MBmasher wrote:

thzz's Insane

00:17:534 (4,1) - blanket okay

nice diff thanks :3

[ Lilu ] wrote:

thzz's Insane

SPOILER

00:10:534 (5,2) - Blanket 5 around the slider end of 2? i like current one~

00:12:534 (2) - maybe don't have this angled up, as it goes against the flow and is a bit off putting dropping down flow. as well as 00:12:867 (3,4) -

00:30:367 (4,5) - overlap these all overlap things are made with 0.5x distance. also i think such overlaps are good for aesthetics since those overlap makes various placement with a regularity.

00:40:034 (3,1) - the way 3 overlaps the end of 1 is kind of messy, maybe make it a complete overlap, or blanket it with 1.

00:44:034 (4,1) - overlap?

00:50:367 (2,3,4) - Possibly reduce the space from 2 to 3, its really awkward to play and doesn't really look good either. same as this -> 00:49:034 (1,2,3) -

01:28:451 (1) - extend the slider until the end of the piano sound? i'll compare with other diffs

[ Sharuresu ] wrote:

thzz's insane

00:05:701 (1,2) - ctrl g should be better
00:11:034 (1,2) - ^ both slider heads are emphasizing strong piano sound. current one sounds better for me~
Good diff, maybe spacing too high for an insane thx~ then several say same thing, so i changed diff's name

[ Sharuresu ] wrote:

Hey m4m from your queue

[General]
For overlap please disable hitanimations

Easy

00:05:700 - make this clickable done
00:12:367 (1,2,3,4) - looks ugly, maybe because these objects are too clos, 00:12:367 (1,2) - try to make a blanket with the end of 00:12:867 (2) - and 00:12:367 (1) - Changed in a different way
00:21:367 (2,3) - too close Changed some things, but DS is always the same, so it has the same distance.
01:11:700 (2,3) - you should do something like this http://puu.sh/spxaz/1041f2261d.jpg yeah, much better
01:15:034 (3,4) - better blanket plzfixed

Normal

00:06:534 - make this clickable done
00:09:034 (2,1) - better blanket done
00:15:700 (2) - what are you following Hmm, can't really tell xD, changed a bit
00:21:034 (2) - ^ Changed
00:43:034 (1) - stack this with 00:41:700 (1) - or move 00:44:367 (1) - a bit down to get the same spacing fixed
00:45:367 (4,2) - bad overlap fixed
00:55:700 (2,1) - ^fixed
01:01:700 (4,5) - ^ fixed

Hard

00:06:450 (4) - overmapped fixed
00:08:867 (5,7) - bad overlap fixed
00:11:950 (10) - overmapped changed
00:12:367 (1,2,2) - bad overlap fixed
00:16:200 - you should map this sound fixed
00:22:367 (5) - what are you following, replace 00:22:201 (4) - with 00:22:367 (5) - changed in another way
00:26:367 (6,7,8) - mmh you should follow the same rythme that 00:25:701 (4,5) -, place two slider instead of 00:26:367 (6,7,8) - done
00:28:867 - place a circle there done
00:31:534 - ^ done
00:54:701 (4,2) - bad overlapfixed
01:22:200 - place a circle there and delete 01:22:367 (2) -Changed, but kept a note at 01:22:534 -

Insane

00:02:867 (5) - you should delete this one to emphasize 00:03:034 (1) - true, fixed
00:05:700 (1,4,5,6) - too close changed
00:08:784 (3) - overmapped Changed
00:10:367 (3,3) - stack done
00:11:367 (2,6) - blanket done
00:14:617 (3) - overmapped changed
00:15:534 (3,4) - slider reverse here should fit better True, changed
00:15:034 (1,5) - stack done
00:20:867 (3,4) - fix blanket please done
00:22:200 (3,5) - bad overlap lol, fixed
01:05:200 (5,1) - fix blanket fixed

End of the world

00:15:534 (2,1) - ctrl g ? no
00:01:201 (1,2) - bad overlap fixed
00:02:200 (3,3) - stack done
00:04:367 (1,6) - ^ done
00:34:034 (3,1) - too close fixed
00:34:200 (4,2) - stack done

Good luck for ranking ! plz mod this https://osu.ppy.sh/s/511505

CuteFunnyCat wrote:

Hi im from the mod que.

Easy:
00:06:034 (4,1) - Fix blanket.

Spacing issues:
Spacing must be around 1.
00:01:700 (1,2) -Spacing difference.
00:03:034 (3,4) - ^
00:05:367 (2,3) - ^
00:06:034 (4,1) - ^
00:08:367 (2,3) - ^
00:16:367 (3,1) - ^
00:24:034 (2,3) - ^
00:25:367 (4,1) - ^
00:25:700 (1,2) - ^
00:40:367 (3,1) - ^
00:50:034 (1,2) - ^
00:51:034 (2,1) - ^
01:01:700 (1,2) - ^
01:02:700 (2,3) - ^
01:04:034 (4,5) - ^
01:05:367 (6,1) - ^
01:17:700 (1,2) - ^ So much spacing difference, I almost remapped ;-;

Normal:

Spacing Issues:
00:13:367 (3,1) - Spacing difference
00:15:034 (1,2) - Spacing difference and why did you change your spacing from start that was 1 to 0,8 and 0,9.
00:27:700 (5,1) - ^
00:30:700 (5,1) - ^
00:33:700 (1,2) - ^
00:35:700 (4,1) - ^
00:37:700 (1,2) - ^
00:39:700 (5,1) - ^
00:47:034 (1,2) - ^
00:49:034 (4,1) - ^
00:51:034 (3,1) - ^
01:02:367 (5,1) - ^
01:09:034 (5,1) - ^
01:11:034 (1,2) - ^
01:12:367 (3,4) - ^
01:13:367 (5,1) - ^
01:20:700 (3,4) - ^

Overlap Issues:
01:02:367 (5,3) - Overlap.
01:06:367 (5,3) - ^ Made many changes here too, so everything prob fixed

Hard:

Overlap Issues:
00:21:867 (3,2) - Overlap.
00:30:700 (9,3) - ^
00:31:701 (2,6) - ^
00:54:200 (2,4) - ^
01:00:867 (4,6) - ^ Overlap that might make things messy. everything fixed


01:13:867 (1,1) - This spinner is a little to close gap should be one white tick. took slider off

01:16:367 (1) - hmm if you lower this one a little https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6634053 like this. changed

That it for my mod hope it helped.

