forum

Girls' Generation - Tell Me Your Wish (Genie) [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
80
show more
Topic Starter
Aldwych
Hi Etsu! o/

Etsu wrote:

Hello!

Taiko NM from my Queue

Sorry I'm so late... npnp it's a long set

don = d | kat = k
big don = D | big kat = K


General:
  1. None.

Kantan
00:29:556 (12) - change d? You should keep rhythm as 00:21:751 (2,3,4) - imo

Seems legit

00:43:703 (30) - change d... the voice decreases and 00:44:190 (31) - change K? It combines well with saucer background


Clap sound in the music and voice is higher than the one before. Finisher needs contrast so no changes too since (30) is still k.


00:56:385 (47,53) - deleted? I'm not sure but it's too kantan (small break) imo It's the kiai, so it's fine, and i want the kiai to be the hardest place.

Likewise in similar parts... No changes further since it is decent.

02:25:654 - to 02:31:507 - I would break and add spiner in 02:31:738 - I listen better that way imo

Not a huge fan keep noticing but for me, it has no sense.

Futsuu
00:34:434 (29,30) - change d? voice as it does not increase (It combines well with the rhythm) imo According to what i've done in the vocals pitches, k is more logic, however i keep notice since both are decent.

00:36:629 (33) - delete? better muzukashii on muzukashii i've done a triple here, Fixed all this section. I guess it's better having some break on finishers

00:39:800 - add note? that emptiness feels weird... when here rhythms Added in case

00:40:532 (43) - delete... no important sound in Futsuu Deleted

00:55:410 (75) - change d? the voice is not so high Prefer keeping as k, my intention due to the 1/1 breaks.

00:59:312 (86) - ^ Same

01:07:117 (108) - delete? as it is a bit long 01:06:873 (107,108,109,110) - and well you are following rhythm in 01:07:605 (110) -

Had to, that's what i've need to do. But actually i'm doing at 01:08:93 instead

02:55:166 (51,52,53,54,55,56) - same... delete in 02:55:654 (53) - ? For this place i'm gonna keep as it is right know this is in accordance to the higher diff which has no break here since it is the "final hyped part"

03:04:678 (83,84,85,86,87,88,89,90) - same... and if you delete notes in 03:04:922 (84,86) - ? I listen better so in this diff imo

Gonna think about it but i like how it is

At least some of your points helped to do some nerfs/break about the futsuu.

Muzukashii
00:34:434 (40,41) - change d? Same as above

00:59:312 (120) - change d? the voice decreases somewhat ^

01:08:824 (152,153,154,155) - if you do dd kk ? some sounds are similar and mix well (It is essential for muzukashii) Wanted to constrast due to the vocal, so i prefer my version.

01:13:215 (170) - change d? Vocal contrast too on "Your wish"

01:16:995 (184) - change k? ^ "Your dream"

01:21:020 (200) - change d? This one is legit

01:22:483 (205) - delete? a short break to a new rhythm in 01:22:727 (205) - imo it's fine

02:54:434 (69) - change d? fixed

03:31:995 (214) - It is not necessary so that finish is not very high sound since i've reduced the volume it's ok, the aim is to use the finisher as final note/dacing pose




Oni
00:32:483 (43,44,45) - better with dkd... you better listen well so that there are no clear sound in kkk imo vocal voice on k + beats on d

00:33:459 (47,48,49,51,52,53) - same^

00:42:117 (78,79) - control + g? 00:42:727 (80,81) - same... and 00:43:703 (82) - change d... I listen better and voice
Beats + clap on the right place

00:46:629 (94) - change k? Fixed

00:55:410 (129) - change d... the voice decreases Same as all aboves

00:56:385 (133) - change k? similar to 00:52:239 (114,115,116) -

Vocals are different, that's why triple d.

01:05:898 (170,171,172,173,174) - that little stream ... and if you do kdddk? voice starts in 01:05:898 (170) - so it sounds good imo

Then i should kdkdk instead which is more logic according to the vocals then. i'm using k at the end as a spike like they're doing

01:06:873 (176,177,178,179,180) - same^

01:12:727 (202) - change d

01:16:629 (219) - change k? Give some diversity on these doublets :<

01:34:922 (293,297,301) - change d... voice similar in this notes 01:34:922 (293,296) - by a secondary choir and is a nice change 00:32:971 - imo Same argues as above

00:32:971 - change k? wat backward? Beats.

03:22:483 (224,225,226) - if your do d k d? I follow the voice imo
combo background synthethiser + vocals



Inner Oni
00:31:385 (46) - change k? the voice end there aaaaaa

00:32:483 (50,51,52) - same in Oni?

00:38:093 (72) - change d? the voice is not so similar imo it is, kkd is for contrast with the beats after

00:41:507 (90) - ^

00:41:995 (93,94,95) - control + g? same previous diff with 00:42:239 (95,96,97,98) - wwwwwwww

00:45:898 (108) - change d?

00:47:849 (118) - mmm.. change k since I see that change colors too and is valid Pattern consistency, look just at the start of the section.

00:55:410 (156) - change d?

00:56:385 (160) - change k?

01:12:727 (244) - change d?

01:16:629 (264) - ^

01:22:483 (293,294,295,296,297,298,299) - not feeling well... I listen better with kddkkdd imo background sythe + vocals.

02:32:483 (625,626,627,628,629,630,631,632,633) - if your do ddkdkddkk although I'm not sure if you use that stream... Why use yours? Mine use d on beats and k-on vocals + DJ stuff which is accurate


03:23:214 (266) - change d? new rhythm section imo no real reason in the music to change to d, no contrast or beat.



Some similar parts should apply it as it is a similar rhythm this music. That's it... Good luck and good map :)
Thanks for the mod! Since i've no replied to all of your suggestions, it means they are rejected and the argues are the same as what i've said above or on the previous diffs.
At least you unlocked me some tourbles i had on the futsuu, thanks! :D
Spork Lover
Hey buddy, M4M as promised from my queue :3

Kantan:
01:00:288 (53) - Donno if you should remove this note due to new players trying to hit the D.
01:42:727 (104,105,106) - I'd probably remove 105, since 01:38:824 (99,100) - practically sounds the same.
01:50:532 (116,117,118) - donno about this one, but just throwing it out there.
02:02:727 (133) - Same as on 1:00
02:45:654 (186) - Same lol
02:57:361 (203) - Hi (You know what I mean, won't mention them anymore xD) It's probably not even a problem, but I thought about it since I used to have that problem a lot when I was new with Taiko.
03:05:166 (215) - :P

