forum

Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix-

posted
Total Posts
107
show more
knifeget
ズドドドドド! ☆ ...
subarasikibuta
ageru~
Hinacle
= =+
rui
omoshiroi :)
Pcell
:lol:
Rigeru_old
:oops:
Topic Starter
Takos
>Reisyth, Suzully, Nech0e, Lunet, S o r d a, swish, Komeiji Yuki, taka1235, _Kiva, knifeget, 3kinnagi, Hinacle, rui, Pcell, Rigeru

Thank you for star~ ><
I wasn't expecting this much of support
PSPDS Eddie
Can I make Hard diff?

and very nice map star~
Topic Starter
Takos

PSPDS Eddie wrote:

Can I make Hard diff?

and very nice map star~
Yes, please make a hard diff~ ;)
and thanks for star
PSPDS Eddie
Mucha_old
:D
Topic Starter
Takos

PSPDS Eddie wrote:

yahooooo
は、はやい...

>Mucha
Thanks for star! :)
taka1235
Norn_NNN
o_o
Topic Starter
Takos

taka1235 wrote:

open the eyes
す、すげぇ...

>Norn_NNN
Thanks for star~
Cyril Scarlet
:oops:
Patchouli
;)
azuki
star for taka
Sure
[General]
- Change artist name format to 'Itou Kanako'. Eastern format (Surname - Firstname) is better than western format for eastern artist if there is not any speacial reason. Also I confirmed it as 'Itou Kanako' in official website. http://steinsgate.jp/goods_01.html
- Add names into tags who gave guest diff. And make same tags in every diff.


[taka]
OD+1
00:20:257 (1) - According to your previous new comboing pattern, removing new combo looks better.
01:15:227 (5) - Unfortunately, this is unrankable technique that setting un-inherited section for change slider speed. You have to remove those two offsets.
01:10:377 (1) - Remove new combo
01:22:398 (5) - Try this position x:480, y:160
02:15:213 (1) - Remove new combo to be consistent with 02:16:650 (3)


[Insane]
00:08:760 (6) - Stack under 00:08:401 (5) to avoid spacing error. That spacing fits at music well, but it is an error in a same combo group. Stacking is also good in my opinion. However adding new combo may look weird.
00:24:209 (2) - Add clap to end of slider
00:27:443 (6) - Add clap
00:28:700 (2) - Add clap to return arrow
01:49:359 (1,2,1) - Would you expand the spacing? This anti-jump doesn't fit IMO. I saw accelerated spacing at next part, but this spacing is too small.


[PSPDS's Hard]
01:00:856 (1) - Remove new combo to be consistent with 00:49:359 (7)
02:06:964 (1) - ^
That's all!


[Normal]
00:38:221 (1,2) - (nazi) one grid down
00:40:736 (1,2) - Try to make them symmetry. Spacing will not so confuse. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/120470
00:43:610 (1,2) - This overlapping looks a bit messy. Try to use spacing 1.0x http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/120475
01:13:790 (1) - Extend to 01:17:383
01:27:622 (3) - Spacing


Good luck~ ☆ლ( ╹ ◡ ╹ ლ)
taka1235
PSPDS Eddie
Fixed~

I mended neither Tag nor Artist.
I think that tag and Artist should be made the same.
I ask that my difficulty mend Tag/Artist to Takos to make Artist and Tag the same.


Download: Kanako Itou - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [PSPDS's Hard].osu
Topic Starter
Takos

ykcarrot wrote:

[General]
- Change artist name format to 'Itou Kanako'. Eastern format (Surname - Firstname) is better than western format for eastern artist if there is not any speacial reason. Also I confirmed it as 'Itou Kanako' in official website. http://steinsgate.jp/goods_01.html ok changed
- Add names into tags who gave guest diff. And make same tags in every diff. fixed, added PSPDS Eddie and taka1235 for every diff

[Insane]
00:08:760 (6) - Stack under 00:08:401 (5) to avoid spacing error. That spacing fits at music well, but it is an error in a same combo group. Stacking is also good in my opinion. However adding new combo may look weird. stacked
00:24:209 (2) - Add clap to end of slider added
00:27:443 (6) - Add clap ^
00:28:700 (2) - Add clap to return arrow ^
01:49:359 (1,2,1) - Would you expand the spacing? This anti-jump doesn't fit IMO. I saw accelerated spacing at next part, but this spacing is too small. hmm... tried 1.0x spacing, hope it looks alright

[Normal]
00:38:221 (1,2) - (nazi) one grid down fixed
00:40:736 (1,2) - Try to make them symmetry. Spacing will not so confuse. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/120470 fixed
00:43:610 (1,2) - This overlapping looks a bit messy. Try to use spacing 1.0x http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/120475 ok, this looks better
01:13:790 (1) - Extend to 01:17:383 oops, didn't realize that
01:27:622 (3) - Spacing omg why did i do this... fixed

Good luck~ ☆ლ( ╹ ◡ ╹ ლ)
Thank you for a helpful mod yk~ >w</


taka1235 wrote:

FIXED

PSPDS Eddie wrote:

Fixed~

I mended neither Tag nor Artist.
I think that tag and Artist should be made the same.
I ask that my difficulty mend Tag/Artist to Takos to make Artist and Tag the same.
>taka1235, PSPDS Eddie
Updated the map, artist, and tags.
Please re-DL when you fix anything next time.
Thank you! :)

>S i R i R u, Patchouli, azuki
Thanks for star~
wmfchris
[General]
- yeah just fix the artist name
- add the guest mappers to the tags in all diff.
- perharps a more balanced difficulty spread is needed. The current situation is N - light insane - insane - insane, and there's quite a big gap between N and I.
- It's suggested that every diff ends at the same time...

[taka]
- Changing SV by inheriting red timing line is prohibited.
- More than 3 SV used :/
00:28:520 (4) - left 1 grid so that the spacing is somehow like 1.3x - 1.0 x
00:45:227 (1) - shift the last slider point left 1 gird to (368,256) such that the distance of the ends of (1,1,1,1) become more regular :3
01:20:422 (5) - whistle here?
01:21:321 (1) - ^
01:22:219 (4,5,6) - quite obvious spacing problem
01:28:866 (7) - + finish?
01:51:321 (1) - similar to 00:45:227

[Insane]
01:08:580 (2) - I prefer removing the whistle here since there's no vocal.
01:10:916 (1) - up 1 grid to make it symmetrical
nice!

[Hard]
00:10:377 (2) - sounds odd.
00:22:053 (6) - right 1 grid lv4

[Normal]
00:18:281 (1,2,3,4,5) - the y-value of the notes: 335, 336, 336, 340, 340 lol plx arrange them in stright line
00:25:287 (3) - right 1 grid lv4
00:38:580 (2) - down several grids if you wish, so down 1 grid as yk said
00:55:107 (3,4,1) - down 1 grid lv4

It seems that the usage of claps in hard is minimized but it still sounds good, nice mapset~ :3

P.S. I'm sorry that the mod refers to the old version (i.e. before ykcarrot mod), so if the mod is different to your current arrangement just skip it.
Topic Starter
Takos

wmfchris wrote:

[General]
- yeah just fix the artist name fixed
- add the guest mappers to the tags in all diff. ^
- perharps a more balanced difficulty spread is needed. The current situation is N - light insane - insane - insane, and there's quite a big gap between N and I. D: hmm what should i do... perhaps make an easy and make normal harder?
- It's suggested that every diff ends at the same time... i'll let taka choose that

[Insane]
01:08:580 (2) - I prefer removing the whistle here since there's no vocal. removed!
01:10:916 (1) - up 1 grid to make it symmetrical fixed
nice! thank you! XD

