Canadian Baka wrote:

Okay, sorry for acting like a 12 year old, goodbye.

._.

Big Cat wrote:

Canadian Baka wrote:

Okay, sorry for acting like a 12 year old, goodbye.

._.

._.

1. 00:17:335 (4,2) - 00:31:335 (4,2) - 00:43:535 (2,4) - there are only two overlaps and a single stack in the entire difficulty. Are they intentional?

1. 00:08:935 (5,1) - the spacing peaks on (5) though (1) is clearly a stronger beat. Perhaps, you could arrange things in a way that would make 5-1 a bigger jump than 4-5?
2. 00:11:735 (5,1,2) - spacing is incosnistent in comparison with the previous similar pattern
   As a matter of fact, the whle part up until recieves way too many changes which are quite minor and can be precieved as inconsistencies, rather than intentional ways of emphasizing things. It also contunues throughout the map later on and I generally don't think these minor changes actually add anything to the map. If anything, I feel like they only make it visually inconsistent.

1. Can we talk about your spacing usage? Let's take 00:07:735 (5,1,2) - 00:09:735 (1,2) - 00:11:335 (1,2,3,4,1) - the spacing values change a lot and I don't really see the reason for it? Then, 00:22:535 (1,2,3) - there is this pattern, where (3) cuts the increasing intensity and lowers the spacing. 00:18:135 (2,3) - the spacing here goes from x1.2 to x2,8 which feels really overdone as the beat you are emphasising is not that strong. Especially when you compare it with the previous jumps on stronger beats like 00:17:735 (1) -
   
   Would you, please, explain the logic you were following as I fail to see it from the context?

1. 00:12:935 (1) - 00:18:935 (5) - there are only two 3/4 sliders in the entire intro and they are quite inconsistent, as the whole intro is built round repetitve sounds.
2. 00:16:535 (2,3) - the low spacing here sort of breaks the jump pattern. Is this spacing change intentional?
3. 00:26:935 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,5,6) - there is no any spacing emphasis on claps and strongerdrum beats, essentially, the whole part is presented as repetitive and very monotonous. Is that intentional?
4. 00:28:935 (1,2,3,4) - due to the way you space things, (1) is not stressed in any way and essentially feels just like any other beat from the previous combo. Are you sure you don't want an additional jump there? Then (2) which is weaker suddenly gets a jump, even though it sounds a lot weaker. And this sort of strange way of spacing things makes the actually reasonable jump from 2-3 feel sort of weakened.
5. 00:32:335 (2,3,5,6) - despite the visual similarity they play very differently. As 2-3 implies sort of "backwards" feel to it, while 5-6 is a very simple and regular flow with a bit of a slowdown caused by a stack.
6. 00:36:735 (2,3) - the spacing here is quite low in comparison with the other similar patterns. Can you explain why?
7. 00:39:335 (2,3,1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4,5,1) - the sliders are clearly groupped in pairs and individual sliders, yet I don't really see any reason for that. In case of 00:40:735 (1,2) - there is a loud snare to justify the jump/separation, but the rest of the sliders seem to follow pretty similar sounds without some kind of musical variation that would allow such spacing.
8. 00:43:735 (1) - the slidershape is different fromthe other ones before and it results in a different feel of the patterns and flow. Which does not seem to make much sense in the context of a very repetitve song. What made you introduce this slidershape here?
   
   I am not sure I am happy with the remapped version. The spacing feels different and the rhythm is kind of inconsistent.

Bakari wrote:

[LGV's Hyper]

1. Can we talk about your spacing usage? Let's take 00:07:735 (5,1,2) - 00:09:735 (1,2) - 00:11:335 (1,2,3,4,1) - the spacing values change a lot and I don't really see the reason for it? Then, 00:22:535 (1,2,3) - there is this pattern, where (3) cuts the increasing intensity and lowers the spacing. 00:18:135 (2,3) - the spacing here goes from x1.2 to x2,8 which feels really overdone as the beat you are emphasising is not that strong. Especially when you compare it with the previous jumps on stronger beats like 00:17:735 (1) -
   
   Would you, please, explain the logic you were following as I fail to see it from the context?

