GeneralMight want to consider one more difficulty between the Insane and Reset. The other diffs have a gap of ~1*, while the gap between those two is marginally larger, but Reset is also MUCH more difficult in terms of technicality/reading than the Insane. I don't think it's bad enough to be unrankable, but it might be a complaint.
00:20:904 (2) - 00:34:618 (2) -
Lower the volume of these echoes, as the hitsounds for them are way too loud right now. I believe these two apply for every difficulty.
Easy00:03:775 (1) - I don't think this needs a new combo, as it could be considered a pair to the slider before it. In addition, the circle after the next slider is not a new combo, which is a bit inconsistent.
00:08:904 (1) - I would comment on changing this NC, but as you put a NC on this beat in every difficulty I think it should be up to you for this one.
00:10:618 (1) - I don't think this needs a NC.
00:15:761 (1) - Many people will complain about slight overlaps like these. Personally, I consider them to look fine aesthetically as long as they aren't overlapping in an awkward manner, but just something to note.
01:03:761 (1) - Probably doesn't need nc, then 01:04:618 (2) - can made into a new combo to match new comboing of the two sliders right before it meaning 01:05:475 (1) - is no longer a new combo
This is pretty nitpicky I guess since almost everything is just comments on newcombos, but this easy is very solid. I like the interesting slider shapes. Do note that I'm not confident in my ability to judge if the difficulty of an easy is balanced.
Normal00:05:275 (1,2) - The blanketing of these sliders is slightly off.
http://i.imgur.com/v7dJN7q.png Perhaps adjust it a bit?
00:10:618 (1,2,3) - Make this a new combo, as this is the start of a measure (large white tick) and it feels off having it just be part of the previous combo, although it is part of that pattern.
00:19:189 (1,2) - This overlap is a bit ugly. It is connected to the next pattern in a way that makes it hard to adjust though, so if you decide you like it how it is that's fine. At least, for me.
00:32:904 (1,2) - These two sliders aren't actually perfectly parallel. Copy the first one and ctrl+g/add a repeat so that it's exact.
00:38:046 (1,2) - This blanket is off.
00:52:404 (4,1) - Slightly awkward overlap. This one should be easy to fix though simply by moving 00:53:261 (1) - slightly
00:55:189 (1) - This shouldn't be a new combo, especially since none of the other difficulties have a new combo here.
01:02:904 (2,2) - I recommend making these sliders the starts of their combos and
01:03:761 (1,1) - Making these not new combos.
01:23:261 (2,3,4,1) - I recommend taking this and using Ctrl+down three times to make 01:23:261 (2) - perfectly overlap the sliderhead/end of 01:21:761 (3) -
Again, nitpicky, but that just shows that the map itself is solid.
HardSome people might not like the overlapping in the intro. It seems ok to me.
00:05:275 (3) - New combo?
00:08:061 (1,2,3,1) - This spacing/timing might be
slightly confusing. It's not that bad though, more of a minor issue. Probably fine in a Hard, especially since it's near the start.
00:09:332 (1,2) - Maaaybe make this slider repeat 6 times and then the following slider repeat not at all, to follow the vocals better.
http://i.imgur.com/RH1izMj.png00:35:368 (4,5) - Might look better if one of these sliders is slightly curved/angled.
00:36:332 (1,1) - Not stacked perfectly - I know osu's editor isn't friendly with exact stacking, so use ctrl+arrow keys to adjust it manually.
00:43:189 (1,3) - Blanket between these two is slightly off
00:43:832 (2,3) - And these aren't perfectly stacked.
01:07:832 (3,4) - This blanket is slightly off, if it was intended to be a blanket. Note that I used ctrl+g and moved the slider's timing to take this screenshot.
http://i.imgur.com/V4GleKQ.png01:08:904 (1,2) - Could do same thing suggested for earlier repeat sliders. (6 beat instead of 4). If you choose to make the earlier change, make sure to change this one too for consistency.
01:23:689 (4,1) - Slightly awkward, as this last slider is completely different from the pattern preceding it. Could move it to other side to make it match, though this could make it look worse.
Insane00:06:561 (6,7) - Slightly misaligned stack (Use ctrl+arrows)
00:19:939 (3) - Maybe make this slider curve the other way to flow into the circle better
01:15:118 (6,7,8,1) - Spacing here is much larger than anywhere else in the map, if you were going for buildup to climax it's fine to make these a bit smaller because the difference between them and everything else is a bit too large right now
01:22:832 (3,4,5,6) - Make this curve a bit gentler, it looks a bit ugly as it is now
Very nice diff.
ResetThis is a tricky one for me to mod. Mainly because I can't really play it well enough to judge properly. But, I'll give you my thoughts.
I wish star rating was more accurate, as if I were to rate this it would definitely be a bit closer to 6 stars. But, consistent spacing, even if it's large, doesn't raise star rating as much as a few really big jumps
The flow in this one is VERY awkward, but I think you should be aware of that considering you mapped it. So, I'll avoid talking about that. After all, changing that would basically require a remap of the entire thing.
One of the most confusing things for first time players of the map will definitely be the stacked circles. The main problem here is that there are both triplet stacked circles and 1/2 stacked circles "pauses"
Personally, I find it a very interesting map, but it's highly likely that people will either love it or hate it.
Sorry I can't provide any proper comments on this difficulty.