[Normal]
00:18:281 (1,2,3,4,5) - the y-value of the notes: 335, 336, 336, 340, 340 lol plx arrange them in stright line didn't realize that because of my small screen ;w;
00:25:287 (3) - right 1 grid lv4 ok
00:38:580 (2) - down several grids if you wish, so down 1 grid as yk said already fixed
00:55:107 (3,4,1) - down 1 grid lv4 ok

P.S. I'm sorry that the mod refers to the old version (i.e. before ykcarrot mod), so if the mod is different to your current arrangement just skip it. no problem
Thanks for mod and star wmf~
PSPDS Eddie
00:10:377 (2) - erased it
00:22:053 (6) - Fix

Fixed~

Download: Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [PSPDS's Hard].osu
Topic Starter
Takos

PSPDS Eddie wrote:

00:10:377 (2) - erased it
00:22:053 (6) - Fix

Fixed~
updated~ XD
DeadAlready
star >~</

SPOILER
ah there are unsnapped notes in taka's diff...:O
Suzully
[General]
  1. 1個目のKIAI TIMEの終わりは01:17:383の方が良いと思います。
[Normal]
  1. 00:08:401 (3,4) - whistle?
  2. 00:11:275 (3,4) - ^
  3. 00:38:940 (3) - ここで1grid上がっているのがちょっとだけ気になりました。1grid下げるか、(2,3)で徐々に上げるかの方が良いと思います。
  4. 00:47:922 (1) - finish
  5. 01:46:844 (1) - こちらにもwhistle
  6. 01:48:281 (2) - 全体のwhistle音だけじゃなくて始端にもつけた方が良い感じです。
  7. 01:54:029 (1) - finish
  8. 02:09:119 (2,3,4) - ちょっと難しいリズムかもしれません。
[PSPDS's Hard]

  • 言う事なしです!
    clapが無くてちょっと音が寂しいかも・・・?
[Insane]
  1. 00:41:275 (4,5,6,7,8) - ボーカルをなぞるならこんな感じ。
  2. 00:47:203 (2) - SV×0.75で3回折り返しのスライダーにしてみてはどうでしょうか。
  3. 00:54:928 (5,8) - new comboを入れたほうがメリハリがつくかも。
  4. 00:57:443 (5,6,7,8,9) - なめらかに置いてみてはどうでしょう。
  5. 01:06:065 (1) - clap
  6. 01:27:622 (1) - clap?最初のAメロで入っていたので。個人的にはclapよりも01:26:724 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3)の音量を上げた方が好みです(・ω・)
  7. 01:35:257 (2) - 1grid右。
  8. 01:53:311 (2) - 前のと同様に。
[taka]
  1. 00:34:898 (4,5) - 消してしまった方がインパクトがあるかもです(主観ですが)。
  2. 00:45:227 (1) - 終端を1grid右?
  3. 01:15:227 (5) - スライダーの開始は01:15:047の方が合っている感じがします。
  4. 01:18:087 (1) - これ以降のノートがスナップされていないです。
  5. 01:38:027 (1) - clap?
  6. 01:40:287 (x) - ノート追加?
  7. 01:51:321 (1) - 終端を1grid左?
    最後 lol
ないすまっぷっぷ(((・ω・)))
たこすさんの譜面は見るごとに成長しててびっくりです :)
PSPDS Eddie

Suzully wrote:

[General]
  1. 1個目のKIAI TIMEの終わりは01:17:383の方が良いと思います。
Fixed

[PSPDS's Hard]

  • 言う事なしです!
    clapが無くてちょっと音が寂しいかも・・・?

Clapの使い方が上手くない(五月蝿くしてしまう)ので自重してます。
ですがほんの少し追加してみました。
Download: Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [PSPDS's Hard].osu
Topic Starter
Takos

Suzully wrote:

[General]
  1. 1個目のKIAI TIMEの終わりは01:17:383の方が良いと思います。
[Normal]
  1. 00:08:401 (3,4) - whistle? 追加しました
  2. 00:11:275 (3,4) - ^ ^
  3. 00:38:940 (3) - ここで1grid上がっているのがちょっとだけ気になりました。1grid下げるか、(2,3)で徐々に上げるかの方が良いと思います。1grid下げて横に並べました
  4. 00:47:922 (1) - finish 追加しました
  5. 01:46:844 (1) - こちらにもwhistle ^
  6. 01:48:281 (2) - 全体のwhistle音だけじゃなくて始端にもつけた方が良い感じです。^
  7. 01:54:029 (1) - finish ^
  8. 02:09:119 (2,3,4) - ちょっと難しいリズムかもしれません。スライダー2つにしてリズムを簡単にしました
[Insane]
  1. 00:41:275 (4,5,6,7,8) - ボーカルをなぞるならこんな感じ。いい方法が思いつかなかったので変えませんでした
  2. 00:47:203 (2) - SV×0.75で3回折り返しのスライダーにしてみてはどうでしょうか。ナイスアイデア!
  3. 00:54:928 (5,8) - new comboを入れたほうがメリハリがつくかも。NC入れました
  4. 00:57:443 (5,6,7,8,9) - なめらかに置いてみてはどうでしょう。なめらかにしました。ぬるーん
  5. 01:06:065 (1) - clap 追加しました
  6. 01:27:622 (1) - clap?最初のAメロで入っていたので。個人的にはclapよりも01:26:724 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3)の音量を上げた方が好みです(・ω・) Aメロに入ってたclapを消してこちらは変えませんでした。音量は5%上げました。
  7. 01:35:257 (2) - 1grid右。修正しました
  8. 01:53:311 (2) - 前のと同様に。変えました
ないすまっぷっぷ(((・ω・)))
たこすさんの譜面は見るごとに成長しててびっくりです :)
Thank you for mod Suzully~ >.<

>Eddieさん
updated
taka1235

Suzully wrote:

[General]


  • [taka]
  1. 00:45:227 (1) - 終端を1grid右?fix
  2. 01:38:027 (1) - clap? fix
  3. 01:51:321 (1) - 終端を1grid左?fix
    最後 lol


MODありです~。
Download: Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [taka].osu
Topic Starter
Takos
lol doublepost... TAT
Your message is too short. Please do not post messages like "star", and make sure you are constructively adding to the thread in question.
Topic Starter
Takos

taka1235 wrote:

Suzully wrote:

[General]


  • [taka]
  1. 00:45:227 (1) - 終端を1grid右?fix
  2. 01:38:027 (1) - clap? fix
  3. 01:51:321 (1) - 終端を1grid左?fix
    最後 lol


MODありです~。
updated~
-Moccha_chii-
Good luck :D
I like this song
and this is from itou kanako <3 <3
kanpakyin
As per your request:

Mostly are suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree

[General]
  1. Would you unify the Stack Leniency?It' not necessary I know but you better to do it.
  2. I would prefer Offset:487 (-10) That seem better for me.Please check the mod before you consider this one!
[Normal]
  1. 00:16:125 (x) - How about follow the music vocal?Just add a note here.
  2. 00:20:616 (1) - Probably add a clap and finish here?Clap is for fitting the music and finish is for the accent point,well,change or not are depend on you.
  3. 00:44:688 (2) - Tiny spacing problem,please fix it!Remember,don't make any kind of jump in Normal and all should follow the distance snap Since this diff is the lower difficulty in this mapset!
  4. 00:58:520 - I highly recommend you add a note here because you're follow the music at 00:58:700 (3) - so I think you should add a note at 00:58:520 - to fit the music perfectly!
  5. 01:46:844 (1,2) - Orz...Would you make it more beautiful?It is a little bit ugly now.
  6. 01:54:029 (1) - For consistent the rhythm of (2.3)- please make this slider to 1/1 and add a reverse.Than add a note at 01:55:107 - .Thats hounds better for me!
  7. 02:09:838 (3) - Oh,no!Please fix the spacing :/ Jump in "Normal" doesn't fair to newbie,so please don't do that!
  8. 02:14:149 (x) - I suggest you stop this spinner at 02:16:305 - then newbie can use more time to catch the next slider and it won't be really weird.
[PSPDS's Hard]
  1. 00:20:616 (1,2,3,4) - I suggest you increase the spacing of them because here has 4 accent point and it is really appropriate for jump :3 and it can make more fun during gameplay!(But the spacing don't be too large ><)
  2. 01:10:197 (1) - Please!Remove this slider D: I can't found any reason that it need to add any note/slider here,if you really want,just add a note at 01:10:556 (1) - with a finish!
  3. 01:17:383 (x) - How about change this green line to soft-5%?It will works better imo.
  4. 01:50:257 (1) - In this case/arrangement,you don't need to add a new combo here because player can read it clarity!Remove the new combo please!
  5. 02:24:119 (x) -Please remove this unnecessary green line!
[Insane]
  1. 00:22:862 (x) - Listen to Playback Rate:25% you can hear you miss a note here \:D/ Add it if possible!btw,this stream is little bit ugly imo,can you make it more beautiful?
    ^For this one!
    424,104,22053,5,0
    406,122,22143,1,0
    384,135,22233,1,0
    359,142,22323,1,0
    334,147,22413,1,0
    307,142,22502,1,0
    283,133,22592,1,0
    259,123,22682,1,0
    241,102,22772,1,0
  2. 00:32:113 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - IMO,these 1/4 doesn't fit the music very well,I think some of the 1/2 here is good enough!No need to stuff such a huge 1/4.
  3. 00:42:173 (8) - A slider doesn't show a good effect during gameplay!If I were you,I would add a note at 00:42:173 - instead of a slider then use a Spinner at 00:42:263 - and end at 00:42:892 -
  4. 00:45:227 (6) - Probably Vertically with (4)- ?
  5. 01:12:353 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Be honest,I don't love this pattern very much >~< only for me!So let you decide to change it or not!
  6. 01:17:293 - Please remove this unnecessary green line!
  7. 01:28:970 (x) - Same as 00:22:862 -,you need to add a note here.
  8. 01:51:874 (1,2,3,4) - This jump are totally broken the flow,previous jump are ok,only this jump are really awkward for me!
  9. 02:24:209 (x) - How about change this green line to soft-5%?It will works better imo.
[taka]
  1. I love this diff!!!!!!
  2. 00:22:862 (x) - Same as Insane diff,you need to add a note here to follow the music,however consider the jump pattern at 00:22:952 (1,2,3) - so just let you decide how to do it :/
  3. 00:32:113 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - Oh no!This is a ridiculous stack,Due to the Stack Leniency it's really ugly during gameplay.
  4. 01:15:227 (5) - oh!I think the shape of this slider is a little bit weird!I recommend you use a spinner instead of it.I'm sure here has macron so I guess a spinner is more appropriate.
  5. 01:23:836 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - Wow this,I know you make this on purpose,however this part is really calm,so too many 1/4 isn't that good here.
  6. 01:41:455 (x) - This break is really weird because the vocal is still singing here,so I prefer you map this.(Also thought about insane diff so you don't need a break for a short song \:D/.2:30 is count as a short song imo.)
  7. 02:24:209 - How about change this green line to soft-5%?It sounds better for me.
That's it!
PSPDS Eddie
SPOILER

kanpakyin wrote:

As per your request:

Mostly are suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree

[General]
  1. Would you unify the Stack Leniency?It' not necessary I know but you better to do it.
  2. I would prefer Offset:487 (-10) That seem better for me.Please check the mod before you consider this one!
[PSPDS's Hard]
  1. 00:20:616 (1,2,3,4) - I suggest you increase the spacing of them because here has 4 accent point and it is really appropriate for jump :3 and it can make more fun during gameplay!(But the spacing don't be too large ><) DS1.4→1.6
  2. 01:10:197 (1) - Please!Remove this slider D: I can't found any reason that it need to add any note/slider here,if you really want,just add a note at 01:10:556 (1) - with a finish!
    fm...Spin was extended, and the slider was erased.
    Treatment as which 02:16:305 is the same is executed.
  3. 01:17:383 (x) - How about change this green line to soft-5%?It will works better imo. Fix
  4. 01:50:257 (1) - In this case/arrangement,you don't need to add a new combo here because player can read it clarity!Remove the new combo please! Fix
  5. 02:24:119 (x) -Please remove this unnecessary green line!
Fix

The correction such as stack andoffset is waiting for the judgment of Takos, it leaves it.
ask takos for the offset correction.


Download: Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [PSPDS's Hard].osu
Topic Starter
Takos
kpy's modding and my reply

kanpakyin wrote:

Mostly are suggestion only,you can ignore them if you disagree

[General]
  1. Would you unify the Stack Leniency?It' not necessary I know but you better to do it. i don't have much preferences for stacking... taka-san might need to change the stack leniency because he stacks so much in some parts. for eddie's diff, i will change it if there is no special reason for it
  2. I would prefer Offset:487 (-10) That seem better for me.Please check the mod before you consider this one! i cant check offset atm, i need somebody to check if this is better
[Normal]
  1. 00:16:125 (x) - How about follow the music vocal?Just add a note here. nah, i think it's too complicated for the easiest diff
  2. 00:20:616 (1) - Probably add a clap and finish here?Clap is for fitting the music and finish is for the accent point,well,change or not are depend on you. added finish
  3. 00:44:688 (2) - Tiny spacing problem,please fix it!Remember,don't make any kind of jump in Normal and all should follow the distance snap Since this diff is the lower difficulty in this mapset! hmm, fixed
  4. 00:58:520 - I highly recommend you add a note here because you're follow the music at 00:58:700 (3) - so I think you should add a note at 00:58:520 - to fit the music perfectly! moved the reverse slider to that position
  5. 01:46:844 (1,2) - Orz...Would you make it more beautiful?It is a little bit ugly now. idk, is it better now? :/
  6. 01:54:029 (1) - For consistent the rhythm of (2.3)- please make this slider to 1/1 and add a reverse.Than add a note at 01:55:107 - .Thats hounds better for me ! ok!
  7. 02:09:838 (3) - Oh,no!Please fix the spacing :/ Jump in "Normal" doesn't fair to newbie,so please don't do that! didn't realize that jump , foolish me XP
  8. 02:14:149 (x) - I suggest you stop this spinner at 02:16:305 - then newbie can use more time to catch the next slider and it won't be really weird. fixed
[Insane]
  1. 00:22:862 (x) - Listen to Playback Rate:25% you can hear you miss a note here \:D/ Add it if possible!btw,this stream is little bit ugly imo,can you make it more beautiful? added, and used parts of your code
  2. 00:32:113 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - IMO,these 1/4 doesn't fit the music very well,I think some of the 1/2 here is good enough!No need to stuff such a huge 1/4. these 1/4 are supposed to fit the synthesizers in the background. taka is doing that too. but i added a volume change here so it fits better.
  3. 00:42:173 (8) - A slider doesn't show a good effect during gameplay!If I were you,I would add a note at 00:42:173 - instead of a slider then use a Spinner at 00:42:263 - and end at 00:42:892 - i dont want to add a spinner here, so just added a few sliders
  4. 00:45:227 (6) - Probably Vertically with (4)- ? no change
  5. 01:12:353 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Be honest,I don't love this pattern very much >~< only for me!So let you decide to change it or not! changed to a diamond
  6. 01:17:293 - Please remove this unnecessary green line! ok
  7. 01:28:970 (x) - Same as 00:22:862 -,you need to add a note here. fixed
  8. 01:51:874 (1,2,3,4) - This jump are totally broken the flow,previous jump are ok,only this jump are really awkward for me! changed to triangle
  9. 02:24:209 (x) - How about change this green line to soft-5%?It will works better imo. ok
That's it!
Mostly fixed.
Offset and stack leniency will be considered with taka-san and eddie-san
Thanks for a detailed and helful mod kpy! XD

>taka-san, Eddie-san
updated~
特別な理由がなければstack leniencyを7に統一しますがよろしいでしょうか?
waiting for taka's reply~ :D
PSPDS Eddie

Takos wrote:

>taka-san, Eddie-san
updated~
特別な理由がなければstack leniencyを7に統一しますがよろしいでしょうか?
waiting for taka's reply~ :D[/color]
OKです
akrolsmir
General:
00:20:616- Kiai here to 00:23:850? I definitely expected one after the sudden volume increase.
01:26:724- ^, to 01:29:958

Normal:
00:11:275 (3,4,1) - Lower, so it flows better from (2)? The transition from curve to straight feels jarring.
00:34:449 (4) - Adjust and rotate so (1,2,3,4) forms a nice square?
00:58:520 (3) - Always try and avoid short sliders that repeat more than once on easier diffs
01:10:916 (1,3) - Have these spiral out or something, so it looks cooler? Eg
01:58:161 (4) - Maybe make this repeat at 01:58:520? It just sounds like there should be a beat or sth there. Alternatively, consider moving everything to white ticks instead of red.
02:05:526 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Here's a good opportunity to add some kind of pattern
02:11:275 (1,2,3,4) - Adjust so the paths aren't touching? Or so that they're all overlapping by the same amount.
02:17:023 (1,2) - Again, try a spiral or some other pattern besides just a line.

This diff seems to switch a lot between curves and straight patterns, which can be disorienting.

PSPDS's Hard:
00:38:401 (2,3) - Space out more, to feel consistent with the distance spacing.
00:41:275 (2) - Not symmetric
01:33:730 (4,5,6) - Even out the spacing (it's noticeable since it's meant to be a mirror image). Consider making 4 just a copy of 6 or vice versa.
01:44:329 (1,2,3) - Space out more.

Insane:
00:04:988 (4,5,6,7,8) - Just go ahead and make this into a pentagon/star
01:31:035 (4) - The angle is too shallow in comparison with the sliders right before it, accentuate the curve
01:49:718 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - I'm not a big fan of patterns stacking like this because in can be confusing/hard to read/boring
02:17:922 (5) - Hiding a repeat sign under the hit from (2) is highly discouraged since it's hard to tell that it is a repeating slider. Repeat the other way?

taka:
These next two are from AIBat:
Remove the kiai time at 00:34:449, or place kiai times at similar places in all the other areas for consistency's sake.
There are lots and lots of unsnapped notes.

00:32:113 (1) - (and on)... wtf spammy. At least try stacking it in an interesting shape?
01:15:227 (5) - Interesting. Is it supposed to imitate something?
01:23:836 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1) - I'm not entirely sure this shape is better since it's a little hard to read, spread it out a bit?

Overall, my favorite diff was PSPDS's Hard- it felt the most coherent out of all of the maps. The others were very interesting in certain places but I didn't really feel a flow going. Still, nice song and good work, starred.
PSPDS Eddie

akrolsmir wrote:

General:
00:20:616- Kiai here to 00:23:850? I definitely expected one after the sudden volume increase.
01:26:724- ^, to 01:29:958


PSPDS's Hard:
00:38:401 (2,3) - Space out more, to feel consistent with the distance spacing. meybe fix
00:41:275 (2) - Not symmetric meybe fix
01:33:730 (4,5,6) - Even out the spacing (it's noticeable since it's meant to be a mirror image). Consider making 4 just a copy of 6 or vice versa.
Fixed
01:44:329 (1,2,3) - Space out more. meybe fix
Thank you for mod.

The correction such as kiai is waiting for the judgment of Takos, it leaves it.
ask takos for the kiai time correction.


Download: Itou Kanako - Skyclad no Kansokusha -Remix- (Takos) [PSPDS's Hard].osu
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply