Nao Tomori wrote:

e

Sonnyc wrote:

General.
-- SliderBorder isn't set, while there is a custom hitcircleoverlay skin being used. I always forget that mb
-- 01:23:663 - Is it only me who feels there is a weird increase of volume inside the mp3? Considering the overall quality of the mp3 being quite fine enough, this was really annoying to happen. I have no idea how to adjust that.

Beginner.
I strongly doubt if this difficulty is really in need. Every rhythms are in a 2/1 gap, which didn't really feel to be reflecting this song nicely enough. It just felt way too simplified to be a part of this map. Besides, the existing easy is beginner friendly enough. No need for an additional beginner diff which is just easy for the sake of being easy. I will disagree here. I want there to be an aentry level diffiuclty because this song is slow enough for it to be mapped without it being under mapped. It still captures the main rhythm and slider shapes like 00:02:794 (1) - and 01:05:402 (1) - help compliment the rhythm. Additionally, I think Osu! needs a lot more quality noob friendly material. I would've loved to have something like this when I just started out.

Easy.
00:07:141 (2) - If you look at the pattern usage, you were expressing 00:06:272 (1,2,3) as the same as 00:02:794 (1,2,3). However if you compare this part of the song with 00:03:663 (2), the instrument in the song is slightly weaker. Using the same pattern while the music being different wasn't good in properly reflecting the song. Structure issue. Also considering that you have left 00:14:098 - 00:19:315 - 00:26:272 empty, which was really similar in sound with 00:07:141, removing this object would make much sense. I don't understand what I'm supposed to change. Easy is very limited as to what you can map and how you do it, and I think I did a fine job. Can you please elaborate further?

Normal.
00:06:707 (2) - Questionable rhythm selection along the song. This was the only slider that the end being muted, but considering there were several similar sections like this in the song, just expressing here that way felt to be inconsistent a lot. It's just for variety. Other sections the same sound were mapped different ways, and this just happened to be the only one that called for a timing point. It's not like this is the only other way I mapped this sound.

Doyak wrote:

I took a brief look at this map as Sonnyc showed me, and the main problem with the Beginner diff I think is that it has too little rhythm variety to show the song's changes. The 1/3rd beats are indeed most important beats, but that doesn't mean these beats show any kind of properties that this specific music has. Literally 90% of other songs out there can also be represented only with 1/3rd beats, or even with the 1st beats only, if you only prioritize the most important ones with such a low intensity, but that doesn't mean the map represents how the song really sounds like. There are rhythm patterns that this specific music only has, and I think you could try to represent them more while keeping this intensity. If not, then maybe this diff is just too easy to represent this music at least to a certain point.

Nao Tomori wrote:

http://puu.sh/tThYF/aabd76932f.jpg me irl tbh

i dont need to wait 24 hrs after dq if thats what u think lo

Nao Tomori wrote:

http://puu.sh/tThYF/aabd76932f.jpg me irl tbh

i dont need to wait 24 hrs after dq if thats what u think lo

Ongaku wrote:

Because there are timing issues, I will be timing the map. Give me 2-3 days, given if school doesnt fuck me over.

Ongaku wrote:

http://puu.sh/tXIgu/97e53f5d20.txt

here you go

the timing is relative to the piano, so yea.

Nao Tomori wrote:

ok so ongaku says the timing is fine so

changed some custom stacking

1. 00:02:817 (1) - unsnapped
2. 01:31:513 - unsnapped line

1. 00:02:823 (1) - unsnapped

ezek wrote:

You should always check the map with AiMod and MA before updating for an icon to avoid this :v

Nao Tomori wrote:

dang i checked it before he updated.. dunno why didnt show up

ezek wrote:

Nao Tomori wrote:

dang i checked it before he updated.. dunno why didnt show up

Because you have to check after he updates, Polka is the one who has to check before he updates :p

ezek wrote:

OwO

Nao Tomori wrote:

qualified

Pachiru wrote:

What a cool song ! Congratz ! :3