1. campa97's Normal (1,68 stars, 115 notes)
2. Hard (2,66 stars, 156 notes)
3. Twilight (3,47 stars, 247 notes)

N0thing wrote:

hey there, promised M4M
Noobmapper here, pls be neglient and comment why you dislike any of my ideas. Also feel free to just ignore them. Every tip could be useful

hard

00:37:677 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - try to push everything to the next white tick left, replace 6 with slider and add sliders until the next note ON THE WHITE TICKS, like this http://puu.sh/t2Ls6/37c51ecc4d.jpg. When I was replaying your version something bothered me. I think it's this. Now something else is bothering me, but if you just make some sliders end on a red tick, then that feeling will fade.
I decided to make it 2 short 2 long 2 shor 2 long sliders, then whenever that sound 00:41:427 (1) - here is coming (I assume it's a whistle) make it a long one, followed by a short, then 2 long, it sounds better to me. feel free to change the combination of SSLLSSLL LSLL LSLL etc. because I#m not really sure there, it just sounds better. Please no. I tried to do it, but it sounds kinda awkward at me, I prefere to keep that part as it is already
00:52:677 (1) - too curvy for my tastes Improved a bit the shape
00:59:239 (2,3,4,5) - that section must have been tricky o.o Not so much though, those are just 4 circles rofl
01:15:880 (2) - I think it sticks out. Try this with DS http://puu.sh/t2LSp/af680d2a52.jpg I'll keep that since it's a triangle
01:33:927 (1) - try putting all of these sliders in the same angle as 01:36:739 (1) - these. Too boring though
I can't really recognize any shapes u serious?, but that's alright. you need to use DS more often and I even thought during playing, that there was a problem with the DS, because I thought that those 00:40:489 (5) - would end either on a red or a white tick, the next note thus also a red or white tick with 00:41:427 (1) - this here being a blue tick. But you actually let the slider end on a blue tick, so I assumed that the DS was messed up. Try to let the players hit on a white or red tick UNLESS you can hear an emphazised sound on the blue tick.

Twilight thing

00:23:848 (5,6,7) - need to improve shape Alright then
00:25:020 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - ^ ^
00:26:427 (1) - think it ends on a red tick. Change SV It ends on the blue tick, listen carefully
00:37:677 (1) - everything ends on a white or red tick, no yellow tick Indeed, those sliders end on the white click just for making the following beat clickable (no beat)(in this case 00:38:028 (2) - this)
00:38:145 (2,3) - ignored those beats. Just pointing out. It's actually alright to ignore beats, as long as the map is nice. But I'd recommend trying a reverse slider for that part anyway (also on all other places. Sometimes a hitcircle is better) Yeah, but that would make the diff easier than it already is right now though
00:52:442 (2) - no beat on that one, put the circle out. It's for emphasize >:D
00:50:802 (1) - try to map them with a small angle towards the ground. I'll keep that shape since it makes various triangles with the other sliders
00:57:598 (4) - there is actually a sound here, but if you put it out then everybody will instead focus on 3 (which is good, because it's an emphazised sound.) Might try a slider here Didn't understood what to do here lol
01:22:207 (1,2) - annoying af to play. 2 streams after each other, then a circle after a stream. Low BPM's streams are often kinda boring to play lol
Try to pay more attention to shape and flow. It was all over the map. but I shouldn't point out each circle. Also rythm is off at times. But it#s still a fking nice map with a fking nice music Tobu is love, Tobu is life \o/

I watched all maps, everytime the offset was shortly after 0:00. In my opinion though, I believe that the offset should be set to 22677. Offset shoulda be okay though :/
Also you might need to change the SV more at times. Pay more attention to rythm, shape and flow. That#s it.

N0thing wrote:

hey there, promised M4M

normal

00:22:677 (1,2) - copy paste to this part 00:26:427 (1,2) - and rotate. Else you have a different flow each time.- Fixed
00:28:302 (3,4,5,6) - I don't know why, but these squares bother me. Maybe because it was different before Fixed
00:24:552 (3,4,5,6) - where the slidertail was part of the square... Yeah, that's good ^^
00:55:958 (6) - out of place, check shape again (of the whole combo) i don't know why i have to check it, that's a triangle with a square
00:56:427 (1,2) - sliderposition just like above copy paste (decide which one you want to keep) They are already copied
01:00:177 (1,2) - And put that shape here too What?
the DS in the quiet part (at the beginning) is higher than the DS during the build up 00:37:677 (1) - . The DS is costant in all parts of map
The DS should be lower at the beginning, the DS during the build up a little bit higher. This difficulty is an easy-normal, is better let DS costant
00:38:731 (2,3,4) - change 4 to a slider too like the others and push everything to the white tick on the left side. http://puu.sh/t2KLp/1988261be9.jpg. It felt off timing when it was on the blue tick What? No!
Same goes for combo afterwards
00:47:052 (3,4) - I think it would be better if you play 3 and 4 like 1 and 2 (look at order ascending and descending of the shape) There are already ascending and descending like 1 and 2
01:01:114 (2,3,4,5,6) - not sure wether you should keep to one shape or that polythingy is ok too... up to you, but take a look at it again I checked this pentagon, seems good
01:09:552 (4) - looks kinda awkward in the corner. copy 1 and rotate it maybe? then you wouldn't need to map the only blanket in the whole map o.O is not the only blanket in this map
01:12:833 (3) - emphazise on 3 more please How i can enpazise a circle?
01:27:364 (2) - try ctrl + g It form a good triangle, i like it
Kiai Section: more DS Is an easy-normal difficulty

Generally I like the map and the music Ty. However especially maps for normal difficulity should be mapped with DS I mapped with ds(if you are going to map entire section with nearly one and the same DS then you might not note the difference, but during playing you will note something bothering you while playing.

Nayrus wrote:

Hi, so i saw your modreq and tried to mod for the first time :^D

Twilight:

00:28:770 (2,3) - I would put a slider here, just like you did before 00:26:895 (2) - Not everything needs to be equal, since it can also be too much boring (expecially on low BPM songs)
00:36:270 (2,3) - ^ 00:34:395 (2) - ^
00:30:645 (2) - Other way around (no slider here), just like the upcoming part, where is no slider 00:32:520 (2,3) - ^
00:38:028 (2) - I would space it x3.0, so that it looks like a 1/4 gap You kidding? That part is enough confusing for the player, and placing a x3.0 space would make things more confusing :/
... - ^ Ehm...^..(?)
00:49:864 (5) - ^ ^

00:52:208 (1,2) - Why not move those so that it looks symmetrical, like 00:50:802 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - Beacause it's for emphasize, like here 01:07:208 (1,2) -
00:54:083 (4,5) - Is there a reason for not putting a slider here? It sounds just like the note before As wrote before, not everything needs to be the same
00:57:364 (3,4) - ^ after ^
01:01:583 (4,5) - ^ before ^
01:05:333 (4,5) - ^ ^
01:12:833 (4,5) - ^ ^
01:16:583 (4,5) - ^ ^

01:03:458 (4,5) - Why no slider here? // 00:55:958 (4) - Or why a slider here, same notes Same as before
00:59:239 (3,4,5,6) - Maybe higher spacing to make it stand out more I used the same DS on all the map, so, sorry but not
01:14:239 (3) - Why no cirles here? ^^^ It's just like here 01:06:739 (3) - (didn't placed circles there too)
01:19:864 (3,4,5,6) - 2 Slider just as before and it always nicer to go from a slider into a stream Okay
01:23:028 (2) - same as above 00:38:028 (2) ^
... - ^ Ehm...^..(?) pt.2
01:32:403 (2) - ^ ^

01:25:958 (7) - 01:24:083 (7,8) - Again exact same notes but different objects ^
01:32:989 (5) - ^ ^
01:31:114 (5) - 01:23:614 (5,6) - ^ ^
01:34:161 (2,3) - 01:35:333 (3,1) - they have a weird flow i would try a different one Yeah, fixed, thanks

The thing with the repeating of same objects for same notes is just the same for Hard diff, you should look over that too I will do it, thanks for modding

N0thing wrote:

I watched all maps, everytime the offset was shortly after 0:00. In my opinion though, I believe that the offset should be set to 22677. Offset shoulda be okay though :/
Also you might need to change the SV more at times. Pay more attention to rythm, shape and flow. That#s it.

N0thing wrote:

Offset usually is at the first audible note Not always though lol. You can keep it that way, but I prefer putting the offset on the first note you actually play, as this will make the white ticks stay on their goddamn place.

Rizevim wrote:

quick mod

General

00:52:677 - why this kiai is so short? D: , u can remove it It's just for emphasize the various drops. I put that so kiai parts are not so much longer
01:07:677 - ^ ^

Hard

00:29:473 - add notes here Ehm...why? :/
00:36:973 - ^ ^

GL!

1. Do S:C1 custom hitclap and hitfinish differ somehow from standart Soft hitclap and hitfinish?
2. ^ Same for N:C2 hitnormal and hitfinish

1. Slider form: you have only 2 slider forms in this difficulty - straight sliders and small curvy sliders without red points in it. Try to make it more diversed so it can be played more interesting, there's bunch of different forms you can apply, as an example I can put some here ( https://puu.sh/taTnQ/bb338d88bd.png https://puu.sh/taTnW/6979faac8b.png https://puu.sh/taTnY/6be64c2f01.png). Red points are very interesting to use, straight sliders are good to be used on slow music. I don't say to use all these shapes randomly - just play around and try to make your map more variative
2. Yellow ticks - I don't get it why you've used 1/8 here, the only place it can be used on this difficulty is 01:35:567 - and I don't suggest to use it there. My thoughts about yellow ticks here: there's no sound on these ticks on a whole difficulty (only 01:35:567 - ), so if you change sliders that end on yellow ticks (with muted ends) on sliders that end on red ticks (with muted ends) it will only be better. In kiai part it even can mislead some players
3. About 01:35:567 - Just change it to slider similar to sliders, that go earlier
4. 00:54:552 (1,2,3) - This looks awesome, 01:02:052 (1,2,3) - this looks not so good. Try to curve first slider and make the flow not in a form of triangle, as you've done earlier, maybe like this ( https://puu.sh/taUCU/a204c0c23d.png ). Still there are many opportunitites to do this place, try to feel what's better
5. 01:05:333 (4,5,1) - Move 5 sligtly upper to make flow not linear, it doesn't feel good here ( https://puu.sh/taUTZ/86609e45d4.png )
6. 01:10:255 (2,3,4,5,6) - Personally I don't like this form, even though it's symmetrical (but vertically), maybe smth like this ( https://puu.sh/taVal/7b2331abf6.png) ?
7. 01:20:099 (4,5,6) - Put 5 slightly upper not to be linear

1. CS 3.8/4/4 for difficulties, wanna differ it somehow (especially for normal)? And maybe you should make AR for normal lower
2. 00:25:958 (6,1) - This doesn't look as cool as this for example 00:31:114 (2,3) - , maybe you can improve it
3. 00:40:841 (4) // 00:44:591 (4) - There's a sound on a red tick, make a slider to the red tick instead of circle
4. 01:12:364 (2,3,4) - This form is also strange
5. 01:21:739 (6,7,1) - Not a mistake, but you're putting everytime this in a straight line, like here 01:33:927 (1,2,3) - so it looks a bit weird there

1. I guess you should grow OD here
2. 00:26:427 (1) - Curve this
3. 00:41:192 (6,1) - Can you move 6 a bit right so it will pour into 1 slider perfectly
4. 01:07:442 (2,1) - Spacing?
5. 01:24:317 (5,1) - This feels really strange while playing, cause 01:24:317 (5) - sounds as strong beat. 01:29:708 (5,6,1) - This transition feels a lot more comfortable. You should to something with places similar to 01:24:317 (5,1) -
6. 01:35:802 (1,2) - Personal opinion - try to place those different from the previous sliders, cause they're on a new combo and it starts to be boring. Or even you can change this for something

kricher wrote:

normal
00:36:739 (2,3) - i think those look better if you move them a bit down like these for example https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6972334 Why? This doesn't interrupt the flow and create a good blanket
00:41:192 - big note here but its a red tick so you dont have to map it since its normal but doesnt seem good not including it since you have some 1/2 later on Why?
00:59:239 (5) - make this a slider that ends at 00:59:473 - It emphasize this part of song
00:59:708 (6) - the same and again at 01:14:239 (5,6) - ^
at the last part this is how i think the timing should be https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6972377 (the note placement is random just look at the timeline on the top) I adjuste this part, it sounds better ^^
hope i was useful Yes, thanks ^^

Aleksander92 wrote:

Hi! Wanna mod this

[campa97's Normal]

1. CS 3.8/4/4 for difficulties, wanna differ it somehow (especially for normal)? And maybe you should make AR for normal lower AR5 is normal for this difficulty
2. 00:25:958 (6,1) - This doesn't look as cool as this for example 00:31:114 (2,3) - , maybe you can improve it I did a little improve
3. 00:40:841 (4) // 00:44:591 (4) - There's a sound on a red tick, make a slider to the red tick instead of circle I leave it, is for emphasize
4. 01:12:364 (2,3,4) - This form is also strange Why?
5. 01:21:739 (6,7,1) - Not a mistake, but you're putting everytime this in a straight line, like here 01:33:927 (1,2,3) - so it looks a bit weird there Isn't too weird, is more simple to play

Rizevim wrote:

quick mod

campa97's Normal

00:59:473 - add notes here No, is for emphasize the part of song
00:59:942 - u can add notes here ^
01:14:473 - add notes here ^

GL! Thanks ^^

kricher wrote:

hard
01:11:192 (4,1) - i think if you get them a bit down like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6972411 it will flow better There's a penthagon and a blanket here, so sorry ahaha
01:26:192 (6) - i dont see why those sliders exist.plz explain For the same reason of 01:24:317 (5) - this
01:30:059 (6) - remove this Why? lol

twilight
00:25:489 (4,5) - mapping those 2 as sliders like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6972431 i think matches the song better Too boring man
00:34:864 (3,4) - making those 2 a slider is an option ^
00:37:091 - since you have some parts that are faster than 1/2 you might as well put a note here That's kinda awkward tbh
00:45:645 (3) - get this the same distance with 00:45:177 (1,2) - Okay, fixed
01:14:708 (4,5) - you can combine those into a slider Nope, I like it


hope i was useful

Aleksander92 wrote:

Hi! Wanna mod this

[General]

1. Do S:C1 custom hitclap and hitfinish differ somehow from standart Soft hitclap and hitfinish? I used the standard skin's hitsou ds since they fit better here tbh
2. ^ Same for N:C2 hitnormal and hitfinish Same

[Twilight]

1. Slider form: you have only 2 slider forms in this difficulty - straight sliders and small curvy sliders without red points in it. Try to make it more diversed so it can be played more interesting, there's bunch of different forms you can apply, as an example I can put some here ( https://puu.sh/taTnQ/bb338d88bd.png https://puu.sh/taTnW/6979faac8b.png https://puu.sh/taTnY/6be64c2f01.png). Red points are very interesting to use, straight sliders are good to be used on slow music. I don't say to use all these shapes randomly - just play around and try to make your map more variative Yeah, ut I actually prefere to use this simple slider in this map, since there aren't strange noises lol
2. Yellow ticks - I don't get it why you've used 1/8 here, the only place it can be used on this difficulty is 01:35:567 - and I don't suggest to use it there. My thoughts about yellow ticks here: there's no sound on these ticks on a whole difficulty (only 01:35:567 - ), so if you change sliders that end on yellow ticks (with muted ends) on sliders that end on red ticks (with muted ends) it will only be better. In kiai part it even can mislead some players I used the 1/8 for emphasize the next clickable beat, with 1/4 there won't fit as well as this imo, moreover I've got a good number of testplays, and no problems were be found in that, so that's not so bad at all
3. About 01:35:567 - Just change it to slider similar to sliders, that go earlier Too boring, sorry
4. 00:54:552 (1,2,3) - This looks awesome, 01:02:052 (1,2,3) - this looks not so good. Try to curve first slider and make the flow not in a form of triangle, as you've done earlier, maybe like this ( https://puu.sh/taUCU/a204c0c23d.png ). Still there are many opportunitites to do this place, try to feel what's better Yeah, this looks really cool, thanks for that!
5. 01:05:333 (4,5,1) - Move 5 sligtly upper to make flow not linear, it doesn't feel good here ( https://puu.sh/taUTZ/86609e45d4.png ) There aren't many linear patterns in this map, so let me keep this lol
6. 01:10:255 (2,3,4,5,6) - Personally I don't like this form, even though it's symmetrical (but vertically), maybe smth like this ( https://puu.sh/taVal/7b2331abf6.png) ? Think that I'll leave this as it actually is, sorry
7. 01:20:099 (4,5,6) - Put 5 slightly upper not to be linear It's a penthagon here, so I won't change anything here lol

[Hard]

1. I guess you should grow OD here The other options are not so high, so OD it's perfect imo
2. 00:26:427 (1) - Curve this Nope, I like it
3. 00:41:192 (6,1) - Can you move 6 a bit right so it will pour into 1 slider perfectly ^
4. 01:07:442 (2,1) - Spacing? Yeah, fixed, thanks
5. 01:24:317 (5,1) - This feels really strange while playing, cause 01:24:317 (5) - sounds as strong beat. 01:29:708 (5,6,1) - This transition feels a lot more comfortable. You should to something with places similar to 01:24:317 (5,1) - That part is pretty cool tho
6. 01:35:802 (1,2) - Personal opinion - try to place those different from the previous sliders, cause they're on a new combo and it starts to be boring. Or even you can change this for something Okay, thanks

Good music choice, good luck further

_orange wrote:

#modreqs

[Hard]

- 00:44:239 (5) - short sliders that curve too much aren't pretty to a lot of people try avoiding these C'mon that's not so bad at all . Other than that, there are already a couple of slider shapes, so let me keep it up lol
- 00:50:802 (1) - the recovery time for this spinner is a bit too short I think, I recommend to try something different... In the mapping rules is written that for hard difficulties the recovery time must be at least 1/2 BPM, so that's correct
- 01:34:864 (3) - NC? Yeah, it sounds good to me

[Twilight]

- I don't agree with the 1/8 either... I think it's confusing and you should map it differently to make it more playable It's for emphasize the next beat, so I'll leave them lol. Nothing wrong was found by testplayers
- 00:51:270 (3) - NC Yeah, thanks

Very solid map, GL!

_orange wrote:

#modreqs

[campa97's Normal]

- I think you should reduce the note density at here 00:22:677 - because it's obviously less intense than 00:52:677 - even though you mapped it the same Yes, i know... But is an easy-normal difficulty
- 00:37:677 (1,2,3) - this isn't too good imo, I don't think they're reflecting the most important sound in the song I like what you did 00:45:177 (1) - here better I use this for emphasize sounds
- 01:14:239 (5,2) - if you can fix this overlap Fixed
- 01:37:677 (3) - NC Ok, thanks

Thanks for your mod ^^

Mir wrote:

A wild mod appears from #modreqs! Yo

[ General]

1. normal-hitfinish2.wav could have a delay of over 5ms which is unrankable. Check and make sure in an audio program. This one seems good to me, but I'll make sure that it'll be okay, thanks
2. Your Hard diff needs more OD because right now it's the same as your Normal difficulty, 4 is pretty low even by Hards' standards anyways so try 5-6? Same with Twilight, you could buff it slightly up to 6.x or even 7 if you wanted to. Changed it to 5
3. Twilight could be given more HP drain since there are a lot more notes. 5.x should be fine. You could lower the Normal HP drain to 3 or so because atm Normal and Hard have the same HP drain. Just look over your difficulty settings again in general. ^
4. You could use a BG of higher quality if you can find one. This one is 1024x768 and that's way below the quality limit (1920x1080). I'm not so good at finding BG lol
5. Can you not find a higher quality version of the MP3? This one seems to be 128kbps and that's kinda low. The max is 192kbps. Downloading the version available for free from here and cutting it to about the same length should be fine and give more quality. If it's too high, you can use a converter online to lower it to 192kbps. Though you may have to change the offset after swapping MP3s. That's exactly what I did, if I'll find a better .p3 I'll use it, thanks
6. Your tags have a typo in them - you spelled "NoCopyrightSounds" as "NoCopirightSounds." The former is the correct spelling. Ooops, u kinda right, thanks

[ Twilight]

1. 00:35:333 (5,1) - This blanket is noticeably off. Fixed e.e
2. 00:41:309 (4) - The sound you're following doesn't have a beat here, and mapping a beat here will cause weird polarity imo. I recommend removing this note to improve playability. It's for emphasize, sorry
3. 01:12:364 (3,4,5,1) - Visual spacing looks too close between 01:12:364 (3,1) - imo. Try this: http://i.imgur.com/06ISMXH.png That looks good to me, so I won't change it, sorry
4. 01:15:177 (1,2,3) - Hmm, this flow is a bit awkward for a point in the music where it's not needing as much emphasis. Maybe place the circle on the other side? http://i.imgur.com/6BwB0PI.png Idk what to do here, I like both, I think I'll ask to someone else
5. 01:33:927 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - Uhhh. What exactly are you going for here? This doesn't seem like any recognizable pattern to me, just a bunch of straight sliders scrunched together. Something like http://i.imgur.com/bzvee8N.jpg perhaps? It's really up to you just, this whole part seems really randomly placed and quite structurally lacking considering this part 00:50:802 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - is more structured and actually is part of a pattern. ^
   

[ Hard]

1. 1. 00:37:208 (5,1) - This blanket is really close, I think you could space it out more and it would look nicer: http://i.imgur.com/HhgPL1E.png Could do the same for the rest of the map: 00:45:880 (2,3) - for example is also really close and could use some more spacing. I've actually made the whole map with DS, so, sorry but no
   2. 00:37:677 (1,2) - Whether you take the above suggestion or not you could make these the same slider to improve aesthetics as well. That could be too boring tho
   3. 00:41:427 (1,2) - Last blanket I'll point out. I recommend checking them all since there are quite a few noticeable errors here that could be polished. Fixed thx

That's everything major.

Good luck.~