Frostings wrote:
Who's going to dictate whether a submission is valid or not? What happens if an Aspire-style map gets the most votes?
Also if this gets 100 submissions, how can you ensure people are gonna bother voting at all, let alone voting fairly?
True. I think it will be hard to have fair vote.
DraciuZ wrote:
Here is the simulation of this contest :
i am certain it will turns out to be something like this
but
are you sure?Osu!Standard :
-Easy > Winner : UnknownUser(HH)
-Normal > Winner : EZMapper-(AAC)
-Hard > Winner : VeteranGuy(FGD)
-Insane > Winner : D(r)umbass
-Extra > Winner : ETMapper(XY)
Taiko :
-Kantan > Winner : EZMapper-(KD)
-Futsuu > Winner : D(r)umbass
-Muzukashii > Winner : VeteranGuy(FGD)
-Oni > Winner : ETMapper(TK)
-Inner Oni > Winner : EZMapper-(AAC)
CatchTheBeat :
-Cup > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-Salad > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-Platter > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-Rain > winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-Overdose > Winner : EzMapper-(AAC)
Osu!Mania :
.
.
.
.
.
OSU!MANIA !!!!!! :
4K
-EZ > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
-NM > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
-HD > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-IN > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
-EX > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
5K
-EZ > Winner : 5KChick(B)
-NM > Winner : 9KDude(F)
-HD > Winner : 9KDude(F)
-IN > Winner : 5KChick(B)
-EX > Winner : 5KChick(B)
6K
-EZ > Winner : UnknownUser(HH)
-NM > Winner : 6Kzzz(C)
-HD > Winner : 6Kzzz(C)
-IN > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-EX > Winner : 6Kzzz(C)
7K
-EZ > Winner : 7KGuy(D)
-NM > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
-HD > Winner : 4KGuy(A)
-IN > Winner : 9KDude(F)
-EX > Winner : 7KGuy(D)
8K
-EZ > Winner : 8KLady(E)
-NM > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-HD > Winner : 8KLady(E)
-IN > Winner : 8KLady(E)
-EX > Winner : 8KLady(E)
9K
-EZ > Winner : CTBMasta(GOD)
-NM > Winner : 9KDude(F)
-HD > Winner : 8KLady(E)
-IN > Winner : UnknownUser(HH)
-EX > Winner : 9KDude(F)
Let us take example on random user i called "CTBMasta(GOD)"
that user wins 8 times out of 2 gamemode
is this contest turns out to be like this? i did not see any problem
but it seems it will be lots of trouble for osu!mania category.
What about this? Why not restrict keymode to only 4 and 7 as major popularity. I doubt other key will have a 'fair' voting upon this category.