VINXIS wrote:

can i gd

1. the tags are wrong. firstly, the track isn't from tyttö ep but from Harbor LP instead. secondly, the genres are basically for other tracks of the LP I guess since Hip Hop and Rap really aren't suitable as genre classifications for the track. and that's the tags that I know the meanings of lolz. btw add Discography 2015 into tags too, it's an official compilation in Bandcamp
2. combo 2 & 3 are way too similar, could consider to change one of them into grey
3. AiMod

1. would be better if you implement new combos based on beat counts instead of vocals or shifting in musical elements on both normal and hard diffs.
2. in ez ignoring 00:17:612 - doesn't seem to be a rational move. it's a major beat in which other similar beats are mapped but this one doesn't, becoming an inconsistency.
3. in norm jump distance between 00:48:638 (3,1) - is relatively too big compared to other notes. not only it heavily disrupts the distance-time concept but it may also serve as an unexpected surprise for the players and might cause them to be unable to catch the note in time.

HootOwlStar wrote:

omargo d cna i gd finna meme
[general]

1. the tags are wrong. firstly, the track isn't from tyttö ep but from Harbor LP instead. secondly, the genres are basically for other tracks of the LP I guess since Hip Hop and Rap really aren't suitable as genre classifications for the track. and that's the tags that I know the meanings of lolz. btw add Discography 2015 into tags too, it's an official compilation in Bandcamp fixed! i kinda copied the tags from the girl next door onto here and added a couple things so whoops nice catch. the only things i did not change were the genre classifications as rap and hiphop because in the tags for harbor lp it includes rap and hiphop and i would say thats a pretty justifiable reason to include them in the beatmap tags too. also, chillhop/lo-fi hiphop come from rap and hiphop so i believe it makes sense. okay tangent done
2. combo 2 & 3 are way too similar, could consider to change one of them into grey i really don't know if grey would fit as well, and the difference between combo colors is very noticeable imo
3. AiMod

[diffs]

1. would be better if you implement new combos based on beat counts instead of vocals or shifting in musical elements on both normal and hard diffs. ncing in normal and hard aren't based on vocals, but on the various timing changes
2. in norm jump distance between 00:48:638 (3,1) - is relatively too big compared to other notes. not only it heavily disrupts the distance-time concept but it may also serve as an unexpected surprise for the players and might cause them to be unable to catch the note in time. i definitely understand what you're saying about this placement but the purpose for it was to be kind of surprising because of how the piano loop starts again unexpectedly. it is kind of vague though so i am willing to change this if more people complain

good luck in everything for everyone. thank you for the mod! i really appreciate it. i'm glad someone finally decided to mod this :]

HootOwlStar wrote:

[*]in ez ignoring 00:17:612 - doesn't seem to be a rational move. it's a major beat in which other similar beats are mapped but this one doesn't, becoming an inconsistency.

sammish wrote:

just a heads up, you spelt hip hop as "hipho0p" in the tags

TheDuckMask wrote:

Dropping this .osb file here once more
Got the fixes in here kek, once again if you need anything else changed let me know~

harmanjit102 wrote:

Also for your Hard difficulty I would actually change the name because the star rating does not meet the criteria for a Hard difficulty, also please capitalize the first letters of all your difficulties lol. the sr for certain difficulties does not need to be the determining factor for each diff names. its based more on the spread of the mapset. also everything is lowercase to fit with the artist and title being completely lowercase. but thanks for the input, haha.
I hope I helped!

Joe Castle wrote:

HI! im here from #modreqs since you requested a mod there, so im here

lets see if i can help you! (this is just my opinion)


normal:

1. 00:13:796 (2,1,2) - you should move this circle a little bit up, just a little bit, so the spacing between the sliders and the circle looks more "perfect"? I definitely know what you mean by more perfect, but the spacing between the objects is consistent and does not really create any spacing inconsistencies. When it comes to aesthetics, the placements look completely fine to me at least.

2. 00:26:043 (2,1,2) - you can move this circle a little bit, just a little bit to the right, with the same reason as #1 This case is more understandable than the last one you pointed out, but it does not really need to be changed either in my opinion. Even though the spacing is sort of off,
it is not a real noticeable change that will affect someones gameplay. The spacing difference is also there to make sure the objects are as perfectly aligned as possible.


hard:

1. 00:35:655 (2,3,4) - in my opinion (you can do whatever you want ) the first slider should be a little bit more closer to the second one I definitely do see why this may be something that could be pointed out, but the main reasoning for the spacing between these sliders is because the song breaks its original melody, tempo, etc. to play this laugh sample; having the spacing difference is able to reflect this moment in the song.


My opinion about the map

its well done actually, and idk if my mod really helps, but i hope it does at least i tried
very good job right here Aw thank you so much! Every mod helps in one way or another, regardless if your ideas were implemented or not. Thank you for the mod and good luck! :]

osuskrub wrote:

rank this now it's my favorite tomppa song

Californian wrote:

when

Sotarks wrote:

general
please add a muted sliderslide for both custom set hitsounds. done
you have tag conflicts double-check that done

snicker
00:14:552 (1,2) - you could swap the ncs here done
00:36:008 (3) - nc this for more readability of the pattern done
00:36:775 (1) - reduce this to a normal 1/1 slider and put a circle at 00:38:307 - done
00:47:503 (1,1) - remove ncs done

normal
00:14:935 (1) - remove nc
00:21:066 (1) - ^
00:27:196 (1) - ^ same here like just fix the NCing of this whole diff it's so weird xD just NC downbeats done for all lol

easy is fine
just confirm metadata please metadata should match for this (i was gonna use discography 2015 but he took it off of his bandcamp i guess it doesn't really matter tho lol)
and call me back, pretty chill map i like the song! :]

Sotarks wrote:

f a i r y f l y i n g

Gabe wrote:

is this map ready to go?

you might want to recheck the storyboard again to make sure the rings are at the right place.