forum

IOSYS - Cirno no Perfect Sansuu Kyoushitsu [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
55
Topic Starter
davidminh0111
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
FastBoy
M4M from ur modding queue
d - don
k - kat
D - big don
K - big kat

[General]
first of all, plz delete all the tags
cuz "yandere" is irrelevant to the song and "cirno","math","class","perfect","iosys" are covered in the title or in the artist
the source is "東方Project"
it is better to change the title to "チルノのパーフェクトさんすう教室"
then the romanised title will be "Cirno's Perfect Math Class"
also plz add "touhou" to the tags as it refers to 東方
add "chiruno no paafekuto sansuu kyoushitsu" as it is the romaji of the title
and add "zun" since he is the creator of touhou
the offset is not set well indeed
after testing, it is better for u to change the offset to 42
(note that the timing of notes shown below is based on this offset (42))
i found that u haven't set the preview point and it is improper
u can set 01:16:327 as the preview point

[Kantan]
00:00:042 - 00:10:156 & 00:21:984 - 00:32:784 these empty spaces are actually weird and meaningless
although u want to lower the diff. of it or it may be ur style, it is not a good way
plz place some notes by yourself
00:11:013 (1) - change to D to make the period 00:11:013 - 00:15:127 seem symmetric and sound better
00:51:470 (16) - change to d to fit the pitch
00:58:327 (28) - change to k to avoid repeating
00:59:013 (29) - change to K to fit the pitch
01:10:927 (6) - move the note to 01:11:013 as if u listen carefully, there is not worth placing note
01:18:213 (4) - change to d to fit the pitch
01:28:499 (18,19,20) - change to kdd as the rhythm there is similar to 01:17:527 (2,3,4)
01:31:242 (22,23,24) - change to ddk with the same reason above
02:00:384 - place D cuz the drum sound there is so strong
02:00:727 (1) - it is recommended to delete it but maybe it is ur style, i leave it to u
u may find that there are some notes not fitting the pitch but i haven't pointed them out
it is because they actually fit the feeling
so deciding placing d or k, pitch and feeling are the factors that we have to consider

[Futsuu]
empty space, u know what to do
00:51:470 (21) - change to d to fit the pitch
01:10:498 (12) - change to k to avoid repeating and make the period 01:05:870 - 01:10:499 seem symmetric
01:47:013 (106) - change to k to fit the rhythm
02:00:384 (1) - place D here and recommend u to delete the spinner

[Muzukashii]
also empty space
00:42:442 (162) - move it to 00:42:384
01:22:670 - place d to fit the rhythm. it is weird if there is no d
01:28:070 (95) - it is recommended to delete it as according to the song, there is not strong enough to place a note
01:59:242 (251) - move it to 01:59:184
02:00:384 (1) - place D here and recommend u to delete the spinner

[Oni]
i don't know why so many notes are not snapped onto the timeline
plz solve this serious problem
btw the pattern in this diff. is not bad

those are my advice
hope that they are helpful to u
enjoy mapping~
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

FastBoy wrote:

M4M from ur modding queue
d - don
k - kat
D - big don
K - big kat

[General]
first of all, plz delete all the tags
cuz "yandere" is irrelevant to the song and "cirno","math","class","perfect","iosys" are covered in the title or in the artist
the source is "東方Project"
it is better to change the title to "チルノのパーフェクトさんすう教室"
then the romanised title will be "Cirno's Perfect Math Class"
also plz add "touhou" to the tags as it refers to 東方
add "chiruno no paafekuto sansuu kyoushitsu" as it is the romaji of the title
and add "zun" since he is the creator of touhou
the offset is not set well indeed
after testing, it is better for u to change the offset to 42
(note that the timing of notes shown below is based on this offset (42))
i found that u haven't set the preview point and it is improper
u can set 01:16:327 as the preview point

[Kantan]
00:00:042 - 00:10:156 & 00:21:984 - 00:32:784 these empty spaces are actually weird and meaningless Fixed
although u want to lower the diff. of it or it may be ur style, it is not a good way
plz place some notes by yourself
00:11:013 (1) - change to D to make the period 00:11:013 - 00:15:127 seem symmetric and sound betterFixed
00:51:470 (16) - change to d to fit the pitch Nah, it's okay
00:58:327 (28) - change to k to avoid repeating I'd prefer change k to 00:59:013.
00:59:013 (29) - change to K to fit the pitch Just told ya
01:10:927 (6) - move the note to 01:11:013 as if u listen carefully, there is not worth placing note Fixed
01:18:213 (4) - change to d to fit the pitch I'd prefer change to d here 01:17:527
01:28:499 (18,19,20) - change to kdd as the rhythm there is similar to 01:17:527 (2,3,4) Nope
01:31:242 (22,23,24) - change to ddk with the same reason above Still not
02:00:384 - place D cuz the drum sound there is so strong Ok
02:00:727 (1) - it is recommended to delete it but maybe it is ur style, i leave it to uI removed it!
u may find that there are some notes not fitting the pitch but i haven't pointed them out
it is because they actually fit the feeling
so deciding placing d or k, pitch and feeling are the factors that we have to consider

