[Hobbes2's Normal]
[Yahuri's Advanced]
- 00:04:335 (2,3,4,1) - Looks so dense compared with everything else around that part.
- 00:14:543 (2,3) - Stacks don't really play well when the below object is weaker than the top.
- 00:28:710 (1) - That long slider is not really necessary imo, how about something like this?
- 00:37:877 (2) - These are totally different than 00:36:418 (2,3,1) so the rhythm here should be different, imo even 2 circles here is still reasonable as you can discern different sounds with different rhythms.
- 00:55:168 (1,1) - Not sure why these aesthetics are intended like this when other things are pretty much a different style.
- 01:09:335 - This would be more significant to map than 01:09:127 imo
- 01:11:418 (4,1,2,3) - [url=puu.sh/v43Sn/aa4ba50287.PNG]This[/url] would be a lot more interesting to map tbh. Well you can use sliders instead of circles, but you get my point.
[Yahuri's Advanced]
- 01:07:861 (3,1) - Why suddenly a 1/1 gap when you didn't do this anywhere earlier zz
- Overall I disagree your rhythm choices as they focused too much on minor sounds to the point where they lose emphasizes on the more important ones or even the main melody, like:
- 00:01:194 would be more emphasized with a hold sound while 00:01:402 is really minor and not necessarily need to be mapped.
- 01:20:361 (1) - The rhythm here is slightly different from 01:19:528 (3,4) so the way it was represented should be different too, I would use a 1/1 slider+circle instead of 01:20:361 (1,2) .
- Et cetera, I can point more things out but it would just being me telling my own interpretation of the song so there's that.
- 00:00:361 (1,2) - 00:02:444 (2,3,4) - Not sure why you treated these differently despite being the same sound.
- 00:14:111 (2) - Could be 2 circles as these beats are equally prominent.
- 00:16:819 (4,5,6) - The stack doesn't play really well since the most prominent thing is 00:16:819 (4) and it's on top so there isn't any much emphasis on it, technically it should be at the bottom of the stack so something like this would prioritize the beats better according to their importance.
- 00:17:236 (7,8) - Should be changed to a 1/4 slider with a similar stack reasoning as above.
- 00:19:319 (2,3,4) - The pattern is arranged with 3 sliders but 00:19:319 (2) - is not musically the same as 00:19:736 (3,4) .
- 00:22:444 (1,2,3,4) - Like, there should be a better placement than this because stacking 00:22:444 (1,4) doesn’t reflect anything related to the song, the pattern would make more sense if they’re arranged in the way that 4 sliders are visually related, currently 00:24:319 (4) looks so random.
- 00:24:944 (5,1) - And these aren't rhythmically the same as 00:22:444 (1,2,3,4) anymore so it should be sth different than just repeating the flow with similar placements.
- 00:30:777 (3,4,6) - Don't stack reverse arrow pls.
- Tbh overall the diff lacks structure, some patterns aren't really executed in a way that they could reflect the song properly, rhythms can be improved more too imo. I also would like to know if you have any reasoning/concept behind your spacings, because I don't understand some stuff you did like 00:12:236 (2,3,4) - 00:21:611 (2,3) - etc and idk if you have any solid reasoning/concept behind these.