[ L u k a s ] wrote:

Easy

1. 00:19:113 (19113|3,19299|2,19486|1,19672|0,19858|2,20045|1) - Isn't this too dense for an Easy? Even though it is low BPM you can delete some of the notes here to reduce the density (and make the more intense parts stand out)
   
   its 1/4, not that bad and it plays fine
   
2. 00:20:231 (20231|3) - Snap this LN to 00:20:976 - ? I am pretty sure it wasn't meant to end on 1/4 and if it was intended then I recommend you snap it cause it's confusing
   
   very much intended, as thats when the sound ends
   
3. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - This too
   
   same as above
   
4. 00:24:703 (24703|1,24889|0,25076|2,25262|3,25448|1,25635|0,25821|2,26007|3) - Same as the first point
   
   same as first answer
   
5. 00:45:573 - Add a note bc strong sound

for consistancies sake, no but ill keep that in mind for the time being

Normal

1. 00:20:231 (20231|3) - Same as in Easy
2. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - ^
3. 00:30:666 (30666|0) - ^
   
   same answer as in easy
   
4. 00:39:424 (39424|1) - I don't see why you put this note here, delete it since there's no noticeable sound on there as far as I could tell. Also it makes it harder for players to play so might as well give them a little break
5. 00:51:349 (51349|3) - ^
   
   i assume you modded this before you updated the song as its not giving me the correct timestamp
   
6. 00:57:219 (57219|2,57312|0,57405|3) - Why didn't you put these as 1/4 like in the rest of the map? Doesn't make much sense to me...
   
   again timestamps broken before you updated

Murasame wrote:

Hi
NM request from my modding quene

Let's begin

Hard

|1|2|3|4|
00:29:641 (29641|3) - move to column 3 for better flow
i disagree

00:30:666 (30666|0) - I'd suggest this LN to end at 00:31:411 -
its playable and more fun as it is imo

00:34:299 (34299|3) - move to column 2 for better flow
00:35:324 (35324|0) - move to column 3, and move 00:35:511 (35511|2) - to column 1 for better flow
00:35:790 (35790|2,35883|1) - ctrl+G for better flow
modified this whole littlle section, as it didnt flow as well as it could of, nice catch


00:37:933 (37933|0) - move to column 3 for better flow
i can get behind that

00:38:678 (38678|0) - move to column 3, 00:38:771 (38771|3) - move to column 2, 00:38:865 (38865|1) - move to column 1 for better flow
i dont think this made it flow any better than it did, but i changed it

00:45:759 (45759|3,45945|2) - ctrl+G, 00:46:132 (46132|3) - move to column 3 for better flow
i think it plays better as it is

00:46:504 (46504|3) - move to column 2
why? it plays better where it is

00:47:716 (47716|2,47809|1) - ctrl+H for better flow
im a big fan of this change

That's it
Good luck

chouyaa wrote:

as requested in game
1|2|3|4

Hard

00:03:275 - add another LN here? there's a sound is getting louder from here
i think its fine how it is

00:07:001 (7001|1) - move to col 1? more balance, and to avoid this 00:06:629 (6629|1,7001|1,7374|1) -
Kinda, reformatted the patterns to avoid the consecutive notes

00:19:299 - isnt it the same kick with 00:19:393 (19393|2,19393|3,19486|0,19486|1) - should be 2 notes as well
wanted to avoid making a double so its less awkward to play, but it makes sense, moved notes before out of the way and made it a double

00:19:206 (19206|2) - i prefer to delete this one to give a little space between the double notes above
no because its a clear beat, also i reformatted the patter so that feels better to play now

00:21:722 - at this part, u can actually map the 1/8 as u did at 00:24:703 - so it will be more consistent with the sounds u mapped
Yes i could, and i considered it, but i decided not to as 1/8 + lns i wouldnt really consider in a hard diff.

