1. Asura (4,94 stars, 214 notes)
2. Nyx Taiko (4,86 stars, 303 notes)
3. Orpheus Telos (5 stars, 282 notes)
4. Orpheus (2,97 stars, 111 notes)
5. Orthrus (4,25 stars, 162 notes)
6. Thanatos (4,61 stars, 209 notes)

• 00:06:432 (1) - Add finish on first repeat? It fits the background cymbal sound imo
  00:27:227 (2) - Few grids up? It will give more variety to the pattern
  00:38:818 (2,3) - One grid up for both (not too sure though, these two seems too far compared to the distance from the previous (1,1))
  00:51:772 (2) - One grid right for the second red waypoint
  01:03:021 (1) - Split this into two symmetrical 1/1 sliders? Like this for example:
  
  SPOILER

  
  01:15:636 (4) - The lack of notes after this slider sounds weird imo... idk, 3/2 slider maybe works well here

• 00:04:045 (1,2,5,6) - Slightly curve them? It will flow better imo. Example
  
  SPOILER

  
  00:16:488 (1,2) - Try to spice the curve using bezier waypoints? Like this:
  
  SPOILER

  
  00:31:318 (5) - It sounds better without the clap imo
  01:20:238 (2) - ...use grid lv4, move the red waypoint 1 grid down and the last waypoint 1 grid left (not very sure though)

• 00:01:657 (2) - Move the clap to (3)'s start?
  00:19:214 (7,8,9,10) - Move all 1 grid down and right, so (10) will be in the center?
  00:55:520 (7) - Few grids down? Or make the slider's end below 00:54:498 (5)
  01:16:827 (6,7) - I'd rather combine these two into a single 3/2 slider >_<
  01:26:202 (4,5,6,7,8) - Arrange like this? (your current pattern seems too forced imo)
  
  SPOILER

  [img]osu.ppy.sh/ss/182584[/img]
  01:27:907 (2) - That extra red waypoint in the end looks ugly ):

Niva wrote:

Mod request via in-game PM ~

[General]
-> I searched at google and found out this song comes from the album "Persona 3 Original Soundtrack", perhaps add "ost original soundtrack" in the tags? Did add "P3P" to not repeat "Persona" (so "P3P Original Soundtrack)
-> I got offset -6 (629 ms), not very sure though Thank, i did recontrol the offset and it seems -8 ms

[Orpheus]

• 00:06:432 (1) - Add finish on first repeat? It fits the background cymbal sound imo
  00:27:227 (2) - Few grids up? It will give more variety to the pattern
  00:38:818 (2,3) - One grid up for both (not too sure though, these two seems too far compared to the distance from the previous (1,1)) Had a better idea, i manually stacked 00:36:763 (2) - 1 grid up
  00:51:772 (2) - One grid right for the second red waypoint no need of that, as I wanted to make thus slider repeat
  01:03:021 (1) - Split this into two symmetrical 1/1 sliders? Like this for example:
  
  SPOILER

  
  01:15:636 (4) - The lack of notes after this slider sounds weird imo... idk, 3/2 slider maybe works well here Had Star rating related problems... but now there seems to have problems, so i added the original notes

[Orthrus]

• 00:04:045 (1,2,5,6) - Slightly curve them? It will flow better imo. Example
  
  SPOILER

  
  00:16:488 (1,2) - Try to spice the curve using bezier waypoints? Like this:
  
  SPOILER

  
  00:31:318 (5) - It sounds better without the clap imo
  01:20:238 (2) - ...use grid lv4, move the red waypoint 1 grid down and the last waypoint 1 grid left (not very sure though)

[Thanatos]

• 00:01:657 (2) - Move the clap to (3)'s start? i want the hitsounds to cleverly follow the music
  00:19:214 (7,8,9,10) - Move all 1 grid down and right, so (10) will be in the center? Nah, it already is in the center
  00:55:520 (7) - Few grids down? Or make the slider's end below 00:54:498 (5)
  01:16:827 (6,7) - I'd rather combine these two into a single 3/2 slider >_< My (Notes), and Way (Slider...)
  01:26:202 (4,5,6,7,8) - Arrange like this? (your current pattern seems too forced imo)
  
  SPOILER

  [img]osu.ppy.sh/ss/182584[/img]
  01:27:907 (2) - That extra red waypoint in the end looks ugly ):
  (since it's an hard and it stay good i added a jump in 01:29:262 (5,6))

