KanaRin wrote:

用中文會比較好吧?
嗯嗯.

[Taiko]

KAT = Blue note ( Big KAT = Big notes , same of DON)
DON = Red note

Color Help:
Red -> You must change it.
Blue -> Change it as well.
Black -> Suggestion only.

00:10:274 (x) - 這裡停有點不好,加個Don這裡.
00:19:674 (2) - 不用大圓吧XD, Remove~
00:22:874 (1,2,1) - 不太match到 , 假如認同就跟我以下做法
00:22:674 (x) - 加個藍
00:22:774 (x) - ^
00:22:974 (2,3) - Remove這兩個.
00:23:274 (x) - 加個藍.
00:35:674 (1) - 大藍
00:41:274 (1) - ^
00:56:474 (T) - 這裡才開始Kiai吧?
01:26:274 (1) - 大藍
01:28:474 (1) - ^

做的很好！又進步了
My Rating: 9.3 / 10

努力 XD

Sumisola wrote:

阿诺....能不能把我guest的名字改回去Sumisola's Insane..........................

[Events]
//Background and Video events
0,0,"Sumisola's BG .jpg"      (保留bg的code，这里根据你不同diff的BG名字)
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
这里删掉lrc的code
//Storyboard Sound Samples
//Background Colour Transformations
3,100,128,255,255

[Events]
//Background and Video events
这里删掉BG的code
//Break Periods
//Storyboard Layer 0 (Background)
//Storyboard Layer 1 (Fail)
//Storyboard Layer 2 (Pass)
//Storyboard Layer 3 (Foreground)
这里是SB的code（这里保留lrc的code）
//Storyboard Sound Samples
//Background Colour Transformations
3,100,128,255,255

Lilac wrote:

The fact that most of these difficulties use a low Stack Leniency is against the rules now, so I'm suggesting talking to the other mappers to change it.

[Normal]
Only thing I'm worried about is the notes after the spinner appear too quickly but I'm not sure about that.

[Jojo's Nagi]
01:18:474 (4,5,6) - It's confusing to read.

[Samuel's Hard]
Unrankable Stack Leniency.

00:18:474 (8) - Spacing. Right.
00:30:874 (6) - That 1/4 sounds weird...plus the slidertick whistle. D: no
00:44:474 (1,2) - The 1/4 difference doesn't sound right. You're right!
01:25:274 (1,2,3,4) - That's really cheap, you know that? Nope. But corrected

Well done. Just don't like the Stack Leniency, that's all.

abalee wrote:

Don't forget to move it to pending plz.

Lilac wrote:

The fact that most of these difficulties use a low Stack Leniency is against the rules now, so I'm suggesting talking to the other mappers to change it.

Odaril wrote:

Why is this in WIP ? o.o

Weezy wrote:

General
- Title should be "motto Hade ni ne! According to wikipedia and other sources.
- Normal and Taiko diffs have different preview times. They should all be the same.

1. As stated above, title is wrong.
2. You need an approach circle in your folder.
3. The skin elements "pause-back.png" and "pause-continue.png" are bigger than the maximum allowed (398x116). It's not a big deal for the pause-continue.png one, but since you will have to modify pause-back, you might as well nazi it.
4. The preview points in Taiko and Nomal are different from the other diffs'.

1. 00:41:074 (1) - This note comes too soon after the spinner. Remember new players don't spin well and need time to readjust their aim (or find their cusor). On top of that, it starts the combo on a red tick, which is in itself confusing. It would be better to just remove it.
2. 00:45:274 (1,1,1) - To stay consistent with your comboing, remove these new combos.
3. 00:53:274 (3) - This feel really out of place here, because the rhythms used have been mostly 1/1 ones so far, and you use a 1/2 kick slider that feels a lot faster than what the map felt so far. Also, I find kick sliders to be generally confusing, because the number of repeats can't be expected, and the cursor hides the repeat arrow, so it can't be read either.
4. 01:00:674 (1) - For consistency, this should be a 1/1 slider.
5. 01:19:274 (4) - Curve the slider the other way around to avoid the overlap ?
6. 01:22:874 (1) - and 01:24:474 (1) - aren't need as new combos.

