[General]
- There are couple LN sections, but I think they're not so common place as to warrant OD 8. I think 8.3 to 8.5 would be better instead since there is quite a lot of short note 1/4 jumpstreams too that are more common place. alright.. increase OD to 8.3 and decrease HP to 8,7
- 05:41:674 - I get that I'm nitpicking here, but the normalizing SV should be 0.94x cause of the rounding from 0.93467... and so on. 6 makes the 4 before it 5 which means it should be rounded up. nitpick away my bad, miscalculation
- The hitclap sounds a bit low quality, but I think this one is similar and cleaner to hear https://puu.sh/wZkFh.wav replaced
[SVs]
Ok, so cause there's multiple BPMs, you gotta average your SV to 1x and then multiply whatever values you found by the normalizing SV. Basically, with the first SV sequences at 00:33:067 - , you want the SV to average out to 1.06x since that's the normalizing. As of now, it normalizes to 1.235x because 2.21 + (0.91 x 3) = 4.94 / 4. Basically the kind of simple math I'll be using for all of this.
i just using old standard SV for long time, since i don't understand this new standard + formula XD. Teach me please~00:33:067 - So going back to this one, the average here is about 1.16x which is .1x above what you need. Math is as follows: 2.21 + (0.91 x 3) = 4.94 / 4 =
1.235 x (175 / 186) = 1.16. What I did was just add up the SVs, divide them by four and then multiply it by the reciprocal of the normalizing SV to bring it back to the unaffected value. If you'd like to average it to 1.06x which is the constant overall SV average in this section, the values of 0.91x should become 0.68x
00:35:467 - Tbh, not really a fan of using the half half method for SV sequences that normally contain 3 units. Instead, I'd suggest using a bump similar to the first SV sequence I pointed out. You could move the slow SVs to 00:35:553 - 00:35:810 - and make it 0.91x to average out properly.
00:38:210 - Same thing here. Poke me if you want work btw
00:44:038 - Might do the same bump SV you did at 00:33:067 - but with the averaged values so that the overall SV average is constant throughout this section of the music.
00:56:896 - Think I already made my dislike of half half SVs like this clear, but my main reason for being against them and preferring bumps is that bumps either give emphasis to the note just hit (in this case, it'd be 00:56:896 - ) or emphasis to the note coming directly after (which would be 00:57:238 - and a reverse bump) but halving the values just makes it so the emphasis isnt really there, but rather just a visual change in the player field as both sides have an equal time with their respective SV.
Anyways, won't pick anymore on the SVs cause a good majority of them actually do average consistently with the normalizing SV, but just wanted to point out a few examples. Feel free to poke me if you need clarification or something.
[Hitsounds]
00:35:467 (35467|3) - Missing f?
added01:27:145 (87145|2) - missing w
added01:58:766 (118766|1) - Dunno, feel like the whistle alone is very anticlimactic for the very ending of this section, so I would consider adding a clap or finish here too so that it still has a little extra emphasis in the sound
added clap instead02:10:946 (130946|3,130946|1) - Double hitsound, I think you meant to make one of these a whistle instead lol
fixed02:38:791 (158791|1,159049|1,159394|1,159566|1,159653|0,159739|1,159825|2,159911|1,159997|2,160084|3,160170|0,160256|2,160342|1,160429|3,160515|0) - I'd consider adding claps here since the snare is rather prominent in the music and serves as anchor points where the player can find where they are in the music should they get lost.
lel, i'am forgot this02:39:308 (159308|0) - Might also add a whistle here for the kick too
added03:06:635 (186635|1,186894|1,187325|2,187411|1,187670|0,187756|3,188015|3,188273|2,188532|0,188618|3,188704|2,188791|1,189480|2,189653|0,189825|0,189997|1,190170|1) - Also suggest adding claps again for the snare
added04:39:108 (279108|0,279753|1,280398|3) - I think there should be crashes here since there are some pretty light ones in the music
added04:41:689 (281689|3) - I'd add a finish here too cause of the reverberating wooden block type sound I guess. It's not a crash, but it still signifies a new musical phrase.
added04:48:786 (288786|3) - Missing clap
added05:11:366 (311366|2,312011|2) - Add finishes to continue the 2/1 structure you set up at 05:10:076 - until the next section of the song comes in.
added05:22:979 (322979|2) - Add finish for a similar reason to the above
added06:30:141 (390141|2,390141|3) - double hitsound
fixed[Chart]
00:30:667 (30667|2,30753|1) - I think it'd be nice to overlap these two LNs for the synth. It'd also differentiate them from the background percussion as the type of note would be different
you're right01:21:955 - There's a pitch change here in the vocal which is what I assume you're following, so I would suggest ending one of the LNs a bit shorter and doing it like so
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8741681 . The timing's a bit hard though, so Im cool if you leave the pattern as is for simplification purposes.
oh nice, i didn't noticed it01:31:685 - 01:32:009 - Similar to the above suggestion, the vocal also changes pitch here as the vocal sample lowers, so I would add a short note to represent it. On top of that, it'd help to cap off the 1/2 LN which makes timing the release of it easier in my opinion as there's a physical cue for the player of when to release (when they hit the next note)
good point01:45:388 (105388|2,105469|3,105550|2,105631|3) - I dont really think the one handed trill here is necessary. it just adds some extra strain to the right hand. I might try to arrange the notes in a slightly more even fashion like this
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8741788 nice01:48:307 (108307|1,108347|0,108388|1) - Personally not a fan of 1/8 minitrills, and the BPM is fast enough that it's not able to be quickly spammed without a miss. I'd prefer if you just made the chord at 01:48:388 - a [34] jump to avoid it altogether, but you could also just live with a 1/4 jack in 3 if you cut off the roll at last section, but this makes the pattern even harder to hit due to the fact that it can't be jumptrilled anymore.
01:56:091 (116091|1,116131|2,116172|1) - ^
i understand, alright~ remove all pattern like this02:39:394 - I'd make this a jump cause of the snare that follows directly after the kick at 02:39:308 - . Would require a bit of rearranging immediately afterwards assuming you dont want to create any jacks, but i dunno, just a thought.
added02:43:704 (163704|1,164049|2,164222|1) - I think it might be better to control H this so that the one handed trill on the left hand at 02:43:273 (163273|0,163360|1,163446|0,163532|1,163618|0,163704|1) - is even with the one handed trill on the right hand in terms of number of notes
no, i'am followed pitch earphone02:54:049 (174049|2,174049|1,174222|1,174222|2) - I might stack one of the notes from both of these jumps with the previous [14] pattern due to the fact that they dont change pitch but the sound seems to differ slightly. In that case, I'd move 02:54:049 (174049|2,174222|2) - to col 4 for the stack.
nice03:11:549 (191549|1,191592|0,191635|1) - *cri*
don't cry plz XD03:24:603 (204603|0,204764|0) - This feels pretty hard to hit due to the fact that you're making the player single tap with their middle finger while holding an LN down with the index which is a bit finger twisting cause of the differing strength of each finger. I would instead try to separate the single taps inside an LN as opposed to the outside. You can do this simply by switching the columns of 03:24:603 (204603|0,204603|2,204764|0) - , though it creates a three note stack in 3.
fixed03:26:861 - I'd say you have room for a short 1/8 burst here if you wanted cause of that buzz sound, but it's up to you.
seem interesting03:41:538 (221538|1,221538|0) - Most of your 1/8 rolls started off with singles I think, so it's a bit inconsistent to suddenly begin them with jumps and end them with triples imo.
rearranged04:05:248 (245248|0,245329|1,245409|0,245571|0,245651|1,245813|0,245893|1) - Think there's a bit of a left hand bias here cause of all the movement being on the left hand despite the right hand having more chords which makes the note count on both hands seem almost the same. I'd try to put a bit of the moving parts onto the right hand too so as to even out the strain.
rearranged04:10:813 (250813|2,250893|1,250893|3,250974|2) - I dislike these types of patterns with an irrational hate lol. I mean, it plays ok, but it does strain the right hand a bit more here and constricts the flow, but it looks like you did it for symmetry, so Im mostly ok with that.
haha XD04:50:882 (290882|2,291044|2,291205|2,291366|2) - I think you extended this stack longer than it really needed to be. To start it off a bit earlier, I would try this
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8741861 good05:20:398 (320398|3,320479|2,320963|2,321044|3,321124|2,321285|3,321366|2,321447|3) - Similar thing to what I mentioned at 04:05:248 - about the hand bias
rearranged05:57:955 (357955|2,357993|3,358030|1,358068|0,358106|2,358143|3,358181|1,358219|0) - I think the antiroll here is a bit unfair to players because it runs in the direction opposite that which most players would feel natural with (think of rolling your fingers and how it tends to be easier to go from pinky to index as opposed to the opposite). I'd make this into a split trill then like so
https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8741876 rearranged with different pattern05:58:558 - Just a passing comment, may not be true as this is based only on my test play, but it feels like a lot of the mini trills and weight are focused on the left hand with very few on the right which gives the impression of a rather significant left hand bias here.
i didn't noticed that 06:15:819 - Don't really see the point in making this a single note as the kick still stays the same strength and loudness, and the following group of jumptrills that follow after are the same [12][34] so the single note wasn't there for a break.
try to make variety pattern here06:17:854 - In this stream, I'd try to be careful of too many stair type patterns like 06:18:005 (378005|2,378081|3,378156|1,378156|2,378231|0,378307|1,378382|2,378457|3,378533|2,379663|1,379739|0,379814|1,379890|2,379965|3,380040|2,380116|1,380191|0,380266|1) - as it can be very straining on the player due to the fact that all the movement is concentrated in one point in time with little breathing room after.
rearranged all part06:53:289 (413289|2,413461|2) - Might consider moving these to col 1 or something instead as they aren't the same pitch as 06:53:118 (413118|2) - which is actually a higher sound.
ok06:53:632 (413632|2) - as for this, the sound is different from 06:53:289 (413289|2,413461|2) - so I think it'd be better to put this in a different column away from the stack.
ok07:30:147 (450147|2,450232|3,450318|2,450489|3,450575|2,450747|2,450832|3) - Same thing I've mentioned a few times about hand bias
rearranged