Request taken from #modreqs.
Please reply to this mod saying what you didn't fix (and what you did) and why.
Also, if you have any question, feel free to ask me in-game.
General- Remove "the Epic of Zektbach ~" from the tags of all difficulties. ~ is unneeded (as it can't be searched anyway) and the rest is already in the source.
Beginner- MAP THIS DIFF TO THE SAME POINT AS THE OTHER ONES. Why wouldn't new players have the chance to enjoy the full song ?
- The difficulty settings are too high for an Easy. AR and OD 4 is just too much. D:
- Your comboes are very long. Try to find a way to make shorter. Remember that notes that end comboes give additionnal health and score, so it's better to have more of these for easier difficulties.
- 02:00:053 (7) - Missing whistle on the first beat. =P
- 02:00:405 - I strongly recommend not to use such huge slow downs in an Easy/Normal diff, especially not this way, right after a note. Slow downs are confusing for new players. Also...
- 01:59:347 (6,7,1) - Broken spacing. (6,7) and (7,1) are spaced the same way, yet the time difference isn't the same. I know, that's because of the slow down, and it does show 0.8 spacing for both, but remember what new players will see: they are spaced the same way, therefore their time difference must be the same, and they will trip. Space (7,1) using 1.6x distance snapping to fix it.
- 02:09:582 (3,4) - This rhythm is a bit complex, especially because you used only 1/1 and 2/1 in the diff so far, so I would recommend you not to use a stack, as stacks make rhythms unclear due to the absence of spacing.
Normal- Shouldn't this be named "Standard" to stay consistent with the other difficulties' names ?
- Same comments as in Easy regarding the length of the diff, comboes, and slow down.
- Your hitsounding is inconsistent. Tons of whistles are missing because of the way you mapped the diff. This causes it to sound really weird.
Hyper- Not entering details because my post would be far too big, but... Your comboing is extremely inconsistent, and so is your spacing. I recommend you to re-check your diff fixing the spacing (especially 1/2s) when it's needed (like 00:39:229 (2,3,4) - ) and the comboing.
Another- Same comment about spacing. I'm not saying you should remove all the jumps though ! But stay consistent with your spacing when you space beats regularly.
- 01:48:053 (5,6,7,1) - These anti-jumps are too sudden. Add a new combo on (5) to make them more readable.
gowww- Tick rate 0.5 is highly frowned upon. You should change to at least tick 1.
- Make this start at the same point as the other diffs ?
- I fail to understand how you mapped this. But well.
The mapset needs more work. Especially the score spread. 500 000, 1 000 000, 9 000 000, 17 000 000, 18 000 000 is a very bad score spread. Mapping the two easiest diffs to the end might improve it.
I don't think you need two 5.00 stars difficulties, but if people are fine with it, I don't mind it.