Just some things about that I said in my mod but was quite vague about it
Basically the reason I was so off in this mod was beacause I couldn't immediately see the large emphasis on the flute in kiai sections which is just my bad, its probably the thing I have the most trouble with when modding cause with your reasoning the map fits
Nerova Riuz GX wrote:
Gottagof4st wrote:nm from my queue
A Tale from the Wayfarer
My general stance on top diffs in a set is that they should map everything the song has to offer which is why I mention undermapping alot in this mod, if you do not agree then fine but it seems weird to me to not map stuff like 1/8 sounds if only by a reverse A top diff should represent the song as possible as it can in one or more certain, complete concept(s). As a result here, the overall density difference is dramatically specified.
This is the statement I probably most regret making as in actuality what you said was pretty much on the spot and what I said was pretty bad
00:45:097 (1) - this slider isn't that great with all the things going on, it actually worked for 00:44:320 (1) - as the background noises weren't that loud but here you have 00:45:291 - this sound which isn't represented enough by making it land on a sharp angle sharps are intentionally made to fit the flutes.
The only flute tone I hear are on 00:44:320 - /00:44:320 - /00:44:708 - , I don't hear any on 00:44:903 (3,1) - so I don't really get the "made to fit the flutes"
01:43:387 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - 1/4 sliders aren't needed here for the exception of 01:44:747 (4) - where something different is needed to show the 1/8 sounds it's still legit because aside from drums the flute is still on going.
If the flute was the focus then there would just be 1 long slider but you mapped each important drumbeat with a sliderhead so if the drums speed up- and the rhythm of the map stays exactly the same then it feels off
01:46:107 (2) - would not map this at all, the sounds are really quiet and it gives 01:46:496 (1) - less impact if you map it a bit weird by the suggestion you gave. it's a really clear beat, also the counter flow gives some more impact on it.
This one is like you said really contradicting the things I said before but the reason why this could be undermapped imo is that there is litteraly no other vocal in the entire song, but this is just preference on wether or not someone wants to map it
I like the spacing and flow in this diff, its pretty nice
Gl with the map