00:39:051 - suggestion > https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9649631
i can see why that makes sense, but it honestly doesnt feel fun to play at all

00:36:070 (36070|0) - move to col 3? i dont think its a good idea to arrange them double 3 stacks like this 00:35:883 (35883|1,35883|0,36070|0,36070|1,36256|0,36256|1) -
because 00:35:883 - and 00:36:070 - has different sounds
the 3 stack like that shouldn't be a problem, it feels fine to play, the different sound is expressed with another note, and it keeps consistant with the other pattern like this later in the song

00:47:995 (47995|3) - move to col 2, same reason as above ^
Same reason as above, having doubles in the same col feels better than having a random trill

00:52:653 (52653|3,52840|3) - move to col 3? its weird for me to put them like 00:52:653 (52653|3,52840|3,53026|3) -
like it doesnt match with the sounds
i understand what your saying here, and for the time being im gunna say no, but ill certainly revisit this one

00:58:243 - suggestion > https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/9649694
the sound is getting fade away at 00:58:616 - and more lower at 00:58:802 -
i disagree, yeah the sound is 'fading' but the beats are the same, i think its fine

goodluck <3

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  
  00:20:231 (20231|3) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there and precise for an easy. also feels like it needs a note next to it for the crash(hit-finish). It helps.
  00:23:212 (23212|1) - same as the other slider, tune it down the same.
  00:26:194 (26194|0) - I'd add another note for the crash
  00:30:666 (30666|0) - I'd add another note for the crash
  00:33:647 (33647|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:39:610 (39610|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:45:573 (45573|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:51:535 (51535|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:58:243 (58243|1,58243|2) - Looks short compared to other diffs. Would leave them as notes honestly.

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  
  00:20:231 (20231|3) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there for a normal.
  00:23:212 (23212|1) - Same i guess
  00:26:194 (26194|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:30:666 (30666|0) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there for a normal.
  00:57:219 (57219|2,57312|0,57405|3) - the lines look unnecessary on a normal like that, just as notes would be fine.

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  
  00:00:480 (480|0,573|1,666|3,759|2) - the lines look unnecessary on a normal like that, just as notes would be fine.

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  00:01:225 (1225|3,1225|0) - Sounded unrelated to the song, so considered unnecessary..
  00:12:778 (12778|0,12778|1,12778|3) - to 00:13:896 (13896|0,13896|1) - looks weird with the note change from 1/4 to 1/2
  00:16:877 (16877|0,16877|3) - to 00:18:740 (18740|2,18740|3) - looks weird with the note change from 1/4 to 1/2
  00:26:194 (26194|3,26194|2,26194|0) - to 00:30:666 (30666|3,30666|1,30666|0) - more focused on the singing i see, but completely weird to rhythm and looked over mapped.

Daniel Segura wrote:

Map looks good overall, I like it and very great on them hitsounds too, but just needs a bit fixin' to do

[Easy]

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  i dont get why this matters so im not changing it.
  
  
  00:20:231 (20231|3) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there and precise for an easy. also feels like it needs a note next to it for the crash(hit-finish). It helps.
  00:23:212 (23212|1) - same as the other slider, tune it down the same.
  
  no, it currently follows the beat, i intend to keep it that way
  
  00:26:194 (26194|0) - I'd add another note for the crash
  00:30:666 (30666|0) - I'd add another note for the crash
  00:33:647 (33647|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:39:610 (39610|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:45:573 (45573|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  00:51:535 (51535|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  
  the songs an easy diff, so ill not add any, but ill take note of this because its rather opinionated
  
  00:58:243 (58243|1,58243|2) - Looks short compared to other diffs. Would leave them as notes honestly.
  
  huh, your right its not the same. I've fixed them to end at the consistant length

[Normal]

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  (same)
  
  00:20:231 (20231|3) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there for a normal.
  00:23:212 (23212|1) - Same i guess
  
  Same deal
  
  00:26:194 (26194|0) - I'd add another note for the crash and timing
  
  i can get behind the extra note
  
  00:30:666 (30666|0) - I'd reduce that slider to that other note there, looks too out there for a normal.
  
  this doesnt add difficulty, and the sound continues
  
  00:57:219 (57219|2,57312|0,57405|3) - the lines look unnecessary on a normal like that, just as notes would be fine.
  
  the lns represent what would be a 1/8 stream, and they fit fine

[Hard]

• Add an additional timing point to the song, without it looks like the 1st tick is off with the whole map. Same timing though but offset to 852 (be sure to resnap the notes)
  
  same
  
  
  00:00:480 (480|0,573|1,666|3,759|2) - the lines look unnecessary on a normal like that, just as notes would be fine.
  
  they are fine as lns, and it should be harder because its a harder diff

Overall looks pretty good and rankable would change the stuff though..