Diff is really solid and consistent imo :D

Futsuu:
01:19:068 (146) - k for consistency with previous patterns? (You even did it on 02:21:020 (304,305,306,307) - )
01:37:117 (188) - If you want, you can change this to a d to emphasize that the vocals go a bit deeper here.
01:42:727 (200,201,202) - This is inconsistent with 00:48:093 (60,61) - and also sounds a little off to me.
01:50:776 (220,221) - If you REALLY want this triple, change the middle note to a d, since there aren't any claps in the song (That's the way you've been doing the dkk up untill now)
02:50:532 (38) - d maybe? :o Would also flow nicely with the next quad (02:52:239 (43,44,45,46) - )

Muzukashii:
00:26:629 (17,18) - To me, I feel that the dkk patterns should apply to the audible claps in the song only (Like you did in the Futsuu!), 'cause imo it feels REALLY nice to do it like that (Here it's kinda overused, so maybe kdk for this triple?)
00:30:532 (28,29,30) - Maybe ddk?
^ Not gonna comment on the clap stuff anymore, 'cause I don't wanna spam the muzu with requests, if you deny them x) (Applies to both 1st and 2nd verse)
00:32:483 (34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42) - Maybe some kdk stuff due to vocal pitch?

Can't find anything else, really nice diff :D

Oni:
00:52:727 (117,118,119) - kkd for consistency with 01:00:044 (148,149,150,151,152,153) - ?
02:00:532 (390,391,392,393,394) - This pattern compared to 00:54:190 (123,124,125,126,127) - is a lot different. Maybe change the one at 0:54 to dkkkd or kdddk if you wanna be REALLY consistent? x)

Really consistent too, I like it :3

Inner Oni:
00:29:800 (39) - Maybe change to d, to emphasize better with the claps that come later?
00:34:434 (58,59,60,61,62) - Feels odd to have a quint on a spot with little audible parts. (even the vocals don't go like this)
00:45:410 (106) - same reason as on futsuu and muzu, where I talked about that the "claps" should be unique. maybe d here?
00:48:825 (124,125) - Same here (dk?) (I won't comment further on those.)
01:23:093 (298) - imo a k works better here to emphasize the d on the white tick :^)
01:31:263 (331,332) - I'll mention this "clap" thing tho lol, 'cause it's pretty hard to recognise :p
01:42:117 (379) - Delete? :3
02:25:532 (603) - Same as on 1:23 :^)
03:24:068 (272) - Same again :3

That's it for me :D Hope my mod helped :3 <3
Topic Starter
Aldwych

Spork Lover wrote:

Hey buddy, M4M as promised from my queue :3

Kantan:
01:00:288 (53) - Donno if you should remove this note due to new players trying to hit the D.
01:42:727 (104,105,106) - I'd probably remove 105, since 01:38:824 (99,100) - practically sounds the same.
01:50:532 (116,117,118) - donno about this one, but just throwing it out there.
02:02:727 (133) - Same as on 1:00
02:45:654 (186) - Same lol
02:57:361 (203) - Hi (You know what I mean, won't mention them anymore xD) It's probably not even a problem, but I thought about it since I used to have that problem a lot when I was new with Taiko.
03:05:166 (215) - :P

Well, all are denied, about the finishers i'm gonna keep noticing if they really disturbs which is maybe right but i'm okay for now, about the deletes, i'm ok with the dkd patterns, i'm also afraid that would make too much gap with futsuu afterall.

Diff is really solid and consistent imo :D

Futsuu:
01:19:068 (146) - k for consistency with previous patterns? (You even did it on 02:21:020 (304,305,306,307) - ) Fixed
01:37:117 (188) - If you want, you can change this to a d to emphasize that the vocals go a bit deeper here. I'm ok since there's no sounds here unless vocals
01:42:727 (200,201,202) - This is inconsistent with 00:48:093 (60,61) - and also sounds a little off to me.
01:50:776 (220,221) - If you REALLY want this triple, change the middle note to a d, since there aren't any claps in the song (That's the way you've been doing the dkk up untill now) Delete all the unconsistencies.
02:50:532 (38) - d maybe? :o Would also flow nicely with the next quad (02:52:239 (43,44,45,46) - ) Prefer ddkk since the vocals use different words between and pitch too.

Muzukashii:
00:26:629 (17,18) - To me, I feel that the dkk patterns should apply to the audible claps in the song only (Like you did in the Futsuu!), 'cause imo it feels REALLY nice to do it like that (Here it's kinda overused, so maybe kdk for this triple?) I use k in combinaton of the basic clap and vocals, i know what you mean and it sounds nice but i don't like overuse of d for nothing and just keeping k for claps.
00:30:532 (28,29,30) - Maybe ddk?
^ Not gonna comment on the clap stuff anymore, 'cause I don't wanna spam the muzu with requests, if you deny them x) (Applies to both 1st and 2nd verse)
00:32:483 (34,35,36,37,38,39,40,41,42) - Maybe some kdk stuff due to vocal pitch? The beats does the pitch and contrast itselves :D

Can't find anything else, really nice diff :D

Oni:
00:52:727 (117,118,119) - kkd for consistency with 01:00:044 (148,149,150,151,152,153) - ? I feel they are singing differently from what you're comparing.
02:00:532 (390,391,392,393,394) - This pattern compared to 00:54:190 (123,124,125,126,127) - is a lot different. Maybe change the one at 0:54 to dkkkd or kdddk if you wanna be REALLY consistent? x) Yeah consistency, but these parts are a bit different, because are 02:00:532n tiffany extends her vocals, that why quints instead of tripple.

Really consistent too, I like it :3

Inner Oni:
00:29:800 (39) - Maybe change to d, to emphasize better with the claps that come later? I prefer k since it seems to follow better the melody, and it gives contrast with the beat @40.

00:34:434 (58,59,60,61,62) - Feels odd to have a quint on a spot with little audible parts. (even the vocals don't go like this)

It serves as an ending section and differences from On, keep noticing tho

00:45:410 (106) - same reason as on futsuu and muzu, where I talked about that the "claps" should be unique. maybe d here?
00:48:825 (124,125) - Same here (dk?) (I won't comment further on those.)

haha, vocals! ¦:^(

01:23:093 (298) - imo a k works better here to emphasize the d on the white tick :^)

Nice idea, keep noticing but the k are used for synthetiser and nothing else. :D

01:31:263 (331,332) - I'll mention this "clap" thing tho lol, 'cause it's pretty hard to recognise :p

Vocal tense here. :D

01:42:117 (379) - Delete? :3 Why ? :3
02:25:532 (603) - Same as on 1:23 :^)
03:24:068 (272) - Same again :3

That's it for me :D Hope my mod helped :3 <3
Thanks for the mod! :D
Even if i didn't applied much, you tried to explained a lot which is really nice.
Keep going! ;)
Spork Lover

Aldwych wrote:

01:42:117 (379) - Delete? :3 Why ? :3
02:25:532 (603) - Same as on 1:23 :^)
03:24:068 (272) - Same again :3

Was basically to emphasize the audible claps in the song even more, but on a second note, I realised that maybe 4 single taps is too plain lol :^)
Nyan
[Kantan]

Increase accuracy to 2.5~3
02:28:581 (165,166,167) - d d d

[Futsuu]

Increase accuracy to 3.5~4
This is a suggestion that removes plenty of notes. You can ignore this suggestion.
Delete 00:52:727 (69) , 00:56:629 (80) , 01:00:532 (91)
Delete 01:55:166 (227) , 01:59:068 (238) , 02:02:971 (249)
Delete 02:38:093 (3) , 02:41:995 (14) , 02:45:898 (25)

03:31:020 (162,163,164,165) - d ddK

[Muzu]

Increase accuracy to 4.5~5
01:04:190 (136,137,138,139,140) - d k d d d k

[Oni]

00:32:483 (43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - k k ddd k k ddd
01:04:434 - add a kat

[Inner Oni]

Increase accuracy to 5.5~6
00:22:483 - add a note
00:26:385 - add a note

01:26:873 - add a note
01:30:776 - add a note
Topic Starter
Aldwych
Nyyaaaan

Nyan wrote:

[Kantan]

Increase accuracy to 2.5~3 For all : I'm ok with my settings, that's my standards
02:28:581 (165,166,167) - d d d Why? There's a clap here actually

[Futsuu]

Increase accuracy to 3.5~4
This is a suggestion that removes plenty of notes. You can ignore this suggestion. I'm gonna think about it and get more suggestions about these place if people notes about it, currently you're right since it doesn't follow the vocals, but the problem actually would be to the spread with muzukashi since there's triple here. So i have to balance a bit and make choices.
Delete 00:52:727 (69) , 00:56:629 (80) , 01:00:532 (91)
Delete 01:55:166 (227) , 01:59:068 (238) , 02:02:971 (249)
Delete 02:38:093 (3) , 02:41:995 (14) , 02:45:898 (25)

03:31:020 (162,163,164,165) - d ddK Seems legit

[Muzu]

Increase accuracy to 4.5~5
01:04:190 (136,137,138,139,140) - d k d d d k I prefer d ddd k d k instead for consistency with seamed patterns



[Oni]

00:32:483 (43,44,45,46,47,48,49,50) - k k ddd k k ddd What why? Why this sudden change?
01:04:434 - add a kat Fixed what i had to do.

[Inner Oni]

Increase accuracy to 5.5~6 Fixed to 6
00:22:483 - add a note
00:26:385 - add a note

01:26:873 - add a note
01:30:776 - add a note
Let these calm parts, calm patterns
Thanks for the mod <3
Raediaufar
not my pick of a song sorry, I like some of their songs like e.g. Kissing You, Dancing Queen.. but not this

have a star instead
_kumakichi
hi

the mapset is (very) solid and the notes are indeed placed in the right place
(which is sth that noobs as skill-less as me could't possibly achieve)
but whether it is fun.........I couldn't possibly judge the map is cool, just that kpop isn't my type

star given...
good luck~
Topic Starter
Aldwych
moar starz'

anyway thanks for the check both ;)
Poii
:) Poii NM service :)

|d for don| D for Big Don| k for katsu| K for Big Katsu|

Futsuu
Mods
00:56:629 (80) - better bury this :v i mean kick it away
01:25:166 (163) - change to d, bass drum sound :v and same as oni
01:27:117 (167) - same ^
01:34:922 (183,184,185,186) - k d k d ? how about d k d k ?
01:59:068 (237) - kill this
01:59:068 (237) - miss this one ?
02:41:263 (12) - k ? you place d here 00:56:385 (79) - and here 01:58:337 (235) - -_-
02:41:995 (14) - delete this
02:56:142 (56) - say goodbye to this note, i mean just delete it :v
03:00:044 (68) - burn this :v i mean del
03:03:946 (80) - BUUURRRRNNN :v del this
03:09:068 - missing girlfriend ? i mean note :v

Muzukashi
Mods
00:51:507 (91) - change to D "Geuraeyo nan"
01:22:727 (208) - change to k, better sound (i think) :v
01:22:971 (209) - you can del this k, for a better sound, cause the snare and vocal is too weak :3
01:27:117 (221,222) - k d ? not d k
01:53:946 (302) - change to D
02:33:459 (441) - better d or k or D ? (i think D)
02:36:873 (2) - change to D
02:44:434 (31) - Throw this :v
02:45:166 (32) - strong vocal, change it to K

Oni
Mods
Oni
01:25:166 (257) - i dunno why sir, but its better when i changed it to d, you can ignore this, in another case, you place d, before triplet, so why you place k there ?
00:51:507 (91) - change to D, its better than K "Geuraeyo nan"
01:53:946 (301) - change to D
02:36:629 (1) - change to D
02:44:434 (31) - del, same pattern like previous
02:45:166 (33) - strong vocal, change it to K

psssttt
Sorry i cant mods Inner oni :o and i cant find any problem with your kantan
8-) Free comment, Free reject 8-)
Topic Starter
Aldwych

PoPoii wrote:

:) Poii NM service :)

|d for don| D for Big Don| k for katsu| K for Big Katsu|

Futsuu
Mods
00:56:629 (80) - better bury this :v i mean kick it away Made some changes on the kiai but fixed at these places.
01:25:166 (163) - change to d, bass drum sound :v and same as oni Fixed on futsuu at least
01:27:117 (167) - same ^
01:34:922 (183,184,185,186) - k d k d ? how about d k d k ? I prefer my version, vocals and tense :V
01:59:068 (237) - kill this
01:59:068 (237) - miss this one ? Wat on these 2? Oo Made my changes tho'
02:41:263 (12) - k ? you place d here 00:56:385 (79) - and here 01:58:337 (235) - -_- -_-
02:41:995 (14) - delete this made same changes
02:56:142 (56) - say goodbye to this note, i mean just delete it :v Did on all wtf how
03:00:044 (68) - burn this :v i mean del
03:03:946 (80) - BUUURRRRNNN :v del this
03:09:068 - missing girlfriend ? i mean note :v
Break :V

Muzukashi
Mods
00:51:507 (91) - change to D "Geuraeyo nan" I like D K K D since the k are for the high vocals and the D as beats or filler
01:22:727 (208) - change to k, better sound (i think) :v That would make too much k for me :V
01:22:971 (209) - you can del this k, for a better sound, cause the snare and vocal is too weak :3 I'm fine with it
01:27:117 (221,222) - k d ? not d k Consitency with 01:31:020 sure
01:53:946 (302) - change to D bla
02:33:459 (441) - better d or k or D ? (i think D) that would make some problems with the next diff, even if K is legit for me.
02:36:873 (2) - change to D
02:44:434 (31) - Throw this :v Don't break my structures! D:
02:45:166 (32) - strong vocal, change it to K Not that much, i mean (32) was kinda important tho.

