KuraiPettan wrote:

General

1. Resnap correctement le début des breaks vu que tu as surement changé d'offset, c'est décalé ah, j'ai oublié, je vais le faire

Normal

1. 01:15:585 (3,1,2,3,4) - Trop de finish ça nique les oreilles ;_; Enlève celui de (1) et (3) (le deuxième (3)) Non, j'ai besoin de ces finish pour rester logique avec la Insane, jvais réduire leur volume
2. 01:29:628 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - Perso, ce type d'anti-jumps dans ce type de diffs j'aime pas trop, Le spacing entre les notes est le même que celui de 01:26:224 (1,2) ce qui peut porter a confusion, (faut pas oublier que c'est une diff pour les noobs hein :p) Justement, j'ai hésité quand j'ai fait ça, alors j'ai demandé à un newbie que je connais de le tester, et il a joué ça sans problème, donc je pense que je peux le laisser
3. 02:58:139 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - Même remarque qu'au dessus

Insane

1. Circle Size 6 : Mes yeux ;__; Je commence à en avoir marre que tout le monde râle, alors je risque de changer
2. 00:12:175 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - Les espaces dans ce stream me dérangent, même si ils sont justifiés musicalements, c'est pas forcément évident à jouer o.o je trouve que celui-là est super facile à jouer...
3. 01:49:203 (6) - Fait un stream en 1/3 qui se termine à 01:49:628, je trouve que ça fait cool :p J'avais fait ça à la base, mais je trouve que la mini-pause est mieux, en tous cas ça m'aide quand je joue la diff ><
4. 02:02:926 - Ce stream owo longass stream XD
5. 02:24:947 (5) - New combo a cause du changement de spacing
6. 02:26:649 (5) - Idem fixed les deux

Star~

NotShinta wrote:

General:
Lol easy and tick 2 plz okay for tick rate, although Astom shall choose for his diff easy discussed over IRC

Insane:
00:12:601 (5) - This jump could easily be read as the last half of the stream coming later. I'd just scrunchstream the whole thing. I don't think it's a problem. The hugely spaced 1/2 before help read this.
02:46:224 (1) - Because of how this is spaced, one could easily tap 1/2 earlier! wooooooops you're right, re-made sliders to a cuter shape


Normal:
00:41:091 (3) - Add a finish, or some other hitsound. Already explained in like three other mod posts why there is no hitsound here ;_;
01:36:011 (2,1) - Yeah, this in the easiest difficulty, no. That's not a proper mod post line, sir. I get the idea though, changed - ,-

RandomJibberish wrote:

Bloops blub blub

General
I'd set Tick 2 on all diffs. k
I think this spread could do with an Easy mahself, but it isn't essential. discussed over IRC

Insane
01:14:734 (1,2,3,4,5) - The song goes softer... so you increase the spacing? Felt kinda weird to me. I thought jumps would fit here ? The song sounds more bland at that point, so I thought I'd only use circles... and the vocals sound like a detache rather than a legato, hence the jumps
02:43:032 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - ^ these are retardedly high - ,- reduced the spacing, but kept jumps
02:45:373 (2,1) - This antijump threw me off, especially since there's even a lyric where I expected the note to be fixe and remade sliders

Astom
00:58:777 (3) - Silenced hitobjects are unrankable and stupid Fixed for now we'll see what Astom says

Normal
00:30:886 (5,1) - Mmm, I don't really agree with such a dramatic antijump in a normal
00:34:287 (4,1) - ^
00:37:689 (5,1) - ^
EVERYWHERE (Antijumps) -^
Forgot to remove them >< fixed

Nice Job.

RandomJibberish wrote:

00:58:777 (3) - Silenced hitobjects are unrankable and stupid fixed, not because you give me a GOOD reason for change it, only because I found a better solution

Astom wrote:

RandomJibberish wrote:

00:58:777 (3) - Silenced hitobjects are unrankable and stupid fixed, not because you give me a GOOD reason for change it, only because I found a better solution

.

Astom wrote:

not having one is disorientating. true, but make your map fit the song is always better

Jarby wrote:

Astom wrote:

not having one is disorientating. true, but make your map fit the song is always better

This is where you lost all credibility. You're blatantly admitting to compromising a map's playability for the sake of some hitsounds or whatever, right? That's exactly what we don't want.

Astom wrote:

Jarby wrote:

This is where you lost all credibility. You're blatantly admitting to compromising a map's playability for the sake of some hitsounds or whatever, right? That's exactly what we don't want.

not having one is disorientating, yea it's true, only if you silence something without a reason, I mean that.

Hitsounds are for make your map MORE easy of play, that includes silence a circle/spinner/slider (or add a whistle,finish,clap) for the good reason of follow the song, is not correct?, make your make fit the song improve your playability not drop it, that includes a good set of hitsounds.

Also, I changed it already, nothing more to discuss, maybe try to respect my decision a little next time?

StrangeSensation wrote:

Nice song! Have you got this song in file 'mp3'?

Jarby wrote:

StrangeSensation wrote:

Nice song! Have you got this song in file 'mp3'?

Check the directory for the song. It should be something like C:\Program Files\osu!\Songs\30162 Hatsune Miku - i LOVE YOU in Windows.