It can come back, but probably not through voting. At least not the open-testing voting we're currently trialing out.Default wrote:
QuillGill wrote:
why can't akasha be ranked tho :c
Who said it can't
Also what happens if a map gets dropped out of the pools? Can it ever come back?
forum
Loved Community Vote: Round 1 (osu!)
posted
Total Posts
94
Please choose up to four (4) maps that you'd like to see enter the Loved listing.
Total votes: 17725
Polling ended
Topic Starter
DeletedUser_7520443
no one did i suppose, but i thought it couldn't since it's been going for rank for a few years now (and they haven't ranked it yet) and instead are going to love it (which was a category made for unrankable maps). but i suppose it's better than getting nothing at all on the map so i shouldn't complainDefault wrote:
QuillGill wrote:
why can't akasha be ranked tho :c
Who said it can't
DeletedUser_4329079
Glad to see the "If its not uncreative jump map #6,148,891,100 its garbage" mentality reflected in the votes. At first i was completely up for letting the community vote for what they want but since the majority of the community cant even play the maps they want loved, i feel that voting should be limited to a certain rank, (at least for standard) maybe 15k could be the cutoff? OR we could just love every map with a certain amount of favorites with no voting.
KNEESOCKS
Is the graveyard a requirement for Loved status? Or am I free to update my map right now and if it wins the vote it's still eligible to be Loved?
Why is sound in motion in that list? IIRC galvenize is still trying to rank it?
It's clearly what most people would find enjoyment from, a lot of players only play jump maps because that's what current mapping enforces. Although I agree, a Graces of Heaven leaderboard would be a lot cooler than a poorly made "ULTIMATE JUMPS XXXTREME RED LIKE ROSES" map. Why don't they just bundle in the 2 coolest maps with the 4 that win.Reddit wrote:
Glad to see the "If its not uncreative jump map #6,148,891,100 its garbage" mentality reflected in the votes. At first i was completely up for letting the community vote for what they want but since the majority of the community cant even play the maps they want loved, i feel that voting should be limited to a certain rank, (at least for standard) maybe 15k could be the cutoff? OR we could just love every map with a certain amount of favorites with no voting.
Some quick feedback already: this isnt a good representation of what people want, it's a representation of what everyone kind of wants. We should be able to pick maps in order of preference and have our preferences be weighted. I voted red like roses, but i 100000% don't want it as much as graces of heaven; yet my vote doesn't reflect that.
DeletedUser_4329079
id love to give all my votes to i see monstas :/
yeah I mean I enjoy watching other people play maps i cant pass too but that doesnt mean the voting results should reflect that.Weed wrote:
It's clearly what most people would find enjoyment from
♥a map can still be updated and go for ranked while it is loved, it will just be moved from loved to qualified if i understand correctlyLiiraye wrote:
Why is sound in motion in that list? IIRC galvenize is still trying to rank it?
it feels a bit unfair that my map is placed with some of the most wanted maps for a long time, and they're probably gonna get replaced with other extremely famous maps next poll (such as brain power or other 500+fav maps) while having no guarantee of coming back if it doesn't get voted like this
not like i have a better suggestion than what we have, but it still feels a bit sad that i'm gonna need to gather some votes so my map doesn't stay rotting in graveyard just because some of the other choices were better
also sad for the mania/taiko/ctb mappers which have even less of a chance
not like i have a better suggestion than what we have, but it still feels a bit sad that i'm gonna need to gather some votes so my map doesn't stay rotting in graveyard just because some of the other choices were better
also sad for the mania/taiko/ctb mappers which have even less of a chance
jesse1412 wrote:
Some quick feedback already: this isnt a good representation of what people want, it's a representation of what everyone kind of wants. We should be able to pick maps in order of preference and have our preferences be weighted. I voted red like roses, but i 100000% don't want it as much as graces of heaven; yet my vote doesn't reflect that.
Basically this, I think it will sort itself out once the most general known well loved non-ranked maps get through the cycle. At some point, there will be less known or more interesting maps that can get into the loved section.