Oni
Mods
Oni
01:25:166 (257) - i dunno why sir, but its better when i changed it to d, you can ignore this, in another case, you place d, before triplet, so why you place k there ? Fixed
00:51:507 (91) - change to D, its better than K "Geuraeyo nan"
01:53:946 (301) - change to D
02:36:629 (1) - change to D
02:44:434 (31) - del, same pattern like previous Fixed yep
02:45:166 (33) - strong vocal, change it to K The rest is denied, same argues as other diffs so.

psssttt
Sorry i cant mods Inner oni :o and i cant find any problem with your kantan
8-) Free comment, Free reject 8-)
Nice mod dude, it polished a bit by removing several mistakes from me. :>
JessiChan
Hihi M4M request ^^

Note: My english is very bad and... i can mod muzu > oni > inner oni. Easiers diff are difficult for me (noob modder) :?

d Little Don
k Little Kat
D Big Don
K Big Kat

Muzukashii
00:25:166 (13) - k
00:29:068 (24) - ^
00:30:776 (29) - d
01:35:166 (245,246) - ctrl + g
01:40:288 (258) - k

Oni
00:28:824 (31,32) - ctrl + g
01:02:117 (158) - d
01:06:873 (179,180) - k
01:10:776 (197) - ^
01:11:020 (199) - d
01:14:678 (214) - k
01:14:922 (216) - d
01:33:946 (293) - Delethe this
01:48:093 (342) - k
02:17:117 (470) - ^
02:19:068 (479) - ^
02:29:312 (521) - add a k here
02:29:800 (523) - d

Inner Oni
00:38:824 (76) - k
00:39:556 (80) - d
00:40:288 (84) - Delete This
00:47:971 (118) - k
00:48:093 (119) - Delete This
01:02:117 (190) - d
01:05:288 (205,206) - ctrl + g
01:06:873 (215) - k
01:10:166 (232,233) - ctrl + g
01:33:946 (345) - Delete this
01:36:995 (357,358) - ctrl + g
01:37:361 (360) - k
01:48:581 (408) - Delete this
01:50:410 (418) - k
01:50:532 (419) - Delete this
02:29:312 (615) - add a d
02:50:654 (81,82) - ctrl + g
02:58:824 (130,131) - ^
02:59:190 (133,134) - ^

Good Look ^^
Topic Starter
Aldwych

JessiChan wrote:

Hihi M4M request ^^

Note: My english is very bad and... i can mod muzu > oni > inner oni. Easiers diff are difficult for me (noob modder) :?

d Little Don
k Little Kat
D Big Don
K Big Kat

Muzukashii
00:25:166 (13) - k It was already from previous mod, guess you got the good intuition.
00:29:068 (24) - ^ Fixed Fixed
00:30:776 (29) - d
01:35:166 (245,246) - ctrl + g Fine with this pattern
01:40:288 (258) - k
Already

Oni
00:28:824 (31,32) - ctrl + g Beat at this place, won't change
01:02:117 (158) - d Keeping the contrast where the beats are.
01:06:873 (179,180) - k Double similar patterns part
01:10:776 (197) - ^ Fixed just because of next pattern for mirror style.
01:11:020 (199) - d Keeping for ^
01:14:678 (214) - k Keeping
01:14:922 (216) - d Keeping
01:33:946 (293) - Delethe this Waaat? Beats?
01:48:093 (342) - k Fixed
02:17:117 (470) - ^ Reverse patterns
02:19:068 (479) - ^ Vocals are not high
02:29:312 (521) - add a k here why?
02:29:800 (523) - d
Why?

Inner Oni
00:38:824 (76) - k
00:39:556 (80) - d
00:40:288 (84) - Delete This
00:47:971 (118) - k
00:48:093 (119) - Delete This
01:02:117 (190) - d
01:05:288 (205,206) - ctrl + g
01:06:873 (215) - k
01:10:166 (232,233) - ctrl + g
01:33:946 (345) - Delete this
01:36:995 (357,358) - ctrl + g
01:37:361 (360) - k
01:48:581 (408) - Delete this
01:50:410 (418) - k
01:50:532 (419) - Delete this
02:29:312 (615) - add a d
02:50:654 (81,82) - ctrl + g
02:58:824 (130,131) - ^
02:59:190 (133,134) - ^

All denied, you're deleting at non-sense part just to follow vocals and completely forgot the beats and you're changing patterns where i used reverse style, some patterns a made to create a music and play style and it has to be kept.

Good Look ^^
Thanks for the mod, will look on your map further :D
Aloda
Hey. Looks like previous modders have gone for the higher diffs, so I'm gonna focus on the lower ones.
Metadata
I'm not 100% sure about this but after a bit of research it seems like the official Korean song title is "소원을 말해봐 (Genie)". You might want to do some research of your own to make sure though.

Also, some things you might want to add to the tags:
  • Oh! (the name of the album the song is from)
    SNSD (common abbreviation of the group's Korean name)
    Since you have the Romanised member names, you might also want to add their Korean names: 태연, 써니, 티파니, 효연, 유리, 수영, 윤아, 서현 and 제시카

General
Your preview point isn't snapped correctly

For 03:08:581 - 03:24:190, the two other times this rhythm happens you've made it Kiai, so why not this time? tbh I think you'd be better off removing the Kiai from the other sections to make more of a contrast between them and the stronger sections preceding them.

It looks like the song only has 3 or 4 different rhythms that it repeats through the song, My suggestions below only mention the first time a rhythm occurs, but note that they apply to all instances of that rhythm.

Kantan
I think your structure in the 00:36:385 - 00:51:995 section is a little weird. You've placed most of your 1/1 patterns so they cover the first half of each bar, but, imo, both the music and the vocals are stronger in the second half. I think this section would play a lot better if you changed it around to match this (move 00:38:824 (22) to 00:37:849 etc). If you're worried about the becoming too similar to the previous section, I think it's okay since the music here is basically just a more intense version of the same thing.

There's something a little off about the first half of your Kiai section(s). It seems like you're trying to map to the vocals, but I think you're missing some of the more important vocal sounds. Try removing 00:52:483 (41) and adding a note at 00:54:434. I think this matches the vocals a little better and plays better too.

Futsuu
I don't really understand the 1/2 patterns you've used at the start. (00:21:751 (2,3,4) etc). Many of them don't really seem to be mapped to anything, and there are some really strong drum sounds that you've ignored. I also think that this density of 1/2 patterns doesn't contrast well with the following section. It has a very similar density to this one, yet the music is much more intense. For this section, you have a couple of options. You could try some simple 1/1 patterns, similar to what you've done in the Kantan, but with the gaps filled in, or, you could map more closely to the rhythm - like this
I think that having 3/4 spacing like this in a Futsuu would be okay here since the bpm is quite low. You could continue with patterns like this throughout the section.

You're mapping to the vocals in 00:36:385 - 00:51:995? I think it would match the vocals a lot better if you moved 00:37:849 (35,36,37) and 00:45:654 (53,54,55) a beat backwards.

I can kind of see what you're mapping to 01:07:605 - 01:23:215, but it plays very strangely imo. I think this section would benefit from mapping closely to the rhythm, since the vocals here aren't really suited to being mapped.

Muzukashii
Like with the Futsuu, I don't really understand your structure at the start. I think you could build on my suggestion to map to the rhythm by including the strong drum beats too. Like with the Futsuu, this structure would be repeated through the section.

For 00:36:385 - 00:51:995, I think you could map a little more closely to the vocals, including some of the 1/4 vocal sounds, like at 00:38:093. As is, your structure seems to be halfway between mapping to the vocals and the rhythm, and it feels very strange to play.

I feel that many of the 1/4 triplet you've used in the Kiai are a little over the top. There are some 1/4 sounds in the background, but you're mapping to the vocals, so you should let that be the main thing that influences your mapping. Particularly in the second half (01:07:605 - 01:23:215), patterns like 01:08:824 (154,155,156,157) are fine since they match nicely with the vocals, but 01:09:800 (158,159,160) and 01:10:776 (162,163,164) feel [i]very[/i/] forced to me. I think you should go through the Kiai sections and try to remove the 1/4 patterns that aren't necessary for the flow of the map.
gl with the map :D
Topic Starter
Aldwych
Hi Aloda!

Aloda wrote:

Hey. Looks like previous modders have gone for the higher diffs, so I'm gonna focus on the lower ones. as you wish
Metadata
I'm not 100% sure about this but after a bit of research it seems like the official Korean song title is "소원을 말해봐 (Genie)". You might want to do some research of your own to make sure though. Wikipedia seems a safe one, applied

Also, some things you might want to add to the tags:
  • Oh! (the name of the album the song is from) Hmmm since it's also a song, i prefer note, the argue is decent, but the result behind may not be ok.
    SNSD (common abbreviation of the group's Korean name) Yup
    Since you have the Romanised member names, you might also want to add their Korean names: 태연, 써니, 티파니, 효연, 유리, 수영, 윤아, 서현 and 제시카 and yep

General
Your preview point isn't snapped correctly It doesn't need to be snapped by what i know ( unless you prove me wrong)
For 03:08:581 - 03:24:190, the two other times this rhythm happens you've made it Kiai, so why not this time? tbh I think you'd be better off removing the Kiai from the other sections to make more of a contrast between them and the stronger sections preceding them. Hmmm nice ideas but for now i'll refuse, by order : I'll keep 03:08:581 as non kiai because after taeyeon solo, it feels weird to keep this as kiai also if you looked at the dance it looks like an ending (even tho that's not the most decent argue to give i admit haha). The two others are still on kiai since it's the collective part song and not solo or duo, it seems logic to group in the kiai. However if it's compromising to the ranking, i'll do the changes but for now i'll keep how it is

It looks like the song only has 3 or 4 different rhythms that it repeats through the song, My suggestions below only mention the first time a rhythm occurs, but note that they apply to all instances of that rhythm. Yep you've described well, it's a pop song so there's no multiple rythm, i'm just doing dense parts depending on how important/calm the music is.

Kantan
I think your structure in the 00:36:385 - 00:51:995 section is a little weird. You've placed most of your 1/1 patterns so they cover the first half of each bar, but, imo, both the music and the vocals are stronger in the second half. I think this section would play a lot better if you changed it around to match this (move 00:38:824 (22) to 00:37:849 etc). If you're worried about the becoming too similar to the previous section, I think it's okay since the music here is basically just a more intense version of the same thing. Tbh i don't see much difference on the changes (i mean what it gives more). HOWEVER, there's something you've may ommit, is the density, if i do the changed, i've to do this 00:45:654 - right? But what's just before? A quint with finisher as end. That would be a bit too dense to play for new players right? Let's keep a clean start part :D

There's something a little off about the first half of your Kiai section(s). It seems like you're trying to map to the vocals, but I think you're missing some of the more important vocal sounds. Try removing 00:52:483 (41) and adding a note at 00:54:434. I think this matches the vocals a little better and plays better too. Yes but have you analised well the first kiai part? All my quints suits because they scale on 1/1 lyrics, just listen again the chorus, there's no 1/2 lyrics on where i mapped, it's between them and i strongly think it's easier for new players to focus on not dense lyrics, the other 1/1 are decent since it's the main beat and easy to follow and look by the white bar

Futsuu
I don't really understand the 1/2 patterns you've used at the start. (00:21:751 (2,3,4) etc). Many of them don't really seem to be mapped to anything, and there are some really strong drum sounds that you've ignored. I also think that this density of 1/2 patterns doesn't contrast well with the following section. It has a very similar density to this one, yet the music is much more intense. For this section, you have a couple of options. You could try some simple 1/1 patterns, similar to what you've done in the Kantan, but with the gaps filled in, or, you could map more closely to the rhythm - like this
I think that having 3/4 spacing like this in a Futsuu would be okay here since the bpm is quite low. You could continue with patterns like this throughout the section. Yep, it sounds good, changed in that way except for 00:31:507 (22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29,30,31) - which i want to keep that way.


You're mapping to the vocals in 00:36:385 - 00:51:995? I think it would match the vocals a lot better if you moved 00:37:849 (35,36,37) and 00:45:654 (53,54,55) a beat backwards Agree, it sounds better..