Astarte wrote:

Hi! From turtle's queue, even though it's closed xd
well... been long since I last mod anyway

Modding ENH as requested~

Easy

You have a normal, so try to make easy as easy as possible, i'll point out a few below
I'd use CS 2.5
AR 3 is fine for easy, but this is a relatively fast bpm, i'd recommend 3.5 - 4 Only changed CS to 2.8 and AR to 3.5

1. 00:06:034 (4,1) - watch your aesthetics, it's important for easier diffs Yes ;-; fixed
2. 00:10:950 (4) - did you make a mistake placing this? Totally, lool, fixed
3. 00:12:367 (1,2,3) - not recommended, 1/2 beats with this fast bpm is not good for easy. I'd make a repeat slider that repeats here 00:12:867 - still map that guitar like your pattern, but more suitable for an easy changed
4. 00:14:367 (5,1) - ^ I wouldn't stack in an easy changed
5. 00:15:034 (1,2) - this is quite hard to play, i'd say this 00:15:367 - is better to be released, not clickable (like what you did here 00:17:700 (1,2) - is better) changed
6. 00:17:367 - why skip this?changed
7. 00:25:700 (5) - why no NC? Don't know ;-;
8. 00:25:700 - also, starting from there, tension is building up, why you skipped notes like these 00:26:700 - ? You're right, fixed
9. 00:36:367 - then, this is a considerably calmer part, but mapped these 00:37:367 (2) - but not in the previous part? fixed
10. 00:41:700 (1,2) - ermm, don't do this in an easy pls :x changed
11. 00:55:700 (5) - NC every 1st and 3rd big white tick, you're ruining your nc consistency fixed
12. 00:57:700 - why is this downbeat not clickable? yeah, changed
13. 01:00:367 - and why is this released? :/ Changed so many things
14. 01:19:367 (1) - start this spinner here 01:19:034 - to extend its length Can't really understand what you meant
15. 01:28:367 (1) - wayyy too short, even less than 2 seconds. For easy, i'd aim for 4-7s of spin timeChanged

Normal

Not a good idea to have the same CS as easy, either increase this, or decrease easy's, or both xd

1. 00:07:034 (7) - NC downbeats ye fixed
2. 00:03:034 - i'm really not a fan of releasing on downbeats :/changed
3. Your NC consistency? 00:01:700 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,6) - you NC every 1st and 3rd big ticks, then from 00:07:034 - you NC every downbeat? make it consistent fixed
4. 00:24:367 - :/fixed ;-;
5. 00:25:700 (1,2,3) - this is quite bad, I'd just map 1/1 with circles to make it harder/build up tension without making it ugly and hard to read changed
6. 00:34:367 (2,3,4) - they should blanket each other?no
7. 01:06:034 (4,5) - why 1/2 all of the sudden?don't know ;-;

Hard

Like easy, I'd use AR8 for this fast bpm Changed to 7.5

1. 00:04:367 - Maybe for hard 3+ and above, NC every downbeat ok
2. 00:13:367 (1) - why NC thisdunno ;-;
3. 00:17:534 (1) - ^ fixed
4. 00:19:034 (1,2,3,4) - quite unreadable, I wouldn't stack nor use 1/4 beats here changed
5. 00:22:367 (5) - 1/1 slider would fit better changed
6. 00:31:534 (1) - would move this to 00:31:367 - otherwise players would tend to miss changed
7. 00:36:367 - why only circles here? normal/easy is harder at this part :/ and don't NC them You're right, fixed .-.
8. 00:47:534 (4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3) - this flow is quite bad changed a bit
9. 00:50:867 - maybe a circle hereI don't think so
10. 00:51:034 - then here, would start a spinner to 00:52:034 - so it doesn't feel empty ok
11. 00:53:701 (1,2,3) - flows bad :/ true, changed
12. 01:14:867 (1) - i'm questioning this note's existenceYeah xD, fixed

One problem also, is your ending time. Best that you make sure all ending time for (all) diffs to be consistent. ENH are yours, not GDs, so they shouldn't have different start and ending time.

That'd be all from me, gl with your map o/
hope this helps tho

Lily Bread wrote:

as request

[End of the World]
00:36:367 (1) - a 1/1 slider will work better, you can map these vocal.
http://puu.sh/srKCC/22ad812928.jpg

00:42:367 (2,3) - same as above.

01:22:367 (4) - i can't hear music here.

[Insane]
00:17:701 (1,2,3) - this is a obtuse angle jump, usually we use this kind of jump when music is very powerful, because this kind of jump is hard to hit than normal jump.

00:22:367 (4,5) - this flow can be improved:
http://puu.sh/srKVk/db90005f7d.jpg

00:50:450 (3) - this triple should at - 00:50:617 -, you can listen to music.

gl

Liena wrote:

vou modar hoje ou amanhã
pela rápida olhada que eu dei vi que seus hitsounds nas low diffs precisam melhorar muito
tenta dar uma olhada na diff do thzz pra comparar os erros, não que você tenha que copiar mas você tem que ver o que tá fazendo errado principalmente nos clap

Phyloukz wrote:

hi, from #modreqs

Easy

In general the slider velocity feels a bit too quick, i'd recommend smth around 0.8x or 0.7x Changed to 0.9

00:12:367 (1) - this slider is placed with an awkward flow, look at the pic and you get what i mean: thats how it is currently http://puu.sh/su9FK/478ce0363a.jpg and this is with better flow http://puu.sh/su9Kx/1ec91832f5.jpg ; circular flows are always really good for beginners since its the easiest to follow. try to keep that in mind for similiar spotsChanged
00:19:034 (3,1) - slight overlap, aesthetically it doesn look really great, here's a solution that always works in lower diffs: try to make equaliteral triangles like http://puu.sh/su9XS/cb1fadbc4d.jpg for your patterns, it gives a loooooot structure! some spots where you could apply that: 00:23:034 (1,2,3) - 00:55:700 (5,1,2) - Changed some of them
00:24:367 (3) - copy paste it to 00:25:700 - and flip vertically for symmetrychanged
00:25:700 - from that point i disagree with the very simple/boring rhythm http://puu.sh/suadt/c451dd8df0.jpg ; 15 seconds does the 1/1 sliderspam last, you get worned out really fast. I suggest you to add other rhythms. Here's an example beginning at 00:27:034 - you can try this http://puu.sh/suap3/700d5507e3.jpg ok changed
01:06:367 (4,1) - the cursor tends to the reverse arrow after the first slider which isnt good for Easy difficulty, new players getting confused really fast because they follow the easiest flow (the easiest flow would end up hitting the reverse arrow instead of the sliderhead) probably fixed

Hard

00:15:867 (4,1) - what about http://puu.sh/suaxU/0e802b9e3a.jpg to make 00:16:200 - clickable. I think this sound deserves to be clickable.changed
00:25:701 (4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4) - for parts like that i suggest you to use the same distance snap since every beat is the same and nothing gets emphasized there fixed
00:28:034 (4,1) - for spots like that you can slightly increase the distance snap because 00:28:367 - is a really strong downbeat and deserves emphasis with DSchanged
00:29:700 (1) - i think 00:29:867 - should be clickable too because its a strong sound, you can try http://puu.sh/suaM1/3439d9a3ab.jpg (it doesnt look overmapped because you can argue with emphasis for 00:29:867 - and it just fits pretty well to the music) Changed, but not in that way
00:40:034 (6,1) - this needs way more distance snap, currently you have same DS there but 00:40:367 (1) - is very strong sound so it deserves emphasis with DSchanged
00:45:701 (1,2,3) - remember the equaliteral triangle thing i mentioned in my Easy mod, you can basically apply that pattern everywhere to create more structure changed in another way
00:50:534 (7,1) - you can give this more DS because 00:51:034 (1) - is very different from the other sounds changed
01:22:867 - 01:22:950 - missing beats; its a Hard 1/4's should get mapped imo fixed

Insane

00:14:200 (1,2) - i think 1.0x DS is better because 1/4 I don't see any problem with it, it's a insane after all
00:19:034 (1,2,3,4) - i would make that also 1.0x DS instead of stacking, or you stack the thing above. Either way is fine but it should be consistentI like the stacking here
00:22:200 (3,4) - you added here a DS increase for no reason, 00:22:367 (4) - isnt a strong or special sound at all. i recommend u to treat it like the other objects around I don't think is a big problem
00:22:700 (5,1) - bad flow, if you look at where your cursor flows after the first slider you see that it flows to the slidertail of (1).. not really, you can easily go from that slider to the other, I also like the pattern, it's not like they are 1/4
00:29:034 (2) - ctrl + g for flow changed
00:37:700 (1,1) - no need to NC them because they are the same as 00:36:367 (1) - (one NC is enough to let the player know theres a different rhythm coming up). Rather put a NC at 00:39:534 (2,3) - because they are different.
00:41:700 (3,1,2) - here u did it right but add NC at 00:43:034 (3) - too Probably fixed the NCs
00:46:367 (5) - why you suddenly ignore the sounds although you mapped them before? i recommend u to keep the rhythm in that section the same because the vocal (i think thats what u wanted to map with this slider) isnt really getting stronger there. Also for all the triples: Give the player a break and add some 1/4 reverse sliders instead of triples. make sure u do that consitently! lol, it's because that part is a little different, there is a double instead of a triple, so added a slider and a double, won't change triples, this part is not supposed to be easy
01:25:200 (3) - NC I think NC should be here 01:25:534 (1) - so I changed to there
01:25:534 (4) - http://puu.sh/subG5/dce4221deb.jpg would fit better This part should be easy, so I added two circles instead of this
01:27:034 - you ignore this sound with the slider, i recommend u to make it clickable since its noticeable and a downbeat changed

Ask someone experienced to check your timing. I think you need to add some timing points at the end because it looks kinda off for me, but im not an expert xD I don't think is that off, people already tried to take a look at bpm, but in the end I think there's nothing wrong

Thats it for me
Best of luck with your map and happy mapping! (:

1. 00:49:034 (3) - como eu disse na normal, slider em downbeat
2. 00:50:034 (1) - NC
3. rip hitsounds

1. SV tá muito alta aqui recomendo usar 1,1x
2. 00:12:034 (6,1) - 00:14:700 (6,1) - dois tipos de stacks em uma normal confude muito eles, o espaçamento da primeira é de dois ticks enquanto a da segunda é só 1, eles vão tentar clickar do mesmo jeito e vão se confundir.
3. 00:18:200 (2) - esse slider não encaixou bem
4. 00:38:367 (5,6,1) - linha reta na diagonal é doloroso de jogar
5. Não faz sentindo você mapear o vocal e os drums aqui 00:36:367 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - e deixar circulos aqui 00:41:700 (1,1,1) -, recomendo mapear também
6. 00:45:367 (4) - ritmo irregular, evita ao máximo terminar slliders em downbeat por que geralmente é um som forte 00:49:700 (5) - aqui você pode deixar
7. 01:12:367 (3,4,5) - dificl de ler
8. essa diff precisa melhorar muito em questão de ritmo e estética

