Sinnoh wrote:

How to rank CtB in 2017 101
1. Have a taiko diff
2. Rank taiko and hope no one notices ctb

We irc'd, will post log later because on mobile.
Also, can't name exactly, but iirc there was a point where your note density was higher than monstratas set in the second half, maybe near end. The Hitsound that's used in it is really loud and annoying to listen to because of that. Monstrata's was fine because less density and less of that Hitsound. Just lower volume of it.

Xinely wrote:

03:13:933 (4) - overmap af if you even say it isnt overmap.. inaudible volume isnt approciate (if you say monstrata's map, its ok because slider's end in std but circle isnt allowed for both modes) terrible reason for a bubble pop but ok i fixed it. Not overmap though so I'm keeping the circle
03:50:652 (1,2) - are weird when you follow drums at 03:45:964 (2,3) - and suddenly you skip drums for them. same for 03:56:277 (1,2,3) - 03:58:152 (1,2) - etc because too many it's my style

what is your concern about slidertick 3? it doesnt make sense when you use 3 (much of sliderticks) and you silent them all because it's in 1/6 and sometimes there are sounds that are ignored for sliders and sometimes things are not silenced so I'll keep it thanks

popping for hitsound volume

feel free to ask ozzy for rebubble after its fixed

1. 00:59:870 (4) - Inaudible hitsound blabla, increase the volume pls
2. 01:10:652 (2,3) - Pretty sure I mentioned this in my first mod but you don't make dashes in between the similar sliders at 01:25:339 (1,2,3) - , so you shouldn't do it here unless there's a special reason.
3. 01:33:464 (3) - Here as well, with the same reason like above I would remove the dash.
4. 03:13:933 (4) - I know xinely did mention this, but if you crank up the music volume and mute the hitsound volume(or even slow down the playback), you really can't hear anything landing on this tick exactly, except all the prolonged sound from the previous ticks. Care to explain what exactly you are following?
5. 03:46:902 (3) - Feels better after the curve but most of the time when I succeeded in catching all objects, I had to catch the fruits on the very edge of the platter. Would curve a little more to stay on the safe side.
6. 04:26:902 (3,4) - Distance here feels more like a dash than a walking one, try to reduce down the distance so that a dash is clearly not required.

Sc4v4ng3r wrote:

To add on to ascendance's reply, when comparing the sounds of 03:50:652 (1,2) - these and 03:45:027 (1,2,3) - , they all contain the similar sounds(ignore the drums, just try to hear the prominent sound instead) - while they aren't exactly the same, the sound from 03:45:027 (1,2,3) - is prolonged during 03:50:652 (1,2) - , so instead he mapped it to the other sound(not drums, it's a similar sound to those at 04:15:027 (1,2,3) - ) so that undermapping is avoided.

For those who are still having doubts on the slider tick rate being 3, the slider ticks are unsilenced during 04:15:027 - until 04:30:027 - because there are 1/6 kicks throughout the whole section that he is following.

For the timing I'll ask some people around later when they are online to double check. I checked with Yuii- who nominated Monstrata's set of the same song and also had a look at the BPM on that set. If you take a look at the logs, there's a conversation near the beginning about simplifying the BPM to keep it consistent throughout rather than make the metronome resets for the sake of halving BPM.

On to the actual modding :

[Farewell]

1. 00:59:870 (4) - Inaudible hitsound blabla, increase the volume pls Sure
2. 01:10:652 (2,3) - Pretty sure I mentioned this in my first mod but you don't make dashes in between the similar sliders at 01:25:339 (1,2,3) - , so you shouldn't do it here unless there's a special reason. I think I said it before, but this whole section is meant to be small tapdashes rather than walks (although it is possible to platewalk almost everything). That being said though, I did adjust some distances to make them more consistent throughout.
3. 01:33:464 (3) - Here as well, with the same reason like above I would remove the dash. Adjusted.
4. 03:13:933 (4) - I know xinely did mention this, but if you crank up the music volume and mute the hitsound volume(or even slow down the playback), you really can't hear anything landing on this tick exactly, except all the prolonged sound from the previous ticks. Care to explain what exactly you are following? The short response is: technically nothing. However, I used this technique in Asymmetry in which I created "artificial sounds" with hitsounding in order to strengthen the emphasis between two sounds, for example, emphasizing heavily on 03:14:089 (1) - which is an extremely strong sound. I felt like having a 1/3 dash would be much less powerful than a 1/6, so I've used the hitsound for artificial emphasis. If it really must be removed, I have no issue with it, but I really like how this works, and I've done it before to great success.
5. 03:46:902 (3) - Feels better after the curve but most of the time when I succeeded in catching all objects, I had to catch the fruits on the very edge of the platter. Would curve a little more to stay on the safe side. Should be much better now.
6. 04:26:902 (3,4) - Distance here feels more like a dash than a walking one, try to reduce down the distance so that a dash is clearly not required. As said previously, these calm sections are meant to be tapdashable, but I've reduced the distance a bit to make it clear that it can be walked possibly as well.

Otherwise a cool map. Call me back.

Sc4v4ng3r wrote:

Ohhhhh ok sorry Mike, had to pop this for timing issues after discussing with JBH.
There's a new rule related to this issue :


So right now the BPM at 01:45:027 - should be halved down to 64 as those piano downbeats are landing half the speed until 02:45:026 - , where it should be 128 again. The 1/12 stream at 02:27:058 - can have double BPM from 64 only on the stream so that the stream is mappable with 1/12, just like the rule dictates.

Other reason for pop include shitty/no replies to suggestions(i.e. to sinnoh's and nely's mod - one you haven't properly replied and one you kinda made a shitty reply even though I covered for you) and failure to come to consensus with nely for the pop, and yea the last one's on me, so you can blame me as well.

Once you fix the timing points and make proper replies to both sinnoh's and nely's mod I will come back and re-check again to avoid this from happening again. Sorry once more ;w;

Sinnoh wrote:

01:45:027 (5) - No reason not to have a 64bpm timing point here. Matches the song far better. If you look at the pulsing osu icon in the bottom right at song select, it doesn't match up at all.
Change it back to 128 at 03:15:027 (1) - and back to 64 at 04:45:027 (1) -
Double the SV multipliers at the low bpm parts to quick fix
two posts bc first one didn't have computer to actually check anything

not changing timing see above, thanks for taking a look though

2017-03-18 02:01 Xinely: pls reply the mod based on CoC with telling reason instead of saying style
2017-03-18 02:02 Ascendance: sc4 answered it quite well
2017-03-18 02:02 Ascendance: it's pretty clear what sounds I'm following there
2017-03-18 02:02 Ascendance: no need to randomly pop again
2017-03-18 02:04 Ascendance: is that good enough for you or are you going to pop again
2017-03-18 02:04 Xinely: oh well. lazy.. i can let it go
2017-03-18 02:04 Xinely: not really tho but lazy to debate as usual
2017-03-18 02:05 Ascendance: there's nothing wrong with that though
2017-03-18 02:05 Xinely: anyway i popped because qat said it was worth due hitsound so i did
2017-03-18 02:05 Xinely: not really wrong but weird ><

If objects cannot be snapped using the editor's supported beat snap divisor, a change in BPM must be used to accommodate it. Objects cannot be unsnapped.

1. We changed the 1/8 monocolor streams to 1/6 on Chromoxx's diff (Hi Raiden)
2. HP +1 on CtB since I forgot to do that with Sc4
3. Adjusted an edge dash I found while testplaying

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

This is it! This is really the end. Through my career as a mapper, I've met a lot of people, done a lot of things, made a lot of mistakes. But I don't think I'd take back that experience for anything in the world. As much as I say I hate this game, it's been a home for me. A shelter from a life that was hard to live. An escape from reality. I think now though, it's about time I move away from running away from everything and enter the real world like I should have done long ago.

Whether you know me as the guy that got kicked from the BNG for bullying people, the guy that speedranks his stuff with some random taiko BN, or even as a terrible 3 digit player that can't play converts and only plays nomod - I hope that I can leave you in a way that allows you to remember me as something I've tried for the past year to become. A mapper.

Thank you for all the great times <3

alacat wrote:

hi hi!
Please don't forget to fix the title "Goodbye To A World" before getting Approved.
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/5830198

Good luck :3

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

She out!

Approved <3

- Magic Bomb - wrote:

[cya nerd]

xEchoAlertx wrote:

Apostraphes still come after x's, btw. Should be "Chromoxx's Divergence," not "Chromoxx' Divergence."

Further reading: https://owl.english.purdue.edu/owl/resource/621/01/

There are other qualified maps currently making the same mistake.

xEchoAlertx wrote:

Apostraphes still come after x's, btw. Should be "Chromoxx's Divergence," not "Chromoxx' Divergence." done to keep consistency with past diff names

Chromoxx wrote:

Words that end with a sound like "s" or "z" can be 's or just '.... since the x is pronounced like "ks" this is perfectly fine...

Chromoxx wrote:

just think of it this way: the diff name is in german

http://german.stackexchange.com/questio ... iv-s-bei-längeren-namen