Adding it now. Thanks! (Though I probably will just leave it up overnight and hit "Submit" in the morning since I'm going to bed)

EDIT: Added, thank you!

(TV edit) --> (TV Size), then full submit. How can this be TV edit? O_o
Tags are not same in all difficulties

Why do you not use custom colors?

[Easy]
Map the map to end of the song.
Well Slider velocity fast for easy. I suggest to discrease it to 0.8. If you do that, don't forget to check all sliders and fix spacings in whole map.
Discrease OD at least by 2. And HP drain too.
00:55:836 - fix kiai start.
01:16:200 - fix kiai end. I suggest to end kiai time there 01:19:109
01:04:564 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - such stuff are not newbie players.

[Normal]
Discrease OD at least by 2. Same with HD drain.
Same Kiai problems as in easy.
Map the map to end of the song.
Slider Velocity is pretty fas for Normal players. I suggest to make 1.00 ~ 1.20
00:42:563 (5) - no jumps in normal diff.
00:48:382 (5) - ^

[Hard]
Same Kiai problems as in normal and easy.
00:28:382 (7) - new combo there
00:57:654 (6) - and there

I like background. Have my star.

General

~All difficulties end at 01:22:741 meanign there is about 15% of the song empty, i suggest you map that also
~Both Hard and Normal had random spacing jumps i'd suggest you fix that unless ofcourse u intended for them to be that way
~also (since commenting on the notes)... i think you should rearrange the notes again to think of better designs as on my point of view it seemed liek the notes had been randomly placed (but idk... it might just be me x_x)
~

Easy

~I suggets you reduce the Hp Drain by 1 - 2 ticks for this difficulty.

00:17:854 - I think its better if you start a slider here which then ends at 00:18:204
00:17: 995 (1) - if u do the above ^... delete this note
00:29:658 (1) - Move this note 1 tick forward
00:43:644 (1) - Change this repeate slider so that it finishes at 00:45:854 (red tick)
01:10:734 (8) - Delete?


Normal

00:18:021 (1) - Delete this repetae slider
00:17:826 (red tick) - Start a slider here that ends at 00:18:206 (red tick) then repeate it
00:19:107 (white) - Start a slider here and end it at 00:19:327 (red tick)
00:19:662 (red) - add a note here
00:20:552 (1) - Extend this slider by 1 tick (if you do this delete the ntoe at 00:21:110)
00:22:003 (5) - Delete this note and then start a slider here which ends at 00:22:216
00:23:298 (1) - Reduce this sliders length by 1 tick
00:27:849 - This section is randomly empty, i think u can add a couple more notes here
00:34:922 (1) - Reduce slider length by 1 tick
00:39:641 - This area is randomly empty, i think you can add a couple more notes to it
00:45:644 (5) - move this note back by 1 tick then change it into a slider which ends at 00:45:826
00:52:018 (5) - I'd suggest you delete this slider and then doign what you did with the spinner on easyer (Move spinner from 00:52:927 to 00:52:018... and then extend it to 00:54:385


Hard

00:17:843 (red tick) - either u can add a note here? OR move the note at 00:18:018 (1) - back by 1 tick
00:39:641 - This area is randomly empty... i think you can add a couple more notes here
00:52:018 (9) - I'd suggest you do what i told you to do in Normal (replace this slider with the spinner and then extend it)


After you have made changes, PM again for a recheck and i'll star it then (hope to hear from u soon

General

~Only thing i can really comment on is that just neat up the designs of the notes a bit more (i added some comments below)

Easy

00:32:382 (1) - Move this Note 1 grid right so that its aligned with 00:31:291 (4)
00:33:836 (3) - You seem to have wanted to make a triangle design here, so if you do the above, move this so its aligned with 00:32:382 (1) (and then ofcourse rearange the rest of the notes after it)

From 00:43:654 to 00:48:385 - i think that these sliders can be placed a little neater
I do like the S Shape slider though
(i'd help with design.. .but u can check any of my maps >_>... i'm not that great rofl)

01:04:564 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - These notes are placed in a way which makes them symetrical to each other... you can rearrange these notes so that they can be placed on opposite side in the middle to make a perfect symmetry (Make sure to add the 7 also as its alla lone D:!)

i made something like this but idk if you'll like it :/



Normal

00:20:564 (1) - The first beggining notes were placed at the centre looking symmetrical, to keep this constant atm, why not try to place this in the centre also? (if you do this, remember to move slider (2) also and the rest of the notes?