1. 00:16:200 (5,1) - esse flow é bem ruim de acertar porque não tenta fazer blanket entre 00:16:200 (5,1) -
2. 00:36:367 (1,2,3,4,5) - finish nos sliders
3. 00:49:367 (3) - esse ritmo tá irregular, 00:49:700 - essa nota é muito forte pra ser ignorada então você tem que fazer isso ser clicável
4. 01:06:867 (4) - por que stackou essa nota, uma pattern diferente aqui pode confundir e também você não usou nenhuma vez no kiai
5. 01:13:867 - não tem porque deixar isso vazio, tem alguns drums mapeáveis
6. 01:16:367 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - não tenho certeza sobre esse spam de 1/4 até que passaria se fosse uma normal, você pode tentar outro ritmo
7. Os hitsounds em geral aqui estão muito sem sentido porém você disse que ia arrumar

1. 00:22:367 (4,5,1,2,3) - essa sessão de stacks ficou bem esquisita imo, 00:23:034 (1) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6664446
2. 00:28:867 - adiciona uma nota?
3. 00:42:200 (1,2) - sugiro remover, não faz sentido seguir o vocal aqui o.o
4. 00:44:867 (1,2,3,4) - aumenta o espaçamento um pouquinho pra dar mais ênfase
5. 00:45:367 (1) - essa nota deveria ter um espaçamento maior, não fica legal com esse stack já que é o mesmo espaçamento de 00:44:867 (1,2,3,4) -
6. 00:46:617 (6,7,2,3,4) - overlap feio, que tal mover 00:47:200 (2,3,4) - pra x:185 x:313
7. 01:23:034 (7) - nc?
   

1. 01:06:201 (2,3) - Do you don't think this spacing so big? maybe stack 01:05:201 (5,3) -
2. funny diff

1. 00:13:200 (1) - remove nc
2. 00:13:700 (4) - add nc
3. 00:14:200 (1) - remove nc sv não mudou
4. 00:15:700 (2,3) - você usou slliders no tick branco aqui 00:15:700 (2,3) - e aqui 00:20:867 (3,4) - você usou nos vermelhos na mesma parte do vocal, recomendo fixar pra consistencia
5. 00:52:867 (2,3) - acho que esse spacing tá grande demais reduz um pouco
6. Eu não tenho muitas skills em extra então acho que é só isso pra mim

InfiWong wrote:

random modder here!

End of the World

General comments: Notes are in rhythm, which is good, but i found problems such as flow and aesthetics, and these should be improved for better player's experience.
00:15:534 (1) - remove nc ok
00:16:367 (1) - remove nc again uhm, why?
00:18:534 (5,6,7,8,1) - decrease spacing, since its the part where the start of the music enters. changed
00:44:367 (4) - replace 1/2 slider with note. I'll keep the pattern
00:46:700 (4) - remake slider to make the same as 00:49:367 (4) - to improve consistency.ok
00:52:867 (2,3,4) - this pattern doesn't seem right to me in terms of flowing from the 00:52:867 (2) - to the 00:53:034 (3) - , try make something like this: http://puu.sh/svfvo/46f94e2bfe.jpg yes, changed it
00:53:700 (1,2) - distance inbetween notes are too far, which doesn't go flow with the rhythm itself. I suggest changing it into this style: http://puu.sh/svfCw/c63f9c69e6.jpg lol true, fixed
00:55:034 (1) - remake the slider: http://puu.sh/svfHC/70bd0580ce.jpg I like the way it is
00:57:367 (1) - remove nc ok
01:00:367 (1,2,3) - try changing into another pattern, it's a really bad flow inbetween notes and sliders yeah, changed it
01:01:700 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - no offense but these jumps are really bad and unrankable imo, either change it in a pattern, or add with sliders to improve flow. They're not unrankable, and I like then.
01:08:034 (1) - remove nc changed
01:09:034 (4) - copy paste from 01:08:700 (3) - then do ctrl and > 2 times to make it consistent in notes.fixed
01:12:034 (1) - remove nc again changed
01:12:367 (3) - put nc here changed
01:26:200 (1,2) - I suggest making a small pattern rather than stacking 3 notes at a time.changed
01:28:367 (1) - change to volume to 5%, since the outro becomes quiet and calm. changed

Conclusion: I found out that the main problem here is mostly flow and consistency inbetween notes, although the rhythm follows the music quite well, there are much more to be improved such as using the NCs, the sliders and notes, as well as creating jumps < hardest part on making a beatmap. my suggestion is to go here > https://www.youtube.com/user/Pishifat to learn simple elements in mapping, I hope you can improve that well, and best of luck on your map to be ranked soon!

Liena wrote:

#modreqs

Easy

1. 00:49:034 (3) - como eu disse na normal, slider em downbeat ok
2. 00:50:034 (1) - NC ok
3. rip hitsounds

rip, logo logo arrumo o de todos
Normal

1. SV tá muito alta aqui recomendo usar 1,1x1.15x agr
2. 00:12:034 (6,1) - 00:14:700 (6,1) - dois tipos de stacks em uma normal confude muito eles, o espaçamento da primeira é de dois ticks enquanto a da segunda é só 1, eles vão tentar clickar do mesmo jeito e vão se confundir.ok
3. 00:18:200 (2) - esse slider não encaixou bem ok
4. 00:38:367 (5,6,1) - linha reta na diagonal é doloroso de jogar ok
5. Não faz sentindo você mapear o vocal e os drums aqui 00:36:367 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - e deixar circulos aqui 00:41:700 (1,1,1) -, recomendo mapear também vdd, ok
6. 00:45:367 (4) - ritmo irregular, evita ao máximo terminar slliders em downbeat por que geralmente é um som forte 00:49:700 (5) - aqui você pode deixar ok
7. 01:12:367 (3,4,5) - dificl de ler acho que ta ok
8. essa diff precisa melhorar muito em questão de ritmo e estética

Hard

1. 00:16:200 (5,1) - esse flow é bem ruim de acertar porque não tenta fazer blanket entre 00:16:200 (5,1) - ok
2. 00:36:367 (1,2,3,4,5) - finish nos sliders ok
3. 00:49:367 (3) - esse ritmo tá irregular, 00:49:700 - essa nota é muito forte pra ser ignorada então você tem que fazer isso ser clicável vdd, ok
4. 01:06:867 (4) - por que stackou essa nota, uma pattern diferente aqui pode confundir e também você não usou nenhuma vez no kiaiok
5. 01:13:867 - não tem porque deixar isso vazio, tem alguns drums mapeáveis psé, ok
6. 01:16:367 (1,2,3,4,1,2) - não tenho certeza sobre esse spam de 1/4 até que passaria se fosse uma normal, você pode tentar outro ritmook
7. Os hitsounds em geral aqui estão muito sem sentido porém você disse que ia arrumar

Insane

1. 00:22:367 (4,5,1,2,3) - essa sessão de stacks ficou bem esquisita imo, 00:23:034 (1) - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/6664446 Eu não acho, vou deixar assim mesmo.
2. 00:28:867 - adiciona uma nota? adicionei aos 00:29:534 - tbm então
3. 00:42:200 (1,2) - sugiro remover, não faz sentido seguir o vocal aqui o.o ok
4. 00:44:867 (1,2,3,4) - aumenta o espaçamento um pouquinho pra dar mais ênfase
5. 00:45:367 (1) - essa nota deveria ter um espaçamento maior, não fica legal com esse stack já que é o mesmo espaçamento de 00:44:867 (1,2,3,4) - Tirei o stack, mas não entendo por que deveria ter um espaçamento maior, não vejo motivo pra dar ênfase ali.
6. 00:46:617 (6,7,2,3,4) - overlap feio, que tal mover 00:47:200 (2,3,4) - pra x:185 x:313 ok
7. 01:23:034 (7) - nc? ok
   

Extra

1. 00:13:200 (1) - remove nc ok
2. 00:13:700 (4) - add nc ok
3. 00:14:200 (1) - remove nc sv não mudou ok
4. 00:15:700 (2,3) - você usou slliders no tick branco aqui 00:15:700 (2,3) - e aqui 00:20:867 (3,4) - você usou nos vermelhos na mesma parte do vocal, recomendo fixar pra consistencia vdd, ok, mudei outras partes um pouco também
5. 00:52:867 (2,3) - acho que esse spacing tá grande demais reduz um pouco dps do mod anterior eu mudei essa parte, o espaçamento tá ok agr
6. Eu não tenho muitas skills em extra então acho que é só isso pra mim

1. 00:14:367 (2) should be more further from (1) . players will think it's the same rhythm as the previous jump when it's actually 2 ticks longer.
2. 01:21:034 move (6) to x 208 y (300) and (5) to x 324 y 336
3. 01:23:700 NC?
4. 01:24:367 the slider doesn't provide feedback for the sound on 01:24:534 something like this would be better
   .

PyroBear wrote:

Hard's the only diff I can find problems My hard is really terrible D:
[Hard]

1. 00:14:367 (2) should be more further from (1) . players will think it's the same rhythm as the previous jump when it's actually 2 ticks longer.changed
2. 01:21:034 move (6) to x 208 y (300) and (5) to x 324 y 336 changed
3. 01:23:700 NC? FC at 01:23:034 - because 01:23:700 - it's a similar sound
4. 01:24:367 the slider doesn't provide feedback for the sound on 01:24:534 something like this would be better
   . Hm, well I prefer one circle and one slider, changed

Trying to eat while modding isn't a good idea

1. 00:01:700 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - these are higher density of the notes than 00:07:034 (1,2,3,4) -
   but the songs isn't so. Would you exchange these?
   
2. 00:29:700 (1) - remove finish and add clap.
   
3. 00:39:034 (3) - add drum-clap to the end,and
   00:40:034 (4) - add drum-finish.

1. 00:22:200 (5) - if you added whistle in order to follow the stling sound here,
   00:22:200 (5) - add whistle and
   00:23:034 (1) - add drum clap.
   
2. 00:09:700 (1) - I prefer this bend to now.
   
   
3. 01:11:367 (2) - this is the last excited part of the song,so the stack doesn't match well.
   
4. 01:24:367 (1) - soft hitsound.

1. I think there are too much 1/2 slider.
   
   I'm very sorry but I skip to mod this diff.

1. 00:01:201 (1,2,3) - It's difficult to click stream at first,so change to something.
   
2. 00:15:700 (4,5) - 00:22:200 (3,4) - 00:25:200 (5,6) - these distance are too long. I recommend to put these a little closer.
   
3. 00:33:701 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - I feel it strange. Would you "Ctrl + J" 2nd times and 4th times?
   
4. 00:51:867 (1,2) - the distance is too short,so I feel cramped.
   
5. 00:56:034 (4) - I recommend 1/2 slider.
   
6. 01:14:700 (4,5,6,7) - make these notes same appearance.
   
7. 01:21:700 (1,2) - I recommend to put these nearby.

1. I feel that the distance of song intro is too long,and SV change in 00:07:034 doesn't good.
   
2. 00:16:367 (1) - 00:17:700 (1) - I recommend 1/2 slider.
   
3. 00:51:700 (2,3,4) - I can't find the right timing well in this part,so
   00:16:367 (1) - I recommend 1/1 slider.
   
4. 01:26:867 (4,5,1,2,3) - bad appearance. put these in some space.
   