...I'll mod the remaining 2 non-taiko diffs when I have time lol, got to sleep atm :3

• 00:10:180 (3) - Add note with clap?
  00:11:373 (7,8) - (7) is too close to (8) compared than to (6), but it's barely noticeable
  00:23:808 (1) - Is this supposed to be slowed down? It seems the unsnapped inherit section causes this slider speed problem
  00:34:035 (6) - Default finish sound (S) sounds better here rather than S:C2 >_<
  00:38:808 (1) - Again, the unsnapped inherit section causes this slider's start spawns the wrong clap sound ):
  00:44:262 (4,5) - Spacing :3
  00:47:672 (6) - Again, slider speed error because of the unsnapped inherit section
  00:55:853 (7) - Use standard clap here rather than S:C2?
  01:04:547 (2,3) - Switch the position of these two? Also, you could curve (1,3) a bit:
  
  SPOILER

  
  01:16:819 (6) - Curve a bit to the right?
  01:27:558 (8) - Whistle here?

• 00:00:541 (1) - Should be 1/4 later I suppose (or it's intentional? o.o)
  00:02:331 (1,2,3) - You could try this rhythm : Remove the whistle from (1)'s end and add whistle on (2,3), it fits the guitar more this way imo
  00:13:922 (5,6,7,8) - I'd rather create a triple after a single note, rather than a single note after a triple here >_<
  00:23:041 (4) - It sounds better without this note imo
  00:23:126 (5) - Use default finish sound rather than S:C2 here?
  00:27:217 (3,4,5,6) - Add whistle on every slider's start? It fits the vocal I think
  00:38:637 (3) - Snap the inherit section in the repeat to 38808. It gives the wrong sound with unsnapped one
  01:22:444 (1,3) - Plays great, but quite hard to read...

Niva wrote:

Here's the delayed mod >_<]
Don't kudosu this because I already got one from the post above.

[Asura (by Kiva)]

• 00:10:180 (3) - Add note with clap?
  00:11:373 (7,8) - (7) is too close to (8) compared than to (6), but it's barely noticeable
  00:23:808 (1) - Is this supposed to be slowed down? It seems the unsnapped inherit section causes this slider speed problem <- fixed
  00:34:035 (6) - Default finish sound (S) sounds better here rather than S:C2 >_<
  00:38:808 (1) - Again, the unsnapped inherit section causes this slider's start spawns the wrong clap sound ): <- fixed
  00:44:262 (4,5) - Spacing :3
  00:47:672 (6) - Again, slider speed error because of the unsnapped inherit section <- fixed
  00:55:853 (7) - Use standard clap here rather than S:C2?
  01:04:547 (2,3) - Switch the position of these two? Also, you could curve (1,3) a bit:
  
  SPOILER

  
  01:16:819 (6) - Curve a bit to the right?
  01:27:558 (8) - Whistle here?

[Orpheus Telos]

• 00:00:541 (1) - Should be 1/4 later I suppose (or it's intentional? o.o) Resnapping error, i say
  00:02:331 (1,2,3) - You could try this rhythm : Remove the whistle from (1)'s end and add whistle on (2,3), it fits the guitar more this way imo Not really...
  00:13:922 (5,6,7,8) - I'd rather create a triple after a single note, rather than a single note after a triple here >_<(The rhythmn is corrected anyway)
  00:23:041 (4) - It sounds better without this note imo
  00:23:126 (5) - Use default finish sound rather than S:C2 here?
  00:27:217 (3,4,5,6) - Add whistle on every slider's start? It fits the vocal I think
  00:38:637 (3) - Snap the inherit section in the repeat to 38808. It gives the wrong sound with unsnapped one
  01:22:444 (1,3) - Plays great, but quite hard to read...

Unsnapped inherit sections cause the problem >_<
Good luck ^^

1. Song Setup - Storyboarding - remove check Letterbox during breaks ( only Asura diff )
2. Song Setup - Audio Lead-in - Only Orpheus Telos diff is different. +1000ms plz
3. Song Setup - Advanced - Stack Leniency - Only Orpheus Telos diff is different. all diff unify it ?
4. KIAI TIME - KIAI TIME end 01:29:774 I think that this matches.

1. 00:19:717 (2,3) - grid move ? 2:x256,y104 3: x176,y104
2. 00:36:763 (2) - one grid down.
3. 00:43:581 (3) - grid move. x172,y304
4. 00:46:990 (1) - Ctrl+J grid x256,y256
5. 01:07:104 (1,2,3,4) - I think it is confused for a beginner.
6. 01:25:172 (3) - spacing too close.

1. OD -1 (lower than hard diff)
2. 00:28:240 (5) - one grid right ?
3. 00:43:240 (6) - one grid up.
4. 00:53:808 (5) - grid. x80,y152
5. 01:06:422 - add note
6. 01:27:899 (4) - add NC
7. 01:28:666 (1) - spinner end 01:29:774

1. 00:04:035 (2) - I think it does not match ><; change circle.
2. 01:16:819 (6,7,1) - I think it does not match vocal. try like this http://puu.sh/aQxq

1. 00:01:649 (1) - I think it is spacing too close
2. 00:15:626 (1) - remove NC
3. 00:47:672 (6) - add NC ?
4. 00:59:944 (8) - ^
5. 01:05:569 (1) - spinner start 01:05:399
6. 01:22:444 (6) - add NC ?
7. 01:25:853 (4) - ^
8. 01:28:581 (1) - spinner end 01:29:774

1. 01:04:035 (4) - add NC ?
2. 01:23:808 (5) - add NC and 01:24:490 - remove NC

kosiga wrote:

hi~ HakuNoKaemi

from my queue ~

here my mod ~

[General]

1. Song Setup - Storyboarding - remove check Letterbox during breaks ( only Asura diff )
2. Song Setup - Audio Lead-in - Only Orpheus Telos diff is different. +1000ms plz
3. Song Setup - Advanced - Stack Leniency - Only Orpheus Telos diff is different. all diff unify it ? It needed a different stack leniency (because of unwanted stacks)
4. KIAI TIME - KIAI TIME end 01:29:774 I think that this matches.

[Orpheus]

1. 00:19:717 (2,3) - grid move ? 2:x256,y104 3: x176,y104
2. 00:36:763 (2) - one grid down. It's manually stacked up
3. 00:43:581 (3) - grid move. x172,y304
4. 00:46:990 (1) - Ctrl+J grid x256,y256
5. 01:07:104 (1,2,3,4) - I think it is confused for a beginner. Nah, it's rightly slow and can be easily seen
6. 01:25:172 (3) - spacing too close.

[Orthrus (by Armin)]

1. OD -1 (lower than hard diff) OD +1 at harder diff
2. 00:28:240 (5) - one grid right ? It's at the right place
3. 00:43:240 (6) - one grid up. (1 grid 3)
4. 00:53:808 (5) - grid. x80,y152
5. 01:06:422 - add note <- should ask him, I don't think...
6. 01:27:899 (4) - add NC <- I'm almost sure he would have done it
7. 01:28:666 (1) - spinner end 01:29:774 <- should ask

[Thanatos]

1. 00:04:035 (2) - I think it does not match ><; change circle.
   [*]01:16:819 (6,7,1) - I think it does not match vocal. try like this http://puu.sh/aQxq

[Asura]

1. 00:01:649 (1) - I think it is spacing too close
2. 00:15:626 (1) - remove NC
3. 00:47:672 (6) - add NC ?
4. 00:59:944 (8) - ^
5. 01:05:569 (1) - spinner start 01:05:399
6. 01:22:444 (6) - add NC ?
7. 01:25:853 (4) - ^
8. 01:28:581 (1) - spinner end 01:29:774

Should ask him, those go more regarding mapping style... (that difficulty is made by _Kiva)

[Orpheus Telos]

1. 01:04:035 (4) - add NC ?
2. 01:23:808 (5) - add NC and 01:24:490 - remove NC

That's all ~

very clean map ~ Star~☆

Good luck ~

kosiga wrote:

[Asura]

1. 00:01:649 (1) - I think it is spacing too close
2. 00:15:626 (1) - remove NC
3. 00:47:672 (6) - add NC ?
4. 00:59:944 (8) - ^
5. 01:05:569 (1) - spinner start 01:05:399
6. 01:22:444 (6) - add NC ?
7. 01:25:853 (4) - ^
8. 01:28:581 (1) - spinner end 01:29:774

wcx19911123 wrote:

from my queue

[General]
I'm not sure but 800x600 is the biggest size of video , if I recall -> the max size for 4:3 is 800x600, for 16:9(aka Widescreen) is 854x480
there are many of unsnapped timing sections in some diffs.. make sure them snap well plz kinda strange, as I did resnap them and they are just 1ms off....

[siin]
add reversearrow.png plz I will, if I'll have a good idea...
it is not default-%.png , it is default-percent.png...
I suggest to use default approachcircle.png , the one you using is not good , too thick.. it make harder to read map imo

[Orpheus]
00:14:604 (2,1) - stack better? Kinda prefer them unstacked as I don't really want to have spacing problems
00:36:763 (2,1,2,3) - don't use anti-jumps in an Easy diff.. it is confusing for newbies It'll means they just aren't adapt to play music games, this is oh-well readable if it isn't the first time you listen to a song
00:51:764 (2,2) - hidden sldiers.. this is unrankble It's really seeable and not unrankble, cause you really have the time to see it plus, the Sv isn't fast plus the start is seeable time before it's covered.
01:16:308 (5,6,7,8,1) - damn.. this pattern will kill newbies.. it is too hard to read the rhyme..

[Orthrus (by Armin)]
remove guest ID from diff name is better imo.. put them in creator's words and tags is enough
HD+2
OD-1
01:21:592 (3) - this note is kinda off.. I think move it to 01:21:763 - is better
01:28:666 (1) - end at 01:29:774 - is better

[Thanatos]
00:12:217 (3) - back arrow is kinda hidden by 00:11:535 (1) - , maybe change direction? I should change the hitburst too...
01:17:331 (7,1) - I think stack this 2 circle is better , easier to read the rhyme manual ...
01:27:728 (1) - move to 01:27:558 - , follow vocal plz What's strange about following drums?

[Asura]
00:30:626 (1) - suddenly speed up.. plz use 0.75x sped here..
00:42:217 (1) - suddenly speed down.. don't do this plz , it is very confusing to read even with slider tick rate 2 , in fact sldier tick do nothing to help to read the slider speed changing
01:28:410 (1) - end at 01:29:774 -

[Orpheus Telos]
OD+1
00:26:365 (5,1) - the spacing is too small.. it makes people click 1 too early..
00:32:416 (1,1) - this is hard to read.. I suggest delete 00:33:353 (1) - and spinner end at 00:33:353 - Two reason: it follow music, while the hitsound DO suggest it
00:52:274 (5,1) - spacing too small
00:52:785 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - jump without flow here.. I think you can change sequence on some circles Changed pattern a bit
01:22:444 (1,3) - hidden slider ._. It make me stoned the fact you didn't see if you couldn't actually see it...

I have to say , this map need much more work..
diff spread is bad , and some diff play really weird

Byakugan249 wrote:

Yo modding this map because of ur request

Orpheus: -> The notes are on different places ._.
00:06:308(1) - stack it perfectly 00:05:399 (2) -
00:27:317(2) - add a clap at the beginning 00:27:217 (2) -
00:27:889(3) - add a clap at the end 00:27:899 (3) -
00:29:945(5) - add a clap here
00:30:627(1,3) - add a clap at the end Was arleady added though
00:35:399(2) - add a clap
00:59:604(1) - remove the spinner and add notes instead. something like This or something similar to this?


Orthrus(by Armin):
please remove "by armin" on the diff. i understand its by armin but why dont u put it on the uploader comments that armin did the orthrus diff?
00:00:967(2) - can u move it down because its touching the Hp bar? Unless you have some BIG HP bar it don't do so
00:16:990(2) - make it look the same as (1) because IMO it doesnt look nice if 2 consecutive sliders look different
01:10:683(2) - same as 00:00:967 same >:<

Thanatos:
No problems here

Nyx taiko(by [Shalon]):
im not gonna mod the taiko but like at orthrus remove "by [Shalon]" and put it on the uploader comments.

Asura:
00:48:353(7) - NC

Orpheus Telos:
00:39:490(1) - unrankable spinner. it has to reach at least 2k to be rankable Supposedly, they did make the auto spinning velocity as even players can go faster >.<,,, yeah, did OD-1 instead, if they change the minium score to the really minium ( I'm not a Insane player neither a perfect hard player, though i can easily 300 this... strange?)

this is the best i can do. GL