01:04:564 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - You can do the same with this like i mentioned in easy (place it in the middle )
The 01:07:109 (8) - Place it Below the 01:06:745 (7) so that the design isn't messed up and also keep the symmetry.
01:16:200 (1) - Move this repeat slider 1 grid right so that it makes a perfect symmetry with 01:17:654 (2)


Hard

00:26:200 (7) - Move this Slider and place it a the bottom/middle of the 00:24:745 (1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6)



The diffs look ok, and i really do like the song (brings back memories ) ^_^
(Star~)

You helped a TON! Thank you so much, it's so much better now! <3

By Mod Request:

General

1. 01:24:018 - end all of the final spinners here

[Easy]

1. 00:47:109 (1) - hmm, more symmetrical? Raise the endpoint 1 grid...

[Normal]

1. 00:17:836 (1) - same as up

[Hard]

1. 00:23:836 (4) - remove clap
2. 00:24:200 (6) - remove note
3. 00:27:473 (3) - add clap
4. 00:31:473 (8,9) - i suggest to change these claps to whistles
5. 00:39:109 (3) - add clap
6. 00:40:382 (8) - clap at the end of the slider

Yeah, I mostly modded on the [Hard] diff.

So I may have missed stuff on the others...

Star though..

Ok mentor checking go!

[General]
(TV Edit)? What's the difference between that and (TV size)?
Also shouldn't it be Buttefly instead of Butter-Fly?

[Easy]
Well, technically it's a fine difficultly but for an Easy it's awfully hard to follow.
I took a little play on it and tried my best at just trying to follow the song (That I haven't heard before) and not thinking at the approach circles/spacing and I didn't fare so well.
Replay

I kinda felt like slower slider velocity would fit here but it might be just me.

The Overall difficulty is awfully high for an Easy and is even bigger than the AR, why?

I guess the somewhat small circle size for an Easy is to keep constant with the other difficulties right?

00:43:654 (1) - This strikes me as it could be centered a lot better, Just try to horizontally flip it until it's centered.
01:10:745 (8) - This circle is just out of place, please remove it.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders

Well as I said above, it's pretty hard to follow, I think this difficulity would be much better if you kept it more simple and maybe only used 1/1.
It's a ok Easy for those that knows this song by hard, but those that don't it's less forgiving and a lot of newer osu! players probably never heard it.

[Normal]
Replay(I admit I was extra clumsy this playthrough <-< 00:42:564 (5) isn't hard to read at all.

00:17:836 (1) - Starting on a red tick is very confusing especially on the easier difficulties., I would say moving it 1/2 forward on the timeline would work much better
00:27:109 (1) - This would be much better as 1/2 or 1/1 longer. It just sounds wrong right now.
00:31:291 (4,5,6) - It's very awkward that you switched to what to map to here, especially because you stopped mapping to the vocals in the middle of the line/combo/whatever. It's even more weird that you map the first time it is that way but not the second time.
00:40:018 (4,5,6) - Can't you map it like 00:38:745 (1,2,3) instead. It's pretty much the same thing so different mapping so close to each other felt awkward.
00:46:745 - (Suggestion) Maybe add a circle here. (If you do that add a new combo on that and remove the new combo on the circle after it.
00:50:382 and 00:51:109 - (Suggestion) Add circles here.
01:11:473 (1,2) - (Uber nazi mode) Move one grid to the right so it's more centered.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders

[Taiko Hell]
Taiko modding is far from anything for me as I hate the mapping style in them, but it striked me that there would be good with some more finishes in the difficulty. 00:26:745 (24), 00:27:473 (3) and 00:28:018 (6) - Would for an example be great places to add finishes on.

Otherwise I guess I can't comment on it much unless I would go into my standard taiko map rage but I felt:
00:06:382 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16) (And all the other patterns like this) is extra stupid as it has a very long unfitting stream and then a part when there even could be more beats and it would work nicely, atleast a circle at 00:08:200 with a clap.

[Hard]
Replay (If you wanna see how bad I am)

Undoubtedly the best difficulty in the set. The patterns and rhythm are pretty good.

Just like in Easy, why does this have higher OD than AD, I don't think it needs that.

The hitsounds felt a bit random here, claps usually doesn't fit on 1/2's and 1/4's and the whistles felt like they were often where they wasn't needed, might do a hitsound mod alone later if you want.

00:18:200 - Add circle
00:46:564 and 00:46:745 - Add circles here please (And if you do that, add a new combo at the first circle and remove the new combo at 00:47:109 (1))
00:49:654 (1,2) - I find this anti-jump just weird, I think moving 00:50:018 (2,3,4,5,6,7,8) down some grids would be a much better option than having that anti-jump.
01:11:473 - This soft hitsound section just feels out of place, I think you would be better without it as it doesn't even exist in the other difficulties.
01:13:473 (10) - I think it would be better if you removed this circle imo.
01:16:200 (1,2) - (Suggestion) Add a clap at the first repeat and at the slider end at both sliders.


Well, not bad- I liked Hard and Normal was decent, Easy felt though as it could be a bit more newcomer friendly and Taiko is... Taiko.
Oh well.
*star*

Modding, CrimmiStyle!!

[Easy]

~ nothing.

[Normal]

01:01:473 (4) - align with (2)

[Hard]

~ nothing.

star.

General:
- I know you put size in tags, but still, why TV Edit instead of TV Size?

Easy:
- Increase Circle Size by 1

01:04:564 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - This is way too hard for an easy :/

Normal:
- Rename to Normal+

wah Digimon! ^^~
star
and i thought the last spinner in easy is too long, or it's just me

YGOkid8 wrote:

General:
- I know you put size in tags, but still, why TV Edit instead of TV Size?

It's to avoid combining with my Taiko TV Size mapset that is in the graveyard. I wanted to keep them separate.

Did increase Easy's circle size, but that combo's fine. It's just tapping to the beat for a bit.

Posting so this doesn't go back to the Graveyard this time.

want to make taiko !!!!!
please !!!!

I sir hope you like this I really do love this song and I hope to bring it justice!
Custom hitsound set in the rar with guest diff ONNNNNN MYYYYYYYY LOVVVEEEEEEE~

Download: ztrotdiff with hitsounds.rar

Thought of you, ztrot, when I test-played this song for Ekaru. Great to see you've made a diff, although it was inevitable


ps: was there a taiko diff in this set? *wonders why she has a nonsubmitted taiko diff for this song*

Hi Nymph here~ request received from wcx19911123's mod queue~
So let's go~
Digimon Adventure~ Cool

General:
Same as lucifer said: The titie “TV Edit”? Not “TV Sive”..?

Easy:
For me HP drain and OD -1 is better~
01:19:109 (1) - I suggest this spinner ends at 01:23:473? (to every diff because the finish hitsound seems a bit sudden now.just suggestion~)

Normal:
Still Hp drain seems to be too high... -2?
00:19:654 (4) - maybe whistle too? I think it sounds better
00:50:564 (3,4,5,6,7,8) - this pattern seems so weird for me...so maybe like this?
Above Normal:
00:17:836 (1) - starts at 00:18:018? Sounds better for me
And seems lots of things can be more symmetrical? Seems you want them to be symmetrical but didn't do well.... Maybe use sometime to make them more beautiful~

Insane:
OD-1 ?....sorry for my bla bla bla about the OD..
01:11:473 (1,2,3,4) - even though the soft hitsounds seems pretty good but the volumn here is so much different from others...

So that is all~ at my suggestion I think the difficulty flow is not very good, I think this map can have a Insane and don't need 3 diffs below 4 stars. Anyway good luck~ ☆~

Did a full reupload. ztrot, thank you, I love it, except...

01:01:836 (1) - This feels weird no matter how many times I play this.

Otherwise, I love it. Thanks~ ^_^

@Haneii: I decided to remove the Taiko Hell diff and just link to the entire Taiko mapset in the song's info, because Taiko Hell is just insane, and I don't want more than 5 diffs on this.

@Heat_Kai: Ah, thanks, but sorry, I don't want more than a total of 5 difficulties on this for multiple reasons. I'm already bending myself by going over 4, actually. ><; But all 5 maps are of a different difficulty level, so it's okay. But yeah, sorry.

Ekaru wrote:

@Heat_Kai: Ah, thanks, but sorry, I don't want more than a total of 5 difficulties on this for multiple reasons. I'm already bending myself by going over 4, actually. ><; But all 5 maps are of a different difficulty level, so it's okay. But yeah, sorry.

Okay

change my tickrate to 2 and add this

Download: normal-slidertick.rar

o-o

[Normal]

00:26:745 : remove clap add fin
00:28:018 : fin
01:03:654 : remove clap add fin

[Hard]
00:28:018 : remove whistle add fin
00:29:473 : fin
00:38:382 : remove whistle add fin
00:39:654 : fin
01:02:927 : remove clap add fin
01:03:654 : ^

[ztort`s insane]

01:32:200 : fin
01:32:382 : ^
01:32:564 : ^

they're just suggestions

star ~

I'd rather not use the finish more than what I have at current the sound itself is very powerful and to over use it would spell disaster

ztrot, hp drain 7 please, thanks, also my message is too short isn't that funny

[general]
tags in osu don't work very well, since they do not match multiple. "tv size" doesn't find this map in osu! (it matches on osu.ppy.sh, but not if you search for "tv size" in quotes). For that reason please add "tv size" without quotes to tags instead of just "size".

[easy]
I found the rhythms in this difficulty to be extremely confusing
00:39:836 - everything before this was very strange, because you're mapping around half of the lyrics. Well the lyrics themselves don't follow an easy rhythm, and taking out half of the beats makes it that much more difficult, at least for the experienced player. Perhaps easy players don't have this problem and go mostly off of the approach circle?

These are some suggestions to make the map easier to play, even though the song won't follow a particular part (which I applaud you for trying to do)
00:21:109 (2) - extend 1/2 earlier, make it end 00:22:200 -
00:23:109 (1) - extend 1/2 earlier
00:24:564 - add 3/2 slider here
00:25:837 (2) - add 5/2 slider
00:30:382 (2,3) - slider
00:57:654 (4) - 1/1 repeating slider.
00:58:745 (4) - circle
00:59:836 (1) - shorten 1/2
01:02:200 (1,2,3) - repeating slider
previous 4 repeat

[normal]
maybe easy's mod was just so critical because I wasn't used to the song, but this one is better since we can put in more notes, and it's a lot easier to follow.
00:20:745 - add note, or make it a slider with end here 00:21:291 -
00:26:564 - add note, or make previous two plus this one a repeating slider
00:29:473 (7) - this is the beginning of a new phrase, probably should have new combo, and I think it would be better to have it as a slider to 00:30:382
00:32:382 (2,3) - make both circles sliders, ending on the white tick before the next note
00:37:836 (3) - extend 1/2
00:47:836 (3,4,5) - might be too tough, consider repeating slider
00:49:654 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - this is weird. If you feel creative with placement, you can use a 1/1 slider, then 3/2, then 2/1. Each will be mapping the emphasized part in the lyrics.
00:52:927 - if you do ^ you can put the spinner start here.
01:04:564 (1) - can you split this up in some way?
01:10:382 (4) - extend 1/2
01:17:291 - add circle?
01:18:745 - ^

[above normal]
shouldn't this be normal+?
00:40:018 (4,5,6) - make these 1/2 offbeat sliders, starting where they are right now. It will map the guitar well.
00:42:200 (4) - not sure if this is 1/2 or 1/4. Put it on the end of a slider so it's not ambiguous
00:45:473 (5,6) - slider
00:48:018 (4) - as before
00:49:654 (1,2,3,4) - this is easier than it was in normal?
01:01:291 - add
01:16:200 (1,2) - maybe leave normal the way it is and do what I suggested there here instead.

[hard]
ah finally I'm getting used to this song. I noticed the spacing is kinda inconsistent too.
00:23:836 (4,5) - slider
00:29:473 (1,2) - make 1 1/2 longer, and 2 a circle on the end
00:42:200 (4) - I think these might be on 1/3 snap actually, which is all the more reason to not force the player to hit them by putting it on the end of a slider.
01:00:745 (3,4) - slider
01:04:382 (1,2,3) - these sliders are offbeat in a weird spot. Move them all 1/2 later and add a circle at the beginning.
01:16:200 (1,2) - *yawn*

[ztrot]
this is the first time someone has made up a drum part that made perfect sense to me.
00:40:564 (4,6) - you should totally add in a different custom cymbal (hopefully mildly softer) to map some of these different cymbal crashes in the music. What drumset only uses one cymbal anyway?
01:03:654 (3) - ^ pretty sure you missed this one, as you mapped it as a finish later.
01:32:200 (1) - ^

oh long mods

oh god that quote siggy man my balls were so big tho B) thanks for the mod and what not message to short loool

nice song and map. little mod~

[Ztort's insane]

00:54:927 (2,4) - Distance error.(Deliberately?)
00:58:382 (2,4) - ^
01:00:927 (1,2,3,4) - Suggestion no jump.(No significant change of rhythm)
01:04:018 (4) - add NC.
01:16:200 (1) - add finish.(Suggestion)
01:17:654 (1) - ^
01:27:836 (5) - add NC.


[Hard]

00:28:382 (7) - add NC.
00:34:745 (6) - ^
00:45:473 (8) - Distance error.
00:56:382 (3) - ^
00:57:654 (6,7) - ^
01:08:927 (6) - add NC.


[Above Normal]

01:00:745 (2,3,4) - Very strange rhythm proposal transform.


[Normal]

01:19:109 - Spinner Recommended start from here.


nice job,GOGO Ranked~

My English is very poor. I hope you can understand.

good lucky and kudosu star~

i'm a new modder...so just suggestions
general
offset211,i think
above normal
quiet loud hitsound...
00:23:291 (1) - half beat shorter,or make the finishing hitsound lower
00:25:109 (3,4) - slider(i don't like seeing too many circles...)
00:25:836 (6,7) - ^
00:28:382 - add a circle
00:34:927 (1) - same->00:23:291 (1)
00:40:018 (4,5,6) - half beat later
00:43:654 (1) - divide into a circle and a one beat silder
01:00:745 (2,3,4) - half beat later and add a note at 01:00:745
01:06:018 (5) - remove
01:06:745 (6,7) - a half beat slider at 01:06:745
01:09:291 - i just prefer to add a circle

yeah~nice song

I've been wanting to mod this for a long time... And now, here I am!

~Easy~
00:21:109 (2) - Center this.
00:33:836 (3,4) - Spacing is off here.
00:50:018 (2,3) - Maybe make these into a slider to make this easier for newbies?
01:04:564 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Maybe replace these with repeaters to make this (again) easier for newbies?
01:16:200 (1,2) - Personally, I think these would look great in a circle pattern. http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/168522

~Normal~
00:26:745 (1) - Replace with finish?
00:41:291 (1) - This would sound better if it ended 1/2 earlier.
00:48:109 (4) - Move this to the previous red line.
00:50:564 (3,4) - Move these both 1/2 earlier and...
00:50:927 (x) - Add note!
00:57:654 (4) - Repeater doesn't really follow the song.
01:04:564 (1) - Lulz, maybe you should swap this part with Easy's.
01:19:109 (x) - Start spinner here.

~Above Normal~
00:23:291 (1) - That whistle doesn't fit.
00:30:927 (x) - Add note maybe?
00:50:018 (2,3,4) - Make this part more like Normal's... or swap them!
01:00:927 (x) - Add note?
01:01:291 (x) - Here too?
01:09:291 (x) - Here too?

~Hard~
01:11:473 (1,2,3,4) - Personally, Soft doesn't fit here. Less is more!

~ztrot's Insane~
00:47:109 (1,5) - Center these using grid size (4) please.

Playing your map has been a pleasure, Ekaru. I'll star once I get the opportunity.

...Fine, I'll go and get this ranked! XP

I'll look at these mods soon.

General
ok

Normal
LINEAR SLIDERS ARE BORING
no other problems

Above Normal
00:55:836 (1) - NOTTT PERRRFEEECCTTTT RAWR
01:07:473 (1) - this goes quite uncomfortably past the side of the grid. I'd rec- ah screw it. FIX IT.

Hard
00:30:382 (4,5,6) - patterns like this aren't very fun to play. Make it more clear that 5 and 6 are reversed.

ztrot
00:20:745 (2,5,6) - they'realmosttouching
no problems

Digimon Adventure is my favourite anime when I was childhood~>////<




red is unrankable issue. bule is need to discuss. Black is just suggest.

good pattern
star~ and good luck!

Hi

General:

• Add "ztrot" to all of the tags
• I suggest mapping to the end like ztrot did. It seems incomplete the way you mapped it.

Above Normal:

• 00:23:291 (1) - I don't think it's best to end this note on here because nothing really sounds off. I would either end it on the the previous white tick, or the next white tick.
• 00:26:745 (9) - New combo on this note to match the music better.
• 00:37:836 (7,8,9,10) - I'm not a big fan of the 4 note stack after the two 3 note stack. It can be really confusing, especially for less experienced players.
• 00:39:473 (3,4,5,6) - I believe this would be better if you mapped it like this I also suggest un-stacking 4,5,6 because it's pretty boring for a part with such energy.
• 00:43:654 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - Ctrl + H and Ctrl + J to deal with spacing issues.

Hard:

• 00:18:745 (3) - Add a new combo to this note because it's where you start mapping the vocals.
• 01:11:473 (1,2,3,4) - I don't see why you made these notes soft, it does not really sound right to me. If there is a reason, I'm sorry I questioned you. To make up for it here of a kiwi

Other than those few things I have no objections with this map.
Nice job~
♪Star♪

Why's it called Butter-Fly and not Butterfly?

Magicphoenix wrote:

Why's it called Butter-Fly and not Butterfly?

Butter-Fly is the correct name.

Hi. My osu! won't work ATM so I'm posting here to keep this alive.

good

Anyways. . .

Overall:
Change "(TV Edit)" to "(TV Size)"

Insane:
00:38:382 (1) - Remove NC? (For pattern's sake, since a lot of this comboing seems like pattern-comboing)
00:38:745 (2) - Add NC?
00:51:654 (4) - NC?

Hurd:
00:26:200 (7) - Lower the left-most sliderpoint so it's symmetrical~

Nurmul:
00:52:018 - Add note?~

Nurmul:
Swaq

Pretty cool mapset :>

hey sorry for the late mod x.x
from me and mythol's queue ~ pls ignore if you don't like

Normal
looks fine xD

Above Normal
00:27:109 (2) - maybe you can make this slider curvy? it stands out from the other sliders lol
01:07:473 (1) - finish

Hard
00:58:564 (10) - NC?
01:10:200 (11) - just one grid to the left for neater spacing (sorry nazi mod lol)

ztrot's Insane
00:31:291 (2) - move first slider point to x:136 y: 264 so it lines up with 5 . And then to fix up spacing after that, move 1 one grid to the left. visual xD: http://puu.sh/rF02
it just looks neater imo, but up to you in the end

gl ~ ^^

Random check from #modreqs
((Umm... seems it's a recheck post




Cell me back when you fixed it~:3

Edit: It's my 2000 post xD