Rename to „Volta‘s Motto! (Take My Hand And Together We Can Reclaim What Was Stolen From Us)“
(kds pls applying for bn next round)
(kds pls applying for bn next round)
forum
*namirin - Kanade [OsuMania|Osu|Taiko]
posted
Total Posts
171
Topic Starter
renamed taiko diff to Volta's Marathon since I feel it fits better rather than feeling out of place with mania
that fine?
that fine?
I don't know, it may cause confusion since Arcwin's diff is also named Marathon but it's mania and at a glance people might think my diff is also mania but different version (without looking at mode icon).
After some consideration, i think Volta's Onior chromoxx' suggestion is the best option to indicate my taiko diff.
After some consideration, i think Volta's Oni
Back~
Kaori > Marathon > Marathon
It’s like people don’t give much thought under what is fine line rankable. I’m still not sure how Marathon is considered to “not be misleading” to it’s difficultly, which was the issue leading to the DQ in the first place. If someone could explain that to me that would much appreciated
It’s like people don’t give much thought under what is fine line rankable. I’m still not sure how Marathon is considered to “not be misleading” to it’s difficultly, which was the issue leading to the DQ in the first place. If someone could explain that to me that would much appreciated
Disqualified as Volta would like to rename his difficulty as "Volta's Oni".
And back~
Requalified~
Requalified~
Why "bg friends.jpg" looks disproportionated? I mean you edit it with adding height with forced
Topic Starter
already addressed this in pms with kittyadventure.KittyAdventure wrote:
Why "bg friends.jpg" looks disproportionated? I mean you edit it with adding height with forced
Hallu. I have something to point out for the Mania diff so this is for arcwin!
Hi arcwin, long time not seen!
Soo.. it's regarding of snapping at some places.
[Arcwin's Marathon]
So it's about 03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - . I have to assume that you follow with your notes the Piano in this part, because.. almost all notes do so. If this is the case, these two notes are not correctly snapped and come way too late.
03:46:350 (226350|0) - This one should be on 03:46:300 - (1/8)
03:46:550 (226550|3) - And this one at 03:46:500 - (1/8)
I first thought you might follow the vocal, but even if so, the note at 03:46:550 (226550|3) - would be still wrong snapped and too early.
03:57:761 (237761|0) - This one is debatable. It is too late.. but for simplification i would leave it where it is.
04:00:547 (240547|2) - This one seems to be too early too. Should be moved 1/12 up i think
Okay, and now the ending from 04:53:160 - where a bunch of problems appear regarding the snaps.
04:53:360 (293360|1) - This one should be on 04:53:393 - (1/12) to catch the piano.
04:53:560 (293560|2) - This one is weird. Before the note is a sound, after the note is a sound.. but not at the note lol. So which one you tried to follow?
Guitar is on 04:53:535 - (1/16) and the Piano is on 04:53:610 - (1/8).. uhh.. yeah. I really don't know which sound you tried to catch so i just point out both
04:53:760 (293760|0) - I first thought this would be a ghost note.. but after increase the volume to 100% i hear a really silent piano sound.. i am not sure if it's correctly snapped.. maybe move it 1/16 up? But i am really unsure because it's so quiet..
04:54:185 (294185|0) - This one should clearly be on 04:54:218 - (1/12)
04:54:385 (294385|2) - This one should be on 04:54:410 - (1/16)
04:56:540 (296540|3) - This is the last one.. mh.. it seems to be too late and i would move it 1/16 down.
That's all. Remaining looks cool. Like i said i would like to hear from you about this. Some seem to be really off but maybe you have some kind of plan behind all this
Otherwise really nice song, i like *namirin <3
Hi arcwin, long time not seen!
Soo.. it's regarding of snapping at some places.
[Arcwin's Marathon]
So it's about 03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - . I have to assume that you follow with your notes the Piano in this part, because.. almost all notes do so. If this is the case, these two notes are not correctly snapped and come way too late.
03:46:350 (226350|0) - This one should be on 03:46:300 - (1/8)
03:46:550 (226550|3) - And this one at 03:46:500 - (1/8)
I first thought you might follow the vocal, but even if so, the note at 03:46:550 (226550|3) - would be still wrong snapped and too early.
03:57:761 (237761|0) - This one is debatable. It is too late.. but for simplification i would leave it where it is.
