forum

WEAVER - S.O.S. [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
78
show more
davidminh0111
Going for ranked
Good luck
Ozu
love this map, so one little suggestion.

In Oni diff, 00:00:280 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - little unmatched with sound to me.
since you followed the drum sound like 00:00:280 (1,2) - kd, 00:00:663 (3,4,5) - must be d kk cause of sound pitch imo.
this is my suggestion.



really sorry for suggest after bubble ;w;
see ya~
Topic Starter
World Fraction

404 AccNotFound wrote:

love this map, so one little suggestion.

In Oni diff, 00:00:280 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - little unmatched with sound to me.
since you followed the drum sound like 00:00:280 (1,2) - kd, 00:00:663 (3,4,5) - must be d kk cause of sound pitch imo.
this is my suggestion.



really sorry for suggest after bubble ;w;
see ya~
Not going to change this unless it is a rankable issue and BN's feel it has to happen, but thanks for trying to help out more. sorry :(
Surono
up to the mapper, but I felt thats enough to emphasized since the loud drums are just 00:00:280 - 00:00:664 - these, 00:00:921 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - these sounds are just kick drums but if to follow the flow is not bad tho, kinda overemphasized imo

@Wolrd Fraction 00:01:818 - just kat this to emphasized the contrast of 00:01:305 (6,7,8,9) - these

if you want, you can apply that suggestion without update because its minor/little suggestion. doesnt need to rebubble
thzz

Surono wrote:

up to the mapper, but I felt thats enough to emphasized since the loud drums are just 00:00:280 - 00:00:664 - these, 00:00:921 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - these sounds are just kick drums but if to follow the flow is not bad tho, kinda overemphasized imo

@Wolrd Fraction 00:01:818 - just kat this to emphasized the contrast of 00:01:305 (6,7,8,9) - these

if you want, you can apply that suggestion without update because its minor/little suggestion. doesnt need to rebubble
i think 00:01:818 - is clearly low sound, so it's better to change 00:01:690 - to k than Surono's tbh. i was fool lol
up to you.

others seem fine. call me again and let's go for qf :)
Topic Starter
World Fraction

thzz wrote:

Surono wrote:

up to the mapper, but I felt thats enough to emphasized since the loud drums are just 00:00:280 - 00:00:664 - these, 00:00:921 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - these sounds are just kick drums but if to follow the flow is not bad tho, kinda overemphasized imo

@Wolrd Fraction 00:01:818 - just kat this to emphasized the contrast of 00:01:305 (6,7,8,9) - these

if you want, you can apply that suggestion without update because its minor/little suggestion. doesnt need to rebubble
i think 00:01:818 - is clearly low sound, so it's better to change 00:01:690 - to k than Surono's tbh.
up to you.

others seem fine. call me again and let's go for qf :)
OK i made the necessary changes. Let's see what happens
thzz
everything looks fine :3

here we go~
Ozu
gratz!! xD
Surono

thzz wrote:

i think 00:01:818 - is clearly low sound, so it's better to change 00:01:690 - to k than Surono's tbh. i was fool lol
up to you. yeah up to mapper, lul madness subjective intensifies
wwwwwwwwww wats this XD gg

anyway, finally congrats for 1st rank. <3
Akemi_Homura
Gratz~ :)
zigizigiefe
Congratz World Fraction o/
rip loli bg
Kagetsu
gratz!!
Shunao
Gratz!~ \o/
Topic Starter
World Fraction
thanks you guys, I really appreciate the comments :D
Nwolf
gratz~
qoot8123
Hi o/
I have some concerns about spread in futsuu:

From 00:51:562 - to 01:27:972 - there is only 3/2 rest moment on futsuu and muzu while kantan has much larger one like 3/1, I think you need to add some 2/1 break on futsuu to make the spread more balance with muzu and kantan like remove 00:56:177 (105) - ,01:04:383 (125) - ,01:12:588 (146) - and 01:20:792 (166) - .
Topic Starter
World Fraction

qoot8123 wrote:

Hi o/
I have some concerns about spread in futsuu:

From 00:51:562 - to 01:27:972 - there is only 3/2 rest moment on futsuu and muzu while kantan has much larger one like 3/1, I think you need to add some 2/1 break on futsuu to make the spread more balance with muzu and kantan like remove 00:56:177 (105) - ,01:04:383 (125) - ,01:12:588 (146) - and 01:20:792 (166) - .
I'm sorry but i have to disagree, I believe the spread between the 2 is fine and further removal of any of those notes would make the spread between futsuu and muzu too great. Thanks for trying to help though.
Kyouren
Gratzz for your first ranked map! :3
Nardoxyribonucleic
The concerns raised by qoot are valid. Additional modding as follows:

  • [Kantan]
  1. 00:40:280 (42) - this note could be removed for a 4/1 rest considering the current note density from 00:35:151 to 00:51:562 - is relatively higher than that in the kiai. By doing so, kiai's intensity could be emphasized more properly.
  • [Futsuu]
  1. 00:40:792 (71) - similar to Kantan, you may delete this note for a better transition to higher difficulties.
  2. From 00:51:562 to 01:27:972 - there are no 2/1 breaks within this 36-second session, which is in fact rather demanding for beginners. The deletions qoot mentioned do not affect overall spread with Muzukashii at all as Muzukashii has similar note density at those specific spots. Therefore, please reconsider his suggestions again.
  • [Muzukashii]
  1. From 00:00:280 to 00:50:536 - similar to Futsuu but in different part of the map, there are no 2/1 breaks within this 50-second session, which is also deemed consecutive at this level of difficulty. I would recommend removing 00:35:664 (91,92) - for a more balanced spread with Futsuu at that spot.
  2. 00:41:049 (107) - similar to Futsuu, you may remove this note as well.
  • [Oni]
  1. 00:36:433 (138) - you may delete this note with respect to the suggestion in Muzukashii for spread refinement.
Topic Starter
World Fraction

Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:

The concerns raised by qoot are valid. Additional modding as follows:

  • [Kantan]
  1. 00:40:280 (42) - this note could be removed for a 4/1 rest considering the current note density from 00:35:151 to 00:51:562 - is relatively higher than that in the kiai. By doing so, kiai's intensity could be emphasized more properly.
  • [Futsuu]
  1. 00:40:792 (71) - similar to Kantan, you may delete this note for a better transition to higher difficulties.
  2. From 00:51:562 to 01:27:972 - there are no 2/1 breaks within this 36-second session, which is in fact rather demanding for beginners. The deletions qoot mentioned do not affect overall spread with Muzukashii at all as Muzukashii has similar note density at those specific spots. Therefore, please reconsider his suggestions again.
  • [Muzukashii]
  1. From 00:00:280 to 00:50:536 - similar to Futsuu but in different part of the map, there are no 2/1 breaks within this 50-second session, which is also deemed consecutive at this level of difficulty. I would recommend removing 00:35:664 (91,92) - for a more balanced spread with Futsuu at that spot.
  2. 00:41:049 (107) - similar to Futsuu, you may remove this note as well.
  • [Oni]
  1. 00:36:433 (138) - you may delete this note with respect to the suggestion in Muzukashii for spread refinement.
EDIT: Everything suggested was changed, i took a deeper look into the map and found what qoot said to be accurate. Thanks for the help.
Ozu
some irc about Futsuu dense and blah blah
02:04 World Fraction: welp
02:04 World Fraction: have to get it requalified
02:04 404 AccNotFound: hi~
02:04 World Fraction: lower diffs were too dense
02:05 404 AccNotFound: ok let's see!
02:05 World Fraction: mainly futsuu
02:05 404 AccNotFound: kantan seems good
02:05 404 AccNotFound: oh ok
02:06 World Fraction: the kiai
02:06 World Fraction: had no 2/1 breaks
02:06 World Fraction: so i gave it 4 according to qoot and nardo
02:07 404 AccNotFound: 00:39:254 (67,68,69) -
02:07 404 AccNotFound: is this also ok?
02:07 404 AccNotFound: 00:43:100 (75) -
02:07 World Fraction: check again
02:08 World Fraction: it didnt update properly
02:08 404 AccNotFound: last pending ver
02:08 404 AccNotFound: ok i will pick that you can consider to delete
02:08 World Fraction: hmmmmm
02:08 404 AccNotFound: 00:59:510 (111) -
02:08 404 AccNotFound: 01:05:151 (124) -
02:09 404 AccNotFound: 01:06:177 (127) -
02:09 404 AccNotFound: 01:13:356 (144) -
02:09 404 AccNotFound: 01:15:408 (149) -
02:09 World Fraction: first and 3rd point are mapped to vocals
02:10 404 AccNotFound: 01:21:562 (163) -
02:10 404 AccNotFound: 01:24:126 (170) -
02:10 World Fraction: and that last one
02:10 404 AccNotFound: first 00:59:510 (111) -
02:10 404 AccNotFound: this
02:11 World Fraction: thats vocals
02:11 404 AccNotFound: up to you, but next is finisher
02:11 World Fraction: shit
02:11 404 AccNotFound: and i think finisher can express the feeling of vocal
02:11 World Fraction: maybe
02:11 World Fraction: thats agood one
02:11 404 AccNotFound: third one,
02:12 404 AccNotFound: 01:06:177 (127) -
02:12 404 AccNotFound: you can move this to 01:06:690 -
02:12 404 AccNotFound: and 01:06:946 (129) - delete
02:12 404 AccNotFound: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8328038 like this
02:13 World Fraction: hmmmmmmm
02:14 404 AccNotFound: just suggestion lol
02:14 404 AccNotFound: this is your map
02:14 404 AccNotFound: btw, i really wanna change 00:53:997 (99) - to k, but i think you will not
02:15 404 AccNotFound: S~ O!! S~
02:15 404 AccNotFound: lolol
02:15 World Fraction: if i did
02:15 World Fraction: i'd change
02:15 World Fraction: the ones around to k
02:15 World Fraction: and keep that as d
02:15 World Fraction: but then its too diff for futsuu
02:15 404 AccNotFound: ok~
02:17 404 AccNotFound: 00:55:408 (102,121,141,160) -
02:17 404 AccNotFound: this is the 1/3 part,
02:17 404 AccNotFound: and consider delete
02:17 404 AccNotFound: now it's good and really fun to play
02:17 404 AccNotFound: and if you delete it, less fun
02:18 404 AccNotFound: but more stable pattern
02:19 World Fraction: idk if futsuu players can handle that
02:20 404 AccNotFound: ?
02:20 404 AccNotFound: more easy
02:20 404 AccNotFound: cause delete and remove confused circle
02:20 404 AccNotFound: imo
02:20 404 AccNotFound: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8328115
02:20 404 AccNotFound: 00:55:151 (101,102,103) -
02:20 404 AccNotFound: this is example
02:21 World Fraction: oh
02:21 World Fraction: ok
02:23 404 AccNotFound: hey
02:23 404 AccNotFound: what's this
02:23 *404 AccNotFound is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1108917 WEAVER - S.O.S. [Oni]]
02:23 404 AccNotFound: 00:53:614 (204,205,206) -
02:23 404 AccNotFound: why this is more easy than muzukashii's one?
02:24 World Fraction: oh WTF
02:24 World Fraction: why aren't they kats?
02:24 404 AccNotFound: lolol
02:26 World Fraction: muzu was supposed to be D d D
02:26 World Fraction: not oni
02:26 World Fraction: JEEEEEEEZZZZZ
02:30 *404 AccNotFound is editing [https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1108915 WEAVER - S.O.S. [Futsuu]]
02:30 404 AccNotFound: 00:58:997 (109) -
02:30 404 AccNotFound: you can also consider to delete this
02:31 World Fraction: no i was told to keep that
02:31 404 AccNotFound: 00:58:228 (107,108,109,110) - kd dk pattern looks little hard
02:31 World Fraction: a while back from thzz
02:31 404 AccNotFound: also for little break time
02:31 404 AccNotFound: ok
02:32 404 AccNotFound: but i little worried this dense...
02:32 404 AccNotFound: https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/8328209
02:32 404 AccNotFound: but up to you!
02:32 404 AccNotFound: end~
Surono


tho this slow bpm but yeah give mercy for newbie, placeholder for checking again.
Nardoxyribonucleic
Rechecked and confirmed with the changes. Both Futsuu and Muzukashii have sufficient rest moments now and the spread becomes more appropriate than before.

Rebubbled~
Surono
back oL_o

now newbies can dt it xd thanks sir nardo.
Ozu
regratz xDDDD
toara_fict
Good Job :3
Please sign in to reply.

New reply