Sinnoh wrote:

not good enuf 4 bn lol u take that bak
00:32:157 (32157|1) - 00:36:070 (36070|3) - 00:47:995 (47995|2) - Lots of potential for SVs with sounds like this, probably only applies to the top diff. Potential maybe. the top diff is being removed so no to this :3
( still contemplating some subtle things with hard however)

Easy
00:16:877 (16877|0,17250|3,17622|0,17995|3) - Would be nice to ctrl-h for pr nice touch

00:19:299 (19299|2) - Since there's no kick until the 3/4 would be best to just delete. 5 note long 1/2 is easier to understand than 7. sure, also rearranged the pattern above

00:20:231 (20231|3) - Extending LNs 1/4 beyond the next note is quite complicated for new players. It's much simpler to just end on 1/1.
This + the next vocal that ends the LN is on the 1/2 but nothing is mapped for that. true it is simpler, but it makes sense it being like this

00:24:703 (24703|1) - Rather than increasing density, try using LNs instead. For some reason it sounds like the sdvx wub or whatever it is, those are usually done with LNs. at first i really didnt like this change, but after trying it in game i came to like it. nice

00:39:237 (39237|1,39610|0) - Linking LNs on the same hand is hard for new players, move the first to lane 3 or 4. i disagree, its not 'to hard' and it makes sense

00:44:827 (44827|0,45386|3) - Deleting these would make it much clearer you're following the synth. Good call

00:57:312 (57312|1) - Vocals were unmapped for rest of the song, don't map here. what? these arnt mapped to the vocals

00:58:243 (58243|2,58243|1) - Opinion, should be notes because the other sounds before it are the same. The extra synth at the end is a different instrument and doesn't start till later i feel this is an insane nitpic, i think its fine. and its also to keep consistant with the other difficulties

Normal
00:17:809 (17809|3,17995|1,18181|2) - Why not do lane 2,4,3? That would give the feeling vocals are quite similar and unique to rest of the song works nice for variation, sure
00:20:231 (20231|3) - Same issue with 9/8 LNs 'issue' i think its fine

00:24:703 (24703|2) - Start of triples section plays odd because 4 has been empty for a while. Maybe move 00:24:517 (24517|1) - to 4? that does help for flow aswell

00:26:007 (26007|3) - This could be moved to lane 1 to emphasise the new kick sure, fixed the section above to avoid a 1/4 jack

00:33:834 (33834|2) - Don't really agree with how this was mapped in general, using more organised triples would be easier to read in general, rather than having jumps everywhere. + The triples aren't nearly as strong as they were in 00:20:231 (20231|3) - . Just going with 1/2 rhythm would be much safer.
You refer to triples in this statement "The triples aren't nearly as strong as they were in 00:20:231 (20231|3) -" but uhh, this diff actually contains no triples. as for the 1/2 arguement, its valid but having that would make it oddly similar to easy, which is something im looking to avoid ( i will come back and consider this later but i think as it stands its okay )

00:51:349 (51349|3) - Same as easy with not mapping this i agree


Hard
00:11:287 (11287|1) - It wouldn't be a bad idea to not map the 1/4 for this section, before bringing back the 1/4 at 00:14:268 (14268|3) - . Song intensity dies down a bit, so having a break would make this section much more playable. i agree with perhaps having something to break up the streams and ill absolutely look into that but this isnt the way to do it, the sounds are still there it just feels weird

00:16:877 (16877|1,17250|2,17622|1,17995|2) - The 1/4 pattern in general didn't feel like it was following the music too much. Points that should be emphasised are just parts of streams, no jumps are being used to emphasise them. Notes in the timestamp should ideally have emphasis, but aren't really emphasised. Putting them at the start of rolls / jumps would help in regard to that. Eg 00:18:368 (18368|2,18740|0) - do this. This didnt link to anything, however i did add some jumps and emphasized the vocals in that section which imo certainly helps the diff