04:00:547 (240547|2) - This one seems to be too early too. Should be moved 1/12 up i think
Okay, and now the ending from 04:53:160 - where a bunch of problems appear regarding the snaps.
04:53:360 (293360|1) - This one should be on 04:53:393 - (1/12) to catch the piano.
04:53:560 (293560|2) - This one is weird. Before the note is a sound, after the note is a sound.. but not at the note lol. So which one you tried to follow?
Guitar is on 04:53:535 - (1/16) and the Piano is on 04:53:610 - (1/8).. uhh.. yeah. I really don't know which sound you tried to catch so i just point out both
04:53:760 (293760|0) - I first thought this would be a ghost note.. but after increase the volume to 100% i hear a really silent piano sound.. i am not sure if it's correctly snapped.. maybe move it 1/16 up? But i am really unsure because it's so quiet..
04:54:185 (294185|0) - This one should clearly be on 04:54:218 - (1/12)
04:54:385 (294385|2) - This one should be on 04:54:410 - (1/16)
04:56:540 (296540|3) - This is the last one.. mh.. it seems to be too late and i would move it 1/16 down.
That's all. Remaining looks cool. Like i said i would like to hear from you about this. Some seem to be really off but maybe you have some kind of plan behind all this
Otherwise really nice song, i like *namirin <3
Thank you so much for the mod, Sir Feerum! About the snaps, they are made on regular snaps for simplification (without using any irregular snaps except a little on the very last part). Piano sounds are really sensitive to be mapped especially if it is played by a human and not computer generated where it can be snapped even on the highest snaps like 1/32 and 1/64. Most snaps are based on the timing points given and it is no problem if played on the normal rate (as they are so minimal). Even with these opinions, I will leave it to you or other QATs to decide and to check the difficulty/snaps whether they are acceptable or not. Though, all points are acknowledged and noted appreciatively and will be used as reference if ever to re-update.Feerum wrote:
Hallu. I have something to point out for the Mania diff so this is for arcwin!
Hi arcwin, long time not seen! Heyo long time as well o/
Soo.. it's regarding of snapping at some places.
[Arcwin's Marathon]SPOILERThat's all. Remaining looks cool. Like i said i would like to hear from you about this. Some seem to be really off but maybe you have some kind of plan behind all thisSo it's about 03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - . I have to assume that you follow with your notes the Piano in this part, because.. almost all notes do so. If this is the case, these two notes are not correctly snapped and come way too late.
03:46:350 (226350|0) - This one should be on 03:46:300 - (1/8)
03:46:550 (226550|3) - And this one at 03:46:500 - (1/8)
I first thought you might follow the vocal, but even if so, the note at 03:46:550 (226550|3) - would be still wrong snapped and too early. For regularity, I made it 1/4 and it matches along with the vocal so I'll left it like that. at 03:46:550 - It may sound like it is too early but it is where the sound of vocal exactly started (like 0 to 100 volume). The standard mode has this note as well.
03:57:761 (237761|0) - This one is debatable. It is too late.. but for simplification i would leave it where it is. same as above
04:00:547 (240547|2) - This one seems to be too early too. Should be moved 1/12 up i think same as above.
Okay, and now the ending from 04:53:160 - where a bunch of problems appear regarding the snaps. Replied on my message below.
04:53:360 (293360|1) - This one should be on 04:53:393 - (1/12) to catch the piano.
04:53:560 (293560|2) - This one is weird. Before the note is a sound, after the note is a sound.. but not at the note lol. So which one you tried to follow?
Guitar is on 04:53:535 - (1/16) and the Piano is on 04:53:610 - (1/8).. uhh.. yeah. I really don't know which sound you tried to catch so i just point out both
04:53:760 (293760|0) - I first thought this would be a ghost note.. but after increase the volume to 100% i hear a really silent piano sound.. i am not sure if it's correctly snapped.. maybe move it 1/16 up? But i am really unsure because it's so quiet..
04:54:185 (294185|0) - This one should clearly be on 04:54:218 - (1/12)
04:54:385 (294385|2) - This one should be on 04:54:410 - (1/16)
04:56:540 (296540|3) - This is the last one.. mh.. it seems to be too late and i would move it 1/16 down.
Otherwise really nice song, i like *namirin <3 I like her songs too <3
Sorry about the late DQ orz
While a lot of snaps can just be simplified to the nearest 1/2 or 1/4 or whatever is more commonly encountered by the player, the part at 03:45:850 - is too nuanced to be simplified as it currently is.
