forum

Orangestar - Kimi no Yozora Shoukaihan

posted
Total Posts
109
show more
Seolv
normal

00:31:771 (1) - this spinner has short recovery time (time between the end of the spinner and the next circle/slider)
01:03:717 (2,3) - intentional overlap? ugly imo
01:07:609 (5,1) - make this same as 01:06:312 (2,3,4) - for consistency cause it's the same sound
01:30:961 (5) - The arrow on this slider is ignoring the vocals which you've been emphasizing this whole diff, so you should add a circle on 01:31:123 - and a 1/2 slider on 01:31:285 -
01:39:069 (6) - remove this circle
01:44:420 (1,2,3,4) - This rhythm isn't very good since idk what you're emphasizing with it. Try this https://gyazo.com/96e5275723bc19f7a850ff2562db854e
02:16:042 (2) - Make this a 1/2 slider to match the vocal
02:17:339 (5) - Same
02:51:880 (6) - Just a suggestion, here you can use a big slider from 02:51:880 - to 02:52:690 - to emphasize the held guitar sound, I just thought it would be cool.
Fu Xuan


From discord uwu/
newton is too fafa yamete

[nextplay]
  1. Since newton asked for aesthetics mod uwu
  2. 00:02:096 (3) - 00:04:690 (3) - You should make your sliders consistent, They were off by like some pixels. g
  3. 00:05:988 (1) - This slider is rotated in an awkward angle imo
  4. 00:08:582 (1,2,3) - Try a positioning like this, to make it organized
  5. 00:11:177 (1,2,3) - Same point above tbh,
  6. 00:19:934 (3,4,1) - Make this a triangle pls :^^^
  7. 00:26:744 (1) - This one is straight, 00:27:393 (2) - while this is rotated to a certain degree, would be better to copy paste tbh uwu
  8. 00:28:042 (3,4,5,1) - u can blanket these
  9. 00:35:826 (3,4,1) - Make a triangle :^
  10. 01:31:285 (4) - 01:32:907 (3) -
  11. 01:34:204 (1,2) - If you blanket this and follow point #4, this would look aesthetically clean af
  12. 01:39:069 (4) - 01:36:798 (1) - ew overlap xd
  13. 01:38:096 (3,4) - Blanket xd
  14. 01:48:474 (3,4) - b
  15. 01:52:366 (1,2,3) - Point 4
  16. 02:12:961 (1,2) - b
  17. 02:49:447 (1) - This isn't a wave slider :thonk:
  18. needs more 2/1, also hitsounds pls

Call me back once everything is fixed!11!1
u can give me kudosu since this is remapped :^
nextplay

-Aqua wrote:



From discord uwu/
newton is too fafa yamete

[nextplay]
  1. Since newton asked for aesthetics mod uwu
  2. 00:02:096 (3) - 00:04:690 (3) - You should make your sliders consistent, They were off by like some pixels. g
  3. 00:05:988 (1) - This slider is rotated in an awkward angle imo
  4. 00:08:582 (1,2,3) - Try a positioning like this, to make it organized
  5. 00:11:177 (1,2,3) - Same point above tbh,
  6. 00:19:934 (3,4,1) - Make this a triangle pls :^^^
  7. 00:26:744 (1) - This one is straight, 00:27:393 (2) - while this is rotated to a certain degree, would be better to copy paste tbh uwu
  8. 00:28:042 (3,4,5,1) - u can blanket these
  9. 00:35:826 (3,4,1) - Make a triangle :^
  10. 01:31:285 (4) - 01:32:907 (3) -
  11. 01:34:204 (1,2) - If you blanket this and follow point #4, this would look aesthetically clean af
  12. 01:39:069 (4) - 01:36:798 (1) - ew overlap xd
  13. 01:38:096 (3,4) - Blanket xd
  14. 01:48:474 (3,4) - b
  15. 01:52:366 (1,2,3) - Point 4
  16. 02:12:961 (1,2) - b
  17. 02:49:447 (1) - This isn't a wave slider :thonk:
  18. needs more 2/1, also hitsounds pls

Call me back once everything is fixed!11!1
u can give me kudosu since this is remapped :^)
Fixed almost everything thanks for Mod!
nextplay
xd
Monstrata
Kanan's Easy

00:12:474 (4,5) - Inconsistent spacing
00:31:934 (1,1) - I don't think this is sufficient recovery time for an Easy. Typically you want about 1 full measure of recovery on an Easy. End it on the downbeat like you do for 02:07:934 (1) - .
00:55:285 (1) - Maybe end the spinner on 00:59:015 - for the syncopated downbeat. (red tick is more important than white when concerning the main melody imo)
02:31:285 (1) - Same, I would have ended it on 02:35:015 - instead, it sounds like a better note to end on

Normal

00:25:285 (3,4) - I would extend this into a 3/2 slider. Don't use so many clicks yet, this is a calm section so use longer sliders and sparser rhythm.
01:57:555 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5) - Same idea, use simpler rhythm to distinguish the section from the previous and later section.

[]

Okay that's all. Call me back when you've replied!
Monstrata
Actually, your combo colors 5 and 6 are really similar. They are hardly distinguishable imo. Please use a different contrast, or make it like Light blue > Dark blue > Light blue > Darkblue again since you have two sets of lighter blues and two sets of darker blues in your color setting.
nextplay

Monstrata wrote:

Kanan's Easy

00:12:474 (4,5) - Inconsistent spacing
00:31:934 (1,1) - I don't think this is sufficient recovery time for an Easy. Typically you want about 1 full measure of recovery on an Easy. End it on the downbeat like you do for 02:07:934 (1) - .
00:55:285 (1) - Maybe end the spinner on 00:59:015 - for the syncopated downbeat. (red tick is more important than white when concerning the main melody imo)
02:31:285 (1) - Same, I would have ended it on 02:35:015 - instead, it sounds like a better note to end on

[]

Okay that's all. Call me back when you've replied!Calling backfor bubbleintensive
Fixed all,thanks for the second re-check!
Topic Starter
newton-

Monstrata wrote:

[]

Normal

00:25:285 (3,4) - I would extend this into a 3/2 slider. Don't use so many clicks yet, this is a calm section so use longer sliders and sparser rhythm. ok done
01:57:555 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1,2,3,4,5) - Same idea, use simpler rhythm to distinguish the section from the previous and later section. agreed,
rhythm should be a lot less dense now


[]

Okay that's all. Call me back when you've replied!
thanks for rechecking again!

edit: forgot to mention that i changed the combo color as per the post 2 posts above
Monstrata
Alright, changes look good! Nominated!

Also since there was discussion about metadata earlier, here's some official information:
http://d-ue.jp/orangestar/#osc
Topic Starter
newton-
this is a great thing to wake up to
JierYagtama
Icon hype OWO
Lasse
quick recheck

hs
00:21:555 (1) - sampleset on sliderbody should be soft like top diff (hs copier doesn't copy that usually)
00:53:988 - add a clap here on all diffs, the drums play 1/1 snares in this measure
00:54:636 - 02:29:988 - 02:30:636 - ^
00:59:177 - 02:35:501 - missing clap on all difs that have a spinner ending here


starlight
00:30:312 - a few of you stacks in this part are slightly broken
02:18:636 (2) - 02:19:447 (1) - I think you intended to have that stacked like you do for most of the map? make sure you also make it fit with 02:20:582 (6) -
02:23:826 (2,1) - slider overlap is quite off

insane
00:11:501 (2,1,2) - stacks are kinda off again
00:14:907 (1,1) -

easy
00:00:799 - part is quite dense in comparison to intensity/other parts, easy solution would be 2/1 gaps.
for example: 00:02:096 (3) - make this into a single circle
00:05:663 (5) - delete
00:21:069 - change this green line to soft cause sudden normal slide sounds pretty weird
00:25:447 - fix break snapping: http://lasse.s-ul.eu/CyLD1Owp.mp4 // 01:24:474 - same // 02:01:123 -

00:39:393 (1) - either actually map this to the cymbal or remove finish
00:50:096 (1) - what is this following, everything is on the red tick before
something like http://lasse.s-ul.eu/20DT6uV0.jpg would make sense
01:10:853 (1) - ^ (and finish placement makes no sense either)
02:15:717 (1) - ^
01:41:988 (1) - remove clap
02:31:285 (1) - add whislte

slider spam in chorus is pretty lol, some suggestions to improve it:
00:41:663 (4) - delete and add circle on 00:41:988 - (fits vocals and melody)
00:52:042 (7) - ^ circle on 00:52:366 -
00:42:961 (2) - could be http://lasse.s-ul.eu/xe4wzXBh.jpg which fits the song much better and you use 3/2 gaps later anyways
02:21:555 (2) - delete, circle on 02:21:880 -
nextplay

Lasse wrote:

quick recheck

hs
00:21:555 (1) - sampleset on sliderbody should be soft like top diff (hs copier doesn't copy that usually)
00:53:988 - add a clap here on all diffs, the drums play 1/1 snares in this measure
00:54:636 - 02:29:988 - 02:30:636 - ^
00:59:177 - 02:35:501 - missing clap on all difs that have a spinner ending here
NEWTON waht have u done here D:!11111!

easy
00:00:799 - part is quite dense in comparison to intensity/other parts, easy solution would be 2/1 gaps. did something different
for example: 00:02:096 (3) - make this into a single circle I...it just fits the vocal/instrumentals better (the sliders)
00:05:663 (5) - delete k
00:21:069 - change this green line to soft cause sudden normal slide sounds pretty weird blame neeton
00:25:447 - fix break snapping: http://lasse.s-ul.eu/CyLD1Owp.mp4 // 01:24:474 - same // 02:01:123 - k

00:39:393 (1) - either actually map this to the cymbal or remove finish mapped
00:50:096 (1) - what is this following, everything is on the red tick before It follows the vocals tho
something like http://lasse.s-ul.eu/20DT6uV0.jpg would make sense
01:10:853 (1) - ^ (and finish placement makes no sense either) remade this part
02:15:717 (1) - ^ ^
01:41:988 (1) - remove clap blame neeton
02:31:285 (1) - add whislte ^

slider spam in chorus is pretty lol, some suggestions to improve it:
00:41:663 (4) - delete and add circle on 00:41:988 - (fits vocals and melody) k
00:52:042 (7) - ^ circle on 00:52:366 - k
00:42:961 (2) - could be http://lasse.s-ul.eu/xe4wzXBh.jpg which fits the song much better and you use 3/2 gaps later anyways did something different?
02:21:555 (2) - delete, circle on 02:21:880 - k
thanks for re-check
Topic Starter
newton-

Lasse wrote:

quick recheck

hs
00:21:555 (1) - sampleset on sliderbody should be soft like top diff (hs copier doesn't copy that usually) done
00:53:988 - add a clap here on all diffs, the drums play 1/1 snares in this measure applied where possible
00:54:636 - 02:29:988 - 02:30:636 - ^ roger
00:59:177 - 02:35:501 - missing clap on all difs that have a spinner ending here no snare sound on 00:59:177 - so didnt apply claps, added claps on the latter one tho


starlight
00:30:312 - a few of you stacks in this part are slightly broken whoops, fixed
02:18:636 (2) - 02:19:447 (1) - I think you intended to have that stacked like you do for most of the map? make sure you also make it fit with 02:20:582 (6) - stacked that too
02:23:826 (2,1) - slider overlap is quite off adjusted

insane
00:11:501 (2,1,2) - stacks are kinda off again fixed
00:14:907 (1,1) - also fixed
also went over hs on easy gd again

thanks for rechecking!
Monstrata
Okay, rebubbled~
Lasse
qualified
Topic Starter
newton-

Lasse wrote:

qualified
i came
nextplay

newton- wrote:

Lasse wrote:

qualified
i came
Same
Fu Xuan

newton- wrote:

Lasse wrote:

qualified
i came
fuk grats i should've continued the gd on this
Kotori-Chan
GRATZ NEWTON !!! <33
- Neon -
Congrats boi!!
xidorn
gratz neeton!
Akitoshi
gratz
Lulu-
gratz xd
Gaia
gratz on your first!
-NanoRIPE-
gratz!
Kyouren
Gratzz for your first ranked map! :3
domSaur
gra
pishifat
added +20 online offset
Blobbability
Congratulations!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply