I'll just ignore the fact that BG has no connection with the song and assume that I lack some knowledge of the overwatch community.
Anyways, a few things I'd like to clear out before this goes on any further. See it as a few questions/suggestions.
[General]
- soft-hitfinish.wav is literally five seconds long. It does cover/overlay with other hitsounds and feels pretty annoying as it is taking ages to stop playing. Consider shortening it?
- Doesn't the cash.png file need at least a pixel of transparency around it to avoid possible visual distortions?
[Beginner]
- Tick Rate 2 does not seem to work well here. The rhythm is mostly 2/1 mixed with 1/1 beats, which makes the ticks feel too spammed. On top of that, it requires beginners to be very careful with sliders and goes against the core idea of the Beginner dificulty.
- Approach Rate and OD/HP seem to be a bit too high for a low-BPM Easy difficulty mapped in 2/1 and 1/1 beats. Consider lowering these settings to match with the actual rhythm/Slider Velocity?
- 00:38:138 (1) - minor - being the only slider curved in such a way and having no specific grounds in music for that I would conclude that the shape is random. Why not use a regular arc shaped slider instead?
Advanced feels a lot more like a Hard, actually. Spacing changes, 1/4 sliders that are meant to be played as drop-offs and the overall difficulty level clearly indicate that this is not an in-between difficulty, it's a solid Hard. Why not name it accordingly?
Also, it seems somewhat alarming to me that during the ranking process we didn't hear much from high-rank players who would be capable of playing a 7* map. So, I am very uncertain of it, but I know nothing about difficulties this hard, so this is strictly up to you.
Hope Beginner is looked at more properly, I would really like to see it happen. Good luck with the map!
Momoka wrote:
BounceBabe wrote:
SV changes need better indication on the harder difficulties, namely 00:02:086 (3) -, 00:03:401 (3) - etc on Over Cash, 01:02:349 (1,2) - 01:04:980 (1,2) - 01:10:770 (1,2) - etc on Extra since they are hard to read and also are bigger SV changes.
ur 87k rank. and have the audacity to talk about reading problems on a 7 star map that arent even problems lol
not surprised.
Yet, they are a mapper and they have a right to voice their opinion. This probably should be checked as well.