03:45:883 - 03:45:916 - Not really that important, but if you wanted to add the 1/12 graces here, I think it'd be cool but I doubt it's all that important and the 1/4 is fine.
03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - Should be shifted down by 1/8
03:47:550 (227550|3,227550|2) - 1/16 above at 03:47:575 -
03:57:761 (237761|0) - 1/16 below at 03:57:736 - , but this and the one above aren't really as necessary
04:00:547 (240547|2) - Up by 1/8 to 04:00:597 -
Otherwise I feel like the snaps should be fine as they currently are.
Final thing I'd like to mention is the hitsound volume. I would keep the hs vol at 04:53:160 - the same as at 04:33:935 - because 20% is barely audible and took me a few tries to hear it even on 0% music and 100% effects. Similarly, the beginning at 00:00:350 - is only audible on the jumps because of the double hit.
While a lot of snaps can just be simplified to the nearest 1/2 or 1/4 or whatever is more commonly encountered by the player, the part at 03:45:850 - is too nuanced to be simplified as it currently is.
03:45:883 - 03:45:916 - Not really that important, but if you wanted to add the 1/12 graces here, I think it'd be cool but I doubt it's all that important and the 1/4 is fine.
03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - Should be shifted down by 1/8
03:47:550 (227550|3,227550|2) - 1/16 above at 03:47:575 -
03:57:761 (237761|0) - 1/16 below at 03:57:736 - , but this and the one above aren't really as necessary
04:00:547 (240547|2) - Up by 1/8 to 04:00:597 -
Otherwise I feel like the snaps should be fine as they currently are.
Final thing I'd like to mention is the hitsound volume. I would keep the hs vol at 04:53:160 - the same as at 04:33:935 - because 20% is barely audible and took me a few tries to hear it even on 0% music and 100% effects. Similarly, the beginning at 00:00:350 - is only audible on the jumps because of the double hit.
Protastic101 wrote:
Sorry about the late DQ orz
While a lot of snaps can just be simplified to the nearest 1/2 or 1/4 or whatever is more commonly encountered by the player, the part at 03:45:850 - is too nuanced to be simplified as it currently is.
03:45:883 - 03:45:916 - Not really that important, but if you wanted to add the 1/12 graces here, I think it'd be cool but I doubt it's all that important and the 1/4 is fine. keeping the 1/4th then o/
03:46:350 (226350|0,226550|3) - Should be shifted down by 1/8 ok!
03:47:550 (227550|3,227550|2) - 1/16 above at 03:47:575 -
03:57:761 (237761|0) - 1/16 below at 03:57:736 - , but this and the one above aren't really as necessary I'll keep them then o u o)b
04:00:547 (240547|2) - Up by 1/8 to 04:00:597 - 1/8 seems too late, used 1/12 instead just what Sir Feerum's suggested
Otherwise I feel like the snaps should be fine as they currently are.
Final thing I'd like to mention is the hitsound volume. I would keep the hs vol at 04:53:160 - the same as at 04:33:935 - because 20% is barely audible and took me a few tries to hear it even on 0% music and 100% effects. Similarly, the beginning at 00:00:350 - is only audible on the jumps because of the double hit. done! also done other points of Sir Feerum's
can you just make the beginning hs vol 35% like the end? I still can't hear the hitnormals for the single notes. Even then, the ending is also pretty hard at 35% and 40% may be better but idk
Fast fixed > u <)b also adjusted other hitsounds (20 => 35% , 35 => 40)Protastic101 wrote:
can you just make the beginning hs vol 35% like the end? I still can't hear the hitnormals for the single notes. Even then, the ending is also pretty hard at 35% and 40% may be better but idk
Topic Starter
so when is my 99th qualify gonna be
[Arcwin's Marathon]
- 03:48:000 (228000|0) - Just too weak this one here so I don't really think you need this. (You didn't catch the weak one here 03:48:750 - too).
Topic Starter
fixedTofu1222 wrote:
[Arcwin's Marathon]Fix and I will bubble.
- 03:48:000 (228000|0) - Just too weak this one here so I don't really think you need this. (You didn't catch the weak one here 03:48:750 - too).
Bubbled :3
qualified =w=
inb4 get dq'ed again
Looks like it’ll get ranked this time! GG for Meep!
finally hecking ranked.