo.01:34:363 (13) - 要不在這裏加個? - Fixed,也有其他人建議加上new combo,考慮過後決定加上,不過我是加在(9).
5. 01:50:885 (1) - 可以把slider的第2個折點拉好一點嗎? - Sorry,did not change anything.
6. 03:21:101 (2) - 其實光聽音樂感覺就可以把這個弄成一個Jump.而且(1.2)-slider的中間疊起來也不太好看. - Sorry,did not change anything.
7. 液,QQ姐的stream都縮短了DS >//< 太萌了

kanpakyin wrote:

[Sp3's Taiko]
Issue/Unrankable stuff
(Something bad in gameplay or unrankable staff,you should take a look on it.)

1. 首先我覺得你必須先檢查一遍所有的3/4note,沒錯這個點子是不錯,但是過量就會有累聚感,就像是一個妹子你會咁興趣,但試太多相同的妹子你就覺得煩,這個是同一個道理,在音樂適合的地方上加沒問題,隨意的加一點也可以,大量的就不好了:/ (你可以去看看RL的圖,3/4note詭異感滿怖)
   修改了一些3/4拍
2. 03:02:188 (x) - Taiko diff在那麼段時間內的Re-Kiai是不允許的,請Remove.

OK

Pattern/Suggestion
(These are totally suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree.)

1. 00:39:635 - 從這裏開始可以加一點音量 fix
2. 00:46:102 (3,4) - 這2個都變don把. fix
3. 00:46:537 (1) - 相反這個因為是高音還有重音所以可以變Finsih+clap fix
4. 00:50:015 (1,1,1,2,1,1) - 這裏有濫用3/4的可能,這裏聽音樂可是正規的1/2+1/4 3連 fix
5. 01:09:146 (1) - 去掉kat加Finsih fix
6. 01:09:580 (2) - 這個在鼓點上,建議加k fix
7. 01:21:972 (x) - 留意這段變速內的3/4note大圓,大部分都和音樂不合,詭異感滿載 改了(不過我認為還好阿lol)
8. 03:14:253 (x) - 加note fix
9. 不列出來的3/4不代表沒問題,還有大量的xx xxxx組合與音樂不太合,新手Taiko mapper還是別用太多偶數連.

恩...

kanpakyin wrote:

[S i R i R u's Diff]
Issue/Unrankable stuff
(Something bad in gameplay or unrankable staff,you should take a look on it.)

1. 02:06:536 (2,3,4,5) - I don't know it should be 1/3 or 1/4,however it was really awkward during gameplay and 02:06:971 (3) - is obvious off with 1/3 snap(Playrate 25).It should be 1/4 snap after 02:06:971 (3) - fixed
2. 02:10:884 (1,2,3) - ^Same,something should snap in1/4. fixed

Beatmap design/suggestion
(These are totally suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree.)

1. 00:55:233 (5) - I think this should be 3/4 T_T 3/4 is more appropriate than 1/2 fixed
2. 01:06:972 (6) - Probably add a clap here? (S2) Than make it back to Normal hitsound from 01:07:189 - Remake
3. 02:05:015 (1) - I really don't recommend a spinner here,although it's rankable but it doesn't show really good effert during gameplay.I suggest use a x0.5 slider instead of it.
4. 03:23:275 (x) - Probably add a note here?Make a triplet here :> you might need to adjust the spacing after adding. fixed

1. 01:00:015 (4) - Remove finish here, add finish to 01:00:450 (1), noce you did so, remove whistle of 01:00:450 (1)
2. 01:06:972 (3) - Remove clap, starts use clap when song climax start, I mean from 01:07:407 on
3. 01:07:407 (1) - Add finish
4. 01:13:494 (4) - Remove this clap, if you want a double clap, add to 01:13:711 sounds better
5. 01:14:363 (1) - Use finish instead of whistle
6. 01:17:841 (1), 01:18:711 (3), 01:19:580 (4) - Add finish
7. 01:30:015 (3) - ^
8. 01:31:754 (2) - ^
9. 02:50:884 (4) - Why use finish here? maybe remove it
10. 03:08:275 (4) - Remove clap, and I think double clap doesn't fit here
11. 03:09:580 (1) - Use finish instead of clap seems better

1. 01:50:885 (1) - This ugly slider doesn't fit Qoneesama
2. 03:16:101 (1), 03:16:536 (2), 03:16:753 (3) - Add finish, remove clap of 03:16:536 (2). That seems sounds better

1. According to your custom normal-hitwhistle2 adding parteen of previous 2, shouldn't it be added at 00:09:581 (1), and next 3 add at 00:11:888 (1), 00:14:196 (1), 00:16:504 (1) - ? What you used just a bit odd compare to previous 2, but last 3 themselves sounds good enough, just...not the same partten
2. 01:59:580 (1) - Add finish
   
   nice map
   star

Breeze wrote:

[Qoneesama] WHY IS PINK? ( つд⊂)

1. 01:50:885 (1) - This ugly slider doesn't fit Qoneesama - Changed it to other style slider.
2. 03:16:101 (1), 03:16:536 (2), 03:16:753 (3) - Add finish, remove clap of 03:16:536 (2). That seems sounds better - Sounds good,changed!

Breeze wrote:

[-Gamu-'s Normal]

1. 01:00:015 (4) - Remove finish here, add finish to 01:00:450 (1), noce you did so, remove whistle of 01:00:450 (1) fixed!
2. 01:06:972 (3) - Remove clap, starts use clap when song climax start, I mean from 01:07:407 on fixed!
3. 01:07:407 (1) - Add finish fixed!
4. 01:13:494 (4) - Remove this clap, if you want a double clap, add to 01:13:711 sounds better 01:13:494 - clap remove, 01:13:711 - clap add
5. 01:14:363 (1) - Use finish instead of whistle fixed!
6. 01:17:841 (1), 01:18:711 (3), 01:19:580 (4) - Add finish fixed!
7. 01:30:015 (3) - ^ fixed!
8. 01:31:754 (2) - ^ fixed!
9. 02:50:884 (4) - Why use finish here? maybe remove it fixed!
10. 03:08:275 (4) - Remove clap, and I think double clap doesn't fit here fixed!
11. 03:09:580 (1) - Use finish instead of clap seems better fixed!

nice map
star[/list]