1. Hard (4.6 stars, 347 notes)
2. Normal (2.87 stars, 201 notes)
3. Roko-Don's Taiko (5 stars, 1114 notes)
4. Ultimate Spark (4.77 stars, 630 notes)

aevv wrote:

found both insanes boring compared to tkillers, felt like the spacing and streams were just placed randomly

Shiirn wrote:

aevv wrote:

found both insanes boring compared to tkillers, felt like the spacing and streams were just placed randomly

I'm not going for absurdity.

aevv wrote:

or fun?

[zelos]
01:29:945 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - im not a fan of this pattern but could go either way on it
^same to the horizontal mirror of it
01:59:162 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - stream doesnt fit here at all
02:09:727 (5) and onwards double spacing for no real reason, considering how there are already a couple large jump sections in the song and how easy the same beat leading toward it is, doesnt fit at all to me, might even say absurd? ^_^
02:26:423 (5) - ^same

overall the consistency of difficulty is bad imo This is for zelos to deal with.

[spark]
01:17:423 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - i try and i try but i cant see how, from both playing it and listening to it how a 1/4 stream works here, plays and sounds dumb to me
^ same applies to all other sections a 1/4 stream is on the same sound Noted and denied.

rest was easy and unexciting

thx cya

1. Fix the tags tab in all diffs. It should contain guest diff's creators.

1. Stack leniency is set to 0.4 on this diff. Either match it with other diffs or make other diffs match this one.
2. 02:33:597 - Two timing sections around this point, one of them is unnecessary. End the kiai here and make one of them sit on this timeline and remove the other one.
3. 02:34:640 - After this point your timing sections aren't snapped correctly.
4. 02:54:466 - Around this point also 2 timing sections where one is completely unnecessary.

1. General: This diff has lots of "lazy" sliders. Tripoint and stretched so they look shabby. Ignore this if you wish though, it's just my inner nitpick self talking here.
2. 01:16:249 - Add a note here. If you feel that you shouldn't have continuous note bashing, remove slider 01:14:032 (8) and add a circle instead, leaving a hole before the next combo or remove a circle 01:18:336 (10).
3. 01:43:510 - 02:00:205 - I recommend using slower sliders for this section. 0.5 or 0.75.
4. 01:57:075 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Use soft soundset for this imo. This doesn't really fit.
5. 02:00:205 (1) - Use whistle instead of a finish. That finish isn't noticeable at all and makes it sound empty, unlike the whisle which was used here quite alot.
6. 02:33:532 - This timing section serves no purpose. Remove it. You can remove the kiai on next one.
7. 02:34:640 - This volume change makes the spinner "explode" while spinning. A bit startling, suggesting to remove it.
8. 02:41:814 - Add a note here. Same deal as above.
9. 02:54:466 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17) - I suggest to remove this completely and make a DRRRRRR slider instead. 230 bpm 1/4 stream is too hard if you ask me, unless you're tkiller.

1. 00:44:036 (4) - I think new combo would be better here than on the next note. It makes it easier to read due to color change and it's a big white tick (also a new music section starts here).
2. 00:52:036 (4) - Similar reason (big white tick, music) for a new combo here.
3. 01:02:703 (7) - ^
4. 02:33:532 - This timing section is unnecessary. You can end the kiai on the next one which is just next to this one. If you think you want to end kiai right at this spot, then you can delete the section next to this since it doesn't really change anything.
5. 02:53:945 (4,1) - (nazi) 1 grid right.

1. 00:28:036 - 00:38:036 - This section has only default hit sound. Ignore this if this is intentional, else I suggest whistles just like you were using them until this point, or to make it different add it in the first and the fourth white tick.
2. 02:14:814 - 02:23:162 - Same deal as above. Disregard the 1st and 4th tick suggestion though.
3. 02:33:597, 02:33:629 - Two timing sections here, just like in the other 2 diffs I mentioned. Delete one of them, I suggest to delete the one at 02:33:629.
4. 02:34:640 - There should be a timing section here instead of at 02:34:673. Not a huge deal but it does change the volume 1/8 too late.
5. 02:35:684 - Also, put the timing section which is almost 1/8 late on this point. This one is a big deal because it messes up your custom hitsound setup.

lolcubes wrote:

As usual, green stuff = ignore if you wish, cosmetic opinions and nazi.

[General]:

1. Fix the tags tab in all diffs. It should contain guest diff's creators.

Also added the source music.

[Ultimate Spark]:

1. Stack leniency is set to 0.4 on this diff. Either match it with other diffs or make other diffs match this one.
2. 02:33:597 - Two timing sections around this point, one of them is unnecessary. End the kiai here and make one of them sit on this timeline and remove the other one.
3. 02:34:640 - After this point your timing sections aren't snapped correctly.
4. 02:54:466 - Around this point also 2 timing sections where one is completely unnecessary.

All fixed.

[Zelos]:

1. General: This diff has lots of "lazy" sliders. Tripoint and stretched so they look shabby. Ignore this if you wish though, it's just my inner nitpick self talking here.
2. 01:16:249 - Add a note here. If you feel that you shouldn't have continuous note bashing, remove slider 01:14:032 (8) and add a circle instead, leaving a hole before the next combo or remove a circle 01:18:336 (10).
3. 01:43:510 - 02:00:205 - I recommend using slower sliders for this section. 0.5 or 0.75.
4. 01:57:075 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Use soft soundset for this imo. This doesn't really fit.
5. 02:00:205 (1) - Use whistle instead of a finish. That finish isn't noticeable at all and makes it sound empty, unlike the whisle which was used here quite alot.
6. 02:33:532 - This timing section serves no purpose. Remove it. You can remove the kiai on next one.
7. 02:34:640 - This volume change makes the spinner "explode" while spinning. A bit startling, suggesting to remove it.
8. 02:41:814 - Add a note here. Same deal as above.
9. 02:54:466 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17) - I suggest to remove this completely and make a DRRRRRR slider instead. 230 bpm 1/4 stream is too hard if you ask me, unless you're tkiller.

[Hard]:

1. 00:44:036 (4) - I think new combo would be better here than on the next note. It makes it easier to read due to color change and it's a big white tick (also a new music section starts here).
2. 00:52:036 (4) - Similar reason (big white tick, music) for a new combo here.
3. 01:02:703 (7) - ^
4. 02:33:532 - This timing section is unnecessary. You can end the kiai on the next one which is just next to this one. If you think you want to end kiai right at this spot, then you can delete the section next to this since it doesn't really change anything.
5. 02:53:945 (4,1) - (nazi) 1 grid right.

All of the above done.

[Normal]:

1. 00:28:036 - 00:38:036 - This section has only default hit sound. Ignore this if this is intentional, else I suggest whistles just like you were using them until this point, or to make it different add it in the first and the fourth white tick.
2. 02:14:814 - 02:23:162 - Same deal as above. Disregard the 1st and 4th tick suggestion though.
3. 02:33:597, 02:33:629 - Two timing sections here, just like in the other 2 diffs I mentioned. Delete one of them, I suggest to delete the one at 02:33:629.
4. 02:34:640 - There should be a timing section here instead of at 02:34:673. Not a huge deal but it does change the volume 1/8 too late.
5. 02:35:684 - Also, put the timing section which is almost 1/8 late on this point. This one is a big deal because it messes up your custom hitsound setup.

All of the above fixed, the timing sections were due to an offset issue.

Just ignore stuff you don't want to change (nazi for example) but I do think most of the stuff needs changing.
\o

aevv wrote:

found both insanes boring compared to tkillers, felt like the spacing and streams were just placed randomly

lolcubes wrote:

As usual, green stuff = ignore if you wish, cosmetic opinions and nazi.

[Zelos]:

1. General: This diff has lots of "lazy" sliders. Tripoint and stretched so they look shabby. Ignore this if you wish though, it's just my inner nitpick self talking here.
2. 01:16:249 - Add a note here. If you feel that you shouldn't have continuous note bashing, remove slider added a note. it did sound kind of better. 01:14:032 (8) and add a circle instead, leaving a hole before the next combo or remove a circle 01:18:336 (10).
3. 01:43:510 - 02:00:205 - I recommend using slower sliders for this section. 0.5 or 0.75. why?
4. 01:57:075 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Use soft soundset for this imo. This doesn't really fit. i think shiirns hitsound sections are just fine.
5. 02:00:205 (1) - Use whistle instead of a finish. That finish isn't noticeable at all and makes it sound empty, unlike the whisle which was used here quite alot. i did try this at one point and it didn't sound pretty at all.
6. 02:33:532 - This timing section serves no purpose. Remove it. You can remove the kiai on next one. i shall leave that up to shiirn
7. 02:34:640 - This volume change makes the spinner "explode" while spinning. A bit startling, suggesting to remove it. ^Same
8. 02:41:814 - Add a note here. Same deal as above. okoi.
9. 02:54:466 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,17) - I suggest to remove this completely and make a DRRRRRR slider instead. 230 bpm 1/4 stream is too hard if you ask me, unless you're tkiller.

I would if i could break the BPM slider speed up rule. also my non-streamy self hit that stream just fine.

Just ignore stuff you don't want to change (nazi for example) but I do think most of the stuff needs changing.
\o

Mystearica wrote:

Maps aren't ranked based on how good they are anyway.

Zelos wrote:

[*]01:43:510 - 02:00:205 - I recommend using slower sliders for this section. 0.5 or 0.75. why?

aevv wrote:

found both insanes boring compared to tkillers, felt like the spacing and streams were just placed randomly

lolcubes wrote:

Zelos wrote:

[*]01:43:510 - 02:00:205 - I recommend using slower sliders for this section. 0.5 or 0.75. why?

Because that section is kinda quiet and having sliders of standard speed feels a bit brutal to me. Don't worry about it though, I'm just saying what I think here, it's not wrong or anything. :3

aevv wrote:

Mystearica wrote:

Maps aren't ranked based on how good they are anyway.

Zelos wrote:

You have yet to actually get a ranked map and some actual kudosu to be posting that aevv.

Now go away.

Zelos wrote:

You have yet to actually get a ranked map and some actual kudosu to be posting that aevv.

Now go away.

Natteke wrote:

At least credit TKiller for using bg and mp3 from his map ???
Also I suggest using AR9 on Ultimate Spark because clusterfucks of circles and sliders are ugly.