1. Tatsujin (6,62 stars, 1949 notes)

G U N D A L A
Putra Petir

Skull Kid wrote:

quick mod because i have to do my homework
i'll re-mod this tomorrow (or in another day)

mod

00:09:618 (9) - k its differ
00:09:772 - add d
00:09:926 (10) - k
00:10:080 (11) - d
00:10:234 (12) - k
00:10:849 - add d
00:11:003 (15) - k
00:11:464 (18) - k
00:12:541 (24,25,27) - delete
00:12:695 (24) - k
00:13:003 (26) - d
00:13:157 - add d
00:15:311 (38,39) - d d
00:15:926 (42) - d
00:17:003 - kiai?? yeh, its problem?
01:14:849 (259,260,261) - wtf this triplet this too over? ok
01:35:695 (395) - d I think fine, the drum is rather loud
01:57:849 (3) - d its snare, I like to keep this
01:58:388 (7) - d same reason on 1:35
why this note here 00:37:311 (34) - is D and 01:58:541 (8) - is K? you dont see the differ? 01:58:541 - bcus here I emphasized the Guitar
02:13:926 (96,97,98) - wtf this triplet² ups
02:34:772 (229) - d
02:42:080 (6,7,8) - kkd
02:42:849 - finish the kiai here no, 02:53:926 - here is fine. its catchy to get turnover of music
03:38:234 - kiai?? pls, this part suit with kiai imo
05:01:311 (12) - finish the kiai here same reason 2:42
05:11:926 (2) - delete no no, guitar pls

Remus wrote:

Hello from my queue o/ \(`L_`

Tatsujin

1. 01:21:772 (307,308) - what about making triple here, not 01:21:926 (308,310) here? I think 01:21:926 (308,309,310) - flow already good at here, synthesis of gitar catchy imo
2. 01:55:080 (89) - maybe don to emphasize 90 ? the flow increasing from 01:53:157 - this 3plet, so that 01:55:003 - at here is dkk ( I think the flow goes up lel )
3. 02:08:234 (62) - don to better rhytm. yes, but I prefer to keep this as kat to still emphasized the snare drum
4. 02:14:388 (99) - you can make gap here to balance density at this part. rearranged and 01:15:311 - here too
5. 02:34:695 (225) - what about kat here? no, dkd enough emphasized the drum
6. 03:06:849 (160,170) - kdkdkdkdkdk will be better cause it will be easier to read/play, sounds almost as you did. yep, 03:07:157 - but from here the flow of guitar started differ
7. 03:21:541 (33) - kat maybe? Looks symmetric then and easier to read. Sounds(for me) as you did. but the sound not really strong as kat imo, example: 03:06:618 -
8. 03:49:234 (3) - you can put here don. oh yes, it sounds clear
9. 04:37:157 (59,60,61) - kkd to emphasize 61. eh no.. 61 is snare lol

Oh, hope i helped a little.
Dragonforce maps are always good
Good luck!

1. Maybe try 80%-90% volume, a bit quieter hitsounds sound better imo.
2. 00:00:388 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) sounds better as D ddK kkD, 00:01:311 is a very strong cymbal and drum sounds of 00:01:003 (2,3) are lower than 00:03:772 (11,12)
3. Maybe try 00:04:388 (14,18) ctrl+g, guitar feels stronger on the second one
4. I think 00:08:541 (4) would work better as d, guitar within 00:08:234 (2,3,4,5) goes lower on 00:08:541 (4).
5. 00:30:849 (148,149,150,151,152) kdkkd or so would sound better as the stream at 00:31:772 sounds a bit similar, and for the high guitar on 00:31:311.
6. I think you should change all finishes starting from 02:49:772 (33) until 02:53:464 to D and change 02:53:926 to K, this could work well for the strong cymbal on 02:53:926. If you listen carefully, the sound goes down a bit from 02:49:311 to 02:49:772, so D could work well here.
7. Maybe add d on 04:02:234 or 04:04:080 etc. for example, I think you should do something to not leave 04:05:926 (1,2,3,4) standing on its own, adding a few notes of similar structure would be good to make it fit in better. You could also have dkdd patterns with similar spacing around it, for example 04:02:234 d and 04:02:926 k and 04:03:618 d and 04:04:080 d and maybe a similar pattern starting at 04:09:618.
8. You could try 03:47:695 (274,275) ctrl+g and 03:48:464 (284,285) ctrl+g as well, I think if parts like 03:47:772 (275,276,277,278) become kdkd it would be a nice accent for the guitar in this stream.

snowball112 wrote:

Heya, mod from PM request. yo

Tatsujin

1. Maybe try 80%-90% volume, a bit quieter hitsounds sound better imo. oeg, 90%
2. 00:00:388 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) sounds better as D ddK kkD, 00:01:311 is a very strong cymbal and drum sounds of 00:01:003 (2,3) are lower than 00:03:772 (11,12) I follow the drum
3. Maybe try 00:04:388 (14,18) ctrl+g, guitar feels stronger on the second one ye
4. I think 00:08:541 (4) would work better as d, guitar within 00:08:234 (2,3,4,5) goes lower on 00:08:541 (4). niicceee
5. 00:30:849 (148,149,150,151,152) kdkkd or so would sound better as the stream at 00:31:772 sounds a bit similar, and for the high guitar on 00:31:311. I didnt realize this.. why kdddk cuz 00:31:157 - this drum I guess snaer.. o dem me based drum mapping. fixed
6. I think you should change all finishes starting from 02:49:772 (33) until 02:53:464 to D and change 02:53:926 to K, this could work well for the strong cymbal on 02:53:926. If you listen carefully, the sound goes down a bit from 02:49:311 to 02:49:772, so D could work well here. 02:49:772 - , 02:53:464 - , and 02:53:926 - . I changed these
7. Maybe add d on 04:02:234 or 04:04:080 etc. for example, I think you should do something to not leave 04:05:926 (1,2,3,4) standing on its own, adding a few notes of similar structure would be good to make it fit in better. You could also have dkdd patterns with similar spacing around it, for example 04:02:234 d and 04:02:926 k and 04:03:618 d and 04:04:080 d and maybe a similar pattern starting at 04:09:618. I doubt about these, bcus theyare just fading sound.. drain time still safe pls... okok, I try this.. *04:02:234 - don pattern, 04:05:926 - kat pattern, and next is don. oye, 04:13:311 - Added spinner
8. You could try 03:47:695 (274,275) ctrl+g and 03:48:464 (284,285) ctrl+g as well, I think if parts like 03:47:772 (275,276,277,278) become kdkd it would be a nice accent for the guitar in this stream. ( ^_J^)b

Good luck

rew0825 wrote:

Hi from My Modding Queue. yo

[ Tatsujin]

1. 00:04:695 (15,16) - How about change these to d I follow the drum and I think guitar already fits it
2. 00:12:772 (27) - Delete? 00:12:541 - I Delete this, and make the current stream as kkdd
3. 00:57:464 (156,157) - Ctrl+g and How about change 00:58:695 (165,166,167,168,169,170) - all of it to d I did ctrl g but I dont change thats all to don.. I like to keep snaredrum as kat
4. 01:14:003 (253) - move to 01:13:541 i heard sound of drum high than 01:14:003 I think is correct, its follow drum and guitar. try to 01:13:926 (252,253,254) - delete these and hear the music lel xd
5. 02:12:618 - add note? yes, nice catchhhh !1!!
6. 05:03:618 (15,16,17,18,19,20,21) - How about change it to k all? nice but I want make comparison with 05:06:849 - this drum.. so I keep them as don

So short mods TwT Good luck <3 but its help me <<<<<<333333 thanks

gaston_2199 wrote:

Hi Surono!
Mod from my queue helo too, thx come here

[Tatsujin]

1. 00:12:541 - Add d no, because I'd like 00:12:618 - flow of guitar start from here
2. 00:33:772 (9) - Remove? hmm no. I hear that guitar, 00:33:849 - maybe I can make 3plet but this enough with 1/2 pattern lol
3. 02:49:311 (32) - D v
4. 02:50:541 (36) - d v
5. 02:51:311 (39) - d v
6. 02:53:003 (48) - D ^ no for all, most of them is snare drum. so thats why I keep with kat for consistency. but 02:53:464 - why I make this D? bcus I feels its different impact with others on this part
7. 02:57:618 (70,71,72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80,81,82,83,84,85,86,87,88) - I suggest follow the battery, but no matter if you want to leave as it is its fine, I dont think thats nice idea.... :'D
8. 03:00:541 (89,90,91) - ddd high drum, I prefer song than making style
9. 03:02:926 - Add d its just a flow, not a beat
10. 03:03:272 (116) - Move to 03:03:311 I think this snap notes is correct with the sound
11. 03:03:695 - Add d same reason at 03:02:926 -
12. 03:04:195 (124) - Move to 03:04:157 same reason 03:03:272 (116) -
13. 03:04:234 - Add d no...
14. 03:04:926 (132) - Remove? this part is strong flow, I cant do that...
15. 03:19:464 (14,15) - I suggest remove this if you want no, I hear some beats from guitar
16. 04:23:003 (4,6) - d oke for this

Nice song, you have a shoot star. I hope this is ranked. Good luck

Aras25 wrote:

manianya tydac bisa mengegrind
tydac kualitid D:
but the tekos..... take it boiz ╭( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)و

Valentrixe wrote:

srsly .. more df?

RuneHigh wrote:

I have yet to try my hand at modding, but I like making maps so I guess my input can be of... assistance.

When I refer to 0, 1, 2, 3, I am speaking of the key columns of course. (e.g. 01 = first and second keys at the same time. 01- = first and second keys at the same time, held) .....

4K Mods

These mods are note changes/recommendations
01:18:234 (78234|2) - 1
01:18:695 (78695|1) - 0
01:19:157 (79157|2) - 3 I keep these points, bcus I just hear the drum are monotone/same, except from 01:21:772 - the guitar
01:25:311 (85311|1,85311|0,85311|3) - Make this a 013- to the 12 I hear strong sound..
01:49:464 (109464|1,109464|2) - 023
01:49:618 (109618|2,109618|3) - 013 I think 2notes is enough
02:12:388 (132388|0) - 3-
02:12:541 (132541|3) - 0 oke for these, I heard the differ from previous LN

These mods are detailed changes that will enhance the song's... flow
03:42:849 (222849|0,222849|1,222849|1) - This 01 should be changed to, potentially 0- with a light stream on the open 3 keys, or 01- with a couple of notes on 2 and 3. It flows better with the music. .. hmm, those sounds are faint
04:11:080 (251080|2) - the timing in this section feels weird in the editor, but seemingly okay during my playtesting. This one, however, is rather glaring. It hits a bit early. just say it, maek new layers sounds from 04:05:926 - this every single notes. yeah early but idk. I bookmarkd these LNs like singlenotes sounds.
04:24:388 (264388|0,264388|3) to 04:25:311 (265311|0,265311|3) - Consider changing that pattern. Feels a bit overused. nothing to be worried in here...

I have also gone through and made a few more edits that were a bit too large to timestamp and whatnot, but I'll just briefly describe them here:
Fixed a few general pattern issues in the solo and pre-solo.
Some very minor timing issues (not including the one detailed above).
Modified some notes to make certain streams more consistent. some people will say randomness, more consistent will say boring. I think I did neat structure but idk wat points which had inconsistent parts. maybe solo parts..

Link to download my edits: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/533654113/ShareX/2016/11/DragonForce%20-%20Cry%20Thunder.osz

Overall I want to say how well your map plays for not having been modded (from what I can tell) for 4K. However, one, rather large, issue I came across was that the difficulty of parts that were not the solo did not match that of the solos - tl;dr the solo is much harder than the rest of the song. Normally that's 100% okay, but the gap between earlier parts of the song and the solo are large, to say the least. it is song, blame Herman Li is Cool

04:25:311 (265311|0,265311|3) - In the version of the map that I edited, this is an example of some ways to increase difficulty in certain areas. The goal is to make the whole song match up, with a harder section sticking out. Don't be afraid to use 3 keys at a time! For a song of this difficulty, the audience that is going to be passing it will be able to handle 3-key streams in small bursts. I will try to look it, thank you!

Okay, I have done this for a bit now and I have mentioned quite a few things. If you have any questions or anything, feel free to let me know. I will keep looking at your map and helping however I can. I REALLY like it thusfar and I can't wait to see it once more experienced modders get a look at it.