1. The hitsounds are way too low. Also, I'm not a big fan of all these added 1/4s, but they play fine.

1. Why does this have a custom name when all the other diffs don't ? Rename it to Jojo's Insane ?
2. The combo colours blend too much with the background. And hitsounds are too low.
3. 00:11:674 (1,2,3,4,5) - Make these jumps even ?
4. 00:24:474 (4) - Why does this slider end on a blue tick ?
5. 00:26:674 (2) - The whistle sounds quite weird here. o.o
6. 00:27:274 (4) - To stay consistent with the hitsounding, add a whistle here.
7. 00:34:674 (7) - Why does this slider end on a blue tick ? It matches nothing in the song...
8. 00:44:274 (6) - Change this slider's shape to avoid the overlap (which partially hides the repeat arrow) ?
9. 01:22:074 (1) - Why does this slider end on a blue tick ? It matches nothing in the song...
10. 01:23:674 (1) - Same...

1. This is... overmapped. the jumps are here for the sake of difficulty. I'd consider that pretty much all of them are huge spacing issues if they weren't readable. Big dislike there.

1. This feels kinda... too much for the song. Rename to Taiko Oni, too ?

Weezy wrote:

General
- Title should be "motto Hade ni ne! According to wikipedia and other sources.
- Normal and Taiko diffs have different preview times. They should all be the same. Fix

Just noticed, why is there no preview image on the beatmap's page?? :S Fix

Everything else is fine.
The things in general need to be changed, but for Normal it's a suggestion.

Odaril wrote:

Weezy wrote:

General
- Title should be "motto Hade ni ne! According to wikipedia and other sources.
- Normal and Taiko diffs have different preview times. They should all be the same.

This. Mod will come as well.

General

1. As stated above, title is wrong.
2. You need an approach circle in your folder.
3. The skin elements "pause-back.png" and "pause-continue.png" are bigger than the maximum allowed (398x116). It's not a big deal for the pause-continue.png one, but since you will have to modify pause-back, you might as well nazi it.
4. The preview points in Taiko and Nomal are different from the other diffs'.

Fix all


Normal

1. 00:41:074 (1) - This note comes too soon after the spinner. Remember new players don't spin well and need time to readjust their aim (or find their cusor). On top of that, it starts the combo on a red tick, which is in itself confusing. It would be better to just remove it.
2. 00:45:274 (1,1,1) - To stay consistent with your comboing, remove these new combos.
3. 00:53:274 (3) - This feel really out of place here, because the rhythms used have been mostly 1/1 ones so far, and you use a 1/2 kick slider that feels a lot faster than what the map felt so far. Also, I find kick sliders to be generally confusing, because the number of repeats can't be expected, and the cursor hides the repeat arrow, so it can't be read either.
4. 01:00:674 (1) - For consistency, this should be a 1/1 slider.
5. 01:19:274 (4) - Curve the slider the other way around to avoid the overlap ?
6. 01:22:874 (1) - and 01:24:474 (1) - aren't need as new combos.

Fix all

Hard

1. The hitsounds are way too low. Also, I'm not a big fan of all these added 1/4s, but they play fine.

Fix the sound effect, but this is diff for easily hard, so I use the 1/4s

Taiko

1. This feels kinda... too much for the song. Rename to Taiko Oni, too ?Fix,and I have add and remove some notes

Nymph_ wrote:

打死我都不说我是来蹭KUDO加吐槽哦大力的


Normal:
01:03:274 (1) - 这箭头上的WHISTLE个人觉得有点违和

Hard:
嘛 根据你说的 我主要提一些我觉得二分之一更好的地方
00:07:674 (5) -
00:21:474 (3,4,5) - 删了4吧
00:31:674 (6) -
01:20:474 (1,2,3,4) -
NAZI完毕 闪人 基本都FIX了 除了01:20:474 (1,2,3,4) - ~感谢~

Odaril wrote:

You need an approach circle in your folder.