00:20:231 (20231|1,20604|0,20790|0) - LNs + Jacks on the same hand are pretty difficult, moving this to another lane would be more comfortable. this now being the hardest diff, i think this is acceptable

00:21:722 (21722|3) - Considering the previous section was a really long 1/4, it wouldn't be too hard for players of this level to hit some triples on these. Also improves consistency with 00:24:703 (24703|1) - if they're added. i dont think triples are ever even necessary here, although i did change some notes into doubles because i do agree with the fact that its pretty easy and players should be able to hit them just fine

00:39:983 (39983|1,40169|1) - If you're using jacks for guitar(?) then adding jacks to 00:40:542 (40542|1) - would also help make it clear you're doing that. + Removing jacks from 00:40:728 (40728|0,40914|0) - since guitar changes a bit on it. mm i think its already pretty clear, (this section has already been heavily revised)

genkicho wrote:

nm from my que

col 1234

Hard

00:07:747 how about this umm no thanks
00:19:299 how about this its not the same sound, what you suggested doesnt make sense
00:20:231 (20231|1) - extend a bit more until red line, imo imaginary mapping style sometime is important to make the pattern looks beautiful no because it ends on the blue line, mapping to the red line doesnt make sense
00:29:734 (29734|1,29920|1,30107|1,30293|1) - avoid (?) this now being the hardest diff, i dont think this is an issue, but something ill look back to in my own time
for the rest idk i just dont like those patterns... kinda.. unbalanced and a bit randomized (?) it's like.. doesnt looks good.. maybe it's just me (?)
example : 00:51:535 (51535|1) - you can move this to 1 (mirror of 4) for balance
example 2 : 00:39:610 (39610|3,41101|1,42591|2) - no LN for col 1, you can delete 1 of those 3 ln and do mirror like i said above i dont get what either of the 2 examples are suppose to accomplish, no ln in col 1 is no issue? this just caused confusion

Normal

the chorus, i think it's too hard for a Normal, because i often multiplayer with my friend(2* player) and he's bad at 1/4... if you still want to keep the 1/4 i suggest dont make it like this 00:33:834 (33834|2,33927|0,34020|3) - , make it more roll-y like 00:34:206 (34206|0,34299|2,34393|1,34579|3,34672|1,34765|2) - i understand what youre saying, but its like this to step up the difficulty and imo the fact they arnt rolls play fine and add a small amount of extra difficulty
00:40:728 (40728|1,41101|1) - avoid (?) unintended 1/2 shielding thats a 1/1 shield? thats uhh not a problem at all
00:51:349 (51349|3,51535|3) - avoid (?) col 1 empty .. maybe this is why i said,, a bit randomized (?) col 1 isnt empty owo?
00:51:535 too easy compared to those 1/4 its suppose to be easier, the main beat goes away

Easy

00:20:231 (20231|3) - reduce length to white line (?) too complicated for easy
00:23:212 (23212|1) - ^ as mentioned in sinnoh's, i think its fine it follows the beat

goodlucc

jkkd wrote:

remap

kds pls

jkkd wrote:

remap

CoffeeLatte- wrote:

Req from my queue forced to mod this aaa

[ Insaiyan ]

00:03:275 - 00:03:461 - they still have piano synthesia if you want to add to...

probably should

00:06:815 - i think the piano synth are strong rather than drum.. how about .. https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10069560 , i think is ok to continous make LN before changing to verse,since this part still at intro

hmm not a bad idea

00:20:231 (20231|0) - did u hear guitar start to play again ? i prefer to make LN for guitar than vocal. and i think the most unique vocal in this song at 00:35:138 -

the vocal is very apparent, so i chose to map that

00:29:827 - 00:30:293 - double ?

sure

00:32:157 - 00:32:343 - 00:32:529 - triple ? feel similar with 00:32:716 - 00:33:088 - same instrument just different chord

build up


00:33:834 - actually the structures are same with hard diff, u just move 2 single note into 1 col and be jack. hm.. i dont have any idea :p u can keep going with this pattern untill other modder mention it...