I can kind of see what you're mapping to 01:07:605 - 01:23:215, but it plays very strangely imo. I think this section would benefit from mapping closely to the rhythm, since the vocals here aren't really suited to being mapped. Tried different things, but i'm not happier. If you have any ideas, do not hesitate

Muzukashii
Like with the Futsuu, I don't really understand your structure at the start. I think you could build on my suggestion to map to the rhythm by including the strong drum beats too. Like with the Futsuu, this structure would be repeated through the section. Changed in that way

For 00:36:385 - 00:51:995, I think you could map a little more closely to the vocals, including some of the 1/4 vocal sounds, like at 00:38:093. As is, your structure seems to be halfway between mapping to the vocals and the rhythm, and it feels very strange to play. Look at the oni before :D

I feel that many of the 1/4 triplet you've used in the Kiai are a little over the top. There are some 1/4 sounds in the background, but you're mapping to the vocals, so you should let that be the main thing that influences your mapping. Particularly in the second half (01:07:605 - 01:23:215), patterns like 01:08:824 (154,155,156,157) are fine since they match nicely with the vocals, but 01:09:800 (158,159,160) and 01:10:776 (162,163,164) feel [i]very[/i/] forced to me. I think you should go through the Kiai sections and try to remove the 1/4 patterns that aren't necessary for the flow of the map. The gap with the oni would be meh after.
gl with the map :D
Finished. Interesting and really decent mod, well that's what i expected tbh, i'm curious how long you took for this mod.
Arrival
salu pierre yves thomas

[General]

Rajoute k-pop et SM Entertainment (leur label) dans les tags

Peut etre OD 2.5 / 3 pour la Kantan / 3.5 pour la Futsuu / 4.5 pour la Muzu ?
Considère vivement 5.5 pour la Inner. OD 6 123 BPM ça fait du OD 9 185BPM en DT.....

[Kantan]

00:49:556 - Rajoute une note ici ? Sachant que tu as un break 4/1 après, et que a correspond au pattern 00:42:239 (27,28,29,30,31) - (et ici aussi du coup 01:51:995 - )

02:35:410 - Spinner ici ? On a deja un bon break 4/1 avant, le joueur connait la musique, c'est que bénéfique.

[Futsuu]

00:37:605 (35) - A déplacer a 00:38:093 - plutot ? Ca rend mieux imo

01:08:581 (113,114,115,116) - A la place de ça qui est un peu boring a jouer, pourquoi pas un 3/2 ? Peut etre pas obligé de le mettre pour chaque autre pattern, mais genre 1 fois sur 2 c'est peut etre intéréssant.

[Muzukashii]

01:22:483 (207) - Triplet ici ?

02:29:312 - Rajouter un kat ici rendrait bien.

03:06:385 (120) - J'aime pas trop ce genre de suggestions, mais change ça en k, car ça va vraiment mieux avec le vocal, et synergise bien avec le pattern k k ddd juste avant.

03:31:385 (212) - Je conseille un doublet dk ici. Mais simple suggestion

[Oni]

00:21:751 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - Que dis tu de ceci a la place ? Je pense que ça colle mieux au rythme général.

01:05:898 (169,170,171,172,173,174,175,176,177,178,179) - Faire ddk k ddddk rend mieux a mon avis.

02:58:946 (109) - Pourquoi pas déplacer cette note a 02:58:459 - ? Un quintuplet qui overlap sur le gros tick blanc rend pas ouf je trouve, et casse un peu le rythme crée avant. Ca permettrait aussi d'accentuer ces deux notes 02:59:068 (110,111) -

[Inner Oni]

00:41:629 (93) - Supprime cette note et met un d a 00:41:873 - ?

01:22:483 (295,296,297,298,299,300,301) - Un peu moche ce pattern ça me fait penser a Verdi Kappa. kdkkdkd a la place me parait mieux

02:55:044 (107) - Supprime cette note ? Je pense qu'avoir un quintuplet avant un stream de plus de 5 notes dessert un peu ce dernier. T'as mieux fait d'avoir triplet + une note 1/2 + stream pour de la mise en valeur. (03:06:020 (175) - Ici aussi par exemple etc)


Bon la quasi totalité de mes suggestions sont valables pour d'autres endroits de la musique oublie pas.

Bonne chance
Topic Starter
Aldwych

Arrival wrote:

salu pierre yves thomas :japanese_goblin:

[General]

Rajoute k-pop et SM Entertainment (leur label) dans les tags oké

Peut etre OD 2.5 / 3 pour la Kantan / 3.5 pour la Futsuu / 4.5 pour la Muzu ?
Considère vivement 5.5 pour la Inner. OD 6 123 BPM ça fait du OD 9 185BPM en DT..... Ok pour le 5.5 Pour le reste, je garde mes standards (TG yael)


[Kantan]

00:49:556 - Rajoute une note ici ? Sachant que tu as un break 4/1 après, et que a correspond au pattern 00:42:239 (27,28,29,30,31) - (et ici aussi du coup 01:51:995 - )

02:35:410 - Spinner ici ? On a deja un bon break 4/1 avant, le joueur connait la musique, c'est que bénéfique.

All fixed

[Futsuu]

00:37:605 (35) - A déplacer a 00:38:093 - plutot ? Ca rend mieux imo

01:08:581 (113,114,115,116) - A la place de ça qui est un peu boring a jouer, pourquoi pas un 3/2 ? Peut etre pas obligé de le mettre pour chaque autre pattern, mais genre 1 fois sur 2 c'est peut etre intéréssant.

All Denied, pour le premier, les deux sont décents, mais je préfère éviter la confusion du aux vocals qui sont un peu 1/4 dans les endroits mentionnés. Et pour le second, ca va over exploser le SR et tout le monde va QQ.


[Muzukashii]

01:22:483 (207) - Triplet ici ? Ca fait un peu tout much, à voir selon les avis.

02:29:312 - Rajouter un kat ici rendrait bien. Yee

03:06:385 (120) - J'aime pas trop ce genre de suggestions, mais change ça en k, car ça va vraiment mieux avec le vocal, et synergise bien avec le pattern k k ddd juste avant. Aussi d'accord

03:31:385 (212) - Je conseille un doublet dk ici. Mais simple suggestion A voir ouais, c'est décent mais pas nécéssaire.

[Oni]

00:21:751 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11) - Que dis tu de ceci a la place ? Je pense que ça colle mieux au rythme général.

Tu met a des endroits :ok_hand: pour en enlver à des endroits :japanese_goblin:, en vrai ca aurait pu être correct sauf que tu veux délete la ou y'a du triple vocal a sniper ez.

01:05:898 (169,170,171,172,173,174,175,176,177,178,179) - Faire ddk k ddddk rend mieux a mon avis.

T'es pas en accord avec ton image mais ce que tu me donne me va parce que j'ai fait un peu trop dans ces endroits comparé aux kiai.


02:58:946 (109) - Pourquoi pas déplacer cette note a 02:58:459 - ? Un quintuplet qui overlap sur le gros tick blanc rend pas ouf je trouve, et casse un peu le rythme crée avant. Ca permettrait aussi d'accentuer ces deux notes 02:59:068 (110,111) - Alors le coup du tick blanc, j'en ai un peu partout ici :joy:, par contre le coup du double k en valeur me va.

[Inner Oni]

00:41:629 (93) - Supprime cette note et met un d a 00:41:873 - ? Non, j'aime ces kkd kkd stuffs. Ca va bien avec ma vision de la choré (AYY AYY LMAO COREE GET IT?)

01:22:483 (295,296,297,298,299,300,301) - Un peu moche ce pattern ça me fait penser a Verdi Kappa. kdkkdkd a la place me parait mieux C'toi le verdi, actually ca colle avec la song xd

02:55:044 (107) - Supprime cette note ? Je pense qu'avoir un quintuplet avant un stream de plus de 5 notes dessert un peu ce dernier. T'as mieux fait d'avoir triplet + une note 1/2 + stream pour de la mise en valeur. (03:06:020 (175) - Ici aussi par exemple etc) J'ai fais ce que j'ai pu, par contre j'ai agrandi le stream de fin parce que tu la mérité.


Bon la quasi totalité de mes suggestions sont valables pour d'autres endroits de la musique oublie pas.

Bonne chance
HUEHUEHUEHUEHUEHUEHUE
Fantazy
hihi~~~
Inner Oni
00:31:020 (44) - d>k
00:32:483 (50,51,52,53) - kkd k
00:33:459 (54,55,56,57) - ddd k or dkd k
00:38:093 - just kd?
00:40:044 - dk
00:45:898 - kd
00:46:385 - dkd or kdk
00:47:849 - kd
00:55:410 (154) - k>d
00:55:898 (155) - k>d
00:59:312 (174) - k>d
01:04:190 (196) - k>d

01:31:507 (330) - k>d
01:34:922 (346,347,348,349) - kdd k
01:35:898 (350,351,352,353) - kkd k
01:36:873 (354,355,356,357,358) - kdddk

01:40:532 - kd
01:42:483 - dk
01:42:971 - dkd kdk kdd
01:48:093 - kkdk
01:50:044 - kdkd
01:57:849 (453,454) - k>d

02:01:507 (473,474,475) - ddk?
02:06:629 (501) - k>d

02:40:776 (23,24) - k>d
02:49:556 (73) - k>d
03:04:068 (161) - d>k
03:06:385 (175,176,177,178,179,180,181,182,183,184,185,186) - kdddkdkdkkdd
03:07:849 (187,188,189,190,191) - kkddk or kdkdk or ddkdk
03:18:580 (241,242,243,244,245) - dkkdk

03:26:873 (281) - k>d
03:27:361 (282,283,284) - k d k
Oni , Muzu
*you can put more note for this diff (oni) ?_? and Muzu little more?_?_?_?_?
(( feel tooo easy DX
Fustuu
01:37:361 (189) - k>d
02:12:239 (275,276,277) - 02:16:142 (287,288,289) - d k d?
01:00:288 (90,91,92) - 02:02:727 (248,249,250) - 02:45:654 (24,25,26) - k k d
gooood luck and EXPLOSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Topic Starter
Aldwych

Fantazy wrote:

hihi~~~
Inner Oni
00:31:020 (44) - d>k
00:32:483 (50,51,52,53) - kkd k
00:33:459 (54,55,56,57) - ddd k or dkd k
00:38:093 - just kd?
00:40:044 - dk
00:45:898 - kd
00:46:385 - dkd or kdk
00:47:849 - kd
00:55:410 (154) - k>d
00:55:898 (155) - k>d
00:59:312 (174) - k>d
01:04:190 (196) - k>d

01:31:507 (330) - k>d
01:34:922 (346,347,348,349) - kdd k
01:35:898 (350,351,352,353) - kkd k
01:36:873 (354,355,356,357,358) - kdddk

01:40:532 - kd
01:42:483 - dk
01:42:971 - dkd kdk kdd
01:48:093 - kkdk
01:50:044 - kdkd
01:57:849 (453,454) - k>d

02:01:507 (473,474,475) - ddk?
02:06:629 (501) - k>d

02:40:776 (23,24) - k>d
02:49:556 (73) - k>d
03:04:068 (161) - d>k
03:06:385 (175,176,177,178,179,180,181,182,183,184,185,186) - kdddkdkdkkdd
03:07:849 (187,188,189,190,191) - kkddk or kdkdk or ddkdk
03:18:580 (241,242,243,244,245) - dkkdk

03:26:873 (281) - k>d
03:27:361 (282,283,284) - k d k

All denied, some parts would have been changed without considering how the patterns are made (you may have not noticed that patterns like 01:09:800 (229,230,231,232,233,234,235,236,237,238,239) - are mirrored every time and you're gonna break it).

Oni , Muzu
*you can put more note for this diff (oni) ?_? and Muzu little more?_?_?_?_?
(( feel tooo easy DX

This is why an Inner Oni has been made, else -> DT since the BPM is low 8)

Fustuu
01:37:361 (189) - k>d
02:12:239 (275,276,277) - 02:16:142 (287,288,289) - d k d?
01:00:288 (90,91,92) - 02:02:727 (248,249,250) - 02:45:654 (24,25,26) - k k d

Not felt the utility

gooood luck and EXPLOSION!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Thanks for the mod, but because you didn't give any explanation, i'm keeping with my version, i can trust only myself if it's good or bad without argues from your side.
Kin
cc, le revive

[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:40:044 (82,83,84) - since you're following the vocal, I think it should be better to have the emphasis on this note 00:40:166 (83) - instead of this one 00:40:288 (84) - . So, how about changing into dkd ? (you also used it here 01:42:483 (381,382,383) - )
  2. if you've fixed it ^ : also same thing here 00:47:849 (118,119,120) - . Since the music is also the same & you're using the same mimic.
  3. 00:54:190 (150,151,152,153,154) - I'd suggest kdkdd since your pattern was following the vocal, but I think you want to make it different from this 00:58:093 (170,171,172,173,174) -
  4. 01:01:995 (190,191,192,193,194) - I think changing this into a kkdkd or another pattern which have this note 01:02:483 (194) - as a d ; would enhance the emphasis here 01:02:727 (195) -
  5. I think, it'd be better to make those 2 notes 01:52:361 (429,430) - different. I'll make 01:52:483 (430) - more emphasized.
  6. 03:19:556 (247,248,249,250,251) - I really prefer the ddkdk pattern here instead of kdddk. You used a lot this pattern to represent this kind of vocal. (tho, i can understand you want to change some pattern to have a more unique map)

[Oni]

  1. 01:04:434 (166,167,168,169,170,171) - Maybe change it to kkddk d instead of kkd kkd ? I think it goes better with the vocal.
  2. 02:44:922 (39) - maybe delete this note ? Since you have an 1/1 break here 02:42:483 -

[Muzukashii]

  1. 01:25:654 (217) - maybe just me, but I think this one as k flow better.

[Futsuu]

  1. I've seen, you're really mapping the vocal. So, maybe don't skip this vocal ? 01:08:337 - or add a k here 01:08:093 - since you use it here : 01:11:995 (124) - 01:15:898 (136) - 01:19:800 (148) -
Bon, après, sur la Kantan, y a genre pas grand chose à dire. C'est une kantan quoi.
jtm bb.
Topic Starter
Aldwych

Kin wrote:

cc, le revive

[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:40:044 (82,83,84) - since you're following the vocal, I think it should be better to have the emphasis on this note 00:40:166 (83) - instead of this one 00:40:288 (84) - . So, how about changing into dkd ? (you also used it here 01:42:483 (381,382,383) - )
  2. if you've fixed it ^ : also same thing here 00:47:849 (118,119,120) - . Since the music is also the same & you're using the same mimic. Agreed, but also the next triple (as you may see, i use twice similar triples on these sections).
  3. 00:54:190 (150,151,152,153,154) - I'd suggest kdkdd since your pattern was following the vocal, but I think you want to make it different from this 00:58:093 (170,171,172,173,174) - It's ok
  4. 01:01:995 (190,191,192,193,194) - I think changing this into a kkdkd or another pattern which have this note 01:02:483 (194) - as a d ; would enhance the emphasis here 01:02:727 (195) - Totally agreed
  5. I think, it'd be better to make those 2 notes 01:52:361 (429,430) - different. I'll make 01:52:483 (430) - more emphasized. Yep, kkdkd then
  6. 03:19:556 (247,248,249,250,251) - I really prefer the ddkdk pattern here instead of kdddk. You used a lot this pattern to represent this kind of vocal. (tho, i can understand you want to change some pattern to have a more unique map)
    Nope, i'll keep the mirors patterns until the end.

[Oni]

  1. 01:04:434 (166,167,168,169,170,171) - Maybe change it to kkddk d instead of kkd kkd ? I think it goes better with the vocal. Looks better yeah
  2. 02:44:922 (39) - maybe delete this note ? Since you have an 1/1 break here 02:42:483 - Done

[Muzukashii]

  1. 01:25:654 (217) - maybe just me, but I think this one as k flow better. It shoould have been since the others are k.

[Futsuu]

  1. I've seen, you're really mapping the vocal. So, maybe don't skip this vocal ? 01:08:337 - or add a k here 01:08:093 - since you use it here : 01:11:995 (124) - 01:15:898 (136) - 01:19:800 (148) - The breaks boi : ok_hand : :100:

Bon, après, sur la Kantan, y a genre pas grand chose à dire. C'est une kantan quoi.
jtm bb.
Moi aussi jtm <3
Merci pour le mod il est top kek.
Kin
some minor change + fixed overlap on 02:36:629 -
here you go!
Surono
soon(tm)

"sasageyohhhh sasa-- salsa, dem " dem annyeonghaseyo
Topic Starter
Aldwych
:eyes:
Surono
no kd

OD2 for what in nowadays...... kantan change to OD 3 then Futsuu change to OD 3.5

* for oni, 00:28:581 - kkd k, need variation here.
* for futsuu, 00:47:361 - don this, same reason above and here I think is overdone with emphasize
* 00:33:946 - add don for kantan, see the futsuu
* 01:40:044 - no clap, don it for futsuu
* 02:32:483 - try slider for muzukashii?
* 03:29:312 - delete for muzukashii
* 02:56:629 - for kantan, try to add here notes and similar spot? since its slow bpm and futsuu has lonnngg pattern. would be challenging for babies~

dkk loverz :tank:
Topic Starter
Aldwych
xdDdD

Surono wrote:

no kd

OD2 for what in nowadays...... kantan change to OD 3 then Futsuu change to OD 3.5 OD 2 in 2k17 lulz

* for oni, 00:28:581 - kkd k, need variation here. nye i agree
* for futsuu, 00:47:361 - don this, same reason above and here I think is overdone with emphasize Dem clap in the song ' L_'
* 00:33:946 - add don for kantan, see the futsuu Only if i don 00:32:971 - here aswell ' L_'
* 01:40:044 - no clap, don it for futsuu don
* 02:32:483 - try slider for muzukashii? Why nut, but i keep 02:33:459 (440) -
* 03:29:312 - delete for muzukashii Should be weird to read.
* 02:56:629 - for kantan, try to add here notes and similar spot? since its slow bpm and futsuu has lonnngg pattern. would be challenging for babies~ Don't feel it necessary, also it should be odd having 1/2 at final part, it's like adding 1/4 on futsuu too :x

dkk loverz :tank:
Korean loli train inc!
Surono

Aldwych wrote:

Korean loli train inc!


rip animemes song or idk, ~genie for ya boiz~~


31th May is HBD of this map?!?! too early lmao
Charlotte
Congratz~~ 8-)
IamKwaN
Can someone explain me the title please? Where did you find it?
Topic Starter
Aldwych
IamKwaN
May I have something official, please?
Kurai
Girls' Generation's Official website: http://girlsgeneration.smtown.com/Disco ... 148?page=6 (some music may randomly play).
IamKwaN
So, 소원을 말해봐 is the Unicode Title and Genie is the Romanised Title?
Kurai
No, 소원을 말해봐 (Genie) is the unicode title. Romanised would be "Sowoneul malhaebwa (Genie)" but they use the direct translation "Tell Me Your Wish (Genie)" in international charts, on YouTube and everywhere else.
IamKwaN
I really doubt, according to your logic, Unicode Artist should be Girls' Generation(소녀시대) then.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6SwiSpudKWI
Kurai
YouTube is not a viable source. I just mentionned it to say that K-Pop producers usually translate their song titles in order to reach an international audience. Also "소녀시대" is "Girls' Generation", which would make no sense to merge together.
IamKwaN
The Youtube video I linked is official, it's from SMTown (probably an old account though).

Also, in the Japanese version Genie single, the song is named as GENIE [KOREAN VER.], I don't know where Tell Me Your Wish comes from, the song is named/translated as exactly Genie.

http://www.girls-generation.jp/CMIYC/di ... raphy.html
Kurai
"Genie" is the Japanese name of the song, the original was released as Genie [Korean Ver.] in Japan I believe for the sake of consistency.

Also: "Tell Me Your Wish (Genie)" [...] It was released on June 22, 2009 as a single from the EP. Written by Dsign Music, Fridolin Nordso Schjoldan, and Yoo Young-jin, and produced by Young-jin, the song is the group's first collaboration with Western composers and producers, which was later encouraged towards their future music.

http://dsignmusic.com/album/tell-me-your-wish-genie/
Topic Starter
Aldwych
So according to your logic, Youtube is more official than Wikipedia.

Maxus
Wikipedia isn't official though, it is a website where literally anyone can edit the information, hence why it's unofficial.
While the youtube link provided by KwaN is directly from the producer company (look at the channel, it has "verified" status in it) and cannot be edited by anyone except the official people , hence why it's official.
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply