wmfchris wrote:

taiko mod request by bakana

00:12:304 - d
01:15:735 - d K

Rating : 8 8.5/ 10

[0:32 vocal is too quite comparing with drum sound, seems a bit too loud/dense there]

no kd

Krisom wrote:

General-
· I'd make lead in 2000 in all diffs, 1500 doesn't seems to be enough (specially in taiko) Done

MeLLon-
HP-1? Oh for the score.. I can't do that><
00:48:649 (3,4,5) - I'd make the spacing between these 3 even, it's kinda confusing right now.Fixed
00:58:078 (1,2,3) - Don't you think [img=http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/85726]this[/img] plays better? The stack+jump is mean in a soft section of a song ;x; Fixed
01:07:678 (3) - New combo? (since there's a finish and a small jump, I thinkit'd fit here) Fixed
End the final kiai time like in the other diffs. Fixed


Taiko Oni-
00:00:535 (1,2,3) - I found these notes a bit awkward for a taiko, I dunno why, I'd delete them, but that's up to you XD Deleted

Hinacle-
Dear Hinacle, you're amazing <3. He is always amazing<3

Normal-
I felt that the sliderspeed+spacing were a tad high for the normal, other than that, I found nothing Umm.. I think Normal is okay for this sliderspeed + spacing, but i will fix the [Easy] diff.

Easy-
Kiai ends in a different place here compared to the other diffs, make it end at the same place Fixed
Spacing and sliderspeed are incredibly high for the easiest diff ._.! Reduce sliderspeed to at least x0.9! Take in mind that the BPM is very high, so the settings should be easier to compensate that. change to 0.9 SV + 1.0 spacing. I think it's good enough~

.

loveFantasy wrote:

asdfasdfasdfmod

[General]
- EDIT: fine now

[Easy]
<00:42:992> (1) 尾巴拔whistle
<00:44:364> (2) 尾的音效有點對比太強, 降音或一樣用SC2:finish
<00:48:478> (1) 頭拔clap下whistle, 尾拔whistle..
<00:49:849> (2) 同44:364
<01:14:364> (2) 結尾停01:15:050?
delete timing sections:

SPOILER

71707,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
73078,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
75821,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
76421,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
76935,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
77535,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
77878,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1
78221,-100,4,2,1,75,0,1

[Normal]
- 一樣刪了KIAI內沒用的綠線
<00:43:678> (2) 拔whistle
<00:45:392> (4) sample夠用的話, 這個finish下在45:050的slider tick point會更好
- 後面一串類似的combo同
<01:14:364> (2) 結尾停01:15:050?

[Hinacle]
- fine

[MeLLoN]
- fine
<01:23:964> (3,4) change to circle first, slider after; since 01:24:135 has a finish and would be better if placing on startpoint of a slider instead of endpoint

Krisom wrote:

Mellon-
00:48:649 (3,4,5) - Spacing is still uneven !

I'm guessing that'd be all. Don't kudosu this reply.

Krisom wrote:

That's not all, either someone changed something or there was en error while submitting...

Mellon-
01:06:649 (1,2,3) - Uneven spacing (you should try something like this if you want a jump...)
(and while we're at it...)
01:02:878 (6,7,1) - If you're going to make (6-7) a jump, I'd add the new combo on (7) and remove it from (1). If you want to keep the new combo pattern (and I suggest you to keep it, since it makes sense) but you want to keep the jump, stack (7) under (6)'s end
01:04:935 (1,2) - Why the jump here?
Damn, errors keep popping up ._.;

Krisom wrote:

That's not all, either someone changed something or there was en error while submitting...Oops..Sorry.

Mellon-
01:04:935 (1,2) - Why the jump here? I will say it can make the map more beautiful & fun to play XD Also i think it's not so hard & the music fits the jump. Anyway, Mellon-san want to keep it. Only this haven't been fixed.

Easy-
00:23:792 (1) - Why does this ends on 1/4?Fixed

Damn, errors keep popping up ._.;

Krisom wrote:

Heh, it's ok. I can live with that jump there I suppose, even if I still don't agree with it following the music. It's up to your taste I suppose.

It's dangerous to go alone, take this (ﾉﾟωﾟ)ﾉ

Krisom wrote:

Heh, it's ok. I can live with that jump there I suppose, even if I still don't agree with it following the music. It's up to your taste I suppose.

It's dangerous to go alone, take this (ﾉﾟωﾟ)ﾉ

jericho2442 wrote:

whats the "feng" tag for? :/ It's the company of this original PC Game. Well but this song is from anime.I think i should add it in the tags :3.

Normal
01:07:678 (3,4,5) - broken spacing, these all need the same spacing to suit the timing, move (4) more away from (5) Fixed
01:19:849 (6,7,1) - this increase in spacing is rather pointless tbh and dont really play good Fixed


MeLLoN
01:23:621 (1,2,3) - this is too confusing to play timing wise because of the feel the rest of the map makes, i REALLY advise to move the timing like this Agree,Fixed.



fix these and i'll rank Oh Thanks XD