[Futsuu]
empty space, u know what to do
00:51:470 (21) - change to d to fit the pitch
01:10:498 (12) - change to k to avoid repeating and make the period 01:05:870 - 01:10:499 seem symmetric
01:47:013 (106) - change to k to fit the rhythm
02:00:384 (1) - place D here and recommend u to delete the spinner

[Muzukashii]
also empty space
00:42:442 (162) - move it to 00:42:384
01:22:670 - place d to fit the rhythm. it is weird if there is no d
01:28:070 (95) - it is recommended to delete it as according to the song, there is not strong enough to place a note
01:59:242 (251) - move it to 01:59:184
02:00:384 (1) - place D here and recommend u to delete the spinner

[Oni]
i don't know why so many notes are not snapped onto the timeline
plz solve this serious problem
btw the pattern in this diff. is not bad

those are my advice
hope that they are helpful to u
enjoy mapping~
Fixed most of them
Btw, thanks for the mod, i will fix your map
sakebi
from queue

d = small red
k = small blue
D = big red
K = big blue

[general]
set a preview point for the map

[kantan]
slider velocity should be 1.40

00:32:955 (37,1) - two notes on same tick
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:16:842 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:38:784 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped

[futsuu]
00:21:984 (52) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:14:442 (22,25) - change from ddd ddd to ddk ddk
01:38:784 (76) - green timing point isn't snapped

[muzukashii]
00:01:413 (6) - should be d instead of D
00:04:156 (15) - change from d to k
00:04:499 (16) - add d 00:04:670
00:19:242 (48,49,50,51) - instead of k d k d, should be d k d k or k D k D
00:20:784 (53,54) - add k between these at 00:20:870
00:21:984 (59) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:37:842 (145) - remove note
01:38:784 (149) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:39:984 (155) - change from k to d
01:41:356 (162,163) - switch from k d to d k
01:42:042 (166,167) - switch d to k
01:42:899 (170) - switch d to k

[oni]
make sure notes and timing points are properly snapped
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

lilligantEX wrote:

from queue

d = small red
k = small blue
D = big red
K = big blue

[general]
set a preview point for the map

[kantan]
slider velocity should be 1.40Fixed

00:32:955 (37,1) - two notes on same tick LOL, I didn't pay attention to this, Fixed
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snappedFixed
01:16:842 (1) - green timing point isn't snappedFixed
01:38:784 (1) - green timing point isn't snappedFixed

[futsuu]
00:21:984 (52) - green timing point isn't snappedFixed
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snapped
01:14:442 (22,25) - change from ddd ddd to ddk ddkFixed
01:38:784 (76) - green timing point isn't snappedFixed

[muzukashii]
00:01:413 (6) - should be d instead of D] It doesn't change
00:04:156 (15) - change from d to kFixed
00:04:499 (16) - add d 00:04:670
00:19:242 (48,49,50,51) - instead of k d k d, should be d k d k or k D k DNah, I think it's suitable
00:20:784 (53,54) - add k between these at 00:20:870Nope
00:21:984 (59) - green timing point isn't snappedAlready
01:05:870 (1) - green timing point isn't snappedSame
01:37:842 (145) - remove note [color=#BFFF00For singing[/color]
01:38:784 (149) - green timing point isn't snappedAlready
01:39:984 (155) - change from k to dWould prefer change to k at 01:40:670
01:41:356 (162,163) - switch from k d to d kFixed
01:42:042 (166,167) - switch d to kFixed
01:42:899 (170) - switch d to kFixed

[oni]
make sure notes and timing points are properly snapped
Thanks
JarHed
:lol: Hi, JarHed's Here my Queue

Muzukashii :

00:00:384 (2) - Change to a Kat Same sounds going on with the 3rd note in the song.

00:00:899 (4,5) - Change (4) to a Don and (5) to a Kat Followup to the previous ^ and it sounds a whole lot better in the song.

00:01:755 (7,8,9,10) - Repeat all of this at these notes as well it s the same thing ^^^

00:41:184 (157,158,159,160,161,162,163) - Snapping points are not correct with the song here, Change it to the picture below (Notes not changed just where they are placed)

Cursor at 00:41:870 --->

01:57:984 (246,247,248,249,250,251,252,253) - Snapping points also incorrect here change to this. (Notes not changed just where they are placed)

Cursor at 01:58:670 --->

Delete 01:59:870 (253) - Change to this pattern here sounds way better and is a better finish up for the map.

Cursor at: 02:00:42
Pattern Here:

Good Muzu just things here and there need to be fixed :)

Oni:

- Its well mapped however add new patterns everywhere where there is 1/4, To be more specific its all DDD or KKK or DDDDK Try to add some patterns in that contribute more technical patterns such as DKD KDDKD\

Im not gonna change much with the Oni simply because the only issue is lack of patterns its well mapped i like it a lot i just think it seems bland ADD MORE PATTERNS
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

JarHed wrote:

:lol: Hi, JarHed's Here my Queue

Muzukashii :

00:00:384 (2) - Change to a Kat Same sounds going on with the 3rd note in the song.

00:00:899 (4,5) - Change (4) to a Don and (5) to a Kat Followup to the previous ^ and it sounds a whole lot better in the song.

00:01:755 (7,8,9,10) - Repeat all of this at these notes as well it s the same thing ^^^

00:41:184 (157,158,159,160,161,162,163) - Snapping points are not correct with the song here, Change it to the picture below (Notes not changed just where they are placed)

Cursor at 00:41:870 --->

01:57:984 (246,247,248,249,250,251,252,253) - Snapping points also incorrect here change to this. (Notes not changed just where they are placed)

Cursor at 01:58:670 --->

Delete 01:59:870 (253) - Change to this pattern here sounds way better and is a better finish up for the map.

Cursor at: 02:00:42
Pattern Here:

Good Muzu just things here and there need to be fixed :)

Oni:

- Its well mapped however add new patterns everywhere where there is 1/4, To be more specific its all DDD or KKK or DDDDK Try to add some patterns in that contribute more technical patterns such as DKD KDDKD\

Im not gonna change much with the Oni simply because the only issue is lack of patterns its well mapped i like it a lot i just think it seems bland ADD MORE PATTERNS
Fixed all, thank you.
Will mod your map later
_yu68
Hello. mod via PM :3

mod
[General]
  1. Please add tag '東方Project'.
[Kantan]
  1. 00:02:784 (3,4) - change to k? I think that be able to represent differences of pitch.
  2. 00:08:270 (7,8) - ^
  3. 00:26:613 (30) - move to 00:26:784 - ? I suggest reduce complex rhythm for beginner.
  4. 00:37:584 (41) - move to 00:37:756 - ? ^
  5. 00:34:842 - add k? This is same as 00:23:870 -
  6. 00:48:384 (10,11) - delete? I think it need to make 4/1 break for beginner.
  7. 00:54:213 (20) - ^
[Futsuu]
  1. Please fix SV to 1.40.
  2. 00:20:956 (35) - move to 00:20:613 - ? I think that flow becomes natural by fiting to vocal.
  3. 00:22:327 (38) - move to 00:22:499 - ? I suggest fit to vocals just like Kantan.
  4. 00:23:699 (41) - move to 00:23:870 - ? ^
  5. 00:25:070 (44) - move to 00:25:242 - ? ^
  6. 00:27:813 (50) - move to 00:27:984 - ? ^
  7. 00:29:184 (53) - move to 00:29:356 - ? ^
  8. 00:30:556 (56) - move to 00:30:727 - ? ^
  9. 00:34:670 (65) - move to 00:34:842 - ? ^
  10. 00:38:784 (74) - move to 00:38:956 - ? ^
  11. 00:40:156 (77) - move to 00:40:327 - ? ^
  12. 01:39:127 (59) - move to 01:39:299 - ? ^
  13. 01:40:499 (62) - move to 01:40:670 - ? ^
  14. 01:47:356 (78) - move to 01:47:527 - ? ^
  15. 01:50:099 (82) - move to 01:50:270 - ? ^
  16. 01:51:470 (85) - move to 01:51:642 - ? ^
  17. 01:55:584 (94) - move to 01:55:756 - ? ^
  18. 01:56:956 (97) - move to 01:57:127 - ? ^
  19. 01:15:470 (20) - Slider is unsnapped. Please fix.
  20. 01:37:413 (56) - remove finisher? Because sound is weak.
[Muzukashii]
  1. change SV to 1.40? 1.40 is used in many ranked maps so it is better.
  2. 00:12:213 (10) - delete? I think that pattern is too long for Muzukashii.
  3. 00:14:956 (25) - ^
  4. 00:17:699 (38) - ^
  5. 00:27:299 (88) - ^
  6. 00:32:784 (116) - ^
  7. 01:34:499 (124) - ^
  8. 01:35:870 (132) - ^
  9. 01:37:242 (140) - ^
  10. 01:49:584 (205) - ^
  11. 00:28:499 - 00:28:670 - add notes? It is same as 00:23:013 - 00:23:184 -
  12. 00:33:984 - 00:34:156 - ^
  13. 01:45:299 - 01:45:470 - ^
  14. 01:50:784 - 01:50:956 - ^
  15. 01:22:756 (68) - delete? I feel this will make complex for Muzukashii players.
  16. 01:28:070 (95) - ^
  17. 01:37:842 (145) - delete? I think that be able to emphasize rhythm of vocal.
[Oni]
  1. change SV to 1.40? Same reason as Muzukashii.
  2. 00:03:813 (21,22) - change to dd? I think that be able to represent difference of pitch between 00:03:984 - and 00:04:156 -
  3. 00:55:927 - add k? There is same sound as 00:57:299 -
  4. 01:14:099 - ~ 01:16:156 - I think the overall balance is bad because this part is too hard. I suggest to change to 1/4s.