not much else that can be done, regardless of the similarities with the chorus its much harder to play

00:47:809 (47809|0,47995|0,48181|0,48368|0) - just uncomfortable to play...

fixed

YaHao wrote:

[Insane]
00:05:138 - This beat is strong enough to be double, and the next note is triple so it will still be different with the cymbal sound
00:32:157 (32157|2,32157|1,32343|0,32343|3,32529|0,32529|1,32716|2,32716|0,32716|3) - They all share the same intensity i believe

No kudosu

1. 00:07:374 (7374|0) - Move to [3] or 00:07:001 (7001|3) - [1] and 00:07:188 (7188|1) - [4] cause it's make balance with triple and doubles. 00:06:815 (6815|3,6815|0,7001|0,7001|3) - This one mapped same lines. But 00:07:188 (7188|1,7188|2,7374|1) - It's not mapped same.
2. 00:07:560 - This parts feels kinda empty, actually really empty. It's must be add notes on 00:07:560 - 00:08:119 - . (Hard kinda rich than this)
3. 00:19:299 - You missed whistle here. Add one more note.
4. 00:20:231 (20231|1,20417|1,20604|1,20790|1,20976|1) - This 2/1 Quad+(Five) jacks should be re-arrange. For the playable
   
   
5. 00:30:666 - Hard diff is more harder than Insane in this part. So it's something was re-pattern like this one? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10165756 .
6. 00:45:386 (45386|1) - Move to [1] cause you mapped 4/1 jacks in before part, so it's mirror as before.
7. 00:47:716 - It's should be jacks? Actually makes doubles 'Whistle' is much better than jacks, so it's really easily read for this.
8. 00:57:405 - Add note on [4] it's makes difference than Hard.

1. 00:44:827 - Why you didn't mapped any notes here? Normal diff mapped simple note here.
2. 00:58:243 (58243|2) - Remove this one. Same as 00:58:057 - 00:57:684 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10165857 .

1. 00:32:343 - This line should be single. It's normal diff not hard.
2. 00:57:219 - ^ Change these too simple notes. Normal diff + 4/1 LN's didn't acceptable for rank.

1. 00:20:231 (20231|3) - It's should be end 00:20:976 - here. Beginners never can catch this.
2. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - ^ If you don't agree with this QAT or BN's will notice that.

SpectorDG wrote:

Mod here

[Insane]

1. 00:07:374 (7374|0) - Move to [3] or 00:07:001 (7001|3) - [1] and 00:07:188 (7188|1) - [4] cause it's make balance with triple and doubles. 00:06:815 (6815|3,6815|0,7001|0,7001|3) - This one mapped same lines. But 00:07:188 (7188|1,7188|2,7374|1) - It's not mapped same.
2. 00:07:560 - This parts feels kinda empty, actually really empty. It's must be add notes on 00:07:560 - 00:08:119 - . (Hard kinda rich than this)
3. 00:19:299 - You missed whistle here. Add one more note.
4. 00:20:231 (20231|1,20417|1,20604|1,20790|1,20976|1) - This 2/1 Quad+(Five) jacks should be re-arrange. For the playable
   
   
5. 00:30:666 - Hard diff is more harder than Insane in this part. So it's something was re-pattern like this one? https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10165756 .
6. 00:45:386 (45386|1) - Move to [1] cause you mapped 4/1 jacks in before part, so it's mirror as before.
7. 00:47:716 - It's should be jacks? Actually makes doubles 'Whistle' is much better than jacks, so it's really easily read for this.
8. 00:57:405 - Add note on [4] it's makes difference than Hard.

applied all those changes bar the last 2, as i feel they dont really matter, no do they have an input on the song

[Hard]

1. 00:44:827 - Why you didn't mapped any notes here? Normal diff mapped simple note here.
   
   modified a bit
   
2. 00:58:243 (58243|2) - Remove this one. Same as 00:58:057 - 00:57:684 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/10165857 .

sure


[Normal]

1. 00:32:343 - This line should be single. It's normal diff not hard.
2. 00:57:219 - ^ Change these too simple notes. Normal diff + 4/1 LN's didn't acceptable for rank.

i disagree, i think its fine

[Easy]

1. 00:20:231 (20231|3) - It's should be end 00:20:976 - here. Beginners never can catch this.
2. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - ^ If you don't agree with this QAT or BN's will notice that.

No, the ln folows the vocal, ending it earlier would be structurely incorrect. how it is, is fine


goodluck!

Weber wrote:

ok

EZ

EZ

00:20:231 (20231|3) - The complexity of this LN ending on a blue tick isn't appropriate for an EZ. The vocals all fall on 1/2 beats, so this should be simplified as such. Shorten the LN back to 00:20:976 - and add a note to 00:21:163 - at 2. Repeat for 00:23:212 (23212|1) -

fixed

00:36:070 (36070|0,36070|1,36256|2,36256|3) - I'd change these to single notes, the pattern is too dense for an EZ, try 4-1-3 for that sequence of 1/2 notes

why not

00:47:809 (47809|1,47995|3,47995|2,48181|0,48181|1) - Same here, 2-3-1.

Yep

00:57:684 - I'd like to see these simplified to fit in line with the rest of the diff's density. First off, 00:58:243 - really don't need to be LNs, extending the map past this point for that tiny bit of fade-out diminishes the impact of the ending imo. Secondly, the two doubles at 00:57:684 - and 00:58:057 - could be changed into singles for the density reason above. Try 4-4-1/2 for this section.

agreed

NM

NM

00:20:231 (20231|3) - Same as EZ, bring it back to the white tick. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - Same. Although it's slightly more appropriate here than it was in the NM, the inconsistency due to the lack of 1/4th rhythms throws this section off because of it and makes it come off as awkward.

rip ln, fixed

00:26:566 (26566|0) - Move to 1 for better hand balance.

fair enough

00:30:666 (30666|0,30666|1,31411|3,31504|2,31598|1) - This is a bit too complex for players around this level to pull off consistently, requires a lot of multitasking. Bring 00:30:666 (30666|0) - back to the white tick alongside the other LN.

aww fine

00:33:647 - The kiai here is waaaaaay too complex, it's basically identical in density to the next two difficulties besides some additional doubles here and there. Besides the inappropriate density, the way you patterned these doesn't lend well to reading at this level for players (patterns that make the player switch hands constantly, instead of more linear 3 note 1/4th patterns like 2-3-4, 1-2-3, 4-3-1 etc etc) I would really recommend just making this the same as the EZ but with alternating singles and doubles. Apply to both kiais.

Understandable, other people have mentioned this too

00:39:237 (39237|0,39424|1,39610|2,39610|3,39983|1,40355|3,40728|1,41101|0,41101|1,41473|2,41846|3,42219|0,42591|2,42591|3,42964|0,43337|1,43709|2,44082|0) - Identical density to the EZ, the difference in density between this and the current kiais is pretty off-putting. I would add some more complex rhythms here, like on some of the vocalist's notes, to both distinguish this from the EZ, as well as give a more appropriate bridge between the two kiais. 00:51:535 - Same here.

Yeah, i get you, fixed

00:54:517 - Like I suggested above, alternating singles and doubles here.

agreed

00:57:219 (57219|2,57312|0,57405|3) - Pretty sure these are ghost notes, I'm not hearing any distinct 1/4th drums here, just some weird synth that almost sounds like it. Remove these and add a 1/1 LN at 00:57:312 - on 3 for the vocalist's held note here. (Might also want to move 00:56:939 (56939|1) - to 1 for hand balance as a result of this change.)
think i did this properly

HD

HD

00:20:231 (20231|1) - Same as above, since you are still using 1/2 for the entirety of this section, having the one stray blue tick makes it inconsistent and awkward. I'd say ending this LN here would only really be appropriate in the MX diff where it's nonstop 1/4 notes.

Fixed

00:30:666 (30666|0) - Same as NM, still feels like making it too complex for no real reason.

theres no real need for it i guess

00:33:647 - Along with the changes in NM, lowering the density by removing every OTHER double here to make the difficulty curve between NM, HD, and MX more consistent. (i.e. remove 00:34:393 - 00:35:138 - 00:35:883 - 00:37:374 - 00:38:119 - 00:38:865 - etc etc.) 00:45:573 - Same here.