0.o for some reason, I can't quite remember how I mapped those... Although I remember that Stingy changed some parts then I changed it again but I can't remember why it's that way.

But I reviewed the map earlier and it seems like I've grouped them by 2 sliders each. (e.g. 00:06:535 (1,2) - 00:08:135 (1,2) - 00:08:935 (3,4) - 00:11:335 (1,2) - 00:12:135 (3,4) - ) See how the spacing between these groups of sliders (not the spacing value, but the visual space) are larger?

If it bugs you, kindly suggest some way of making the effect more noticeable as I can't really think of any.

Stingy wrote:

~ Polka's Normal (PolkaMocha)

Stingy wrote:

no I'm going to try to get it qualified again

Stingy wrote:

Yeah.

Find some BNs, guys. I'm sick of getting told 'don't map shitty songs'. Besides, it's not even TV Size! What fun is that?

🙃

Joe Castle wrote:

Stingy wrote:

Yeah.

Find some BNs, guys. I'm sick of getting told 'don't map shitty songs'. Besides, it's not even TV Size! What fun is that?

🙃

dont make me shoot other 4 stars to motivate you, so you better rank it

Stingy wrote:

>:'^V GO AWAY JOE

ByBy wrote:

from my q

[general]
*inconsistency in tags check them twice
*inconsistency on preview time set it at all diffs on 00:24:150 -
*you set 8 combo colours but as i can see there's only white combo colour try to reset the combo colours
*disable widescreen support
*timing is not consistent

[HOS's Easy]
*would be gramatically correct if you'll name "HOS' Easy" instead
*the difficulty is NOT hitsounded
neat diff

[Polka's Normal]
*00:44:950 (1,2,3) - that's pretty similar to 00:32:150 (1,2) - and 00:38:550 (1,2) - but here you did not use 1/2 rhythm here which kinda breaks the consistency as the song is still on 1/2 here so it wouldn't hurt to make a rhythm by 2 3/2 sliders both with reverse arrow for the sake of consistency
: ok_hand:

[Hard]
*00:19:335 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,1) - too much 1/2s here tbh after you did the rhythm at 00:16:135 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4) - really demanding tbh consider nerfing them both of them for instance or just 00:19:335 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,1) - Nerfed a tiny bit
*00:25:735 (1,2) - imo the rhythm would work much better if you will ctrl+G them in order to make 00:26:135 - clickable as it is a prominent sound like 00:25:746 - for example http://puu.sh/x6R5W/1c5efce784.jpg // 00:33:335 (1,2) - same // 00:46:135 (1) - I like the offbeats :3
*00:49:335 (4) - offscreen
the kiai needs to be a bit nerfed since there are too many circles imo meh changed some things

[kreme]
*00:06:535 (1,1,1,1) - in this part at other diffs you mapped it but here you most likely nerfed it, even if it's the hardest diff of the set and that's not really fair adding only 2 1/1 notes and 2 spinners while on other diffs this got mapped the best choice would be to map this part instead of putting only 2 circles and spinners and that's all *sigh* fine...
*00:25:335 (1,1) - the transition between these is not really good because of the poor flow since this one is an angle slider (a really sharp one) and the next one is just a sloopy straight slider maybe having something like this https://puu.sh/x6SPu/1d68113ec1.jpg would make the flow work much better no ;w;
*00:37:335 - that prominent beat is getting ignored which is not really good and leave an unnecesary gap in the music tbh adding an 1/1 circle there wouldn't hurt so much No because the vocals are way more important
*00:45:735 (5,6) - the instruments are the same here so there's no reason in spacing them more why don't you space them as you did at 00:45:135 (2,3) - for instance? fixed a little bit

neat map sorry if my mod was sooooo poor i wasn't concentrated enough to mod it properly ;w;
gl!

Milan- wrote:

Easy
-20-25% volumen is not even audible, raise it atleast by 15-20% i'd say ok

Hard
-00:14:535 (5) - nc? the crashes start to sound here ok
-00:14:535 (5,6,7) - uneven ds triggers me so hard lmao fixed a bit
-00:33:335 (1,2) - 1/1 slider would be nice in these, so it's easier to say what you're mapping after the pause I think it's okay because the beat start on a pick-up

krispy kreme
-ur idff is bugged update pls well I'm updating after the mod so idk
-00:12:335 (4,5,6,1) - like http://puu.sh/ybStm/e54cfde78d.jpg looks and fits better i think hmm okay
-00:19:135 (8,1) - by spacing these so much, the jump between 00:19:335 (1,2) - become kinda underwhelming. i'd lower it just by placing (8) closer this was intentional, and also, I don't think it's very bad ;w;
-00:32:135 (1) - try x486y4. follows the motion between 00:31:935 (6,1,2) - better i think I agree :3
-00:32:335 (2,3) - also not sure why these are so close, did you run out of space ?xd if you wanted to do like contrast using lower ds, then you should do the same with this part 00:39:335 - where you just jump like the rest of the kiai I do it like this because in 00:39:335 - , my emphasis follows the new raindrop sounds
-00:43:335 (3,4) - the overlap with 00:42:935 (1) - is weird because 00:43:935 (2) - is just stacked, both stacked like http://puu.sh/ybSKs/95bfbb0c9b.jpg looks better 1) it would ruin spacing. 2) It matches with the overlap of 00:44:535 (5,6) -
-00:49:335 (3) - nc like 00:48:535 (1) - ? oop >^>

not sure why you wanted me to mod this but i tried xd

1. 00:49:735 (3,4) - just so the circle (4) doesn't look like it is over the circle (2), move it to x:296 y:176 and to make sure the previous slider still makes a great flow with this circle, rotate it by 11degrees.
   
   example

   

1. I'd highly recommend to delete the first two objects. This difficulty is the only one that starts at 00:00:135 - and for consistency purposes, it would be better to make it follow the other difficulties.
2. You should aim custom hitsounds instead of default hitsounds as they do not harmonize with the song.

1. 00:12:535 (6,1) - This is the only place in which you've made the spacing wider to emphasize the sound coming from 00:12:935 - . You should try to make it more consistent overall with 00:09:335 (8,1) - , 00:14:135 (4,1) - , 00:15:735 (4,1) - . 00:17:335 (5,1) - .
2. 00:38:135 (1) - After this slider, you have an awkward break and I can't seem to understand why there is one. You should map something that will follow the sounds coming from that part. Here's an example of a rhythm that works greatly with the difficulty:
   
3. 00:44:935 (7) - As mentioned on the previous suggestion, you are leaving an awkward break, which doesn't make much sense due to the difficulty. Map something here also. I can suggest you to add a circle to 00:45:335 - and a 1/2 slider to 00:45:735 -
4. 00:50:935 (2) - This circle, which is following the breathing sound coming from here, should be moved down as the intonation of the breathing is 'meh' and should be emphasized that way. What about you stack it with 00:50:135 (3) - ?

1. 00:23:735 (1) - you should not ignore the vocals at the end of this slider because it feels weird to play the next objects which mainly follows the vocals. make this slider shorter by 1/4 and add a circle to make it more obvious that you're following the vocals.
2. 00:32:135 (1) - make a wider spacing here to give more intonation to this new measure. you could do like what's shown in the picture below.
   
   example

   
3. 00:32:935 (3,4,1,2,3,4,5) - I see there was a thing going on with 00:33:335 (1,2,3,4) - , but wouldn't it be better to start doing it with the two previous objects as well? do something like this, below.
   
   example

   
4. 00:50:935 (1) - this slider is pretty loud for the end of the song. delete the finish hitsound on the tail to make it softer, by still following your idea and your choice of hitsound.

1. 00:24:935 (1,2) - As you might want to put more emphasis/intonation here because of the vocals "Krispy Kreme", you should move these two sliders around. The slider (1) could be moved to x:174 y:184 and the slider (2) could be moved to x:326 y:39, which would make a little jump and would give more intonation to this vocal part.
2. 00:25:335 (1) - Following the previous suggestion, do a CTRL+G to start the slider the other way. Previously, your 1/4 sliders were making ups and downs from a slider to another, making it a linear flow. Coming at this slider, you're breaking the flow by making this slider the same way as the previous one. That's why, in this case, starting the slider the other way will be better for the flow.
3. 00:25:735 - This is the only difficulty which is not using a kiai time starting here. I'd recommend using one as it will first, follow the other difficulties and second, will show that this part is 'kiai-worthy'.
4. 00:44:535 (5,6) - These objects are not following the most dominant sounds which are at 00:44:535 - and 00:44:735 -. Do a CTRL+G to these two objects, so at least it's going to be greatly emphasized.
5. 00:50:935 (1) - Move this circle to x:252 y:104. It will follow the movement of the two previous objects, shown in the screen below.
   
   example

   

Gabe wrote:

rdm mod

Hard

1. 00:12:535 (6,1) - This is the only place in which you've made the spacing wider to emphasize the sound coming from 00:12:935 - . You should try to make it more consistent overall with 00:09:335 (8,1) - , 00:14:135 (4,1) - , 00:15:735 (4,1) - . 00:17:335 (5,1) - .
2. 00:38:135 (1) - After this slider, you have an awkward break and I can't seem to understand why there is one. You should map something that will follow the sounds coming from that part. Here's an example of a rhythm that works greatly with the difficulty:
   
3. 00:44:935 (7) - As mentioned on the previous suggestion, you are leaving an awkward break, which doesn't make much sense due to the difficulty. Map something here also. I can suggest you to add a circle to 00:45:335 - and a 1/2 slider to 00:45:735 -
4. 00:50:935 (2) - This circle, which is following the breathing sound coming from here, should be moved down as the intonation of the breathing is 'meh' and should be emphasized that way. What about you stack it with 00:50:135 (3) - ?

the flow from this difficulty could be reworked.. a lot. The movement from most objects are not flowing enough and you kinda need to do hard 'robotic-ish' movements and it's not pleasant. I believe you can do better! remapping with everything in mind.

Krispy Kreme!

1. 00:24:935 (1,2) - As you might want to put more emphasis/intonation here because of the vocals "Krispy Kreme", you should move these two sliders around. The slider (1) could be moved to x:174 y:184 and the slider (2) could be moved to x:326 y:39, which would make a little jump and would give more intonation to this vocal part. I like the idea but it would ruin my SV pattern
2. 00:25:335 (1) - Following the previous suggestion, do a CTRL+G to start the slider the other way. Previously, your 1/4 sliders were making ups and downs from a slider to another, making it a linear flow. Coming at this slider, you're breaking the flow by making this slider the same way as the previous one. That's why, in this case, starting the slider the other way will be better for the flow. I agree o:
3. 00:25:735 - This is the only difficulty which is not using a kiai time starting here. I'd recommend using one as it will first, follow the other difficulties and second, will show that this part is 'kiai-worthy'. I don't see this as a problem but if someone else points it out, I'll consider it more :3
4. 00:44:535 (5,6) - These objects are not following the most dominant sounds which are at 00:44:535 - and 00:44:735 -. Do a CTRL+G to these two objects, so at least it's going to be greatly emphasized. I think this is a much better emphasis because of the change in rhythm. There is a change in vocals here when they "bounce", so that is why I decided to have them this way
5. 00:50:935 (1) - Move this circle to x:252 y:104. It will follow the movement of the two previous objects, shown in the screen below. I did this on purpose and I like it this way~
   
   example

   

Kisses wrote:

you replied to milan but not irreversible, idk if you forgot to or not ~

Veridian wrote:

Mod reply lol