However, yes right now it seems we have to deal with a lot of maps that EVERYBODY has an interest in getting into the loved section. Now, I for one hope one day to see https://osu.ppy.sh/s/294728 in loved. But, seeing as its' at least going to be upwards of 10+ more rounds before we enter unknown territory for Loved. It's going to take a while...
The only problem I have with this system is that voting in maps that are still WIP is counterproductive and makes no sense as they just take up slots for other maps that are not going for rank.
Though I do like this whole voting thing, it feels comfy.
If a map drops out of the pool due to lack of votes, I definitely don't feel it should be indefinite. Maybe give it some time to cool off (like 2-3 polls), and then bring them back in and see if they fair better against different competition. With only two chances, it just doesn't seem right to axe a beatmap forever from being able to pass into Loved status via Voting.
Also as Jesse mentioned, a better way to show varying preference in the available choices. The ability to cast multiple votes out of the 4 for one map that was suggested earlier seems like a good place to start.
Also as Jesse mentioned, a better way to show varying preference in the available choices. The ability to cast multiple votes out of the 4 for one map that was suggested earlier seems like a good place to start.
"Nero vs After School - Sound In Motion vs AH (Fauxami Mashup) by galvenize"
>4%
Are you guys shittin' me?
cmon it DESERVES to be noticed loool
>4%
Are you guys shittin' me?
cmon it DESERVES to be noticed loool
all of these maps are great
love all of them, what is stopping you
i am retarded
I'm pretty sure the broken link affects how much votes that Hanatan beatmap gets which kinda sucks.
There are easily other 4 maps in the pool that people would be fairly satisfied with, not even checking out which one this beatmap is.
There are easily other 4 maps in the pool that people would be fairly satisfied with, not even checking out which one this beatmap is.
where is the option that lets me put all 4 of my votes into graces of heaven
yea kagerou is an amazing map, ripEnDy_S wrote:
I'm pretty sure the broken link affects how much votes that Hanatan beatmap gets which kinda sucks.
There are easily other 4 maps in the pool that people would be fairly satisfied with, not even checking out which one this beatmap is.
DeletedUser_7520443
same honestly hope it has a comebackXexxar wrote:
yea kagerou is an amazing map, ripEnDy_S wrote:
I'm pretty sure the broken link affects how much votes that Hanatan beatmap gets which kinda sucks.
There are easily other 4 maps in the pool that people would be fairly satisfied with, not even checking out which one this beatmap is.
(but srsly all the maps above are maps I want to see in the loved category why can't they all
)sampling paradise when
Yeah the idea of some maps not making it into Loved from the first poll and then having no second chances is ridiculous. Especially considering how tight its' between some of the maps right now.
There should be a cooldown period before they are brought back in again, I agree with. But, they shouldn't be indefinitely removed from a chance to get into Loved. Especially for maps that aren't WIP or have been decided upon by the mapper that it isn't worth ranking anymore.
There should be a cooldown period before they are brought back in again, I agree with. But, they shouldn't be indefinitely removed from a chance to get into Loved. Especially for maps that aren't WIP or have been decided upon by the mapper that it isn't worth ranking anymore.
Im going to be really sad if Graces of Heaven doesnt make the cut. This map is basically made for this section.
I love how people are destroying this vote akepkeaopea
map should be ranked, not just loved. no idea why galv has never pushed it toward getting ranked honestlySecretpipe wrote:
"Nero vs After School - Sound In Motion vs AH (Fauxami Mashup) by galvenize"
>4%
Are you guys shittin' me?
cmon it DESERVES to be noticed loool
Ha.jesse1412 wrote:
Some quick feedback already: this isnt a good representation of what people want, it's a representation of what everyone kind of wants. We should be able to pick maps in order of preference and have our preferences be weighted. I voted red like roses, but i 100000% don't want it as much as graces of heaven; yet my vote doesn't reflect that.
I only voted for graces of heaven to account for this.
Out of curiosity, could Eighto be loved? The map wasn't uploaded by the creator and the creators are both banned, does this matter? Idk if this is the right place to say this, but, Eighto is iconic.
i see no reason why centipede should have a leaderboardImakuri wrote:
where is centipede wtf
I'm pretty sure RLR will be first and Augoeides will be second, or vice-versa