Tough change to come to terms on but its for the better

00:39:610 - Adding a double every 1/1 starting from 00:39:983 - seems like a better way to, like with the NM, make the gap between the two kiais more consistent density-wise with the rest of the map. 00:51:535 - Again, same here.

Your right it does, fixed

00:54:517 (54517|2,54517|1,54703|2,54796|1,54889|2,54889|3) - This is a little too heavy on column 3, swap 00:54:330 (54330|3,54517|2) -'s columns to make it a little easier.

i can agree with that

00:57:312 - Like in the NM, ghost notes, replace it with a double at 00:57:312 -.
unsure (rip timestamp)

00:58:243 - Above, ditch the LNs.
unsure

Insaiyan

Insaiyan

00:31:411 (31411|3,31504|2,31598|1,31691|3,31784|2,31877|1,31970|3,32063|2) - Make these LNs to keep the difficulty curve consistent with HD.

Sure

00:57:125 - Now that i'm listening closer, I think a 1/8th drumroll would better suit this synth here, for this diff only.

That works out

00:58:243 (58243|2,58243|3,58243|1,58243|0) - Ehhhh, you can keep these as LNs as opposed to the other diffs since you're going for 4 note patterns here instead of 3 note.

Dont really get what your asking here

Call me back.

Tofu1222 wrote:

Anyway.
Weber please check hitsounds next time ;w;

4K: 1|2|3|4


[Normal]

1. 00:31:411 (31411|3,31504|2,31598|1,31784|2,31877|1,31970|0) - I can see your idea to simplify them, but it is kinda weird for me to intentionally not mapping only one of each. Might also wanna delete 00:31:504 (31504|2,31877|1) - so as to simplify this part from 1/4 snaps to 1/2 snaps. That will be a better way.

SpectorDG wrote:

Normal modders mentioned unrankable = Not accepted
Same problem mentioned by BN = Accepted .. why?

edit : nice

SpectorDG wrote:

mal modders mentioned unrankable = Not accepted
Same problem mentioned by BN = Accepted .. why?

edit : nice

CrumpetFiddler wrote:

SpectorDG wrote:

applied all those changes bar the last 2, as i feel they don't really matter, no do they have an input on the song = I'm mentioned all unrankable issue, but you think it's not matter for the song. Also If you didn't change these next BN or some QAT will be mention that. You can ask them from Weber, Tofu1222 : These mods really not matter the song? If this guy not mentioned that you guys will notice that?

[Normal]

1. 00:32:343 - This line should be single. It's normal diff not hard.
2. 00:57:219 - ^ Change these too simple notes. Normal diff + 4/1 LN's didn't acceptable for rank.

i disagree, i think its fine = Look at these, you still didn't agree when im noticed again. And after "BN" noticed same as mine. Then you accepted. Same one mentioned by BN

[Easy]

1. 00:20:231 (20231|3) - It's should be end 00:20:976 - here. Beginners never can catch this.
2. 00:23:212 (23212|1) - ^ If you don't agree with this QAT or BN's will notice that.

No, the ln folows the vocal, ending it earlier would be structurely incorrect. how it is, is fine
= I'm very easily explained unrank issue but you not accepted when im noticed 4/1 patterns on Easy difficulty, But Weber mentioned that you was accepted. (cause im not the BN?) It's similar

goodluck!

thanks for the mod

shionelove wrote:

umm i can't tell what you have to fix before re-qf well,but offset must be 852 due to music theory issue
some songs have Auftakt melody and this has.

Maybe some BNs tell you with better English and you can fix without any concerns,or i will call QAT police to DQ again.

Insaiyan:add 00:57:452 here because there is same 1/8 snare sound as 00:57:405 .

CrumpetFiddler wrote:

If its that bad a qat will intervene without your help.

SpectorDG wrote:

Normal modders mentioned unrankable = Not accepted
Same problem mentioned by BN = Accepted .. why?

edit : nice