Moralities around skinning.

posted
Total Posts
4
Topic Starter
Faunsce
So what are your guys's morals around skinning. What will you skin, what will you not. Is it wrong to borrow skinning ideas even if credit is given. Ripping one or two skin elements especially the tough ones for brand new skinners such as sounds, is that wrong with credit given(In General ignoring if they say it is ok for borrowing but more or less the idea around it)?
Railey2
borrowing ideas is always fine unless they are 1:1 replicas. It is very hard in general to be creative without deriving a lot from other sources, be it on purpose or subconsciously. The same applies to making skins in osu. Giving credit when you were inspired by other skins is nice, but not a necessity in my opinion.

Now if you take components of a skin and copy paste them from the original folder into your own one, then that is a different issue, especially when the person who made it wants it to not be meddled with. Thats the only thing that is not ok to me. Everything else flies.
Kheryo
About "borrowing ideas", I'm fine with that.
This is how we move forward, there's no shame in using ideas or concepts you've seen in other skins if you feel that they really improve the experience. It's actually a good thing since that idea/concept will reach more people through your skin, be reused, and eventually become the new norm. (eg : blank sliderendcircle. This wasn't that much of a thing 2-3 years ago but is one of the best changes I've seen since)

Regarding your next point, pretty much everyone uses the same sounds in one way or another, especially hitsounds. These are hard to come by and even harder to create from scratch, only a few skinners can claim sounds as originally of their creation.

Credit : If you use or intend to use a skin element from another skin, ask the creator for permission or look for permission info in his skin post.
If he's okay with it, just go for it and mention him in the credits. Messaging him about it is always nice even if permission is given in his post.
Mentioning people who inspire you with their skinning practices, ideas and concepts is also a good thing. It warms up the community and stuff.

Also, no mixed skins. Strive to keep it >90% original in terms of image files, and you should be fine.
Topic Starter
Faunsce
Thanks guys!
Please sign in to reply.

New reply