I think that this mapset needs more advice from skilled mappers.
Good luck!
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

_yu68 wrote:

Hello. mod via PM :3

mod
[General]
  1. Please add tag '東方Project'.
[Kantan]
  1. 00:02:784 (3,4) - change to k? I think that be able to represent differences of pitch.
  2. 00:08:270 (7,8) - ^
  3. 00:26:613 (30) - move to 00:26:784 - ? I suggest reduce complex rhythm for beginner.
  4. 00:37:584 (41) - move to 00:37:756 - ? ^
  5. 00:34:842 - add k? This is same as 00:23:870 -
  6. 00:48:384 (10,11) - delete? I think it need to make 4/1 break for beginner.
  7. 00:54:213 (20) - ^
[Futsuu]
  1. Please fix SV to 1.40.
  2. 00:20:956 (35) - move to 00:20:613 - ? I think that flow becomes natural by fiting to vocal.
  3. 00:22:327 (38) - move to 00:22:499 - ? I suggest fit to vocals just like Kantan.
  4. 00:23:699 (41) - move to 00:23:870 - ? ^
  5. 00:25:070 (44) - move to 00:25:242 - ? ^
  6. 00:27:813 (50) - move to 00:27:984 - ? ^
  7. 00:29:184 (53) - move to 00:29:356 - ? ^
  8. 00:30:556 (56) - move to 00:30:727 - ? ^
  9. 00:34:670 (65) - move to 00:34:842 - ? ^
  10. 00:38:784 (74) - move to 00:38:956 - ? ^
  11. 00:40:156 (77) - move to 00:40:327 - ? ^
  12. 01:39:127 (59) - move to 01:39:299 - ? ^
  13. 01:40:499 (62) - move to 01:40:670 - ? ^
  14. 01:47:356 (78) - move to 01:47:527 - ? ^
  15. 01:50:099 (82) - move to 01:50:270 - ? ^
  16. 01:51:470 (85) - move to 01:51:642 - ? ^
  17. 01:55:584 (94) - move to 01:55:756 - ? ^
  18. 01:56:956 (97) - move to 01:57:127 - ? ^
  19. 01:15:470 (20) - Slider is unsnapped. Please fix.
  20. 01:37:413 (56) - remove finisher? Because sound is weak.
[Muzukashii]
  1. change SV to 1.40? 1.40 is used in many ranked maps so it is better.
  2. 00:12:213 (10) - delete? I think that pattern is too long for Muzukashii.
  3. 00:14:956 (25) - ^
  4. 00:17:699 (38) - ^
  5. 00:27:299 (88) - ^
  6. 00:32:784 (116) - ^
  7. 01:34:499 (124) - ^
  8. 01:35:870 (132) - ^
  9. 01:37:242 (140) - ^
  10. 01:49:584 (205) - ^
  11. 00:28:499 - 00:28:670 - add notes? It is same as 00:23:013 - 00:23:184 -
  12. 00:33:984 - 00:34:156 - ^
  13. 01:45:299 - 01:45:470 - ^
  14. 01:50:784 - 01:50:956 - ^
  15. 01:22:756 (68) - delete? I feel this will make complex for Muzukashii players.
  16. 01:28:070 (95) - ^
  17. 01:37:842 (145) - delete? I think that be able to emphasize rhythm of vocal.
[Oni]
  1. change SV to 1.40? Same reason as Muzukashii.
  2. 00:03:813 (21,22) - change to dd? I think that be able to represent difference of pitch between 00:03:984 - and 00:04:156 -
  3. 00:55:927 - add k? There is same sound as 00:57:299 -
  4. 01:14:099 - ~ 01:16:156 - I think the overall balance is bad because this part is too hard. I suggest to change to 1/4s.

I think that this mapset needs more advice from skilled mappers.
Good luck!
I will try my best. You are one of the skilled taiko mapper
Thank you very much
toara_fict
M4M

FastBoy wrote:

[Oni]
i don't know why so many notes are not snapped onto the timeline
plz solve this serious problem
btw the pattern in this diff. is not bad

those are my advice
hope that they are helpful to u
enjoy mapping~

lilligantEX wrote:

[oni]
make sure notes and timing points are properly snapped

JarHed wrote:

Oni:

- Its well mapped however add new patterns everywhere where there is 1/4, To be more specific its all DDD or KKK or DDDDK Try to add some patterns in that contribute more technical patterns such as DKD KDDKD\

Im not gonna change much with the Oni simply because the only issue is lack of patterns its well mapped i like it a lot i just think it seems bland ADD MORE PATTERNS

_yu68 wrote:

I think that this mapset needs more advice from skilled mappers.
Good luck!
ok. i check Oni


[ General]
  1. tag : Project' ...delete ' ?
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

[ Oni]
  1. 00:06:899 (37) - change k ( high pitch sound. )
  2. 00:20:442 (120) - delete Finish

  3. 00:17:699 (103,104) - swap. ( follow bass drum sound 00:17:184 (100) - 00:18:556 (110) - )
    or
    00:17:013 (99,100,101,102) - swap ( if you want follow Vocal pitch. )

  4. 00:23:870 (144) - delete Finish or 00:24:727 (150) - delete finish and 00:25:242 (153) - add finish. ( Unity is lacking )

  5. 00:32:099 (199,200) - or 00:31:927 (197,198,199,200) - change d. ( Emphasis 00:32:270 (201) - note. & 00:32:184 (200) - 00:32:270 (201) - is different sound. )

  6. 00:27:984 (172) - 00:28:842 (177) - 00:29:355 (180) - 00:30:213 (185) - 00:30:727 (188) - 00:33:470 (209) - 00:34:327 (214) - 00:34:842 (217) - 00:35:699 (222) - 00:36:213 (225) -00:38:956 (244) - ( some 00:23:870 (144) -)

  7. 00:45:299 (280) - 00:46:671 (287) - 00:48:041 (294) - 00:51:470 (313) - 00:55:584 (334) - 00:56:956 (341) - 00:57:299 (342) - 00:58:327 (348) - 00:59:013 (350) - 01:07:413 (416) - 01:09:984 (426) - delete finish. ( noizy )

  8. 01:16:842 (471) - ADD FINISH

  9. 01:24:384 (519) - delete finish & 01:25:070 - add Finish.

  10. 01:29:870 (553) - 01:34:499 (577) - delete finish.
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

I think unity of placement is very lacking.
It seems that Finish is also arranged at random.
Oni remapped you to recreate it once or ask GD. recommend it.

Good Luck
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

toara_fict wrote:

M4M

FastBoy wrote:

[Oni]
i don't know why so many notes are not snapped onto the timeline
plz solve this serious problem
btw the pattern in this diff. is not bad

those are my advice
hope that they are helpful to u
enjoy mapping~

lilligantEX wrote:

[oni]
make sure notes and timing points are properly snapped

JarHed wrote:

Oni:

- Its well mapped however add new patterns everywhere where there is 1/4, To be more specific its all DDD or KKK or DDDDK Try to add some patterns in that contribute more technical patterns such as DKD KDDKD\

Im not gonna change much with the Oni simply because the only issue is lack of patterns its well mapped i like it a lot i just think it seems bland ADD MORE PATTERNS

_yu68 wrote:

I think that this mapset needs more advice from skilled mappers.
Good luck!
ok. i check Oni


[ General]
  1. tag : Project' ...delete ' ?


- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

[ Oni]
  1. 00:06:899 (37) - change k ( high pitch sound. )Fixed
  2. 00:20:442 (120) - delete FinishFixed

  3. 00:17:699 (103,104) - swap. ( follow bass drum sound 00:17:184 (100) - 00:18:556 (110) - )Fixed
    or
    00:17:013 (99,100,101,102) - swap ( if you want follow Vocal pitch. )No, it doesn't fit the vocal either the pitch (slow down the song and you will get it

  4. 00:23:870 (144) - delete Finish or 00:24:727 (150) - delete finish and 00:25:242 (153) - add finish. ( Unity is lacking ) Yeah, I should fix all the Drum sound

  5. 00:32:099 (199,200) - or 00:31:927 (197,198,199,200) - change d. ( Emphasis 00:32:270 (201) - note. & 00:32:184 (200) - 00:32:270 (201) - is different sound. ) Fixed

  6. 00:27:984 (172) - 00:28:842 (177) - 00:29:355 (180) - 00:30:213 (185) - 00:30:727 (188) - 00:33:470 (209) - 00:34:327 (214) - 00:34:842 (217) - 00:35:699 (222) - 00:36:213 (225) -00:38:956 (244) - ( some 00:23:870 (144) -)You mean emphasis

  7. 00:45:299 (280) - 00:46:671 (287) - 00:48:041 (294) - 00:51:470 (313) - 00:55:584 (334) - 00:56:956 (341) - 00:57:299 (342) - 00:58:327 (348) - 00:59:013 (350) - 01:07:413 (416) - 01:09:984 (426) - delete finish. ( noizy )Fixed

  8. 01:16:842 (471) - ADD FINISHFixed

  9. 01:24:384 (519) - delete finish & 01:25:070 - add Finish.Fixed

  10. 01:29:870 (553) - 01:34:499 (577) - delete finish.
Fixed
- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

I think unity of placement is very lacking.
It seems that Finish is also arranged at random.
Oni remapped you to recreate it once or ask GD. recommend it.

Good Luck
Thanks
I don't need GD btw. OwO
Namki
Actually, source must be "東方Project".
Also, it's better to use actual game name as "東方紅魔郷 〜 the Embodiment of Scarlet Devil.", but Cirno appears in a half of Touhou games so idk.
Shortthu
metadata can take from here
put metadata taken from that mapset on the map desc or just ask alacat idk lul
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

Namki wrote:

Actually, source must be "東方Project".
Also, it's better to use actual game name as "東方紅魔郷 〜 the Embodiment of Scarlet Devil.", but Cirno appears in a half of Touhou games so idk.
Yeah Im not sure about that.

I cant take that metadata because i love this metadata more, Shortthu.
Shortthu

davidminh0111 wrote:

I cant take that metadata because i love this metadata more, Shortthu.
so, you can't rank this mapset
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

Shortthu wrote:

davidminh0111 wrote:

I cant take that metadata because i love this metadata more, Shortthu.
so, you can't rank this mapset
!!!!
kvgyubh
hi,let's mod
☆general
 ・from 01:57:984 (819) - --->sv up is too fast.make it more smooth and slower sv up
☆Inner Oni
 ・00:00:042 (1,2,3,4) - --->dddk change to ddkk(?)
 ・00:01:242 (7) - --->change to k(?)
 ・00:01:756 (10) - --->change to k(?)
 ・00:03:127 (17,18,19,20) - --->change to kkdd(?)
 ・00:04:156 (23,24,25,26) - --->change to kkdk(?)
 ・00:05:013 (27,28,29) - --->change to kkk(?)
 ・00:07:242 (39) - --->change to d(?)
 ・00:07:927 (42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - --->change to ddkkkdkkk(?)
Topic Starter
davidminh0111

kvgyubh wrote:

hi,let's mod
☆general
 ・from 01:57:984 (819) - --->sv up is too fast.make it more smooth and slower sv up It should be in Inner Oni
☆Inner Oni
 ・00:00:042 (1,2,3,4) - --->dddk change to ddkk(?) No, because there is a high pitch at that point
 ・00:01:242 (7) - --->change to k(?)Ok
 ・00:01:756 (10) - --->change to k(?)Same as 1st one
 ・00:03:127 (17,18,19,20) - --->change to kkdd(?) ^
 ・00:04:156 (23,24,25,26) - --->change to kkdk(?)^
 ・00:05:013 (27,28,29) - --->change to kkk(?)Yeah, there's a high pitch there
 ・00:07:242 (39) - --->change to d(?) Still not,high pitch
 ・00:07:927 (42,43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - --->change to ddkkkdkkk(?)No, the pitch.
I would recommend you to slow down the song and you will get it.
Thanks for your mod :)
[R]
yo


[General]
- for better appearance BG, open file in notepad and find :
[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"moe 942041 cirno.jpg",0,00
Change to :
[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"moe 942041 cirno.jpg",0,80

- consider to remove some finisher while the part is calm

[Kantan]

00:31:584 - change kat for variety with 00:34:327 - since pitch in here high
00:37:070 - same ^
00:43:584 - delete
01:03:470 - delete ?? it feels no break while there has 2 spinere
01:11:013 - guess finishere more work in 01:11:356 - to give emphasize
01:35:013 (1) - spinner should start in 01:35:013 (1) - and the rest 01:35:527 - can add note
01:54:384 - delete ??

[Futsuu]
00:17:870 - change kat ti give an emphasize
00:26:442 - delete ?? density in here high
00:31:070 - move 00:31:242 - and delete 00:31:413 -
00:31:584 - instead slider, maybe just put note like kantan thing
00:36:042 - add note ??
00:36:213 - remove finishere, no reasonable to put in here
00:48:042 (12,13,14) - no need finisher, still calm here, put note in 00:48:213 - instead
00:58:842 - add note ??

[Muzukashii]
00:08:099 - delete
00:09:470 - delete
00:11:356 - | 00:11:870 - delete for better flow
00:14:613 - delete ^
00:47:184 - change kat ?? for variety
00:48:213 - change don ^
01:12:042 - delete, it's to long for muzukashi

[Oni]
00:13:156 - | 00:13:327 - delete, guess stream stop here
00:21:042 - delete to match with vocal
00:26:870 - delete??
00:32:784 - change kat to emphasize 00:32:956 -

[Inner]
00:19:584 - an average for increasing SV is around 1-5 | 10 is to far so maybe you can reduce it

that's all from me
good luck
Topic Starter
davidminh0111
:P

[R] wrote:

yo


[General]
- for better appearance BG, open file in notepad and find :
[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"moe 942041 cirno.jpg",0,00
Change to :
[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"moe 942041 cirno.jpg",0,80

- consider to remove some finisher while the part is calm I don't know how to do the BG help O_o (now I know)

[Kantan]

00:31:584 - change kat for variety with 00:34:327 - since pitch in here high Ok
00:37:070 - same ^Fixed
00:43:584 - delete No, because there's a vocal here. Not really hard for beginners
01:03:470 - delete ?? it feels no break while there has 2 spinere Yeah, I would agree with that
01:11:013 - guess finishere more work in 01:11:356 - to give emphasize Ok
01:35:013 (1) - spinner should start in 01:35:013 (1) - and the rest 01:35:527 - can add note At 01:36:042 , spinner here
01:54:384 - delete ??Wait, why?? O_o

[Futsuu]
00:17:870 - change kat ti give an emphasize Fixed
00:26:442 - delete ?? density in here high Fixed
00:31:070 - move 00:31:242 - and delete 00:31:413 - No, because there's a vocal there. No change
00:31:584 - instead slider, maybe just put note like kantan thing Still not, because there's a long vocal of the music here.
00:36:042 - add note ?? Ok
00:36:213 - remove finishere, no reasonable to put in hereYeah
00:48:042 (12,13,14) - no need finisher, still calm here, put note in 00:48:213 - instead Only remove finish at 12. add note
00:58:842 - add note ??

[Muzukashii]
00:08:099 - delete Why???? OwO???
00:09:470 - delete ^
00:11:356 - | 00:11:870 - delete for better flow Not better flow
00:14:613 - delete ^ ^
00:47:184 - change kat ?? for variety Sure
00:48:213 - change don ^ Fixed
01:12:042 - delete, it's to long for muzukashi Deleted a note at 01:12:042

[Oni]
00:13:156 - | 00:13:327 - delete, guess stream stop here No, vocal of music... O_o
00:21:042 - delete to match with vocal Fixed
00:26:870 - delete?? Same reason as 1st one
00:32:784 - change kat to emphasize 00:32:956 - Fixed

[Inner]
00:19:584 - an average for increasing SV is around 1-5 | 10 is to far so maybe you can reduce it Fixed

that's all from me
good luck
Thanks for your mod. I appreciate it
Ladies Night

SΞCTOR #712

NM Request | ✶ | Taiko

Metadata Check

  • Song Title
  1. Change the current Song Title to "Cirno no Perfect Sansuu Kyoushitsu", this is the modified Romanisation with correct English for it.
    Source
  2. Add "東方紅魔郷 ~ the Embodiment of Scarlet Devil." to Source, since this is how the official game title is shown. (The weird hypen spacing is intentional.)
    Tags
  3. Change 東方 Project' to 東方Project in tags, there should be no spacing since that's how the official name is shown and also there's no apostrophe after Project.
  4. Change Touhou to Touhou Koumakyou in tags, this is the romanised translation of 東方紅魔郷.
  5. Add 東方氷雪歌集 in tags, this is the name of the album in Japanese, the song starred in.
  6. Add Cirno's Math Class in tags, this would be the song title in full English.
  7. Add ARM in tags, he arranged the song.
  8. Add 夕野ヨシミ in tags, lyrics were written by them.
  9. Add Yuuno Yoshimi in tags, this is the romanised name of 夕野ヨシミ in English.
  10. Add miko in tags, since she sang as the vocalist.
  11. Add Alternative ending in tags, part of the alias of miko.
  12. Add quim in tags, since he was part of the vocals as the chorus.
  13. Add Team Shanghai Alice in tags, this is the circle that ZUN releases Doujin games/music under.
  14. Add 上海アリス幻樂団 or 上海アリス幻楽団 in tags, Japanese name of Team Shanghai Alice.
  15. Add Otenba Koimusume in tags, romanised translation of the original theme this song was rearranged for.
  16. Add おてんば恋娘 in tags, Japanese name of Otenba Koimusume.
  17. Add Stage 2 Boss Theme in tags, the arrangement of this song was based on this original boss theme for Cirno created by ZUN.
  18. Add IO-0147 in tags, this is the catalog number of the album. (Optional)
  19. Add IO-0191 in tags, catalog number of the album "Grimoire of IOSYS – Touhou BEST ALBUM vol.1", which the song also starred in. (Optional)
Sources used: 東方Project第6弾, 東方氷雪歌集, Touhou Anthology of Ice and Snow, Grimoire of IOSYS – 東方BEST ALBUM vol.1, IOSYS's Discography, the Embodiment of Scarlet Devil, Team Shanghai Alice, Lyrics: チルノのパーフェクトさんすう教室, VGMdb, SoundCloud.

General Suggestions

  • Audio
  1. I'd suggest you get a 192kbps MP3 version of this song since the MP3 you use currently in the Song Folder is 160kbps and the higher bitrate would make the audio experience better.
    Unused Hitsounds
  2. You have unused custom Hitsounds in your Song Folder, delete the following: taiko-normal-hitclap.wav, taiko-normal-hitfinish.wav, taiko-normal-hitnormal.wav, taiko-normal-hitwhistle.wav. These custom Hitsounds aren't used since you only used the soft sampleset of the custom Hitsounds you applied for the Inherited Timing Points.
    Inconsistent Values
  3. All of your tags from other difficulties conflict with Muzukashii's tags, make sure to have the same tags for all of the difficulties to keep consistency.
  4. Your Muzukashii difficulty has a different Source compared to the rest of the mapset, make sure the source is "東方紅魔郷 ~ the Embodiment of Scarlet Devil." for all of the difficulties.
  5. Make sure to turn off Widescreen support for all difficulties except Oni, since that difficulty has it unchecked already. Your map doesn't have a storyboard currently so you don't need this option on. You can find it by going to Song Setup > Design > Misc. Toggles > Widescreen Support and toggling that option off for all difficulties except Oni since Oni has it unchecked already.
  6. All difficulties except Kantan and Muzukashii don't actually have the correct 1.40x base SV. You can fix this by going into File > Open osu. in Notepad > Difficulty > Slider Multiplier and changing that decimal number to 1.40x for the base SV. Do this for all difficulties except Kantan and Muzukashii since both of them are correct already.
    Difficulty Settings
  7. Not sure why you have the same difficulty settings for all of the mapset so here's some suggestions: Kantan - OD3 and HP7, Futsuu - OD4 and HP6, Muzukashii - OD5 and HP5, Oni - OD5.5 and HP5, Inner Oni - OD6 and HP6. You can adjust these settings under Song Setup > Difficulty, hold shift for the decimal settings.
    Hitsound Volume
  8. While 100% is applicable as the Hitsound volume for all of your Inherited/Timing Points, I still feel that you can tone it down 95% or 90% even and it still have the same effect since 100% is a bit loud considering it's used throughout the entire song; especially with the custom Hitsounds. Make sure to apply these changes for all of the mapset if you choose to change this.

[Kantan]

  1. 00:19:927 (22) - Change to D finisher, you used a Don finisher for the same sound earlier at 00:19:242 (20), would keep consistency.
  2. 00:45:984 (6) - Change to k, The vocalist sounds different here and you can emphasize that since these two notes earlier at 00:45:299 (4,5) are similar.
  3. 00:51:470 (14) - ^, same reasoning as above.
  4. 00:55:585 (19) - ^, same as the reason stated above.
  5. 00:56:956 (22) - ^, same like the reasons shown above.
  6. 00:57:984 (24) - Change to k, it would contrast the two notes at 00:57:642 (23,25) and emphasize the vocals a bit better than regular 1/2 (d,d,d).
  7. 01:05:989 - Inherited Timing Point here is unsnapped, make sure to snap this to 01:05:956, if you're using the 1/4 Beat Snap.
  8. Change to d finisher, the vocalist is loud here and so is the bass here as well.
  9. 01:13:413 (10) - Change to k, it would represent the louder vocals here and the snare drums here as well.
  10. 01:16:842 (1) - Change to K finisher, not sure why you missed this but, you can emphasize the start of the Kiai section and the loud crash sound here.
  11. 01:23:527 (11) - Move this note back to 01:23:356, sound much better here since we're going off of the vocals here and the rhythm kinda abruptly stops here.

[Futsuu]

  1. 01:07:584 (5) - Change to k, sounds better than a regular Don and plus, plays well as it's the opposite of this pattern earlier at 01:05:870 (1,2,3).
  2. 01:16:842 (21) - Change to K finisher, start of the Kiai section and you can show that with a finisher and there's also a loud crash sound here that can be represented.

[Muzukashii]

  1. 00:07:756 (25,26,27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37) - This little section right here uses Kats way too much and it's a bit boring to play, just adding Dons into this section would make it more fun in variation and as well as sound rhythmically better.
  2. 00:37:584 (138) - Change to d, this would contrast and emphasize the Kats at 00:37:756 (139,140,141) much more and also prevent the overusage of Kats here.
  3. 00:40:670 (154) - ^, same as the reasoning above, just in a different place for the pattern but it still offers variation and sounds better as well.
  4. 01:00:384 (229,230,231,232,233,234,235,236,237,238,239,240,241,242,243,244,245,246,247,248,249,250,251,252) - This section here is just constant 1/2 notes, why not break them up in smaller parts since it's a bit hard to play these patterns at Muzukashii level?
  5. 01:15:470 (41) - This slider end here is unsnapped, make sure to snap the slider end to 01:16:242 if you're using 1/4 Beat Snap.
  6. 01:16:842 (42) - Change to K finisher, emphasizes the start of Kiai section and the synthetic sounds here.
  7. 01:46:499 (182,183,184,185,186,187,188) - Any justification for using all Kats here? I feel like you could of change some of these into Dons and it would sound better and be more fun to play.
  8. 01:54:213 (222) - Change to d, would emphasize the bass here a lot better and add variation into this pattern here.

[Oni]

  1. 01:00:384 (359,360,361,362,363,364,365,366,367,368,369,370,371,372,373,374,375,376,377,378,379,380,381,382,383) - Stream is a bit too long for an Oni difficulty, breaking the stream into smaller parts would suffice.
  2. 01:04:499 (394,395,396,397,398,399,400,401,402,403,404,405,406,407,408,409,410) - ^, same as the reason shown above.
  3. 01:05:989 - Inherited Timing Point here is unsnapped, make sure to snap this to 01:05:956, if you're using the 1/4 Beat Snap.

Overall Summary

  1. Quite a lot of inconsistencies and simple mistakes that make executing the mapset's concept a bit hard to show, but with some more mods; this mapset can be better.
Best of endeavors with this mapset.
Thanks for requesting from SΞCTOR #712.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply