@elena2705: my fault, fixed
@Kitty tag and names changed! Thanks for metadata xD
also updated abhor's change
thanks for mod!Rizen wrote:
GeneralNormal
- 00:50:385 - need a second uninherited timing point here to reset the metronome. significant beats like the kiai start at 01:06:210 - should land on the large white tick added! also resnap green lines
- the song has two types of cymbals in the music like at 01:10:168 (1) - and 00:14:777 (1) - . perhaps you can hitsound these too with a normal-finish addition to enhance the mapset further i'd love to, but i think current normal finish doesn't fix those cymbal better, so i will search for some other hs for them. All of the hs(cympal)-related mods are the same reply with that, so i will not reply them.
Flower
- 00:02:908 (3,4) - very slight mis-blanket noooooooooooo
- 00:25:493 - consider mapping the vocals here as you have done in the next section like at places like 00:41:319 (2) - ? imo would be best to either follow all or not follow them at all as i mentioned in yoshimaro's mod, here is (relatively) a quiet part, so i decided to arrange a more sparse rhythm here to show difference between this part and the following same but more strong one.
- 00:48:407 (1) - perhaps a finish at slider head for cymbals?
- 00:54:342 (1) - whistle at slider end? has that snare drum in the music mmm finally i decided to not add that cuz sound at 00:54:837 - is different with, like 01:04:563 (2) - (and more weak) so i decided to not put whitsle on it
- 00:56:320 (4) - forgot a NC here am i dreaming
- 01:04:893 (3) - change to a 1/6 slider then circle? to highlight the drums here good idea
- 01:17:751 (7,1) - your theme of opposing sliders isn't shown here, when you have done it in almost every other situation. What I mean is you usually flow like 01:01:925 (5,1) - or 00:57:969 (7) - where the slider directions do not line up you've got a point. using ctrl+j on 01:17:751 (7) - for a better consistency.
if there's something you don't understand or if I explained a point badly, don't be afraid to pm me
- 00:01:919 (1,2,3) - I don't quite understand why you increased spacing here compared to 00:00:930 (1,2,3) - since the song intensity between the two are the same. would be best to stick with one universal spacing imo up until the instruments pick up at 00:07:853 (1) - ok, remapped the beginning piano part
- 00:08:842 (1) - change to a 1/3 repeat slider, similar to 00:10:821 (1) - ? to map that percussion on that purple tick ok
- 00:19:723 (2,3) - space circle 3 out more, spacing too similar to 00:16:755 (1,2) - which are spaced different rhythmically ok
- 00:31:427 (4) - unsnapped, change beat snap divisor back to 1/12 fixed
- 00:39:835 (2) - move a tiny bit lower to make the difference in spacing and hence rhythm clearer at 00:39:505 (1,2,3) - prefer current structure of 00:39:835 (2,3,4) - , so i moved 00:39:505 (1) - up a bit
- 00:41:483 (3,4,5) - I can't really see a reason why circle 5 should be spaced out more considering the intensity here is rather leveled out throughout this sequence. Like you even made it spaced evenly at 00:27:636 (4,5,6) - changed
- 00:46:429 (1) - stack this on top of slider head of 00:46:759 (2) - ? spacing at 00:46:429 (1,2,3) - way too similar considering they are different rhythmically. current spacing implies they are all 1/3 spaced apart when it's not good idea
- 00:49:726 (4,5) - ctrl+g the placements? would give emphasis to 00:49:726 (4) - as that's where the drum snares start here has also a flow change at 00:49:396 (3,4) - so i think it works too
- 00:51:210 - imo would be best to map these vocal parts too as you have done so at 00:25:493 (2) - . applies to entire section ok
- 01:02:255 (1,2) - space a bit more here, a bit too less here imo here i like to increase ds just on the strong drum beat. but i also changed shape of 2 and adjusted 01:03:738 (5) - for a more suitable ds
- 01:25:005 (1) - perhaps move this to on top of 01:24:510 (3) - ? having the last non-spinner object at the very corner of the play field makes the transition to the spinner kinda awkward changed pattern and moved 1 down a little bit
good luck!
@Kitty tag and names changed! Thanks for metadata xD
also updated abhor's change