5. 01:28:284 (3) - delete it.
   
   Overall,I feel there are a lot of vertical jamp.I feel these some strange, but you don't have to change it.

yotm wrote:

M4M~ My first mod in English!

[Easy]

1. 00:01:700 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - these are higher density of the notes than 00:07:034 (1,2,3,4) -
   but the songs isn't so. Would you exchange these?OK
   
2. 00:29:700 (1) - remove finish and add clap.OK
   
3. 00:39:034 (3) - add drum-clap to the end,andOK
   00:40:034 (4) - add drum-finish.OK

[Normal]

1. 00:22:200 (5) - if you added whistle in order to follow the stling sound here,OK
   00:22:200 (5) - add whistle andOK
   00:23:034 (1) - add drum clap.OK
   
2. 00:09:700 (1) - I prefer this bend to now.OK
   
   
3. 01:11:367 (2) - this is the last excited part of the song,so the stack doesn't match well.OK
   
4. 01:24:367 (1) - soft hitsound.OK

[Hard]

1. I think there are too much 1/2 slider.
   
   I'm very sorry but I skip to mod this diff.

[Insane]

1. 00:01:201 (1,2,3) - It's difficult to click stream at first,so change to something. I don't think is that hard, is just a triple
   
2. 00:15:700 (4,5) - 00:22:200 (3,4) - 00:25:200 (5,6) - these distance are too long. I recommend to put these a little closer. changed
   
3. 00:33:701 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - I feel it strange. Would you "Ctrl + J" 2nd times and 4th times? Didn't really understand what you meant
   
4. 00:51:867 (1,2) - the distance is too short,so I feel cramped.changed
   
5. 00:56:034 (4) - I recommend 1/2 slider.I don't think so
   
6. 01:14:700 (4,5,6,7) - make these notes same appearance.changed
   
7. 01:21:700 (1,2) - I recommend to put these nearby.changed

[End of the World]

1. I feel that the distance of song intro is too long,and SV change in 00:07:034 doesn't good.I think the distance is ok but changed SV
   
2. 00:16:367 (1) - 00:17:700 (1) - I recommend 1/2 slider. I prefer this way
   
3. 00:51:700 (2,3,4) - I can't find the right timing well in this part,so
   00:16:367 (1) - I recommend 1/1 slider.Well, I mapped the guitar, it' okay for me
   
4. 01:26:867 (4,5,1,2,3) - bad appearance. put these in some space. I meant to do that way, I like it
   
5. 01:28:284 (3) - delete it. I can hear two piano sounds
   
   Overall,I feel there are a lot of vertical jamp.I feel these some strange, but you don't have to change it.

Dinshego wrote:

Hello! Sorry for a late mod

Easy

00:05:700 (3) - I think this slider should be reversed, like 00:03:034 (3), so the pattern can be recognized easily. Hmm I think it's not necessary
00:07:034 (1,2) - This flow is kinda weird for me. I suggest you to make a clockwise flow and make it comfortable.

00:09:700 (3,4) - And then change the flow to anticlock, following 00:12:367 (1)
I will keep it this way, but not a bad suggestion
00:22:700 - Why empty? I notice this part 00:20:034 (4) has a circle which there's no vocal in it. All the instruments were constant, and here they all make a little pause, that's why I made it empty, not changing for now
00:32:367 (4) - I don't see any reason why you put red anchor here... I don't see a reason why I can't use
00:36:367 - To be honest, starting from this part until 00:51:034 can make a huge confusion for the player, because the beat is no longer following the vocal, which you emphasis it before. Try to think about this again. but starting from here 00:31:034 - I was mapping the instruments wasn't I?, well that's obvious because there was no vocal, so I kept mapping it
00:52:367 (1,2) - I suggest you to change this like 00:54:367 (4) to make it easier. So also 01:04:367 (1,2)It doesn't fit well
01:00:367 (3) - How about change it to reversed slider like 00:59:034 (1)? Since reversed is better at emphasizing the vocal for this part. True, but too many reversed D:
01:03:034 (3) - There's vocal here. Adding a circle would be better.I think slider is good
01:17:700 (3) - I think this should be reversed slider. Changed
01:23:034 (1) - I don't think slider could be a good choice. Usually slider tail is used for less important beat, and I consider these 01:23:034 and 01:23:700 are both important. I suggest you to add two circles instead.I don't think that really matters that much in an easy diff

Gosh, I'm worried my mod could change your easy to normal D: sorry about this orz

Normal

00:03:700 (5) - This would be better with two circles instead, following this 00:02:369 (2,3) part. The sound of drums is different, so yeah..
00:12:375 (1,2) - I think this should be unstack, the same thing you do it here 00:05:708 (3,4) I prefer stacked
I want to point out for this part 00:20:375 until 00:23:375. You're emphasizing the vocal better, while 00:15:042 to 00:20:042 have the different pattern and way to emphasis. I think you should make both of them same. That's true, changed a bit
00:41:375 - There's vocal here, so I suggest add a circle Well, there's two vocals, so a slider was better
00:45:708 (4,5) - I would replace this to a slider, following the vocal. Hmm I prefer it this way
00:55:042 (1) - Imo, this part will be better with two circles on the white ticks. I don't think so
00:55:708 (3,4) - And I would replace this to a slider too. 00:56:367 (4) - I thinks this part needs to be a circle
01:16:042 (5) - NC here.Here right? 01:16:367 (1) -
01:16:375 (2) - I think you can put this slider to reversedI don't see why

01:17:708 (4) - Remove NC
01:20:042 (1) - NC here 01:19:034 (1) - added NC here, and removed NC

Hard

00:14:700 (3) - Spacing too narrow?
00:18:034 (5) - ^This one's too
From this 00:23:034 to 00:24:367, here's my suggestion.

00:27:034 (1,2) - I would replace this to a slider from 00:27:034 to 00:27:367*
00:27:701 (2,3) - ^A slider from 00:27:700 to 00:28:034, too.*
00:29:034 (3,4) - ^A slider from 00:29:034 to 00:29:367*
*If you apply these suggestion, you can add a circle here 00:28:200, 00:28:200, and 00:29:534
From 00:36:367 to 00:50:700, you no longer emphasizing the vocal. This can make a confusion. So also in kiai part. I'm going to remap hard, this one is so bad, so sorry making you waste time modding this diff

1. for diff spread wise, i suggest hp3, 4, 5 for ez, nm, hd and ex with hp6 or higher
2. 712758.jpg (2020x1200) exceeds current rankable limitation which is 1920x1200

1. 00:01:694 - missing finish
2. 00:08:028 (2) - 00:09:361 (4) - 00:10:694 (6,8) - add clap? just like 00:05:361 (2,4) -
3. 00:09:694 (5) - add new combo here, consistent with how u did combo patterns previously
4. 00:14:361 (3) - inconsistent spacing
5. 00:21:694 - add clap as well? somehow similar to 00:20:361 -
6. 00:23:028 - u might wanna add some hitsound, it lacks feedback here
7. 00:32:028 - 00:33:361 - etc. I personally suggest adding circle to make rhythm here a bit more intense to distinguish its intensity from 00:36:361 (1,2) - the slow part where u also apply 2/1 rhythm gaps
8. 00:39:028 - missing finish
9. 00:43:028 (2) - maybe make it same curve as 1 so visual can be consistent
10. 00:54:361 (4) - because of this rhythm pattern it seems that u messed up the upcoming nc patterns, for example 01:03:028 (3) - should be a nc cuz it's obviously where the second chorus starts, so u'll need some rearrangement here.
11. 00:57:694 - finish?

1. 00:01:694 - finish
2. 00:11:528 (5,6) - 00:12:361 (1,2) - etc. such stacking patterns are confusing for beginners and highly discouraged in normal diffs
3. 00:43:694 (5) - a random whistle? if it's intended for vocal or sth, make it consistent at 00:38:361 (5) -
4. 00:43:694 (5,6,1,2) - intensity of music here doesnt call for 4 circles in a row, especially when comparing with 00:45:694 (4,5,6,7) - . So i suggest turning 00:43:694 (5,6) - a slider
5. 00:57:694 - finish?
6. 01:20:361 (3,4) - consider turning them into a slider, 4 sounds really minor compared with 3 so making them both circles doesnt make much sense
   
   overall structure can be improved in this diff imo, i feel you are just simply following ds so some patterning and flows feel pretty random to me

1. 00:01:694 - finish
2. 00:04:361 (5) - nc
3. 00:04:028 (4,5,6) - spacing emphasis is weird here, 00:04:028 (4,5) - should be larger spacing to emphasize the finish sound, or at least same spacing
4. 00:12:361 - lacks hitsounding here, finish or clap or sth
5. 01:04:194 (4,1) - stack can be used as emphasize but it's inconsistent with the rest patterns in the kiai part, so changing to an unstack one would be a better choice
6. 01:05:028 (3,4) - spacing is clearly off here
7. 01:12:361 - missing whistle and new combo it seems
8. 01:17:694 (3,4) - it may just be me but it feels visually too close for a 1/1 rhythm gap
   
   need some consistency in spacing in this diff, i'm just mentioning the most obvious ones

1. 00:01:694 - finish
2. 00:03:528 (3,4) - visual spacing for this blanket feels inconsistent with the rest in this section such as 00:02:028 (2,3) - 00:07:694 (3,4) - 00:09:361 (6,1) -
3. 00:30:027 (7,1,2) - what about same spacing so the 1/1 gap is perfectly distinguished from those 1/2 ones
4. 00:48:694 (2,3) - no need to force blanket pattern here, the spacing doesnt imply 1/2 gap properly
5. 00:55:361 (2,3,4) - this pattern feels like a hard diff :\ could use some flow and spacing emphasis here
6. 01:21:694 (1,2,3) - i suggest unstacking 3 so that the rhythm change is more intuitive to read

1. 00:37:195 (3,2) - what about making visual spacing of the blanket consistent with 00:36:361 (1,2,3) - 00:39:028 (1,2) - for a better appearance
2. 01:06:195 (2,3) - i feel spacing here (3.5x) is bit too much for a non-emphasizing note considering how u dealt with the rest of kiai, i suggest moving 3 to somewhere around 180,280

1. 00:01:361 - u added finish here in insane diff but not here ;;
2. 00:01:694 - unused inherited point
3. 00:06:194 (1,2) - not overlapping would make the pattern consistent with 00:04:861 (4,5,6) -
4. 00:27:361 - missing clap
5. 00:30:361 (4,5) - similar point about overlapping here
6. 00:44:361 (1,2,3,4) - ~ this is cool!
7. 00:53:694 - 01:08:361 - finish?
8. 01:02:528 (2,1) - why smaller spacing when the music is still as strong as previous 12 jumps
9. 01:23:028 (1,2) - i suggest the slowdown starts with these two sliders, also what about https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/7412643 this pattern, it fits the 1/1 gap better imo

Garden wrote:

General

1. for diff spread wise, i suggest hp3, 4, 5 for ez, nm, hd and ex with hp6 or higher Changed
2. 712758.jpg (2020x1200) exceeds current rankable limitation which is 1920x1200 Changed bg resolution

Easy

1. 00:01:694 - missing finish fixed
2. 00:08:028 (2) - 00:09:361 (4) - 00:10:694 (6,8) - add clap? just like 00:05:361 (2,4) - fixed
3. 00:09:694 (5) - add new combo here, consistent with how u did combo patterns previously fixed
4. 00:14:361 (3) - inconsistent spacing fixed
5. 00:21:694 - add clap as well? somehow similar to 00:20:361 - added
6. 00:23:028 - u might wanna add some hitsound, it lacks feedback here added some whistles
7. 00:32:028 - 00:33:361 - etc. I personally suggest adding circle to make rhythm here a bit more intense to distinguish its intensity from 00:36:361 (1,2) - the slow part where u also apply 2/1 rhythm gaps added some circles
8. 00:39:028 - missing finish added
9. 00:43:028 (2) - maybe make it same curve as 1 so visual can be consistent changed
10. 00:54:361 (4) - because of this rhythm pattern it seems that u messed up the upcoming nc patterns, for example 01:03:028 (3) - should be a nc cuz it's obviously where the second chorus starts, so u'll need some rearrangement here.Oh, prob fixed NCs now
11. 00:57:694 - finish?added

Normal

1. 00:01:694 - finish
2. 00:11:528 (5,6) - 00:12:361 (1,2) - etc. such stacking patterns are confusing for beginners and highly discouraged in normal diffs
3. 00:43:694 (5) - a random whistle? if it's intended for vocal or sth, make it consistent at 00:38:361 (5) -
4. 00:43:694 (5,6,1,2) - intensity of music here doesnt call for 4 circles in a row, especially when comparing with 00:45:694 (4,5,6,7) - . So i suggest turning 00:43:694 (5,6) - a slider
5. 00:57:694 - finish?
6. 01:20:361 (3,4) - consider turning them into a slider, 4 sounds really minor compared with 3 so making them both circles doesnt make much sense
   
   overall structure can be improved in this diff imo, i feel you are just simply following ds so some patterning and flows feel pretty random to me About this diff, rhythm was kinda weird, so I almost remapped the whole thing, probably is much more better in regards to rhythm, aesthetics and structure, and made changes accordingly to what you said :3

Hard

1. 00:01:694 - finishFixed
2. 00:04:361 (5) - nc Fixed
3. 00:04:028 (4,5,6) - spacing emphasis is weird here, 00:04:028 (4,5) - should be larger spacing to emphasize the finish sound, or at least same spacing Changed to same spacing
4. 00:12:361 - lacks hitsounding here, finish or clap or sth Fixed
5. 01:04:194 (4,1) - stack can be used as emphasize but it's inconsistent with the rest patterns in the kiai part, so changing to an unstack one would be a better choice Changed
6. 01:05:028 (3,4) - spacing is clearly off here Fixed
7. 01:12:361 - missing whistle and new combo it seems Fixed
8. 01:17:694 (3,4) - it may just be me but it feels visually too close for a 1/1 rhythm gap Fixed
   
   need some consistency in spacing in this diff, i'm just mentioning the most obvious ones Made some changes in spacing, it is probably much more consistent now.

Insane

1. 00:01:694 - finish added
2. 00:03:528 (3,4) - visual spacing for this blanket feels inconsistent with the rest in this section such as 00:02:028 (2,3) - 00:07:694 (3,4) - 00:09:361 (6,1) - fixed
3. 00:30:027 (7,1,2) - what about same spacing so the 1/1 gap is perfectly distinguished from those 1/2 onesok, changed
4. 00:48:694 (2,3) - no need to force blanket pattern here, the spacing doesnt imply 1/2 gap properly oh, right, fixed
5. 00:55:361 (2,3,4) - this pattern feels like a hard diff :\ could use some flow and spacing emphasis here Yeah :\ , fixed
6. 01:21:694 (1,2,3) - i suggest unstacking 3 so that the rhythm change is more intuitive to readunstacked

End of the World

1. 00:01:361 - u added finish here in insane diff but not here ;; Added a whistle in both, is probably better.
2. 00:01:694 - unused inherited point fixed
3. 00:06:194 (1,2) - not overlapping would make the pattern consistent with 00:04:861 (4,5,6) - fixed
4. 00:27:361 - missing clap fixed
5. 00:30:361 (4,5) - similar point about overlapping here Fixed
6. 00:44:361 (1,2,3,4) - ~ this is cool!Thanks~ ^-^
7. 00:53:694 - 01:08:361 - finish? Added in both
8. 01:02:528 (2,1) - why smaller spacing when the music is still as strong as previous 12 jumps fixed
9. 01:23:028 (1,2) - i suggest the slowdown starts with these two sliders, also what about https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/7412643 this pattern, it fits the 1/1 gap better imoProb right, fixed.

There's still some potential to improve this mapset, so I'm not gonna push it forward for now. And good luck with further process!

AllieBork wrote:

You can't really count this as a mod, I suppose, just a couple of things I noticed.

Timing:

+7ms on the offset looks the best.

End of the World

00:03:028 (1,2) - this is extremely easy to misread as the slider ending on the red tick. On top of that, there's also an important sound of the song there. oh that was a mistake from remap, fixed but won't change slider cause I don't really think that sound is that important
01:16:861 (2) - end this on the red tick too like above.
00:44:361 (1,2,3,4) - consider changing this into a stream of 5 leading into the last note. Because of the section before it, and the timing within the beat, the change to this section is very sudden. Replacing it with a stream would remedy that.
00:56:361 (1) - It seems reasonable to add a Finish hitsound here to keep the pattern going
00:59:028 (1) - ^
01:01:694 (1) - ^
01:07:028 (1) - ^
01:09:694 (1) - ^
01:12:361 (1) - ^
01:11:028 (2) - ^ | also consider reworking the new combos here:
01:11:028 (2,3,1,2,3,1) - so that it becomes 1,2,3,1,2,3
00:39:528 (3) - perhaps replace this with a 1/2 slider. Not as confident with this one, so take it with a grain of salt, but this section fooled me rhythmically the first time(thought it'd follow vocals, but now it negates one note)


... Guess I did more than a few, oops.