1. Suggestion:Difficulty Setting:
   
   1. Circle size:5
   2. AR:6
   3. HP:5
   4. Volume: Normal:60%
2. 00:02:074 (1) - You forgot to change it to kat?
3. 00:04:474 (1,2,1,1,1) - Remove 5-plet to a 1/2 and a triplet,I suggest: O OOO
4. 00:07:674 (1,1,2) - I suggest change this to dkk,it sounds better for me!
5. 00:09:674 (3) - Change this to k..
6. 00:10:474 (2,3,1) - Triplst doesn't fit the music too much imo,Some simple 1/2 is good enough here.Just remove (3)- i sokey though.
7. 00:14:274 (2,1,2) - Consider kkk?Sounds better for me.
8. 00:16:474 (1) - Change this to d.
9. 00:16:674 (1) - Move this to 00:16:874 - and change it to k.
10. 00:17:674 (1) - Change this to k.
11. 00:18:474 (3) - ^ Same.
12. 00:29:874 (1,1,1) - dkk doesn't fit the music very well,ddk sounds much better for me.
13. 00:53:274 (2) - How about change it to kat?
14. 00:55:474 (1,2,3,4,1,2,1) - Stream doesn't fit here too much!!!Simple 1/2 or 1/1 Big finish is good enough here.
15. 01:00:074 (2) - Change a big kat here to follow the previous big note.
16. 01:09:674 (2) - ^Same.
17. 01:11:074 (2) - Change it to k,them remove 01:11:374 (1) -
18. 01:28:474 (x) - The Kiai Time should be finished here.

kanpakyin wrote:

Taiko mod Start:
Mostly are suggestion only,you don't need to follow them if you disagree.

[Taiko Oni]

1. Suggestion:Difficulty Setting:
   
   1. Circle size:5
   2. AR:6
   3. HP:5
   4. Volume: Normal:60%
      Fix all XD
2. 00:02:074 (1) - You forgot to change it to kat?Fix
3. 00:04:474 (1,2,1,1,1) - Remove 5-plet to a 1/2 and a triplet,I suggest: O OOOFix
4. 00:07:674 (1,1,2) - I suggest change this to dkk,it sounds better for me!Fix
5. 00:09:674 (3) - Change this to k..Fix
6. 00:10:474 (2,3,1) - Triplst doesn't fit the music too much imo,Some simple 1/2 is good enough here.Just remove (3)- i sokey though.Fix
7. 00:14:274 (2,1,2) - Consider kkk?Sounds better for me.Fix
8. 00:16:474 (1) - Change this to d.Fix
9. 00:16:674 (1) - Move this to 00:16:874 - and change it to k.Fix
10. 00:17:674 (1) - Change this to k.Fix
11. 00:18:474 (3) - ^ Same.Fix
12. 00:29:874 (1,1,1) - dkk doesn't fit the music very well,ddk sounds much better for me.It is DKK but the color is DKD ouch
13. 00:53:274 (2) - How about change it to kat?Fix
14. 00:55:474 (1,2,3,4,1,2,1) - Stream doesn't fit here too much!!!Simple 1/2 or 1/1 Big finish is good enough here.Fix
15. 01:00:074 (2) - Change a big kat here to follow the previous big note.Fix
16. 01:09:674 (2) - ^Same.Fix
17. 01:11:074 (2) - Change it to k,them remove 01:11:374 (1) - Fix
18. 01:28:474 (x) - The Kiai Time should be finished here. Fix

Lilac wrote:

Odaril wrote:

You need an approach circle in your folder.

Pretty sure we removed this rule...or found it redundant. Not sure though, I remember this discussion cropping up somewhere.

Please let me recheck this tomorrow or some other time as I really don't have much time anymore. Must sleep.I am sure I haven't full submit, but now I finish.