1. osu!community
  2. osu!
  3. Feature Requests
posted
If this topic has already been created,then sorry..

Well,why can't we use different Approach Rates in map? For example - for sliders we can put slowdown,but for circles we can't do nothing. and sometimes it doesn't look good when the song with AR 9 has a calm moment and the circles fall so fast. So,we can create inheriting timing section,and put different AR there. What do you think about it?
posted
No because if we had this, it would be totally disorienting and unnecessary.
posted

Kitsunemimi wrote:

No because if we had this, it would be totally disorienting and unnecessary.

Well,who knows. With slowdowns and 2x speed sliders it is not disorienting,and with circles with different AR's it will be?
posted
I can see the moments when this is useful, for example, Beats And Pieces is a song I tried to map. It starts at 70 BPM and anything over 6-7 looks wrong but ends at 200 BPM and anything under 9 looks wrong!

So yeah, this have my support but it better be justified to when it's used as this can be abused very easy.
posted
Will definitely need special permission even if it's implemented, I also support this. We can still utilize this and keep abuse to a minimal, or at a halt, since with the addition of another feature, there's bound to be a restriction of some sort over this.
posted
No no no no no. I dread to see the abuse this would cause despite it's potential good uses.

Xgor wrote:

It starts at 70 BPM and anything over 6-7 looks wrong but ends at 200 BPM and anything under 9 looks wrong!.

Go full troll and set AR5 for the whole thing :D
posted

RandomJibberish wrote:

No no no no no. I dread to see the abuse this would cause despite it's potential good uses.


And this is why we have our friendly BATs and MATs!.

Other than that, I have no support. I'll see how it turns out before supporting.
posted
edit : not supporting, adapting to a new speed will confuse me.
posted
I know there are a lot of people against this, but I really do think this is a good idea. For songs that have both soft and intense parts a changing AR could work very well.

Of course there's potential for abuse, but seeing as we have an approval system I really don't think that's much of an issue.
posted
Much as I want this, it'd probably end up with some terrible mapper abusing it for 'creativity'.
posted
Increase AR to 10 at all kiai time sections, fuck yeah.
posted

0_o wrote:

I know there are a lot of people against this, but I really do think this is a good idea. For songs that have both soft and intense parts a changing AR could work very well.

Of course there's potential for abuse, but seeing as we have an approval system I really don't think that's much of an issue.


Exactly. If people tried to map "I Prefer the Sky (Remix)", they would know what I'm talking about. ;P
posted
Well, yes there will be many maps abusing this
but i want this :3
posted
I totally despise when this happens on rhythm games like DDR.
posted

MetalMario201 wrote:

I totally despise when this happens on rhythm games like DDR.

or you know, taiko.
posted
It worries me to think how much this can easily be abused (and will be) and have to deal with mappers refusing to change any of it because "it fits"

However I have seen several maps where this idea could be very helpful...
I guess half support~
posted
I am surprised that my idea has such a good support.
That is the first time when I do it,so Idk if it is bad or not - that I voted 4 times for this idea by myself :)
posted
*holds gun to head*

*cringes and pulls trigger*
posted

peppy wrote:

*holds gun to head*

*cringes and pulls trigger*

Don't laugh,I am kinda new in this topic :) My previous ideas vere denied by you,so I don't know how does this system work.
posted

peppy wrote:

*holds gun to head*

*cringes and pulls trigger*

NOOOOOO!!! *takes the gun away from ppy*

Anyways...i don't support. It would be too much confusing. Kiai is enough for me. :o
Please sign in to reply.