19:37 Chocola_2287: ---------------------modding----------------------
19:38 Chocola_2287: 00:00:090 (1) - I prefer lowering volume to 30% here. The volume here covered the sound effect in the music
19:38 Chocola_2287: you might as well consider nerfing this part since it is the beginning, and its mood is calm compared to other part
19:39 Grimbow: 30 is a bit low imo since the volume of the song doesn't change much between here and the next section
19:39 Grimbow: if anything, the next section is quiter imo
19:39 Chocola_2287: at least you can do lowering volume
19:40 Chocola_2287: not 30 but it can be any higher
19:40 Chocola_2287: 80 is really too loud for me
19:40 Chocola_2287: 00:12:090 (85,86,87,88,89,90,91,92,93) - I have a feeling that you have to reorganize the pattern here
19:41 Chocola_2287: 00:12:721 (93) - imo has to be isolated to emphasis the structure of the map
19:41 Grimbow: Ye I'll lower the note density a little from 00:10:195 - to 00:20:300 -
19:41 Chocola_2287: 00:12:642 (92) - you might want to consider deleting this
19:41 Chocola_2287: and 93 to d
19:42 Grimbow: nah, I will keep that as kkddk, to follow the vocal thing
19:42 Grimbow: all the vocal samples are mapped with 5 note patterns
19:42 Grimbow: at least
19:42 Grimbow: except 00:19:905 (151,152,153,154) - because the final note is a finisher and I wanted to keep the emphasis
19:43 Chocola_2287: 00:15:721 (119,120,121,122,123,124,125,126) - d kdkkd k ?
19:43 Chocola_2287: 00:17:695 (138,139) - ctrl + G?
19:44 Grimbow: regarding 00:15:721 (115,116,117,118,119) - I'm following the synth you can hear play here
19:45 Grimbow: and to 00:17:695 (134,135) - I'd like to keep all the vocal samples as kkddk in this section
19:45 Chocola_2287: 00:22:590 (182,184) - delete?
19:45 Chocola_2287: if ^ applied, 00:22:826 (185,186,187,188,189) - d ddk d
19:46 Chocola_2287: 00:25:037 (206,207,208,209,210) - similar to ^
19:46 Chocola_2287: and ^^^
19:46 Grimbow: part of the vocal sample, I'll keep it
19:46 Grimbow: (regarding 00:22:590 - )
19:47 Grimbow: 00:22:432 (176) -
19:47 Grimbow: deleted that note though
19:47 Grimbow: the pattern was a bit long I guess
19:47 Chocola_2287: idk but I wont map it that way, I can barely notice the map structure at that part
19:47 Chocola_2287: not even tbh
19:47 Chocola_2287: maybe generally restrict your patterns to 7plets?
19:47 Grimbow: well we do have completely different mapping styles :v
19:48 Chocola_2287: 00:31:668 (260) - you might want to change it to d to be consistent with 00:36:721 (304) -
19:48 Grimbow: I have removed a few of the longer note patterns in that section
19:48 Grimbow: made them into 7 note patterns
19:49 Grimbow: changed that to a d
19:49 Chocola_2287: 00:37:195 (307,308,309,310) - Ctrl + G
19:49 Grimbow: done
19:49 Chocola_2287: 00:37:511 (310) - this has to be isolated, to emphasize the 3 and 6 plets belongs to different part
19:50 Chocola_2287: 00:50:616 (33) - why did you changed the fx you are emphasizing here?
19:51 Grimbow: I always map the vocal samples throughout the entire map
19:51 Grimbow: keep it consitent
19:51 Chocola_2287: I prefer following a single source of fx during mapping (tbh that's the problem I always encounter
19:51 Chocola_2287: no
19:51 Chocola_2287: 00:40:511 (1) - from here you follow the low-pitch bass
19:51 Grimbow: it's a very calm section and it would be very boring without variation
19:51 Grimbow: there's no vocal sample there
19:51 Chocola_2287: 00:50:616 (33) - but from here you followed the high-pitch piano-like fx
19:52 Grimbow: unless you mean at 00:52:984 -
19:52 Grimbow: in which case I will add notes there to make sure the vocals are followed
19:53 Chocola_2287: 00:51:721- ; 00:52:984- ; 00:54:247- perhaps k in all 3 timesnaps?
19:53 Chocola_2287: the kats act as the fill up of the high-pitch fxs
19:54 Chocola_2287: and making the patterns more interesting
19:54 Grimbow: ah I see what you mean
19:55 Grimbow: here I am following the up/down synth sounds
19:55 Grimbow: as part of the buildup
19:55 Grimbow: instead of the bass that I was in the section prior
19:55 Grimbow: starts at 00:50:616 (33) -
19:55 Chocola_2287: btw uncheck countdown
19:56 Grimbow: did
19:57 Chocola_2287: 01:19:984 (65) - thanks for pp
19:57 Chocola_2287: 01:23:142 (85) - pp
19:57 Grimbow: '<'b
19:57 Grimbow: iirc removing those doublets doesn't effect SR
19:57 Chocola_2287: 01:25:037 (95) - when this being k it really took the emphasis this part should have
19:58 Grimbow: so no inflated SR
19:58 Chocola_2287: 01:24:721 (94,96) - 95 really took some emphasis between these 2 notes
19:58 Chocola_2287: 01:27:879 (108) - same here, lack of emphasizing
19:58 Grimbow: oh? I thought it flowed well since it follows the pitch of the synth
19:59 Chocola_2287: it did not go well imo
19:59 Chocola_2287: 01:32:616 (130,131) - ctrl + G, percussion landed on 131
19:59 Chocola_2287: 01:35:142 (142) - same as 108
19:59 Grimbow: 01:32:932 (131) - is the snare clap though :thinking:
20:00 Chocola_2287: but it is relatively low pitch tho
20:01 Grimbow: whaaaaat, the snare claps are the most prominent sounds in this section
20:01 Grimbow: they're pretty loud
20:02 Chocola_2287: 01:56:300 (253) - you might want some variation here
20:02 Chocola_2287: i.e. ddkkddkd....
20:03 Chocola_2287: 02:01:353 (290) - I would add a x1.05 SV here to emphasis the quick beats here
20:04 Grimbow: Following the drums on the buildup so I'll keep that as is atm
20:04 Chocola_2287: but it feels boring to play
20:04 Grimbow: I have a buildup at the end of the kiai where the pitch climbs
20:05 Grimbow: so I'll keep the kiai at 1x so that the buildup doesn't go into unreadable
20:06 Chocola_2287: 02:56:379 (684,685) - ctrl + G, consistent with 02:53:853 (658,659) -
20:07 Grimbow: Changed!
20:10 Chocola_2287: 04:40:826 (1315) - add finisher?
20:10 Chocola_2287: feels odd when every odd note has finisher but that
20:10 Chocola_2287: 04:50:616 (1366) - I am sure these pattern lack some emphasizing
20:10 Chocola_2287: just too dull when all of these are kats
20:11 Grimbow: added!
20:11 Grimbow: there's not much to follow here apart from the snare claps
20:13 Chocola_2287: 05:23:458 (1) - I prefer this is a finisher note only
20:13 Chocola_2287: a break session can somehow emphasize the calm part
20:14 Grimbow: Hmmm
20:14 Grimbow: I feel like the spinner captures the vocal pretty well though, and most people finish spinners pretty fast
20:14 Chocola_2287: 06:05:774 (225) - wtf 1/6 pp session
20:15 Grimbow: fits the music!
20:15 Chocola_2287: 06:19:668 (368,369,370,371) - not sure why you mapped 1/6 here
20:15 Chocola_2287: no 1/6 in music here tho
20:16 Grimbow: same kind of sound as 06:20:932 (381,382,383,384) -
20:16 Chocola_2287: 06:14:616 (313,314,315,316,317) - might as well pointing this out
20:16 Chocola_2287: well the electric buzz as 1/6 is fine for me
20:16 Chocola_2287: just a bit weird, worth pointing it out
20:17 Grimbow: I can understand the concern
20:17 Grimbow: I could have made this a lot more pp map with some of the 1/6 but I kept it pretty tame :V
20:17 Chocola_2287: :thinking:
20:18 Chocola_2287: ye I think thats all from my side, I am not good at modding such song so cant really give out useful suggestions